Finally got around to finishing Relic (sorry about the delay), my first Goodreads Giveaway win.
As guilty as it may make me feel, I really wanted to be honest in my review. That being said; Relic definitely needs some work.
The novella was very short (I believe 178 pages), and the excerpt and description on the back of the book promised a compelling, thought-provoking premise. However, I feel like it really failed to deliver in that regard. It says that "Relic describes a world in which human soldiers are replaced with something much deadlier..." etc. etc. but that is entirely misleading, because even by the end of the story that is not the case.
Beyond that, the novella reads like an early draft to a larger, much more interesting novel. I can see that a lot of research seemed to have gone into the science, but that is in no way reflected in the text, which explains what little science is present as if the target audience was a group of upper elementary school kids. The immersion into the story was broken for me by situations that were implausible; the first example that comes to mind is the fact that Dr. Summerston's every move was being monitored... except his Google searches?! Many corporations monitor employees' internet history, but not a military-based top-secret facility with an unreliable scientist in their midst? Also, much of the novella's dialogue and word choice were painfully repetitive (Chapter 10 was hard to get through, because the same things were being said over and over). A portion of the already short tale was needless fluff (the random sexual tension between the fake surrogate parents?). There were unnecessary page breaks, grammar mishaps, cheesy meta-references...
I suppose I could summarize this review by saying that Relic seems to be in dire need of an editor.
Like I said, I grudgingly post this review out of gratefulness for receiving the book at all. However, I was asked to review it, and review it I have. I would probably give it a 3/10 in its current state. I do look forward to perhaps reading it in a second, more polished iteration.