This novel is a sort of regency mystery & romance story. The protagonist is an art teacher for young ladies who is planning to become an independent, professional artist-No easy feet in regency times for a woman due to the patriarchal views of the time-who is maneuvered into chaperoning a group of young ladies to visit a noble household where a supposed murder may have occurred. Since she is an artist, there is an interesting narrative characterization technique where our protagonist pictures characters as subjects for a painting, allowing for the reader to differentiate and understand the personality and physical appearance of character turned art piece-I found this really affective and interesting.
In addition to the wonderful narrative technique and interesting characters, the author also does a wonderful job with pacing. Observe this excerpt:
“Hannah, it was hoped, would marry a country squire and raise children. But Hannah had fallen in love, with her painting.”
Many writers will dogishly try to follow grammar arcana and ignore the pacing potential of punctuation samples. In our above sample the writer uses the last coma to make an ironic joke of expectations while also continuing the back ground information on our heroine. Well done indeed!
The narrative continues on in an interesting manner that I at least enjoyed reading. There were flashes of dramatic irony, humor, and romance that pulls the reader along. While each of the girls is interesting in her own way, Emily is my and probably most readers favorite-she seems to have the soul of an old, grumpy man despite being a bright, young lady. Wonderful dichotomy! The earl himself is a picture of contradictions, being originated from working class America but now an earl. Clearly the author has an amazing hand at making engaging characters to populate her plots.
As one cannot make enough of Lady Emily, here are a few examples of the grumpy lady sleuth in training.
*
“But as the short journey wore on, the girls grew more restive.
‘We shall all be crushed inside this carriage,’ Lady Emily promised after they had bumped some distance from Barnsley. ‘He’ll roll it on the next curve, you wait and see.’”
*
“‘I hope this is a pleasant visit,’ she muttered, tone implying she sincerely doubted it.”
*
“‘Someone should catalog it,’ Lady Emily muttered. ‘Otherwise, who knows what the visitors will run off with.’”
*
“‘He must have given up his vows for her,’ Lady Emily muttered to her friends. ‘They probably tortured him for it.’”
*
[on suggestions on what music to play next]
“‘A battle hymn,’ Lady Emily suggested,’or better, a dirge.’”
*
One can almost picture an old man flipping through the morning paper with a cup of coffee scowling at everyone in the dear lady’s replies. Anyway, i digress . . . Onwards then.
*spoiler*
Eventually the plot comes to a choice point where the protagonist must choose between her art and her love. That she immediately thinks to choose love seems strange to me-seems a more fateful, all consuming decision than that quick a resolution.
Further, as the plot continues and the antagonist is revealed in not so subtle ways that would make Disney villains everywhere shake their heads in shame, we are left with some indisputable facts-the mystery and adventure are back drops for the interactions of the characters. While they-the murder and art mystery, the adventure, and danger-are well enough, the real plot is the wonderful interactions of the characters, which I found absolutely charming.
*end spoiler*
I originally was going to end this review with unsolicited begging for the author to write a solo adventure for lady Emily where she is the prot, but it seems this already has been done-can not wait to begin these. In conclusion, this book is a charming bit of off color regency romance filled with character growth and all sorts of adventure and intrigue. I recommend it and give it 4 out of 5 dire Lady Emilys.