What do you think?
Rate this book
Flos Magicae #3
A Thief and a Gentleman
Sebastian is a con artist with expensive taste. Unfortunately, he has no hope of living the high-class life he craves without stealing it. So, that’s exactly what he’s going to do. He might be a pathetic ex-convict by day, but by night, he’s London’s most notorious jewel thief. All he needs is someone to provide him with food, money, and a place to stay while he plans the heist that will secure his future once and for all.
When a friend dares him to seduce Morgan Hollyhock—rich, handsome, and incredibly boring—Sebastian thinks he’s found the perfect mark. There’s just one problem. He and Morgan have history, and he’s unprepared for the flood of emotions when he sees Morgan again for the first time in twenty years.
For once, Sebastian wants to be honest about who he is and what he’s done. But Morgan has always been a stickler for the rules. If Sebastian opens up about his crimes or his past, Morgan might turn him in, or worse, reject him. And that won't just jeopardize Sebastian's criminal career. After a lifetime of cheating and lying, Sebastian is appalled to realize that he does in fact have a heart to break.
A Thief and a Gentleman is a full-length MM novel set in a 1920s universe infused with magic. All the books in the Flos Magicae series can be read as standalones.
When a friend dares him to seduce Morgan Hollyhock—rich, handsome, and incredibly boring—Sebastian thinks he’s found the perfect mark. There’s just one problem. He and Morgan have history, and he’s unprepared for the flood of emotions when he sees Morgan again for the first time in twenty years.
For once, Sebastian wants to be honest about who he is and what he’s done. But Morgan has always been a stickler for the rules. If Sebastian opens up about his crimes or his past, Morgan might turn him in, or worse, reject him. And that won't just jeopardize Sebastian's criminal career. After a lifetime of cheating and lying, Sebastian is appalled to realize that he does in fact have a heart to break.
A Thief and a Gentleman is a full-length MM novel set in a 1920s universe infused with magic. All the books in the Flos Magicae series can be read as standalones.
397 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 24, 2023
105 people are currently reading
743 people want to read
About the author
Arden Powell
26 books425 followersArden Powell (they/them) is a Canadian author and illustrator with stories in Lightspeed Magazine, Baffling Magazine, and Haunt Publishing, and whose books include The Faerie Hounds of York, The Bayou, the Flos Magicae series, and their short story collection, The Carnelian King and Other Stories. A nebulous entity, they live with a senior rescue hound and an exorbitant number of houseplants, and enjoy the company of both.
Join their newsletter for news about new releases, sales, cover reveals, and more:
https://subscribepage.io/ardenpowell
Read their exclusive Flos Magicae epilogues for free on Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/collection/83...
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/ardenpowell....
Join their newsletter for news about new releases, sales, cover reveals, and more:
https://subscribepage.io/ardenpowell
Read their exclusive Flos Magicae epilogues for free on Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/collection/83...
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/ardenpowell....
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
Read
July 21, 2023My new Flos Magicae novel comes out at the end of July! It's the longest of the series so far, with a few familiar faces in supporting roles, as well as a host of new characters who were an absolute delight to write (I'm looking at Kitty and Adam here specifically. She's a goal-oriented cat burglar; he's just Ken).
And, of course, the new leads: Sebastian, ex-con, con artist, and jewel thief extraordinaire (a character hinted at in both A Novel Arrangement and Winter's Dawn), and Morgan Hollyhock, Alphonse's morose cousin who needs something (someone) to come along and introduce some havoc to his life.
Content notes, for those who need them:
And, of course, the new leads: Sebastian, ex-con, con artist, and jewel thief extraordinaire (a character hinted at in both A Novel Arrangement and Winter's Dawn), and Morgan Hollyhock, Alphonse's morose cousin who needs something (someone) to come along and introduce some havoc to his life.
Content notes, for those who need them:
November 6, 2023
Thank you so much to the author and Booksprout for the ARC!
I’m a massive fan of Arden Powell’s work— their ability to craft stories that meld together atmosphere, magic, and heart wrenching romance is truly wonderful. I’ve loved the Flos Magicae world thus far and was super excited to dig into the newest instalment early!
The story follows former childhood friends Morgan, wealthy and reticent, and far too wise on Sebastian tricks, and Sebastian, jewel thief and general schmoozer, as they reunite and try very hard not to fall in love.
Morgan is bored. With too much money and nothing to do, he find himself intrigued, if not a little wary, when his former childhood friend comes back into his life. On the opposite end of the spectrum is Sebastian, who just wants a comfortable life even if he has to charm his way into the beds of London’s aristocrats to do it. When he finds himself newly without a mark to seduce and Morgan conveniently available (and rich), the two start up something like a friendship. Only, Sebastian has quite a bit jewel heist looming on the horizon, and is doing his best to keep any sort of moral qualms from coming into the equation.
I loved seeing these two fall in love, especially Sebastian. As he slowly dropped his mask around Morgan and allowed himself to be vulnerable, even at the expense of some of his scheming, he wormed his way into my favourite character in the series. Friends to lovers is my favourite romance trope and this story did it so well!
As with the rest of the series, the magic was fluid and woven seamlessly with the rest of the story. I found Sebastian’s more… unusual usage of it especially compelling 👀
Overall, this story and the rest of the series will appeal to fans of Freya Markse’s A Marvellous Light and CL Polke’s Witchmark series— aka queer fantasy romance set in an Edwardian (inspired) world! I really loved this series and will continue to read and recommend all of Arden Powell’s work.
I’m a massive fan of Arden Powell’s work— their ability to craft stories that meld together atmosphere, magic, and heart wrenching romance is truly wonderful. I’ve loved the Flos Magicae world thus far and was super excited to dig into the newest instalment early!
The story follows former childhood friends Morgan, wealthy and reticent, and far too wise on Sebastian tricks, and Sebastian, jewel thief and general schmoozer, as they reunite and try very hard not to fall in love.
Morgan is bored. With too much money and nothing to do, he find himself intrigued, if not a little wary, when his former childhood friend comes back into his life. On the opposite end of the spectrum is Sebastian, who just wants a comfortable life even if he has to charm his way into the beds of London’s aristocrats to do it. When he finds himself newly without a mark to seduce and Morgan conveniently available (and rich), the two start up something like a friendship. Only, Sebastian has quite a bit jewel heist looming on the horizon, and is doing his best to keep any sort of moral qualms from coming into the equation.
I loved seeing these two fall in love, especially Sebastian. As he slowly dropped his mask around Morgan and allowed himself to be vulnerable, even at the expense of some of his scheming, he wormed his way into my favourite character in the series. Friends to lovers is my favourite romance trope and this story did it so well!
As with the rest of the series, the magic was fluid and woven seamlessly with the rest of the story. I found Sebastian’s more… unusual usage of it especially compelling 👀
Overall, this story and the rest of the series will appeal to fans of Freya Markse’s A Marvellous Light and CL Polke’s Witchmark series— aka queer fantasy romance set in an Edwardian (inspired) world! I really loved this series and will continue to read and recommend all of Arden Powell’s work.
August 22, 2023
3.5 stars
A very fun, quick read which was exactly what I was looking for. The combination of friends to lovers and a heist plot was intriguing but I’m not sure that it always worked. The characters, Sebastian in particular, had really inconsistent motivations and opinions.
A very fun, quick read which was exactly what I was looking for. The combination of friends to lovers and a heist plot was intriguing but I’m not sure that it always worked. The characters, Sebastian in particular, had really inconsistent motivations and opinions.
September 13, 2023
I've given this a B+ at AAR, 4.5 stars.
Arden Powell’s Flos Magicae series of 1920s set fantasy romances comprises a mixture of full-length novels and novellas that can be read in any order. I’ve been meaning to give their books a try for a while, so I picked up the most recent entry, A Thief and a Gentleman, which features a romance between a con artist with expensive tastes and the handsome, wealthy – but somewhat repressed – gentleman he is dared to seduce. I enjoyed it a lot – the writing is assured (apart from a couple of small glitches), the romance is a tender slow-burn,and the characterisation is excellent; the PoV character is a damaged but loveable rogue and the secondary cast is vibrant and three-dimensional.
Without the funds to support the kind of high-class lifestyle he aspires to, Sebastian’s only option is to grift and steal it – and he isn’t too picky about what he has to do to get what he wants. When his most recent paramour kicks him out (after discovering Sebastian has done a stretch in Blackwood prison), he’s inconvenienced rather than heartbroken; he just needed someone to provide food, money, and a roof over his head while he finished planning the robbery of a lifetime. When the book opens, he’s just knocked on the front door of his best friend and partner-in-crime, Kitty Delaware, hoping she will put him up for a few nights, or at least until he can find himself another mark. Fortunately for Sebastian, Kitty’s partner, Adam, is pretty easy-going; he knows what Sebastian is and how he lives, and he knows that together, Sebastian and Kitty are the most notorious jewel thieves in London. They’re planning to steal a portion of the Cheapside Hoard, currently on display at the British Museum, and they’re almost ready to do the job; just a few more days to put the finishing touches to the plan and they’ll be rich – and Sebastian will never need to rely on anyone else ever again.
Later that day, Adam invites Sebastian to accompany him to the Stag’s Head – a fashionable London club populated entirely by wealthy gentlemen with too much time on their hands and too few hobbies. It’s a trifle dull for Sebastian’s taste, but needs must – and at least the attendees’ vapid personalities make them easy marks. When Adam introduces Sebastian to his friend, Alphonse Hollyhock, the name rings a very quiet bell; it’s not until Alphonse mentions that his cousin Morgan is sitting at the bar that the bells begin to ring louder. Sebastian hasn’t laid eyes onMorgan Hollyhock in twenty years, not since that one, idyllic summer when they were boys together, and finds himself actually eager to see Morgan again, even briefly considering the idea of finding a friend rather than another mark. But he hadn’t been prepared for the disappointment that hits him when the other man clearly doesn’t recognise him. Not willing to open himself up to rejection or ridicule by reminding Morgan who he is, Sebastian introduces himself as Tom, enters into a conversation – during which Morgan reveals himself to be very reserved and staid – and, because pickpocketing is almost second nature to him, lifts Morgan’s watch as he leaves.
Later, Kitty and Adam notice Sebastian is out of sorts despite his attempts at nonchalance and insistence that while Morgan is, indeed, handsome and rich, he’s too boring for Sebastian to want to shackle himself to him for any length of time. But he has to abandon the pretence at indifference when Adam points out that he hasn’t stopped fiddling with the watch, and then bets Sebastian twenty pounds that he can’t seduce Morgan. Sebastian pretends to consider the idea, but as his avarice and his inclination are in alignment on this occasion, he takes the bet.
Realising that his usual methods of seduction are unlikely to work with Morgan, Sebastian decides to try a different tack. After admitting to his deception the day before and then returning Morgan’s watch, Sebastian tells him about the bet and suggests that perhaps they can help each other out. Sebastian doesn’t need to actually sleep with Morgan in order to win the money; he just needs to spend a few nights under his roof and for them to pretend to be a couple in front of Adam and Kitty. And in exchange, Sebastian will help Morgan to alleviate the crushing boredom he’d confessed to at the club. Morgan, who freely admits to living a very dull, hermit-like existence, really is in desperate need of a change of pace and has to admit that Sebastian is the most interesting thing to happen to him in a long time – but he can’t help feeling a little wary, too. Sebastian is flamboyant, and flirtatious, his morals leave much to be desired and he lies with impunity – but despite it all, Morgan is smitten.
Flighty/stick-in-the-mud pairings don’t always work for me (so many of them feature the ‘manic pixie’ type, which I can’t stand), but I really liked this one. Sebastian is charming and smart, with a dry sense of humour; he’s also desperately lonely but refuses to admit it, he jokes and flirts to avoid dealing with any real emotions, and he has a self-destructive tendency that often gets the better of him. His life since he and Morgan first met has clearly not been an easy one, and his stint behind bars – in a prison designed specifically to suppress all forms of magic – has clearly affected him more deeply than he cares to admit. But despite all that, you can’t help but like him and want him to get his happy ending. Sebastian’s is the sole PoV in the story, so we don’t get into Morgan’s head, but he’s nicely drawn, too – he’s straight-laced and considers himself to be dull and uninteresting but he’s a kind and decent man, and despite his fascination with Sebastian, is no pushover. I loved watching Sebastian fighting his feelings for Morgan tooth and nail, and Morgan’s gentle persistence in believing better of him; they have great chemistry and their relationship – from friendship to romance – is a lovely slow-burn that allows them both time to start to let down their guards with each other and look beyond the surface.
The magical elements of the book are interesting and come into play in unusual ways (and some slightly naughty ones!) and I liked Sebastian’s friend Kitty – she’s whip-smart and no-nonsense and their friendship is really well written. Most of the secondary characters have appeared in the other books in the series, but the plotlines don’t cross over, so I was able to jump into the series here without any problems, and I’ll definitely be going back to read some of the others.
I do have a couple of small reservations. Not having Morgan’s perspective makes it difficult to understand why he so readily goes along with Sebastian’s scheme, and there are a few places where the single PoV kinda slips; it doesn’t switch, but there are times when some of the things Sebastian says and thinks don’t really fit.
Those minor niggles aside, however,A Thief and a Gentleman is a refreshingly different and thoroughly entertaining read, and it earns a strong recommendation. Sebastian is a wonderful central character with a very distinctive voice, the romance is warm and tender and the plot is interesting and well thought-out. I’ll definitely be reading more from Arden Powell.
This review originally appeared at All About Romance .
Arden Powell’s Flos Magicae series of 1920s set fantasy romances comprises a mixture of full-length novels and novellas that can be read in any order. I’ve been meaning to give their books a try for a while, so I picked up the most recent entry, A Thief and a Gentleman, which features a romance between a con artist with expensive tastes and the handsome, wealthy – but somewhat repressed – gentleman he is dared to seduce. I enjoyed it a lot – the writing is assured (apart from a couple of small glitches), the romance is a tender slow-burn,and the characterisation is excellent; the PoV character is a damaged but loveable rogue and the secondary cast is vibrant and three-dimensional.
Without the funds to support the kind of high-class lifestyle he aspires to, Sebastian’s only option is to grift and steal it – and he isn’t too picky about what he has to do to get what he wants. When his most recent paramour kicks him out (after discovering Sebastian has done a stretch in Blackwood prison), he’s inconvenienced rather than heartbroken; he just needed someone to provide food, money, and a roof over his head while he finished planning the robbery of a lifetime. When the book opens, he’s just knocked on the front door of his best friend and partner-in-crime, Kitty Delaware, hoping she will put him up for a few nights, or at least until he can find himself another mark. Fortunately for Sebastian, Kitty’s partner, Adam, is pretty easy-going; he knows what Sebastian is and how he lives, and he knows that together, Sebastian and Kitty are the most notorious jewel thieves in London. They’re planning to steal a portion of the Cheapside Hoard, currently on display at the British Museum, and they’re almost ready to do the job; just a few more days to put the finishing touches to the plan and they’ll be rich – and Sebastian will never need to rely on anyone else ever again.
Later that day, Adam invites Sebastian to accompany him to the Stag’s Head – a fashionable London club populated entirely by wealthy gentlemen with too much time on their hands and too few hobbies. It’s a trifle dull for Sebastian’s taste, but needs must – and at least the attendees’ vapid personalities make them easy marks. When Adam introduces Sebastian to his friend, Alphonse Hollyhock, the name rings a very quiet bell; it’s not until Alphonse mentions that his cousin Morgan is sitting at the bar that the bells begin to ring louder. Sebastian hasn’t laid eyes onMorgan Hollyhock in twenty years, not since that one, idyllic summer when they were boys together, and finds himself actually eager to see Morgan again, even briefly considering the idea of finding a friend rather than another mark. But he hadn’t been prepared for the disappointment that hits him when the other man clearly doesn’t recognise him. Not willing to open himself up to rejection or ridicule by reminding Morgan who he is, Sebastian introduces himself as Tom, enters into a conversation – during which Morgan reveals himself to be very reserved and staid – and, because pickpocketing is almost second nature to him, lifts Morgan’s watch as he leaves.
Later, Kitty and Adam notice Sebastian is out of sorts despite his attempts at nonchalance and insistence that while Morgan is, indeed, handsome and rich, he’s too boring for Sebastian to want to shackle himself to him for any length of time. But he has to abandon the pretence at indifference when Adam points out that he hasn’t stopped fiddling with the watch, and then bets Sebastian twenty pounds that he can’t seduce Morgan. Sebastian pretends to consider the idea, but as his avarice and his inclination are in alignment on this occasion, he takes the bet.
Realising that his usual methods of seduction are unlikely to work with Morgan, Sebastian decides to try a different tack. After admitting to his deception the day before and then returning Morgan’s watch, Sebastian tells him about the bet and suggests that perhaps they can help each other out. Sebastian doesn’t need to actually sleep with Morgan in order to win the money; he just needs to spend a few nights under his roof and for them to pretend to be a couple in front of Adam and Kitty. And in exchange, Sebastian will help Morgan to alleviate the crushing boredom he’d confessed to at the club. Morgan, who freely admits to living a very dull, hermit-like existence, really is in desperate need of a change of pace and has to admit that Sebastian is the most interesting thing to happen to him in a long time – but he can’t help feeling a little wary, too. Sebastian is flamboyant, and flirtatious, his morals leave much to be desired and he lies with impunity – but despite it all, Morgan is smitten.
Flighty/stick-in-the-mud pairings don’t always work for me (so many of them feature the ‘manic pixie’ type, which I can’t stand), but I really liked this one. Sebastian is charming and smart, with a dry sense of humour; he’s also desperately lonely but refuses to admit it, he jokes and flirts to avoid dealing with any real emotions, and he has a self-destructive tendency that often gets the better of him. His life since he and Morgan first met has clearly not been an easy one, and his stint behind bars – in a prison designed specifically to suppress all forms of magic – has clearly affected him more deeply than he cares to admit. But despite all that, you can’t help but like him and want him to get his happy ending. Sebastian’s is the sole PoV in the story, so we don’t get into Morgan’s head, but he’s nicely drawn, too – he’s straight-laced and considers himself to be dull and uninteresting but he’s a kind and decent man, and despite his fascination with Sebastian, is no pushover. I loved watching Sebastian fighting his feelings for Morgan tooth and nail, and Morgan’s gentle persistence in believing better of him; they have great chemistry and their relationship – from friendship to romance – is a lovely slow-burn that allows them both time to start to let down their guards with each other and look beyond the surface.
The magical elements of the book are interesting and come into play in unusual ways (and some slightly naughty ones!) and I liked Sebastian’s friend Kitty – she’s whip-smart and no-nonsense and their friendship is really well written. Most of the secondary characters have appeared in the other books in the series, but the plotlines don’t cross over, so I was able to jump into the series here without any problems, and I’ll definitely be going back to read some of the others.
I do have a couple of small reservations. Not having Morgan’s perspective makes it difficult to understand why he so readily goes along with Sebastian’s scheme, and there are a few places where the single PoV kinda slips; it doesn’t switch, but there are times when some of the things Sebastian says and thinks don’t really fit.
Those minor niggles aside, however,A Thief and a Gentleman is a refreshingly different and thoroughly entertaining read, and it earns a strong recommendation. Sebastian is a wonderful central character with a very distinctive voice, the romance is warm and tender and the plot is interesting and well thought-out. I’ll definitely be reading more from Arden Powell.
This review originally appeared at All About Romance .
July 27, 2023
I absolutely loved Morgan and Sebastian! This story has two friends reuniting over twenty years later, but their lives have diverged where Sebastian is a jewel thief and Morgan is a rather uptight, quiet man of leisure. I love all of Arden's books, but I loved the dynamic between them and how Sebastian slowly gets Morgan to open up. How they figure out the relationship and what things will be like going forward made me so happy because neither man really has to change, just meet the other where they are. There were also nods to other books and characters in the series, and there are a few characters mention who I hope get their own books.
July 22, 2023
I loved The Bachelor's Valet to pieces and was slightly afraid the author's other books couldn't live up to it. Alphonse was a ridiculous lovable himbo and the book was a brilliant piece of humorous fluff but I never wanted a sequel too similar, I don't think it would even work. I haven't yet read the other books in the series but I was too excited not to pick up an ARC copy of this one. Luckily A Thief and a Gentleman works, and I adore it probably just as much as The Bachelor's Valet.
This book is not as constantly hilarious, but there are countless of funny and moving moments. Initially I thought it was a good book but perhaps not a real competitor to TBV. Eventually I went with 5 stars because it just has so many elements that are my cup of tea, and it keeps getting better the further you go in. The second half was pure love for me.
I like imperfect main characters, lovable scoundrels and lost boys, and Sebastian is all of that. He's a downright cleptomaniac and a compulsive liar but I just want him to be happy. And don't I love a reserved and a bit stuck up love interest - always. The pairing reminds me of one of my favourite books The Gentle Art of Fortune Hunting by K.J. Charles. There are many similarities but these are definitely different books.
There's some suspense in the form of heists and the use of magic is much more prevalent in this book, when it almost felt inconsequential in The Bachelor's Valet. I also enjoyed the friendship between Sebastian and Kitty as well as some moments of gender-nonconformity.
I have to concede that if you aren't as much into above things as I am, it might not be a 5 star book for you, but it should be a good or even great one still.
This book is not as constantly hilarious, but there are countless of funny and moving moments. Initially I thought it was a good book but perhaps not a real competitor to TBV. Eventually I went with 5 stars because it just has so many elements that are my cup of tea, and it keeps getting better the further you go in. The second half was pure love for me.
I like imperfect main characters, lovable scoundrels and lost boys, and Sebastian is all of that. He's a downright cleptomaniac and a compulsive liar but I just want him to be happy. And don't I love a reserved and a bit stuck up love interest - always. The pairing reminds me of one of my favourite books The Gentle Art of Fortune Hunting by K.J. Charles. There are many similarities but these are definitely different books.
There's some suspense in the form of heists and the use of magic is much more prevalent in this book, when it almost felt inconsequential in The Bachelor's Valet. I also enjoyed the friendship between Sebastian and Kitty as well as some moments of gender-nonconformity.
I have to concede that if you aren't as much into above things as I am, it might not be a 5 star book for you, but it should be a good or even great one still.
January 16, 2024
There is this specific type of character that I simply can't help but adore whenever I encounter them.
It's the charming, foppish and flirtatious "gentleman" that is not so secretly a manipulative and selfish cad. They're often a con-man, a cat thief, a spy or something similar. Usually, they're secretly a decent person at heart (they do have some standards, darling! ), and are hiding some big hurt or desperation (often loneliness) which they are covering with their foppish persona.
Sebastian fits this character type to a tee, and I adore him.
Imo, the author did an excellent job at portraying him, with all his charm, flaws and unhealthy coping mechanisms, without needing to bash the reader over the head with them.
However, the ending was a little strange. Certain events were set up that I expected to happen - but then didn't, leaving Sebastian's character arc somewhere I didn't expect it to be left at at the end. From a writing perspective, it was certainly an interesting decision, though as a reader wishing for escapism and only wanting good things for the characters, I was relieved about the lack of serious angst and drama.
It's the charming, foppish and flirtatious "gentleman" that is not so secretly a manipulative and selfish cad. They're often a con-man, a cat thief, a spy or something similar. Usually, they're secretly a decent person at heart (they do have some standards, darling! ), and are hiding some big hurt or desperation (often loneliness) which they are covering with their foppish persona.
Sebastian fits this character type to a tee, and I adore him.
Imo, the author did an excellent job at portraying him, with all his charm, flaws and unhealthy coping mechanisms, without needing to bash the reader over the head with them.
However, the ending was a little strange. Certain events were set up that I expected to happen - but then didn't, leaving Sebastian's character arc somewhere I didn't expect it to be left at at the end. From a writing perspective, it was certainly an interesting decision, though as a reader wishing for escapism and only wanting good things for the characters, I was relieved about the lack of serious angst and drama.
July 27, 2023
Thank you to Booksprout for the ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.
A sweet story of friendship and love but I found the heist plotline and the slow burn a little boring. Couples from past books in the series are also featured, though I haven't read the full series and didn't remember the couples from the books I did read... It might be better to read this series closer together to better remember character plotlines and the rules of this alternative history.
The innate magic use of this world is interesting and it's treated more of a quirk than something more extraordinary, on the account of most everyone has use of it. You could remove the magic elements and it would be much the same story.
My ARC copy had a few typos but nothing too glaring.
This series would probably appeal to fans of steampunk and urban fantasy, and fans of books like Rowling's Fantastic Beasts franchise, as it has that feel though without any imaginary technology elements.
A sweet story of friendship and love but I found the heist plotline and the slow burn a little boring. Couples from past books in the series are also featured, though I haven't read the full series and didn't remember the couples from the books I did read... It might be better to read this series closer together to better remember character plotlines and the rules of this alternative history.
The innate magic use of this world is interesting and it's treated more of a quirk than something more extraordinary, on the account of most everyone has use of it. You could remove the magic elements and it would be much the same story.
My ARC copy had a few typos but nothing too glaring.
This series would probably appeal to fans of steampunk and urban fantasy, and fans of books like Rowling's Fantastic Beasts franchise, as it has that feel though without any imaginary technology elements.
January 26, 2024
very fun very quick to read overall an enjoyable experience i’ve come to love arden powell
July 26, 2025
I’ve had a weakness for thief characters—solo, cat burglar, jewel thief types, not so much con-men, and definitely none of your group-project “heist” bullshit—since I was a kid.
I suppose that goes to explain why I picked this as my third read from Arden Powell, and to some extent why I kept going when it became clear this was going to be a crushing disappointment.
I enjoyed the two earlier, shorter works from Powell I read: The Faerie Hounds of York and The Bachelor’s Valet. Where did this one go so wrong?
Well, for one, the writing style just completely smothered any hint of dramatic tension in its crib. The events of the story could not have been told in a more bland manner had Powell deliberately set out to do so. Then there’s the complete failure to address any of the baggage the characters are carrying. Sebastian’s got obvious PTSD, but it’s treated more like atmosphere than an actual issue. And as for the love interest, Morgan, we never really get to know him, and the things Sebastian tells us about him are nowhere in evidence on the page.
The setting is nominally a fantasy world, an alt version of 1920s London with magic. But the magic honestly feels pointless and unnecessary, and feels more like an excuse for not researching than a necessary part of the story. I noted that in The Bachelor’s Valet but that one had other things going on which actually worked, regardless of the setting.
This book just really didn’t work for me on any level. There’s potential in the ideas here, but sadly none of it was ever realized.
I suppose that goes to explain why I picked this as my third read from Arden Powell, and to some extent why I kept going when it became clear this was going to be a crushing disappointment.
I enjoyed the two earlier, shorter works from Powell I read: The Faerie Hounds of York and The Bachelor’s Valet. Where did this one go so wrong?
Well, for one, the writing style just completely smothered any hint of dramatic tension in its crib. The events of the story could not have been told in a more bland manner had Powell deliberately set out to do so. Then there’s the complete failure to address any of the baggage the characters are carrying. Sebastian’s got obvious PTSD, but it’s treated more like atmosphere than an actual issue. And as for the love interest, Morgan, we never really get to know him, and the things Sebastian tells us about him are nowhere in evidence on the page.
The setting is nominally a fantasy world, an alt version of 1920s London with magic. But the magic honestly feels pointless and unnecessary, and feels more like an excuse for not researching than a necessary part of the story. I noted that in The Bachelor’s Valet but that one had other things going on which actually worked, regardless of the setting.
This book just really didn’t work for me on any level. There’s potential in the ideas here, but sadly none of it was ever realized.
July 28, 2023
I've come to love Arden Powell's charming Flos Magicae series, and each new story in this enchanting world of blended magic, history, and romance is a treat. A Thief and a Gentleman is a particularly fun one; I love the juxtaposition of Sebastian and Morgan's conflicting and complementary personalities and damage, and the heist side of the story is just plain fun. This one has more cameos and references from the previous stories in the series, too, and it's a delight to see them all come together into a more fully realized world. (As with the other stories, it works fine as a standalone, but getting to see all the bits and pieces coming together and intertwining is an extra treat for the reader who's enjoyed the rest of the books already.) A Thief and a Gentleman puts magic more in the foreground than some of those earlier stories, and that's another treat, getting to see the ways in which Sebastian's thoughts on magic (influenced by a stint in Blackwood prison and conversations with a fellow prisoner...) and approach to it differ from that of the more propriety-bound upper-class Hollyhocks and the like.
Flos Magicae is a magical treat of a series, like delicate sugary desserts with the occasional sharp, bitter bite for much-needed contrast, and A Thief and a Gentleman is a lovely, fun, and emotionally satisfying addition to the world.
Recommended for fans of A Marvellous Light, C.L. Polk, K.J. Charles, and anyone who's ever shipped Wooster and Jeeves.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Flos Magicae is a magical treat of a series, like delicate sugary desserts with the occasional sharp, bitter bite for much-needed contrast, and A Thief and a Gentleman is a lovely, fun, and emotionally satisfying addition to the world.
Recommended for fans of A Marvellous Light, C.L. Polk, K.J. Charles, and anyone who's ever shipped Wooster and Jeeves.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 17, 2023
A Joyfully Jay review.
3.75 stars
A Thief and a Gentleman is the third book in the Flos Magicae series by Arden Powell. The stories take place in same universe and timeline; there are even a few cameos by the MCs from the previous stories as well. All of which is to say there is a delightful sense of familiarity about the world and this setting.
Overall, if you’re a fan of opposites attract or wrong-side-of-the-tracks tropes, I think you’ll enjoy the dynamic between Sebastian and Morgan.
Read Camille’s review in its entirety here.
3.75 stars
A Thief and a Gentleman is the third book in the Flos Magicae series by Arden Powell. The stories take place in same universe and timeline; there are even a few cameos by the MCs from the previous stories as well. All of which is to say there is a delightful sense of familiarity about the world and this setting.
Overall, if you’re a fan of opposites attract or wrong-side-of-the-tracks tropes, I think you’ll enjoy the dynamic between Sebastian and Morgan.
Read Camille’s review in its entirety here.
May 9, 2024
3.5
I felt no real spark between Sebastian and Morgan most of the time especially because Sebastian constantly ignored Morgan’s boundaries and kept pushing.
It felt manipulative.
And I hated his constant lying because Morgan deserved better.
Even after some heartfelt conversation Sebastian just couldn’t help himself.
Sebastian kept breaking one promise after the other and still had the audacity to just take and give nothing in return.
A thief through and through.
What was the moral of the story?
You can be a thief and take and lie and just be as selfish as you want with no real consequences and get everything you ever wanted because in the end it was unfair of your partner to want honesty and you shouldn’t have to change even if your not a good person?
I felt no real spark between Sebastian and Morgan most of the time especially because Sebastian constantly ignored Morgan’s boundaries and kept pushing.
It felt manipulative.
And I hated his constant lying because Morgan deserved better.
Even after some heartfelt conversation Sebastian just couldn’t help himself.
Sebastian kept breaking one promise after the other and still had the audacity to just take and give nothing in return.
A thief through and through.
What was the moral of the story?
You can be a thief and take and lie and just be as selfish as you want with no real consequences and get everything you ever wanted because in the end it was unfair of your partner to want honesty and you shouldn’t have to change even if your not a good person?
September 1, 2023
I previously read and enjoyed the novella The Bachelor's Valet by this author and saw this one recommended by a friend. Overall I enjoyed the book, and the writing is uniformly good. I did have a difficult time getting into the story, even with the clever maigical system and the vivid descriptions. When the events sort of repeated themselves, I was thinking this might have been stronger as a novella. However, the characters are wonderfully drawn and it might have just been my scattered brain that couldn't settle on the story for a bit. I'll definitley try another book in the series.
May 28, 2024
The book was cute enough, I guess, but I did not vibe with Sebastian and his absolute ass of a personality. The heists were fun and the sprinkles of magic were an interesting idea but I felt like the more I got into the book the less I liked Sebastian and how little I enjoyed his relationship with Morgan.
July 25, 2023
This was tremendous fun! A fast-paced trip around the life of jewel thief Sebastian, who runs into a greatly missed childhood friend one day, and can’t quite let him go again. We catch up with old friends from the Flos Magicae series, as Sebastian bounces off them on his way to yet more illegal activities. The dialogue is smart and snappy, the magic is intriguing, and the romance is lovely, even if they are both pillocks!
This feels like it belongs to the same universe as KJ Charles’ Spectred Isle, which is in no way a criticism - I’ve really loved both books. I’m also a big fan of books set in 1920s London, with its decadent parties and gorgeous clothes. There’s really nothing about A Thief and a Gentleman that I didn’t enjoy - I’ll be adding it to my rereading shelf, right next to The Bayou.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This feels like it belongs to the same universe as KJ Charles’ Spectred Isle, which is in no way a criticism - I’ve really loved both books. I’m also a big fan of books set in 1920s London, with its decadent parties and gorgeous clothes. There’s really nothing about A Thief and a Gentleman that I didn’t enjoy - I’ll be adding it to my rereading shelf, right next to The Bayou.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
dnf
June 26, 2024DNF at 3%. There's nothing wrong with this book - I'm just writing this for my own records. I realized I wasn't in the mood to read about a loveable thief character.
July 24, 2024
Messy second chance
criminals and aristos
nonsense. Charles lite.
criminals and aristos
nonsense. Charles lite.
August 8, 2023
dnf @ 36%
really thought i'd just push through and get this book over it but nope not doing this anymore. there have been so many instances of a character saying no to being seduced only to be met with the main character repeatedly trying to do exactly the opposite of what's been asked of him. the whole premise is nothing but icky and i know they both really have feelings for eachother but you don't force consent onto someone and i simply don't want to keep reading a second more of this story
really thought i'd just push through and get this book over it but nope not doing this anymore. there have been so many instances of a character saying no to being seduced only to be met with the main character repeatedly trying to do exactly the opposite of what's been asked of him. the whole premise is nothing but icky and i know they both really have feelings for eachother but you don't force consent onto someone and i simply don't want to keep reading a second more of this story
December 2, 2024
Instead of paying for bad fanfiction, just play "Tally Ho" by Kreg Segall. No need to endure Haze from Wish when you can have the real thing, all for yourself 🫶
July 30, 2023
This book had a very strong beginning. In fact, I couldn't put it down and very well ruined my sleep cycle. But the truth is, a lot of the themes and issues that were developed in the beginning weren't really satisfied in the later half.
The biggest thing, Sebastian's relationship with his own criminal activity. He wants to be free of it, saying that he's constantly afraid, and dreams of a life where no one recognized him as a thief, etc. But when he blatantly defends his actions, saying that he will always be like this, I got a hundred mixed signals of what he actually wants. Morgan said, "I don't want to change your spots, or anything else about you." But isn't that Sebastian's goal, to change? What is his goal then, if not that? I was so confused. The constant defending of pickpocketing was not endearing. It wasn't like he was Robin Hood. He stole from everyone, and refused to change. I have no idea why.
Sebastian: "He hates that I'm a thief."
Me: That's bad because...?
Also, I had a problem with Sebastian being so butthurt about not being trusted when he was blatantly lying to Morgan.
Morgan: "I want to believe you. But I can't help feeling that you've been lying to me from the moment we met."
Sebastian: That shouldn't have hurt, considering the truth of it
No, sorry, you shouldn't feel hurt. You should feel guilty, ashamed, take your pick. But hurt wasn't something I could sympathize with.
Another thing. The argument about the what-if bailout. Sebastian gets offended Morgan will not hypothetically bail him out of jail, should the need arise. What? Why? If someone doesn't bail you out, it means they care enough to want you to punished and unlearn bad habits, and be less prone to them in the future. It's hard medicine, but often times irl, when you see things like a mom not wanting to bail her son out of jail to because of criminal activity, it's because she understands that there is nothing she can do for him, so she has someone else teach the lesson. It's always hard to watch, but it's such an admirable decision for a loved one to do.
It was very clear that the book thought bailing someone out and not having them deal with any consequences, and go back to the criminal life they lead, is the moral high ground, which is what Morgan eventually admitted he would do. Thieving was treated like just a quirky personality trait.
Rant over. I really loved the dynamics. I thought Sebastian's relationship to sex also went unresolved. The beginning was great. The devlopment of said relationship was poor.
That's about it!
The biggest thing, Sebastian's relationship with his own criminal activity. He wants to be free of it, saying that he's constantly afraid, and dreams of a life where no one recognized him as a thief, etc. But when he blatantly defends his actions, saying that he will always be like this, I got a hundred mixed signals of what he actually wants. Morgan said, "I don't want to change your spots, or anything else about you." But isn't that Sebastian's goal, to change? What is his goal then, if not that? I was so confused. The constant defending of pickpocketing was not endearing. It wasn't like he was Robin Hood. He stole from everyone, and refused to change. I have no idea why.
Sebastian: "He hates that I'm a thief."
Me: That's bad because...?
Also, I had a problem with Sebastian being so butthurt about not being trusted when he was blatantly lying to Morgan.
Morgan: "I want to believe you. But I can't help feeling that you've been lying to me from the moment we met."
Sebastian: That shouldn't have hurt, considering the truth of it
No, sorry, you shouldn't feel hurt. You should feel guilty, ashamed, take your pick. But hurt wasn't something I could sympathize with.
Another thing. The argument about the what-if bailout. Sebastian gets offended Morgan will not hypothetically bail him out of jail, should the need arise. What? Why? If someone doesn't bail you out, it means they care enough to want you to punished and unlearn bad habits, and be less prone to them in the future. It's hard medicine, but often times irl, when you see things like a mom not wanting to bail her son out of jail to because of criminal activity, it's because she understands that there is nothing she can do for him, so she has someone else teach the lesson. It's always hard to watch, but it's such an admirable decision for a loved one to do.
It was very clear that the book thought bailing someone out and not having them deal with any consequences, and go back to the criminal life they lead, is the moral high ground, which is what Morgan eventually admitted he would do. Thieving was treated like just a quirky personality trait.
Rant over. I really loved the dynamics. I thought Sebastian's relationship to sex also went unresolved. The beginning was great. The devlopment of said relationship was poor.
That's about it!
July 30, 2023
Arden Powell is quickly becoming an autobuy author for me. This is their first novel I have read and they were all amazing.
This one is about an ex-convict who is a jewel thief. After being kicked out of his lover's house, he seeks out a naive rich man to con and give him a roof over his head. He comes across a childhood friend with whom he'd lost contact and is dared to seduce him. However, Morgan may prove to be more than Sebastian bargained for and soon he may have to decide between jewels and love.
The premise of this book is very up my alley. I think we deserve more jewel thief plot lines. In here we get some exciting heists in the breaks between romance and relationship development. It's simple but perfectly executed.
The characters is where the story really shines. I loved Sebastian very much with all his messiness. He is the type who'd joke and flirt to hide any sort of geniuine feeling. He sabotages everything that may be good for him and learning to trust is extremely difficult.
Morgan is a complete opposite. He is a stable presence, as soon as he comes into Sebastian's life. A lot of characters describe him as boring but I have never felt that way. He is careful and a bit repressed but he is also very reliable and kind, a safe haven to Sebastian's storm.
The side characters are also charming. Kitty and Adam are good friends to Sebastian and always ready to help while also not taking his shit. We also have cameos from other characters from this series and I was happy to see Alphonse and Jacobi doing well.
The romance is delicious. While Sebastian fights against his feelings for Morgan like a feral cat, Morgan is sweetly pining and has been probably since they were kids. That, however, doesn't stop him from making sure Sebastian doesn't fuck him or himself over. They teach each other how to be better and the childhood friendship gives another layer of sweetness to their relationship.
The writing style, as always, is beautiful. Arden manages to create this rich atmosphere in all of their books and while in those series it's less visible than in their horror stories, everything is still beautifully described and the dialogue and banter are a delight.
All in all, this is absolutely a new fave from this author and a must read if you are a fan. Moreover, of you are into the queer gaslamp fantasy romances, this is absolutely one for you.
This one is about an ex-convict who is a jewel thief. After being kicked out of his lover's house, he seeks out a naive rich man to con and give him a roof over his head. He comes across a childhood friend with whom he'd lost contact and is dared to seduce him. However, Morgan may prove to be more than Sebastian bargained for and soon he may have to decide between jewels and love.
The premise of this book is very up my alley. I think we deserve more jewel thief plot lines. In here we get some exciting heists in the breaks between romance and relationship development. It's simple but perfectly executed.
The characters is where the story really shines. I loved Sebastian very much with all his messiness. He is the type who'd joke and flirt to hide any sort of geniuine feeling. He sabotages everything that may be good for him and learning to trust is extremely difficult.
Morgan is a complete opposite. He is a stable presence, as soon as he comes into Sebastian's life. A lot of characters describe him as boring but I have never felt that way. He is careful and a bit repressed but he is also very reliable and kind, a safe haven to Sebastian's storm.
The side characters are also charming. Kitty and Adam are good friends to Sebastian and always ready to help while also not taking his shit. We also have cameos from other characters from this series and I was happy to see Alphonse and Jacobi doing well.
The romance is delicious. While Sebastian fights against his feelings for Morgan like a feral cat, Morgan is sweetly pining and has been probably since they were kids. That, however, doesn't stop him from making sure Sebastian doesn't fuck him or himself over. They teach each other how to be better and the childhood friendship gives another layer of sweetness to their relationship.
The writing style, as always, is beautiful. Arden manages to create this rich atmosphere in all of their books and while in those series it's less visible than in their horror stories, everything is still beautifully described and the dialogue and banter are a delight.
All in all, this is absolutely a new fave from this author and a must read if you are a fan. Moreover, of you are into the queer gaslamp fantasy romances, this is absolutely one for you.
July 25, 2023
thank you so much to booksprout for providing me with a free digital arc of this book. i am leaving this review voluntarily and all opinions are my own.
this is my first time reading arden powell but certainly not my last. this book was an absolute delight. from the setting to the plot to the characters to the writing—i was in love from the very first page.
sebastian is one of the rare main characters who i loved from the very beginning. he is funny and confident, cunning and smart. but he is so much more beyond that as well. he is deeply haunted by his past, struggling to trust anyone but himself and his parther in crime, kitty. witnessing him open up to morgan and allowing himself to finally stay instead of constantly running away was so heartwarming and rewarding.
morgan... oh morgan. what an absolute gem. i loved him from the very second he was introduced. despite being closed-off and broody at first, he is such an endearing character. he's caring and creative, kind and simply a good person. watching him come out of his shell was great. i loved that he still kept his shy demeanour but also allowed himself to let lose a little.
the dynamic between the two main characters as well as the side characters was excellent. the build-up and development of their friendship and romance felt incredibly natural, as did their fights. their chemistry was off the charts, and every time sebastian pushed a little and morgan didn't pull away, i found myself giggling. i love it when romance books manage to make me truly root for the main couple. i truly hope this isn't the last time we get to see morgan and sebastian.
A THIEF AND A GENTLEMAN is a historical romance set in 1920s london with magic, a seductive thief haunted by ghosts of the past, and a closed-off artist hungry for a little more than what his day to day life has to offer. this book is perfect for everyone who wants to lose themself between the pages in a world so similar yet so different than our own. if you loved a marvellous light by freya marske, be sure to give this one a go as well.
this is my first time reading arden powell but certainly not my last. this book was an absolute delight. from the setting to the plot to the characters to the writing—i was in love from the very first page.
sebastian is one of the rare main characters who i loved from the very beginning. he is funny and confident, cunning and smart. but he is so much more beyond that as well. he is deeply haunted by his past, struggling to trust anyone but himself and his parther in crime, kitty. witnessing him open up to morgan and allowing himself to finally stay instead of constantly running away was so heartwarming and rewarding.
morgan... oh morgan. what an absolute gem. i loved him from the very second he was introduced. despite being closed-off and broody at first, he is such an endearing character. he's caring and creative, kind and simply a good person. watching him come out of his shell was great. i loved that he still kept his shy demeanour but also allowed himself to let lose a little.
the dynamic between the two main characters as well as the side characters was excellent. the build-up and development of their friendship and romance felt incredibly natural, as did their fights. their chemistry was off the charts, and every time sebastian pushed a little and morgan didn't pull away, i found myself giggling. i love it when romance books manage to make me truly root for the main couple. i truly hope this isn't the last time we get to see morgan and sebastian.
A THIEF AND A GENTLEMAN is a historical romance set in 1920s london with magic, a seductive thief haunted by ghosts of the past, and a closed-off artist hungry for a little more than what his day to day life has to offer. this book is perfect for everyone who wants to lose themself between the pages in a world so similar yet so different than our own. if you loved a marvellous light by freya marske, be sure to give this one a go as well.
October 3, 2023
I didn't realize until partway through that this was book 3 in a loosely connected series, but I definitely didn't mind! This book is so unique and creative and fun and I ended up totally devouring it. The idea of a magical 1920s London was super interesting and well developed, especially the way the magic was described and explored. I also really liked reading about these characters. While I'm used to the pairing of "uptight, repressed blond" and "chaotic brunette" that seems to happen a lot in queer fiction (which I'm not complaining about because I eat it up every time), this had a super creative twist to it with Sebastian, our chaotic brunette, being a thief and serial sugar baby. The dynamic between Sebastian and Morgan was also really enjoyable to read with its constant tightrope of trust vs deception and vulnerability vs pretend.
I did wish we'd seen more depth and development to Sebastian as a character bc I feel like we got these tantalizing glimpses of introspection that didn't quite come to as much fruition as I wanted before the book ended. There was just some interest backstory and motivation there that could have been grappled with further. But I still very much enjoyed him as a character and his relationship with Morgan.
The writing overall was solid with some truly lovely moments of description and voice. But there were also portions that fell a bit flat and relied too much on "telling" for my taste, which may have added to my issue with the lack of development in Sebastian. There were also a few typos and grammatical errors, which weren't horrible but did distract me out of the story a bit.
Overall, this read very fast and I found myself constantly wanting to read it and see what happened throughout! Lots of fun, a nice romance, and definitely making me go back to read the previous books in the series to get more of this world and the author's style!
I did wish we'd seen more depth and development to Sebastian as a character bc I feel like we got these tantalizing glimpses of introspection that didn't quite come to as much fruition as I wanted before the book ended. There was just some interest backstory and motivation there that could have been grappled with further. But I still very much enjoyed him as a character and his relationship with Morgan.
The writing overall was solid with some truly lovely moments of description and voice. But there were also portions that fell a bit flat and relied too much on "telling" for my taste, which may have added to my issue with the lack of development in Sebastian. There were also a few typos and grammatical errors, which weren't horrible but did distract me out of the story a bit.
Overall, this read very fast and I found myself constantly wanting to read it and see what happened throughout! Lots of fun, a nice romance, and definitely making me go back to read the previous books in the series to get more of this world and the author's style!
July 25, 2023
I enjoyed this book so much! Con artist jewel thieves struggling with the notion of Feelings is always my catnip, and I have really liked all the other books in the flos magicae series, so my hopes were high here, and it did not disappoint.
The development of the relationship between Sebastian and Morgan was very well done, allowing the time for Sebastian to move deeper into his feelings and for both of them to start to lower their guards, without dragging it out for too long.
The use of magic is absolutely one of my favourite things here too - how the world building lets magic take on a substantial role in itself, basically another character, or range of characters, with personality, needs and desires of their own.
The (human) side characters were superb, both those from earlier books - this book stands alone no problem, but having read the other books certainly adds extra depth - and especially the New characters of Kitty and Adam. I would love to read more of Kitty's backstory, I completely adored her!
I did feel that I would have liked to have delved a little more into Sebastian as he opened up and dropped his guard at the end, especially in terms of being upfront with Morgan about the depth of his fears. I felt the book began to go there but there was a lot more to be teased out. On the other hand, there was so much more that could be delved into, that an additional teasing out would not have mined the depths without say, another whole book (yes please!!!) And I did thoroughly believe in the HEA so it definitely did enough for me. I'm just greedy! (But seriously, a sequel would also work so so well!)
Overall, a book and two characters that completely stole my heart.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The development of the relationship between Sebastian and Morgan was very well done, allowing the time for Sebastian to move deeper into his feelings and for both of them to start to lower their guards, without dragging it out for too long.
The use of magic is absolutely one of my favourite things here too - how the world building lets magic take on a substantial role in itself, basically another character, or range of characters, with personality, needs and desires of their own.
The (human) side characters were superb, both those from earlier books - this book stands alone no problem, but having read the other books certainly adds extra depth - and especially the New characters of Kitty and Adam. I would love to read more of Kitty's backstory, I completely adored her!
I did feel that I would have liked to have delved a little more into Sebastian as he opened up and dropped his guard at the end, especially in terms of being upfront with Morgan about the depth of his fears. I felt the book began to go there but there was a lot more to be teased out. On the other hand, there was so much more that could be delved into, that an additional teasing out would not have mined the depths without say, another whole book (yes please!!!) And I did thoroughly believe in the HEA so it definitely did enough for me. I'm just greedy! (But seriously, a sequel would also work so so well!)
Overall, a book and two characters that completely stole my heart.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 20, 2023
3.5 stars
This author's writing is seriously addictive! I love how they set up a story and their character interactions are always so fun to read.
Sebastian's only hope of living the high-class life he craves is stealing and conning so that's exactly what he does. He just needs some comfortable lodging while he can work out the heist of stealing London’s most notorious jewels. When a friend dares him to seduce Morgan Hollyhock—rich, handsome, and incredibly boring—Sebastian thinks he’s found the perfect mark. There’s just one problem. He and Morgan have history, and he’s unprepared for the flood of emotions when he sees Morgan again for the first time in twenty years.
Sebastian is an intriguing character. In a lot of ways, he could come across as unlikeable, being a con artist and a thief with little regard to anyone other than his closest friends. And yet I also found him sympathetic and charming. There were some moments where I didn't enjoy the romance. Even though Morgan set clear boundaries I felt like Sebastian was always trying to wriggle around them or blatantly ignore them, which rubbed me the wrong way. He always excused it as "Well if Morgan didn't want to he would tell me" but that's not always how that works.
And I wish we'd got to know Morgan a bit better. From what we read about him I really loved his character but I wish we'd seen more of his background, the reason behind him being so closed-off.
The magic in this book was also intriguing, especially in how Sebastian used it for his heists. I love the world in which this series is set. And, speaking of, it was lovely seeing some of the previous characters. I especially enjoyed seeing a glimpse of Alphonse and Jacobi being happy together. I definitely preferred The Bachelor's Valet but I also enjoyed aspects of this story too.
This author's writing is seriously addictive! I love how they set up a story and their character interactions are always so fun to read.
Sebastian's only hope of living the high-class life he craves is stealing and conning so that's exactly what he does. He just needs some comfortable lodging while he can work out the heist of stealing London’s most notorious jewels. When a friend dares him to seduce Morgan Hollyhock—rich, handsome, and incredibly boring—Sebastian thinks he’s found the perfect mark. There’s just one problem. He and Morgan have history, and he’s unprepared for the flood of emotions when he sees Morgan again for the first time in twenty years.
Sebastian is an intriguing character. In a lot of ways, he could come across as unlikeable, being a con artist and a thief with little regard to anyone other than his closest friends. And yet I also found him sympathetic and charming. There were some moments where I didn't enjoy the romance. Even though Morgan set clear boundaries I felt like Sebastian was always trying to wriggle around them or blatantly ignore them, which rubbed me the wrong way. He always excused it as "Well if Morgan didn't want to he would tell me" but that's not always how that works.
And I wish we'd got to know Morgan a bit better. From what we read about him I really loved his character but I wish we'd seen more of his background, the reason behind him being so closed-off.
The magic in this book was also intriguing, especially in how Sebastian used it for his heists. I love the world in which this series is set. And, speaking of, it was lovely seeing some of the previous characters. I especially enjoyed seeing a glimpse of Alphonse and Jacobi being happy together. I definitely preferred The Bachelor's Valet but I also enjoyed aspects of this story too.
July 27, 2023
I really enjoyed this latest installment in the Flos Magicae universe! After reading A Novel Arrangement, which was wonderful, I was delighted that the author's writing continues in this novella to be engaging and strong. Sebastian is a great MC: flamboyant, pouty, flirty, unashamed, desperately lonely but pretending he isn't...and of course a thief with grand aspirations. I was happy that there was a strong connection with A Novel Arrangement story-wise: not only do we see the couples from the previous novels, but they specifically talked about a jewel thief...and that's Sebastian (and his partner Kitty)! It was fun to see other sides to this 1920s universe: the club Eden as a haven for queer people, and the criminal side of things with the multiple heists in this book.
The magical aspect continues to be interesting and build on itself, this time we see some security magic and the theory of where magic comes from and what it can do is expanded upon.
I loved Kitty - in fact all of the women in the series are entertaining and well-written.
I will say I found Morgan a little too aloof and hard to read - while I know that was intentional since we are only getting Sebastian's POV, it was a little frustrating. I'm not sure I fully understood why Morgan was as guarded as he was.
I'm also not sure I fully buy into their childhood bond. I think that could have been developed a bit more. It doesn't really get detailed until the latter half and I think it's a little late in the game. Still, a great addition to the series!
I was provided an ARC by Booksprout in exchange for an honest review.
The magical aspect continues to be interesting and build on itself, this time we see some security magic and the theory of where magic comes from and what it can do is expanded upon.
I loved Kitty - in fact all of the women in the series are entertaining and well-written.
I will say I found Morgan a little too aloof and hard to read - while I know that was intentional since we are only getting Sebastian's POV, it was a little frustrating. I'm not sure I fully understood why Morgan was as guarded as he was.
I'm also not sure I fully buy into their childhood bond. I think that could have been developed a bit more. It doesn't really get detailed until the latter half and I think it's a little late in the game. Still, a great addition to the series!
I was provided an ARC by Booksprout in exchange for an honest review.
February 18, 2024
This was my second read in the Flos Magicae series, and I enjoyed this just as much as the first. I want to read all the books in the series now.
Sebastian is a thief and con artist who is between jobs, and planning the heist of a lifetime with his partner in crime, Kitty. He runs into Morgan Hollyhock, whom he had known as a boy and renews the acquaintance. A bet with Kitty's boyfriend, Adam, to seduce Morgan has Sebastian make a deal with Morgan. But the more time he spends with Morgan, the more Sebastian finds himself getting emotionally invested. But Morgan is respectable, staid and completely disapproving of Sebastian's thieving ways. Can Sebastian have his cake and eat it too?
This was a fun read, and Sebastian is such an interesting character. I loved the magical system and how Sebastian can talk to magic and do things that others can't. I laughed at how some of the magics he encountered were like overeager puppies rather than the guard dogs they were supposed to be.
The world of Flos Magicae is an alternate universe London in the 1920s and it's well realised. Magic is common but not flaunted. I loved the world building, especially the enchanted make up which can make people stand out as well fade away in crowds. Sebastian's unique abilities were very intriguing.
Warnings for panic attacks and PTSD.
I cried at times too, just because Sebastian's emotions were too much for me and for him too.
Recommended for anyone who likes queer books, fantasy, romance and magic.
Sebastian is a thief and con artist who is between jobs, and planning the heist of a lifetime with his partner in crime, Kitty. He runs into Morgan Hollyhock, whom he had known as a boy and renews the acquaintance. A bet with Kitty's boyfriend, Adam, to seduce Morgan has Sebastian make a deal with Morgan. But the more time he spends with Morgan, the more Sebastian finds himself getting emotionally invested. But Morgan is respectable, staid and completely disapproving of Sebastian's thieving ways. Can Sebastian have his cake and eat it too?
This was a fun read, and Sebastian is such an interesting character. I loved the magical system and how Sebastian can talk to magic and do things that others can't. I laughed at how some of the magics he encountered were like overeager puppies rather than the guard dogs they were supposed to be.
The world of Flos Magicae is an alternate universe London in the 1920s and it's well realised. Magic is common but not flaunted. I loved the world building, especially the enchanted make up which can make people stand out as well fade away in crowds. Sebastian's unique abilities were very intriguing.
Warnings for panic attacks and PTSD.
I cried at times too, just because Sebastian's emotions were too much for me and for him too.
Recommended for anyone who likes queer books, fantasy, romance and magic.
September 9, 2023
Some things I liked and some I disliked in this book. It’s well written, plenty of suspense, a decent storyline, interesting characters, some humour. I read the whole thing and I won’t if I’m not enjoying it. But I really didn’t like the way Sebastian spoke to Morgan, telling him he had a stick up his arse, calling him frigid, rigid, repressed. I found it patronising, judgemental and rude. He practically tells Morgan to ‘cheer up love’ at one point, telling Morgan to stop looking so serious as if it’s ok to tell someone to change their facial expression. I get the feeling we’re supposed to like Sebastian and this isn’t an intentional character flaw, I suspect the author doesn’t realise it’s not ok to speak to a person like this. Also creeped out by the fact Sebastian has relationships with men to scam money out of them. He was so pushy in his persual of Morgan, to the point of harassment.
I suspect the author is not a Brit, there’s a few wrong words and phrasings, especially for 1920’s. I correctly predicted there would be a ‘you don’t get to….’ and sure enough that phrase popped up, I hate that phrase.
I suspect the author is not a Brit, there’s a few wrong words and phrasings, especially for 1920’s. I correctly predicted there would be a ‘you don’t get to….’ and sure enough that phrase popped up, I hate that phrase.
October 2, 2023
In all, there was too much Sebastian and too little Morgan.
This was a quick, relatively lighthearted read that captured my attention almost immediately. There was potential in both the plot and the characters that I think could have been fleshed out a bit further to not feel so rushed.
Sebastian had a strong start that was progressively worn down by his inconsistent internal monologue among other things. Over time, Sebastian became incessant, petty, and chaotic. I was turned off by his attempts to get Morgan into bed after being asked to stop (repeatedly) and (repeatedly) lying that he would. Maybe it would have been better if Morgan was the one to initiate the intimacy and in turn going against his own better judgment.
On the other hand, I wish we could have gotten some insight into Morgan's thoughts, feelings, experiences, etc. He was so serious and stoic with little to no glimmer of actual personality which could have potentially been fixed with a dual perspective. I regret to say that the spark was just not there for me in any aspect.
This was a quick, relatively lighthearted read that captured my attention almost immediately. There was potential in both the plot and the characters that I think could have been fleshed out a bit further to not feel so rushed.
Sebastian had a strong start that was progressively worn down by his inconsistent internal monologue among other things. Over time, Sebastian became incessant, petty, and chaotic. I was turned off by his attempts to get Morgan into bed after being asked to stop (repeatedly) and (repeatedly) lying that he would. Maybe it would have been better if Morgan was the one to initiate the intimacy and in turn going against his own better judgment.
On the other hand, I wish we could have gotten some insight into Morgan's thoughts, feelings, experiences, etc. He was so serious and stoic with little to no glimmer of actual personality which could have potentially been fixed with a dual perspective. I regret to say that the spark was just not there for me in any aspect.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews