Gorgeous photos and delicious-sounding recipes. This is one a rarity for me since I'm rating without having cooked anything from it yet, but my purpose in reading it was to get a better handle on Spanish food in general. While the recipes look solid and sound wonderful, they are only for American kitchens in areas that have lots of access to seafood and specialty meats, cheeses, vinegars, etc. While the chef does make alternate ingredient suggestions, even the alternates are often not available outside major cities. So my rating is based on not only how much I enjoyed reading the book and what I think of the contents, but is heavily slanted toward how practical it would be for me to cook from it and accessibility to ingredients (very little to both). If I were to live in LA, Chicago, NYC or Atlanta, I would rate it much higher.
I have huge respect for Chef Andres' work and dedication to helping others, but maybe before labeling a cookbook 'for American kitchens," he really needs to get out of Miami, Dallas, DC, and Los Angeles, and take an extended tour through the middle of the country and it's mostly smaller towns where access to international or specialty ingredients is often limited. And while, yes, just about anything can be ordered on-line, most people can't justify the cost simply to try a new recipe.