The first critical biography of J. Gresham Machen, examining the full arc of his intellectual career
J. Gresham Machen is known as a conservative hero of the fundamentalist-modernist controversy. But was he always so staunchly antimodernist?
In this sweeping new biography, Richard E. Burnett examines the whole of Machen’s life and career—from his early years at Princeton, to his experience in the First World War, to his founding of Westminster Theological Seminary . Burnett pays special attention to topics that have received little attention from biographers, like Machen’s crisis of faith and his support for historical criticism of Scripture.
Incorporating all of Machen’s major works as well as his previously unpublished private correspondence, Burnett crafts a nuanced narrative of Machen’s intellectual journey from enthusiastic modernist to stalwart conservative. Nuanced and thorough, Machen’s Hope will challenge scholars’ assumptions about Machen and his dynamic era.
I first encountered the name J. Gresham Machen in college. Although I didn't take Greek in college, the first-year Greek class used his grammar. When I got to seminary, I found out more about him in Jack Roger's Philosophical Theology class where we discussed the Rogers and McKim book The Authority and Interpretation of the Bible: An Historical Approach and later from reading George Marsden's book on fundamentalism. My understanding of Machen is that he was an arch-conservative who broke both with Princeton Seminary and the Northern Presbyterian Church. As is often true, the story is more complicated than what I had understood.
Richard Burnett, a Presbyterian (PCUSA), editor, and director of the MA program in Reformed Theology at the University of Dubuque Theological Seminary, offers us a magisterial biography of Machen that focuses on his transformation from someone who embraced the modern idea of the university represented by Johns Hopkins, the first modern university in the nation, one that followed a more German university model. After his education at Johns Hopkins and then at Princeton where he studied New Testament at the seminary, where BB Warfield still held court, and a graduate degree in philosophy at the University, he spent time at Gottingen and Marburg universities, studying with leading German scholars. When Woodrow Wilson became President of Princeton University, he supported Wilson's attempt to modernize the university along the lines of Johns Hopkins. He wasn't necessarily a liberal but he was committed to creating a system of higher education that was scientifically oriented. When he joined the faculty of the Princeton Seminary, after deciding against pursuing doctoral studies in Germany, he sought to raise the educational standards of the seminary so that they reflected that scientific mindset.
Over time, however, Machen began to abandon that modernist impulse and ultimately embraced an antimodernist theology. In this biography, which is based largely on letters that Machen wrote to colleagues, friends, and especially his mother, Burnet focuses not on the closing years when Machen left Princeton and founded Westminster Theological Seminary along the lines of the old Princeton of Warfield, and the Presbyterian Church for a new Orthodox Presbyterian Church, which he helped found. While he moved ultimately to an antimodernist position, he eschewed the fundamentalist label, though fundamentalists sought his support. The reason for this is that while he had moved to a more conservative position, he found the fundamentalists to be too anti-intellectual for his taste. So, we see a continuance of that desire for a high level of intellectual engagement.
Burnet lays out helpfully Machen's struggle with his faith, as he sought to balance his commitment to strong intellectual foundations with a more conservative theological heritage. We learn that Machen's roots, especially through his mother, were in the Deep South. We see elements of racism in his views. Politically, though he supported Wilson who was a family friend as he ran for the Presidency, he was quite libertarian in his views. He favored limited government, such that the government has as little involvement as possible in daily life.
Ultimately, what we encounter here is a very complicated person who sought to apply to theology and the study of the Bible all the tools of the scientific study of the Bible, together with an ongoing commitment to supernaturalism. This is where he found resistance to his perspectives on theology, including his defense of the virgin birth and his major study of Paul's theology.
Machen's hope was rooted in this desire for the establishment of a strong scientifically based university education, along the lines of Johns Hopkins. But what he discovered was that his pursuit of intellectual excellence ran aground on the emergence of a much more secular vision than he was willing to embrace. Thus, in the end, he traded that vision of a strong university version of scholarship for Christian scholarship, of the sort rooted in Old Princeton, a vision he once sought to jettison but now embraced in Westminster Seminary. As Burnet writes, in these later years "There was no more talk about university ideals. The hope he once had in the ideals of the New Princeton had been crucified, dead and buried. Now he hoped for the resurrection of a new, transfigured form of the Old Princeton" (p. 568).
One might ask why we might need a new biography of J. Gresham Machen, especially if like me you are not part of a conservative Reformed tradition. It's a good question. One thing I've found reading biographies of theological leaders whether Bonhoeffer, Barth, Brueggemann, or in this case Machen, is that context matters. When we read biographies such as this one we discover how choices made impact the direction our journeys take. One thing that I kept wondering about had to do with Machen's decision not to pursue doctoral studies in Germany. It's clear had an affinity for Germany, had made friends there, and respected the teachers he had there, which included Wilhelm Herrmann (one of Barth's teachers) and Adolph Julicher (Marburg). How might his life story changed had he gone that route?
This is truly a magisterial study of a somewhat enigmatic but influential figure. His Greek Grammar continues to be used to this day. The seminary he founded continues to thrive. For conservative Christians of a Reformed bent, his voice continues to beckon. So, if we wish to understand how one moves from liberal to conservative perhaps this is a book to explore.
I was greatly impressed by this biography of J. Gresham Machen. This book is more of an intellectual biography, as it explores Machen's thought and interaction with the ideas of his day. A prior knowledge of 19th and 20th century German theology helps to make sense of the author's engagement with theologians such as Hermann, Julicher, Bultmann, Strauss, and others. Also, a basic understanding of the "History of Religions" school and "Quest for the Historical Jesus" will aid the reader. This book changed my perspective on Machen and also gave me a greater appreciation for his work. Admittedly, the book is intended for a very niche audience. Therefore, I would be selective about who I recommended this to.
The thesis of this book is that the young J. Gresham Machen (1881-1937) at first endorsed the scholarly advance of contemporary German universities while later opposing the theological modernism that they helped introduce to the United States. I certainly don’t claim to have Machen’s intellectual, spiritual, or philosophical depth, but the intellectual tension reminded me of my own graduate years, half a century ago, when I simultaneously attended a major research university and a storefront fundamentalist church and felt at home at both and at neither.
Although Burnett writes clear and careful prose, his disquisition is, shall we say, deliberate. It’s 600-pages long. Putting the best spin on that length, I quote George Marsden, who calls it “impressively detailed and comprehensive.” Burnett takes leisurely excursions into (among other things) Machen’s upper-class Southern background, the rise of Johns Hopkins University, nineteenth-century German higher criticism, and the intellectual and religious conflicts that divided Princeton University and Princeton Seminary during the early twentieth century. Even a sympathetic reader may be tuckered out by it all.
“Machen's Hope: The Transformation of a Modernist in the New Princeton,” is what one might call an “intellectual biography” of J. Gresham Machen, who was a Professor, Presbyterian leader, and warrior in the battle for the inspiration and sufficiency of the Holy Scriptures in Presbyterian life in the 1920s and 1930s. Richard E. Burnett uses Machen’s (and others’) writings, and personal letters to show Machen’s progression from a “modernist” (the author’s word) to the confessional churchman who battled theological liberalism until his death in 1937. As one whose theological journey went down many rabbit trails before I settled into the ecclesiastical setting where I have remained for the last 30-some-odd years, I was amused at the seeming surprise of the author at Machen’s journey. Unless one has a great interest in Machen’s life, or the Presbyterian controversies of the early twentieth century, reading this book will, quite frankly, bore you to tears. Full disclosure: Although a bit tedious at times, I still managed to enjoy it; especially Machen's letters back and forth with his Mom. (813 pages)
An excellent (partial) biography of a great man. It's long (about 600 pages), but it's so well-written that I desired more. It shows how Machen's philosophical attitude towards modernism and criticism changed over the course of several decades. The book is helpful in understanding how the Fundamentalism v Modernism controversy came about, and how one great mind in particular slowly wrestled with the issues. The author is part of the PCUSA, but is very charitable towards Machen, while giving an honest evaluation of his faults.
“‘Machen’s Hope: The Transformation of a Modernist in the New Princeton’ [offers] readers the chance to learn, in just under 600 pages, lessons that took J. Gresham Machen a lifetime to understand.”