3.5 stars
My biggest criticism of this book: it's written for an organized person.
What I mean by that is it's not written for the average, disorganized or chaotic people--it's written for people who already have some motivation and ability to get their life organized. Some of the suggestions are so detailed, specific and idealistic that the average person will not have time, motivation or long-term commitment to follow them. While some suggestions can be taken by anyone at any level of organization, a lot of them are not designed for people who really struggle with organization in the first place. As the author is a self-proclaimed very-organized-person (she even tells a cute story about her first organization realizations when she was a kid), she shows her expertise throughout the book, but she does it from an organized person's perspective--not thinking about how someone who's at a level much below hers would be functioning. As she's grown up organized and basically says she's been organized her whole life, her tips are good, but on the other hand she doesn't really understand the disorganized person's dilemma.
If you want to be super, ultra, extremely organized, way beyond the normal level and the level you'll find in other organizing books, this book WILL be good for you. But in order to become that organized, you've got to have a LOT of time, motivation and money--and if you are lacking one of those, you will have a very difficult time becoming organized. This book expects you to have all three. And it expects you to be extremely detail-oriented and to take lots of your time on small tasks, which, yes, will make you more organized - but add up to take a lot of your time and energy, which most people don't have much to spare.
An example of what I'm talking about:
"if you don't know why phone calls are taking up so much of your time, fill out this sheet:" (17)
-Time
-Person
-Originator
-Precall Activity
-Subject
-Length
>>>> Now, there's nothing wrong with a call log, that's actually a good idea if you find phone calls are taking up a decent amount of your time. But, why the need for all those details - is the "precall activity" or "subject" or "time" really necessary? Just write down who called you, for how long, and about what. Patterns will quickly emerge. For the average person, that's good enough.
As well, I'm sure another common complaint is that this book offers many, many suggestions that require money - hiring a cleaning person, babysitters, personal shopper, etc. Those aren't the best examples, but she will often recommend hiring someone to do work for you. There's nothing wrong with this, but again it does not take into account people who cannot afford that--or who don't have lots of time to do the work themselves.
My third complaint is that the book is incredibly outdated. There were entire sections I'd skim through or skip because they were from the 1990s. This book was for a time when paper dominated record keeping, email was like a new thing, PDAs were a thing, mail and letters were big things, using computers wasn't a natural skill, the Internet was pretty new, etc. While some of the tips still hold, a bunch of them are now irrelevant and the book could be updated.
The standout sections were at the end -- all the ones to do with kids. The author has rounded up a collection of great, thoughtful, creative and sometimes unique ideas in this area. I would pick up the book just for those chapters (even if you ignore everything else).
One of the best strengths of this book was the fact that it was so encompassing--almost any area you could think of in your life that could be organized, was in here. From procrastination, personal time, calendars, home organization, schedules, chores, kids, errands/shopping/etc. the author did a fantastic job of creating a well-rounded book.
Because I don't travel often, and when I do travel I already have a pretty good & simple system for myself (make a list of all the things to take, based on past lists, and pack), I skipped most of the sections on travelling, although I did read part of the section on traveling with kids (just for fun) and it was good!
I understand the principle, but I disagree with her idea that you should NEVER have a junk drawer. If you mean a 'drawer you throw junk in without any regard', I agree. But if you mean a drawer with various items--such as scissors, tape, keys, vitamins, batteries, matches, rubber bands, and other little bits & pieces of things that need to be stored somewhere but don't have another home--then yes, I disagree. If you organize the drawer properly once, you should be able to keep it neat and organized. Using tiny boxes/small organizers especially helps.
The author has good tips on organizing expectations of a spouse or someone you live with. Also love the encouragement of colour-coding. 👍
Overall, I'm conflicted if I would fully recommend this book to others. Some parts of it are great, but the others are sometimes overly-detailed, outdated, expecting people to prioritize organization above all other chores/tasks/life demands. Almost no one will find all the sections relevant, so you can skip whatever you're not interested in. However, if there is a certain area you are interested in, you might find a few gems in here, so for that reason I would say: pick it up, skip what you don't need, and just read the parts you do. The good news is that there's both a table of contents and index at the back for easy finding.