I have learned a great deal from Steven Forrest's books. I love the way that he brings alive the fixed and effective concepts and techniques of traditional astrology with a poetic vision that bursts forth in images that stay in the reader's mind and enrich our understanding of the signs, houses, transits, etc. His book about the Moon's nodes in the context of evolutionary astrology, Yesterday's Sky, was a masterpiece.
But this book is dissapointing, though there were flashes of Forrest's brilliance scattered through it that still makes it worthy of being read. The central flaw here is that Forrest seems to have fallen in love with a theory--a way of interpreting the the 8 phases of the moon based on the analogous Celtic way of breaking the seasons down into 8 points--and jimmied it into classic astrology, a role it isn't up to, and which with it's 8-fold divisions does not mesh well with traditional astrology and chart interpretation.
I applied his scheme, in particular the use of progressed moon phases, to several charts I know very well (of older people who have gone through several progressed moon phase cycles), and simply did not see the techniques described in this book describing the way those lives unfolded or, for that matter, making the charts more meaningful. This was in great contrast to several of his earlier books which had deeply enriched my understanding of those charts.
Forrest argues that the moon is about the inner life--desires, mood, impulses etc,, only to illustrate his description of each phases with external events from the lives of celebrities--people whose inner development is unknown to us. The fact that some rock star put out an album when the progressed phase of the moon was such and such, isn't enough to justify the interpretations Forrest has invented for that phase. We don't know anything what the inner journey of these celebrities are about, and even Forrest isn't suggesting that these phases are useful for predictive work.
In short, nothing Forrest presents here validates what is, when all is said and done, a scheme whose interpretation Forrest himself invented from whole cloth. This is very different from bringing alive the underlying schema of classical astrology that have held up for centuries.
Forrest mentions that other authors' moon phase theories had not worked for him, which when his did not work for me, made me wonder if philosophizing about moon phases is a pitfall for those who are drawn to philosophizing and become tempted to impose structure on an elusive phenomenon.
There is some good stuff in this book. Forrest is eloquent about looking at the sky and getting a feel for the planets from their actual interactions, not just what sortware comes up with. And I came away with an awareness of phases and the role they might play in how planets relate which will stick with me and make me more sensitive to the differences between waxing and waning aspects (i.e. the square between a faster planet approaching a slower one and the square of the same planet leaving the other being different in quality.)
But I came away feeling that imposing the 8-fold phase system that takes up most of this book on charts is probably not a productive use of our astrological time given how much is already there on a chart which performs the same function as the new 8-fold cycles that Forrest imposes on traditional astrology.
Better to think of this book as philosophy, and decouple it from traditional astrology and the reading of charts. This is Forrest philosophizing about the stages of the cycle from emanation to dissolution, from birth to death, a worthy subject, but not really the chart analysis topic he presents it as here.
That said, because Forrest is such an intelligent writer and someone who has thought deeply about life, this book is still worth reading. But if you are looking for astrological techniques that will bring your charts to life and give you more insight that will help you counsel people in how to work through life issues, Forrest's earlier book, Yesterday's Sky, is a much better book.