Holy moly... this was a convoluted one. And I say that in the most complimentary way possible. Harry is once again brought in to solve a case that threatens disaster no matter the outcome, and all the suspects keep ending up dead - which leads to convenient assumption type answers that Harry just doesn't eff with. This case was a riddle inside an enigma spritzed with a little dusting of mystery, and more layered than an onion... and I loved it, while at the same time kind of waiting for the disaster to strike every other sentence.
I have come to realize that this series is now my go to for when I don't know what I want to read, because I know that there's gonna be an interesting case (or two or three) and that Harry's situation is going to be tenuous at best, but despite it all, he's gonna do his damndest to get to the bottom of it... even if it doesn't quite work out the way that all the TV shows imply that it should - with the bad guys being outed and the truth being told, and the good guys winning the day. This series is grim as fuck like that - because the reader knows the truth by the end, but it never really feels like we get closure from it. Realism, I guess.
One thing that made this book particularly difficult to read was the social repercussions of the main plot murder and subsequent investigation. It's no secret that we have some pretty fucked up race relations in the US, and that has not gotten better no matter how many people claim that we're living in post-racism America. (Stop saying this, people. It's just ignorant. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.)
This book was written in 1999, and references the Rodney King beating and subsequent rioting when the cops got off of the charges completely, as well as the OJ Simpson trial. In a way, these two major trials are used as something of a crutch for the attitudes that Harry displays. And, don't get me wrong, I love Harry Bosch - he's one of my favorite detectives, but he's not very... woke. Harry has lived through his own trials and tribulations, but he's still white, and male, and a cop, and as such, has a somewhat more predictable perspective on certain things than what someone else would have. But, to his credit, he is essentially, mostly neutral. He isn't ACTIVELY racist, or sexist, or otherwise shitty... he just acknowledges things based on his own experiences, and if offered a different view of something, doesn't necessarily reject it out of hand, even if he doesn't necessarily understand it. Really, Bosch is open to info, even if it's not what he expects, and that, along with his ethical desire for truth and accountability, is what makes him a great detective and a great character.
But still, this was a difficult book to read knowing that in the nearly 20 years since this was written, and close to 27 years since Rodney King... very, very little has changed. Black people are still being beaten, choked, tazed, and shot and killed by cops (and People "Standing Their Ground" Against Scary Teenagers), and the cop almost never faces any repercussions for it. It's essentially a "We investigated ourselves, and we found that we didn't do anything wrong." situation... again and again and again. It's a problem. One that, as a nation, we need to fix, but apparently would just rather ignore or deflect from.
An example: Just last week a white female officer entered into an apartment in her building that she THOUGHT was hers, but wasn't, and shot and killed the unarmed black male who did live there. She wasn't arrested for 3 days. THREE DAYS... to just go about her life after entering the wrong apartment, pulling her service weapon and murdering the man who lived there. And now info was released that the victim had weed in his apartment, as though that makes it OK for him to be murdered in his own home by a cop who "forgot" where she lived. Absolutely sickening. I'm sure that there's a lot more to this story, but what I've seen so far, a delayed arrest and then what seems to be an attempt to smear the reputation of the victim, does not bode well for justice. :(
Anyway... seeing this from the other perspective - the desire to, at least on the surface, remain transparent and accurately hold a the responsible party accountable (even if the killer turned out to be a cop) in an effort to avoid civil unrest was interesting. It was definitely a political tight-rope walk, especially in LA where, as mentioned, they'd had rioting resulting from a mishandled police accountability case not all that long ago (when this was written). Public perception is key, as well as trust. And... that trust is easily lost, which makes the Police Chief's job of reassuring the public all the harder.
But that brings me to my next point. One of the things that I love about this series is that we get to know the cops that Harry gets to know, and despite Harry's clear as crystal opinions of them, I never really know if I completely trust his views. Meaning that, he may not trust someone, but I'm not convinced that he's always right about them. Harry is unreliable in that way. He behaves and reacts to things in a way that are completely foreign to me, sometimes in purely petty ways, and I find myself wondering why he takes the risks he does when there's next to nothing to gain from it. If he was just to hold his cards a bit, he could actually make a play that matters, but he's always showing his hand. Then, on the flip side, when I think he'd benefit from calling out something that he knows, he sits on it. (HARRY, let's get on the same page here! Why you gotta be so difficult?? Ahh, whatever. You're you, and that's all you can be, and I am down with it.)
But, for instance, I found myself really unsure how to feel about three cops that we've seen throughout the series, and that I would ordinarily be inclined to trust... each for different reasons, DESPITE their repeated... interactions... with Harry, some of which are most definitely Harry's own fault. Harry doesn't share my inclination and suspects them, which I can understand his reasoning for doing, given their history, but needed more than just "Harry says so" to go along with.
I liked how Harry's personal life was tied in, though... it felt a bit like an afterthought and really nothing more than a distraction for Harry. But... as little as there was of Harry's relationship, it actually worked to make me curious about what is going on there. How did things go so far off the rails in such a short time? What's going on with Eleanor? Inquiring minds want to know!
I really do love this series though. I enjoy that each book is interesting on multiple levels, but is also just really enjoyable reading. It is what it is, and can bring up serious social issues without being preachy or annoying about it. I like that.