What do you think?
Rate this book
When Skies Have Fallen #1
Quando o céu desmoronar
Para muitos, em um 1944 devastado pela guerra, o amor floresce no salão de dança, e o aviador Arty Clarke não é exceção. Ele é um pensador e um sonhador; mas não é a bela e talentosa dançarina em seus braços, sua melhor amiga Jean, que inspira seus sonhos. Quando seu olhar encontra o do sargento Jim Johnson, Arty ousa imaginar uma dança diferente.O amor deles é proibido, tanto pelas Forças Armadas quanto pela lei, mas com a astúcia e o apoio de Jean, Arty e Jim tentam diminuir a distância entre os dois e encontrar o amor verdadeiro, apesar do perigo e de um desastre capaz de destruir os sonhos de Arty para sempre.O casal irá resistir, não importa quantos céus tenham caído?
335 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 7, 2015
117 people are currently reading
776 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 139 reviews
September 24, 2022
Oh, Debbie McGowan. Oh, oh, oh.
This is the sweeping story of Artie and Jim, two gay men trying, like everyone else, to survive during WW2. It is obvious right from the start that the author has taken great pains to be historically accurate, giving this epic story validity as a gay historical romance so realistic it will take your breath away.
Have you ever made a snow ball, then rolled it around until it gets bigger and bigger, taking away all the snow and leaving behind only freezing, ruined grass? This story, that is what it does. It starts off sweet and gentle, then gains momentum and grabs every molecule of snow, like an enormous avalanche encapsulating history, morality, friendship, loyalty and love.
It is a story that is indeed about the sky falling, and the world going mad, but in the middle of that maelstrom there are two people and a light that never goes out. To me, that quiet and clever gentleness is Debbie McGowan.
I read this story in parts as it was written, then again last night. Each time I noticed something else, another aspect to this intricate world that the author depicts so starkly. Although it is set almost eighty years ago, too many of the issues in this story are still shouting their nasty voice loudly today. LBGT people around the world are still dictated to by political, economic, religious institutions. Who is the enemy and who is the friend?
I cried a few times when I read this, and so will you. It is a very beautiful story about ordinary people trying to do ordinary things. Does anyone ever win a war? Maybe not, but sometimes, love can triumph :D
Thank you to the author and the LOR team.
A re-read. Still beautiful
July 10, 2015
Just beautiful. This was so much more than I expected.
When Skies Have Fallen is not just the story of two young men meeting and falling in love during WW II but it's also the story of their hard-fought HEA in the aftermath of the war when men who should have been treated as heroes were persecuted because of their love for one another.
I thoroughly enjoyed the development of Arty and Jim's relationship during the war. One English, the other American, they are immediately attracted to one another when they meet at an air force dance. Arty and Jim are cautious and inexperienced and, against the backdrop of war, they fall in love gradually. I love that the relationship develops slowly as it seems true to these men and their times - despite their attraction, they are friends first and then lovers. As war nears an end, Arty and Jim are making plans on how they will be together when tragedy strikes and one is injured. However, they hold each other up, their love stays strong and they are both able to survive the war.
The author could have easily ended at this point with an epilogue showing how Arty and Jim got their HEA. Instead, the author stays true to the time and shows us what happened after.
The second half of the story follows Arty and Jim as they try to build a life together in England. They have wonderful friends who know who they are to each other and Jim, especially, is not afraid to shout it to the world. But this is not a world that is accepting of gay men and there are many struggles for Arty and Jim through this period -- I could not help but draw parallels to other heroes like Alan Turing and what he faced after the war. The one constant for Arty and Jim is their love for one another and, yes, they do make it together. Not only do they get their HEA but they are also part of the fight for justice so that other men like them could be together openly.
There are so many wonderful moments in this book and so much emotion. In my opinion, the author went far and beyond what was asked for in the prompt. This is a completely heartfelt, full-length historical novel. Huge bucketfuls of thanks to the author (and the team at LOR) for giving this to us for free.
Very highly recommended!
When Skies Have Fallen is not just the story of two young men meeting and falling in love during WW II but it's also the story of their hard-fought HEA in the aftermath of the war when men who should have been treated as heroes were persecuted because of their love for one another.
I thoroughly enjoyed the development of Arty and Jim's relationship during the war. One English, the other American, they are immediately attracted to one another when they meet at an air force dance. Arty and Jim are cautious and inexperienced and, against the backdrop of war, they fall in love gradually. I love that the relationship develops slowly as it seems true to these men and their times - despite their attraction, they are friends first and then lovers. As war nears an end, Arty and Jim are making plans on how they will be together when tragedy strikes and one is injured. However, they hold each other up, their love stays strong and they are both able to survive the war.
The author could have easily ended at this point with an epilogue showing how Arty and Jim got their HEA. Instead, the author stays true to the time and shows us what happened after.
The second half of the story follows Arty and Jim as they try to build a life together in England. They have wonderful friends who know who they are to each other and Jim, especially, is not afraid to shout it to the world. But this is not a world that is accepting of gay men and there are many struggles for Arty and Jim through this period -- I could not help but draw parallels to other heroes like Alan Turing and what he faced after the war. The one constant for Arty and Jim is their love for one another and, yes, they do make it together. Not only do they get their HEA but they are also part of the fight for justice so that other men like them could be together openly.
There are so many wonderful moments in this book and so much emotion. In my opinion, the author went far and beyond what was asked for in the prompt. This is a completely heartfelt, full-length historical novel. Huge bucketfuls of thanks to the author (and the team at LOR) for giving this to us for free.
Very highly recommended!
April 18, 2017
5 Stars
Yep, I’m dishing out all the stars for this one.
Beginning in 1944 in war-torn England, and spanning over twenty years, this story follows the epic love shared between British airman Arty Clarke and American Sergeant Jim Johnson.
Their story is one of great romance, but also friendship, loyalty, heartache, injustice and a necessary fight for social change.
I absolutely adored their romance, but I was slightly overcome by many of the situations Arty and Jim faced in this story. Assuming their struggles are historically accurate, I was heartbroken and enraged by some of the challenges they were confronted by throughout, but thankfully Arty and Jim obtained their own HEA by the end. On top of which, I personally feel all the more enlightened on the issues touched upon within, which is always a plus.
Impressively, McGowan shed a necessary light on the inequality and discrimination placed on LGBT individuals of that time, who often faced devastating consequences due to the prejudice and intolerance of others. Thankfully, the world has come a long way since, due to brave, altruistic individuals like Arty and Jim, who fought for social justice and the universal human right for people to love who they want to love, without judgement and fear of persecution.
When Skies Have Fallen has become an instant favourite of mine. I HIGHLY RECOMMENDED it to anyone who is after reading a poignant historical M/M romance – you won’t regret it!
P.S. It's FREE!!!!
Yep, I’m dishing out all the stars for this one.
Beginning in 1944 in war-torn England, and spanning over twenty years, this story follows the epic love shared between British airman Arty Clarke and American Sergeant Jim Johnson.
Their story is one of great romance, but also friendship, loyalty, heartache, injustice and a necessary fight for social change.
I absolutely adored their romance, but I was slightly overcome by many of the situations Arty and Jim faced in this story. Assuming their struggles are historically accurate, I was heartbroken and enraged by some of the challenges they were confronted by throughout, but thankfully Arty and Jim obtained their own HEA by the end. On top of which, I personally feel all the more enlightened on the issues touched upon within, which is always a plus.
Impressively, McGowan shed a necessary light on the inequality and discrimination placed on LGBT individuals of that time, who often faced devastating consequences due to the prejudice and intolerance of others. Thankfully, the world has come a long way since, due to brave, altruistic individuals like Arty and Jim, who fought for social justice and the universal human right for people to love who they want to love, without judgement and fear of persecution.
When Skies Have Fallen has become an instant favourite of mine. I HIGHLY RECOMMENDED it to anyone who is after reading a poignant historical M/M romance – you won’t regret it!
P.S. It's FREE!!!!
June 10, 2020
This story is a free gift from the author, and a Lambda award winner. Beginning in WWII, and moving on through some of the post-war years, this tells of the awakening of a young gay man to the possibilities, joys, and pains, of a fully-lived life. I really enjoyed the period feel of the action and language and tone. The emotions have a water-color lightness, and the phrases echo the time and place. These are not modern young gay men set into a frame of the war in England, but men of their times. The relationship is sweet and slow, and the social setting feels real.
There are moments of love, and moments of pain. Both the war, and the social risks and injustices that follow, form the framework within which Arty, and his American lover Jim, must somehow make a good life. There are mentions of raids on gay men, of the Kinsey report, and other significant historical situations. And yet the mood is warm and focused on the men's future together. Deeply difficult times are sometimes slipped over, and the moments of connection are the backbone of the story. A fascinating and superbly-researched read, not as angsty as it might have been, but deeply believable, almost a comfort read as it brings these men through hard times to their happy ending.
There are moments of love, and moments of pain. Both the war, and the social risks and injustices that follow, form the framework within which Arty, and his American lover Jim, must somehow make a good life. There are mentions of raids on gay men, of the Kinsey report, and other significant historical situations. And yet the mood is warm and focused on the men's future together. Deeply difficult times are sometimes slipped over, and the moments of connection are the backbone of the story. A fascinating and superbly-researched read, not as angsty as it might have been, but deeply believable, almost a comfort read as it brings these men through hard times to their happy ending.
July 11, 2015
How on earth do you write a review of a story like this?
I won't lie. I cursed Debbie McGowan up and down over the last two days. And seriously wept while reading this book. Not just tears for two fictional characters but for all the real people these two represent.
As I cried I also made a mental list of the people I wanted to read this. Not something I have ever done before.
I love this story. Perhaps more than anything I have read from this author. And that says a great deal because I already Ioved this author.
Never has there been a more beautiful, heartbreaking, and hard won HEA. But this story is more than just a romance. This is the story of the lives of two men. A tale spanning 23 years, during a social climate that is hard to imagine. It's a lesson in history. It's a reminder of how far we are have come and how very far we still have left to go.
So, how on earth do you write a review of a story like this?
I have absolutely no idea.
July 8, 2015
I have read every single one of Debbie McGowan’s books and this one stands head and shoulders above all of them.
In the interests of full disclosure, I feel it prudent to mention that I’m also married to her but that is inconsequential. I’m also probably her fiercest critic.
When Skies Have Fallen is at times, a touching romance, a tear jerker, an emotional roller coaster if you’ll excuse the cliches. But not withstanding, a bloody good read.
It is also however, and in my opinion more importantly a brilliantly told piece of social commentary of the story of many many gay men living though war time (and beyond) Britain and how they were treated by the establishment.
This is essentially the story on the ‘other’ unknown soldier. To all the gay military personnel who could never be themselves or risk, imprisonment (or worse). This could be their story.
Read this book. History demands it.
In the interests of full disclosure, I feel it prudent to mention that I’m also married to her but that is inconsequential. I’m also probably her fiercest critic.
When Skies Have Fallen is at times, a touching romance, a tear jerker, an emotional roller coaster if you’ll excuse the cliches. But not withstanding, a bloody good read.
It is also however, and in my opinion more importantly a brilliantly told piece of social commentary of the story of many many gay men living though war time (and beyond) Britain and how they were treated by the establishment.
This is essentially the story on the ‘other’ unknown soldier. To all the gay military personnel who could never be themselves or risk, imprisonment (or worse). This could be their story.
Read this book. History demands it.
May 24, 2016
Let me begin this review by saying two things. First, I don’t review many books—I’m a writer, not a book reviewer. But I’m also a reader. And once in a while, often once in too great awhile, I read a book that is different, that offers more than the standard fare, that touches something in me. “When Skies Have Fallen” is exactly such a book.
The second thing is more of a disclaimer. Not only do I consider Deb a friend, she is also my publisher. So to avoid any conflicts of interest, I don’t usually review her books, of which there are many; she is enviably prolific. Yet, this book is so remarkable to let our relationship silence me was unfair to Deb and to any readers I could encourage to read this book.
Arty Clarke, Englishman and Texan Jim Johnson meet each other in, of all places, a dance hall, during the war in the 1940s; they are serving their respective countries, fighting a war neither of them is sure he believes in. We get a very real feel for who each man is—through their shared love for each other, and their devotion to the adorable strays they take under their wing; from Arty’s geek-like knowledge of butterflies, and Jim’s sweet expressed interest in said butterflies, to Jim’s fierce refusal to slip on the hair shirt of shame for loving another man. No pretty pampered insulated boys, are these two. They love through injury and separation and the enmity of those who would condemn them.
The writing is simple and effective an d never overshadows the story being told. One of my favorite lines is simply this: “Arty turned into Jim’s embrace, the smile that usually greeted him absent, in its place manifest passion he was unable to resist.”
At the end when Arty regains something we—and he—assumed had been lost forever, I just about wept with joy.
So, if you’re ready for something that is not the all-too-familiar boy-meets-boy day one, boy shags boy day two and continuously thereafter, this is a book not to be missed. It is most justifiably a 2016 Lambda Literary Award finalist.
The second thing is more of a disclaimer. Not only do I consider Deb a friend, she is also my publisher. So to avoid any conflicts of interest, I don’t usually review her books, of which there are many; she is enviably prolific. Yet, this book is so remarkable to let our relationship silence me was unfair to Deb and to any readers I could encourage to read this book.
Arty Clarke, Englishman and Texan Jim Johnson meet each other in, of all places, a dance hall, during the war in the 1940s; they are serving their respective countries, fighting a war neither of them is sure he believes in. We get a very real feel for who each man is—through their shared love for each other, and their devotion to the adorable strays they take under their wing; from Arty’s geek-like knowledge of butterflies, and Jim’s sweet expressed interest in said butterflies, to Jim’s fierce refusal to slip on the hair shirt of shame for loving another man. No pretty pampered insulated boys, are these two. They love through injury and separation and the enmity of those who would condemn them.
The writing is simple and effective an d never overshadows the story being told. One of my favorite lines is simply this: “Arty turned into Jim’s embrace, the smile that usually greeted him absent, in its place manifest passion he was unable to resist.”
At the end when Arty regains something we—and he—assumed had been lost forever, I just about wept with joy.
So, if you’re ready for something that is not the all-too-familiar boy-meets-boy day one, boy shags boy day two and continuously thereafter, this is a book not to be missed. It is most justifiably a 2016 Lambda Literary Award finalist.
July 11, 2015
I don't think I have words to do this story justice. I love all Debbie McGowan's books, but this one really is outstanding.
What makes it so powerful for me, is the juxtaposition of the writing style with the events being described. It is not written to be bitter or angry, and so this quiet dignity reinforces the ferocious stupidity of ignorance and inequality.
A lot of reviews say this is a devastating story, but for me this was not so much about the guys - because I knew Debbie would bring them home - but simply because the book is so bloody fantastic.
Standing ovation to you, Debbie McGowan.
What makes it so powerful for me, is the juxtaposition of the writing style with the events being described. It is not written to be bitter or angry, and so this quiet dignity reinforces the ferocious stupidity of ignorance and inequality.
A lot of reviews say this is a devastating story, but for me this was not so much about the guys - because I knew Debbie would bring them home - but simply because the book is so bloody fantastic.
Standing ovation to you, Debbie McGowan.
July 11, 2015
A review is coming awesomely soon. :D
August 9, 2015
Even in war, just the simple act of giving oneself over to the music could soothe away every trouble.
Wow, I want to thank the author for this absolutely lovely and great book that she contributed to this year's writing project of the M/M Romance Group.
WHEN SKIES HAVE FALLEN is a free 250 pages long novel about Arty and Jim, set in historic England, and spanning the time from 1944 near the end of WWII until 1967 when being homosexual was no longer prosecuted.
Though Arty and Jim face many challenges through the war and their private life after, this is a very romantic and mostly light, feel-good read. The author created two wonderful man that I loved reading about.
This is a drama-free book, which I appreciated very much. It is very sweet and romantic, without getting sappy. There are great supporting secondary characters and cats ;-) and dancing :D
I loved every minute of it and recommend the book.
Wow, I want to thank the author for this absolutely lovely and great book that she contributed to this year's writing project of the M/M Romance Group.
WHEN SKIES HAVE FALLEN is a free 250 pages long novel about Arty and Jim, set in historic England, and spanning the time from 1944 near the end of WWII until 1967 when being homosexual was no longer prosecuted.
Though Arty and Jim face many challenges through the war and their private life after, this is a very romantic and mostly light, feel-good read. The author created two wonderful man that I loved reading about.
This is a drama-free book, which I appreciated very much. It is very sweet and romantic, without getting sappy. There are great supporting secondary characters and cats ;-) and dancing :D
I loved every minute of it and recommend the book.
July 12, 2015
I love LOVE historicals. Especially well written, well researched ones. And this was both of those things. I also love stories written around WWII, because it seems like one of those eras we forget in romance. And wow this had some meat on it for a free read from the Love is and Open Road event. Great book, and I definitely recommend it. Although, there was conflict, but I felt like for the time—and as a historical romance enthusiast, here—perhaps not ENOUGH conflict.
But very well done.
But very well done.
December 10, 2015
As I was getting into bed the other night at 3.am, blearily rubbing my eyes and mentally listing out the stuff I was going to put off from doing the next day, it suddenly occurred to me that I'm a big fan of Debbie McGowan but I actually haven't read any of her work?????? Like, what???? That was crazy dumb!
So to rectify this grievous error I immediately downloaded a pdf of When the Skies Have Fallen (yes, at 3 am) and then I fell asleep while I was waiting for it to download (I've have very spotty internet because of awful weather)
Then I got up today morning and finished it in one sitting (2-3 hours I think?) and I was like... Why didn't I read this sooner??
Then I could have read it again twice by now.
Because this book is so worth the rereads.
And I'm not saying it just because I know the author or anything, but seriously, it has been a while since I read a book like this that's simple in its complexity but still so profound and moving and amazing and uguuuuuuuuuuu I CAN'T I CAN'T WITH THIS PERFECTION *flaps around squealing*
I feel like I can easily say why I didn't like a certain book, or speak at least somewhat intelligently about books I do like, but when it comes to books I really love, the books that really deserve eloquent discussions and intelligible praise, all I can do is flail like an upturned cockroach and squeal excitedly.
Hrmmmm.
Anyway, I'll try.
I said this book was simple. Well, many people wouldn't call a book simple when it is set during the WWII and also deals with the LGBT issues that existed at the time.
When I say it's simple, I mean the basic plot line. There are no dramatic twists or turns or grandiose declarations of love or extraordinary circumstances or anything like that. Or rather there are, but none of them felt like a plot device. I could sum it up as 'Two men fall in love with each other during the war, they face challenges, but eventually they get a happy ending.' I could sum it up like that, but that's a terrible disservice to the beautiful prose and the flawless storytelling that makes this book what it is. There are twists, and there are declarations of love, and there are extraordinary circumstances, but all of them are woven together so deftly, so organically, that at times it feels like it isn't fiction at all.
I think that's what makes this book so wonderful: how extraordinary it is in its ordinariness. How beautifully it portrays the day-to-day of that time, making it something... above ordinary, and truly special. A tale of different people coming united by a beast as cruel as war, and how they live their lives in the aftermath.
It made me weep tears of outrage as well as joy, took me along on Arty's and Jim's journey as if I was right there with them. I snorted when DH Lawrence read to Arty while he was stuck in hospital, the rose arch scene made me laugh and roll my eyes and sigh with the perfectness of that moment, and when the officers came in the middle of the night, it made my gut clench in dread and apprehension.
And the first night Artie and Jim spend together? I think that was the first time I actually became overwhelmed with emotion while reading asmutty bit scene featuring love making (I'm sorry I tried to phrase it elegantly but this is all I can do atm whoops).
Artie and Jim will be a couple I remember for a long time.
And that epilogue, and the last dance? Sheer. Perfection.
Perfection, I tell you!!11!!!!
AND THIS BOOK IS TOTALLY FREE LIKE WHAT EVEN HOW DID WE GET SO LUCKY GAHHH
My deep and sincere thanks to the author, the DRitC team, and the prompter for being responsible for this great story.
So to rectify this grievous error I immediately downloaded a pdf of When the Skies Have Fallen (yes, at 3 am) and then I fell asleep while I was waiting for it to download (I've have very spotty internet because of awful weather)
Then I got up today morning and finished it in one sitting (2-3 hours I think?) and I was like... Why didn't I read this sooner??
Then I could have read it again twice by now.
Because this book is so worth the rereads.
And I'm not saying it just because I know the author or anything, but seriously, it has been a while since I read a book like this that's simple in its complexity but still so profound and moving and amazing and uguuuuuuuuuuu I CAN'T I CAN'T WITH THIS PERFECTION *flaps around squealing*
I feel like I can easily say why I didn't like a certain book, or speak at least somewhat intelligently about books I do like, but when it comes to books I really love, the books that really deserve eloquent discussions and intelligible praise, all I can do is flail like an upturned cockroach and squeal excitedly.
Hrmmmm.
Anyway, I'll try.
I said this book was simple. Well, many people wouldn't call a book simple when it is set during the WWII and also deals with the LGBT issues that existed at the time.
When I say it's simple, I mean the basic plot line. There are no dramatic twists or turns or grandiose declarations of love or extraordinary circumstances or anything like that. Or rather there are, but none of them felt like a plot device. I could sum it up as 'Two men fall in love with each other during the war, they face challenges, but eventually they get a happy ending.' I could sum it up like that, but that's a terrible disservice to the beautiful prose and the flawless storytelling that makes this book what it is. There are twists, and there are declarations of love, and there are extraordinary circumstances, but all of them are woven together so deftly, so organically, that at times it feels like it isn't fiction at all.
I think that's what makes this book so wonderful: how extraordinary it is in its ordinariness. How beautifully it portrays the day-to-day of that time, making it something... above ordinary, and truly special. A tale of different people coming united by a beast as cruel as war, and how they live their lives in the aftermath.
It made me weep tears of outrage as well as joy, took me along on Arty's and Jim's journey as if I was right there with them. I snorted when DH Lawrence read to Arty while he was stuck in hospital, the rose arch scene made me laugh and roll my eyes and sigh with the perfectness of that moment, and when the officers came in the middle of the night, it made my gut clench in dread and apprehension.
And the first night Artie and Jim spend together? I think that was the first time I actually became overwhelmed with emotion while reading a
Artie and Jim will be a couple I remember for a long time.
And that epilogue, and the last dance? Sheer. Perfection.
Perfection, I tell you!!11!!!!
AND THIS BOOK IS TOTALLY FREE LIKE WHAT EVEN HOW DID WE GET SO LUCKY GAHHH
My deep and sincere thanks to the author, the DRitC team, and the prompter for being responsible for this great story.
July 19, 2015
I'm a huge sucker for WWII historicals, so when I saw this listed on the Love Is An Open Road page, I was very excited to read it. What I didn't expect was to read it cover to cover in two sittings overnight. I just couldn't put it down.
The real strength of this book is its characters. Not only do our main characters, Arty and Jim, come to life as very three-dimensional, believable people, but the cast of supporting characters is rich and diverse, adding their own stories and personal struggles into the mix. I very much liked Jean and her battle to come to terms with her expected role as wife and mother after the war, and was glad she was able to realize her dreams almost as much as I was for the main characters to find their happiness together. Joshua, Jim's brother, was also very likable. Charlie I struggled to like as much, but could appreciate that his heart was in the right place even when he expressed it clumsily.
As for all the feelings this book evoked in me... I'm still reeling from them. The yearning of two people deeply in love, but forced to be apart, the fear of living in times when love was a crime, the challenges of life, family, and disability... they're all here, and I dare you to read this book and come away unmoved. An absolute must-read, and one for my favorites shelf.
The real strength of this book is its characters. Not only do our main characters, Arty and Jim, come to life as very three-dimensional, believable people, but the cast of supporting characters is rich and diverse, adding their own stories and personal struggles into the mix. I very much liked Jean and her battle to come to terms with her expected role as wife and mother after the war, and was glad she was able to realize her dreams almost as much as I was for the main characters to find their happiness together. Joshua, Jim's brother, was also very likable. Charlie I struggled to like as much, but could appreciate that his heart was in the right place even when he expressed it clumsily.
As for all the feelings this book evoked in me... I'm still reeling from them. The yearning of two people deeply in love, but forced to be apart, the fear of living in times when love was a crime, the challenges of life, family, and disability... they're all here, and I dare you to read this book and come away unmoved. An absolute must-read, and one for my favorites shelf.
October 25, 2015
I’m not a person who reads historicals, and I tend to avoid war—especially the Second World War. That being said this is one of the most amazing books I’ve read in a long time. Debbie had me crying…several times. How she managed to write this story within the timeframe of DRitC is beyond me. I can’t even phantom the amount of research she must’ve done. Fantastic!
August 4, 2015
What a great story!
Two guys from different sides of the pond meet because of the war and fall in love. This is a story of their journey and of the struggles they went through during the war and after. All the research that must have gone into the writing of this book made it so very believable. As I read it, I felt like a movie was being played out in my mind. i really enjoyed it AND it's a free read! Can't get better than that.
Two guys from different sides of the pond meet because of the war and fall in love. This is a story of their journey and of the struggles they went through during the war and after. All the research that must have gone into the writing of this book made it so very believable. As I read it, I felt like a movie was being played out in my mind. i really enjoyed it AND it's a free read! Can't get better than that.
July 31, 2015
What a great romantic story - two guys fall in love during WW2 and maintain their love for each other through ups and downs until being gay is no longer a criminal offence.
This story is driven by a strong narrative, great characters, realistic events and good writing - it's great.
At the end I had a tear in my eye, as the ending is sweet, true and heartbreaking.
Loved it.
This story is driven by a strong narrative, great characters, realistic events and good writing - it's great.
At the end I had a tear in my eye, as the ending is sweet, true and heartbreaking.
Loved it.
dnf
January 11, 2021DNF at 6%
September 29, 2015
Wow.
Wow. Wow. WOW.
It is safe to say I have never cursed an author as much as I did Debbie McGowan when I was reading this book. When Skies Have Fallen may actually be one of my favourite novels from this author. It is written in such a way that I cannot describe - I was sucked in from the very start, chewed up, regurgitated and spat out. I felt like I'd been through an emotional mangle by the time I finished.
Arty and Jim's plight struck me to the core. This was an educational journey for me as well as an emotional one, and the meticulous research into detail that Ms McGowan is renowned for really pays off in this authentic and heart-wrenching tale. I've never really been a sucker for romance, forbidden love or will they-won't theys, but this book just defies all stereotypes and expectations to be possibly the best book I have read this year.
I dare you to read it and not be touched. I dare you not to cry, to laugh and to dream along with the characters. An absolute stunner.
Wow. Wow. WOW.
It is safe to say I have never cursed an author as much as I did Debbie McGowan when I was reading this book. When Skies Have Fallen may actually be one of my favourite novels from this author. It is written in such a way that I cannot describe - I was sucked in from the very start, chewed up, regurgitated and spat out. I felt like I'd been through an emotional mangle by the time I finished.
Arty and Jim's plight struck me to the core. This was an educational journey for me as well as an emotional one, and the meticulous research into detail that Ms McGowan is renowned for really pays off in this authentic and heart-wrenching tale. I've never really been a sucker for romance, forbidden love or will they-won't theys, but this book just defies all stereotypes and expectations to be possibly the best book I have read this year.
I dare you to read it and not be touched. I dare you not to cry, to laugh and to dream along with the characters. An absolute stunner.
July 25, 2015
Some books entertain. Some make you feel. Some make you think. Then there are those cherished stories, the ones that burrow deep, that offer all three. This is such a story. Beautifully crafted with an attention to historical detail that enriches and truly brings Arty and Jim’s world to life.
Theirs is a world ravaged by war and rife with social injustice made worse (or possible) by cruelty or ignorance or just plain apathy. It is also a world in which the light of hope flickers like a beacon thanks to the kindness of some, the love of others, and the incredible resilience of the human spirit. And at the heart of all of this are Jim and Arty and the ardent and tender and enduring love they have for each other. That is the true inspiration.
Thank you to Debbie McGowan for participating in this year’s M/M Romance Love is an Open Road writing event and to Tiffany for a stellar prompt.
Theirs is a world ravaged by war and rife with social injustice made worse (or possible) by cruelty or ignorance or just plain apathy. It is also a world in which the light of hope flickers like a beacon thanks to the kindness of some, the love of others, and the incredible resilience of the human spirit. And at the heart of all of this are Jim and Arty and the ardent and tender and enduring love they have for each other. That is the true inspiration.
Thank you to Debbie McGowan for participating in this year’s M/M Romance Love is an Open Road writing event and to Tiffany for a stellar prompt.
July 8, 2015
This was absolutely fabulous. Falling in love amidst the terrors of WWII, knowing their love is criminal in the eyes of the law, but finding support in amazing friends and family members, Jim and Arty do what they have to do to stay together. Utterly brilliant in the emotional writing, this took my breath away.
Free from the M/M Romance group's Love Is An Open Road event.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
My gratitude to the author.
Free from the M/M Romance group's Love Is An Open Road event.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
My gratitude to the author.
May 28, 2019
4.5*
This was marvelous. I cried, it was angsty for sure but is really one of the most amazing love stories I've read. Through WWII, the persecution, horrific unfair punishments, fear and hiding, these men's love persevered and my heart is so full right now.
The narration was hard to get used to at first, but as it went on I found it fit, is like listening to an old record. Tim Hillborne transported me there.
This was marvelous. I cried, it was angsty for sure but is really one of the most amazing love stories I've read. Through WWII, the persecution, horrific unfair punishments, fear and hiding, these men's love persevered and my heart is so full right now.
The narration was hard to get used to at first, but as it went on I found it fit, is like listening to an old record. Tim Hillborne transported me there.
January 25, 2017
Oh the feels...
This book is delightful.
From the characters to the scene setting to the story to the heart break to the emotion tugging on my heartstrings.
It's beautiful and so much more than I expected.
This book is delightful.
From the characters to the scene setting to the story to the heart break to the emotion tugging on my heartstrings.
It's beautiful and so much more than I expected.
November 14, 2018
Actual Rating: 3.5 stars
When Skies Have Fallen is a very optimistic historical gay romance despite it being set during and after World War II. It's a story filled with enough kindness to heal wounds.
What I liked the most is the overflowing positivity this book radiated when it came to Arty and Jim's relationship. They loved bravely and truthfully and had adequate support from some of the people dearest to them.
I really enjoyed this book, but I think it could've been better if the first half of it was shortened and the latter half lengthened to make room for more depth. The post-war events introduced more of the LGBT community's struggles back then, but did not elaborate them that well. The author, in my opinion, should have lessened the fluff the book contained and focused more on the issues at hand, especially those in the last three to four chapters. I wanted to see Arty and Jim really fight for each other because all I got were glimpses in those supposedly-major events.
When Skies Have Fallen is a very optimistic historical gay romance despite it being set during and after World War II. It's a story filled with enough kindness to heal wounds.
What I liked the most is the overflowing positivity this book radiated when it came to Arty and Jim's relationship. They loved bravely and truthfully and had adequate support from some of the people dearest to them.
I really enjoyed this book, but I think it could've been better if the first half of it was shortened and the latter half lengthened to make room for more depth. The post-war events introduced more of the LGBT community's struggles back then, but did not elaborate them that well. The author, in my opinion, should have lessened the fluff the book contained and focused more on the issues at hand, especially those in the last three to four chapters. I wanted to see Arty and Jim really fight for each other because all I got were glimpses in those supposedly-major events.
March 21, 2018
Beautifully written freebie from Debbie, published in 2015 under the Goodreads Love is an Open Road banner, and unfortunately buried on my kindle ever since. 🙁
Set in WWII and going forward until 1967, when the Sexual Offences Act in the UK decriminalised homosexual acts in private between 2 men over the age of 21. We meet Arty, a young RAF mechanic, and Jim, over in the UK with the US Army, who spot each other across a crowded dance hall. 😍😍 I'm not going into any more detail, I can only highly recommend this read to you...ENJOY!!
Set in WWII and going forward until 1967, when the Sexual Offences Act in the UK decriminalised homosexual acts in private between 2 men over the age of 21. We meet Arty, a young RAF mechanic, and Jim, over in the UK with the US Army, who spot each other across a crowded dance hall. 😍😍 I'm not going into any more detail, I can only highly recommend this read to you...ENJOY!!
September 8, 2018
3.5 stars
This reminded me a lot of Kaje Harper's Into Deep Waters. Two guys meet during WWII, fall in love and decide to make a life together. One gets injured near the end of the war. We see them as they grow older, living through the various social and political changes and victories for gay rights. They get cats. And that's pretty much where the similarities end.
Arty and Jim are air force technicians, Arty for the Brits, Jim for the Americans. They first see each other at a dance hall, where the attraction is instant. They officially meet later at Jim's base when Jean, a friend of Arty's, finagles a "chance" meeting on a supply run. They figure out a way to see each other, meeting in an empty field between their two bases and slowly fall in love.
It was refreshing to see them actually get to know each other before falling into bed. Logistically, they couldn't have risked it sooner than they did (not that that would stop some authors - and you know who you are) and so the build up of their relationship fits the times and dangers that surround them. Unfortunately, a lot of the getting to know you gets summarized, though we do still get to see enough of it to see the connection between them. That's not really an issue.
What was an issue for me was that they had it so amazingly easy at the start. They're both missing from their bases for hours at a time while they're rendezvousing; this is never an issue. Arty's friends and sister, and Jim's mom, are all amazingly supportive; not really an issue either as there are others who are not that they need to be careful of. But even the nurse is on their side, and the others in the hospital don't seem to raise much of a fuss about anything either. They do come up against plenty of strife later though, as England during this time was extremely homophobic, to the point that gay POWs were made to serve their full prison sentences without taking into account the time already imprisoned by the Nazis. Plus, there were the "witch" hunts, extremely reminiscent of Gestapo searching for Jews, gays and everyone else they deemed unworthy. It was unsettling to read at times, and those parts of the story were very well done with evoking the tension and dread Jim and Arty had to live in.
I was ready to give this 4-stars until the very end, when I thought we'd get to read about Jim and Arty finally deciding to fight the system and instead it jumps to the epilogue several years later, where England has finally decriminalized homosexuality. I wanted to see more of the fight, to see Jim and Arty standing up and being strong together as a unit, and I didn't get that.
And this is just a personal nitpick, but I'm not a fan of the title being repeated in the narrative of the text multiple times. Once or twice is cool, but more than that and I start to feel like I'm being knocked over the head with it. Yes, I get it, the title is metaphorical. Now leave me alone so I can read my book.
This reminded me a lot of Kaje Harper's Into Deep Waters. Two guys meet during WWII, fall in love and decide to make a life together. One gets injured near the end of the war. We see them as they grow older, living through the various social and political changes and victories for gay rights. They get cats. And that's pretty much where the similarities end.
Arty and Jim are air force technicians, Arty for the Brits, Jim for the Americans. They first see each other at a dance hall, where the attraction is instant. They officially meet later at Jim's base when Jean, a friend of Arty's, finagles a "chance" meeting on a supply run. They figure out a way to see each other, meeting in an empty field between their two bases and slowly fall in love.
It was refreshing to see them actually get to know each other before falling into bed. Logistically, they couldn't have risked it sooner than they did (not that that would stop some authors - and you know who you are) and so the build up of their relationship fits the times and dangers that surround them. Unfortunately, a lot of the getting to know you gets summarized, though we do still get to see enough of it to see the connection between them. That's not really an issue.
What was an issue for me was that they had it so amazingly easy at the start. They're both missing from their bases for hours at a time while they're rendezvousing; this is never an issue. Arty's friends and sister, and Jim's mom, are all amazingly supportive; not really an issue either as there are others who are not that they need to be careful of. But even the nurse is on their side, and the others in the hospital don't seem to raise much of a fuss about anything either. They do come up against plenty of strife later though, as England during this time was extremely homophobic, to the point that gay POWs were made to serve their full prison sentences without taking into account the time already imprisoned by the Nazis. Plus, there were the "witch" hunts, extremely reminiscent of Gestapo searching for Jews, gays and everyone else they deemed unworthy. It was unsettling to read at times, and those parts of the story were very well done with evoking the tension and dread Jim and Arty had to live in.
I was ready to give this 4-stars until the very end, when I thought we'd get to read about Jim and Arty finally deciding to fight the system and instead it jumps to the epilogue several years later, where England has finally decriminalized homosexuality. I wanted to see more of the fight, to see Jim and Arty standing up and being strong together as a unit, and I didn't get that.
And this is just a personal nitpick, but I'm not a fan of the title being repeated in the narrative of the text multiple times. Once or twice is cool, but more than that and I start to feel like I'm being knocked over the head with it. Yes, I get it, the title is metaphorical. Now leave me alone so I can read my book.
February 26, 2016
This historical WWII didn't break my heart in the same way that the previous ones from the same time period did. The war and the suffering didn't rip me open and leave me heaving. No, this one accomplished that showing the non war related suffering and persecution from the time. Arty & Jim were such vividly alive characters and it was an honor to go on this journey (no matter how hard in places) with them. Special mention of how wonderful the side characters were here. From friends to siblings, these men had a fantastic support network that I wish everyone could have.
July 8, 2018
I found it an incredibly moving story and a stark reminder of how difficult life was for gay people when being homosexual was against the law.
And yet, even nowadays so many LGBTQ+ people are still living a lie -even here in Britain- just to 'fit in' and not to upset friends or loved ones. We still have a long way to go...
When Skies Have Fallen show us how live can survive and blossom against all odds.
Definitely one of my all-time favourites!
And yet, even nowadays so many LGBTQ+ people are still living a lie -even here in Britain- just to 'fit in' and not to upset friends or loved ones. We still have a long way to go...
When Skies Have Fallen show us how live can survive and blossom against all odds.
Definitely one of my all-time favourites!
May 31, 2016
3.5 stars.
This book was very well written.
It was beautiful and captivating, and I just loved every minute of the first half of the story.
The second half, though, which is about the years that followed ww2, was slow moving, and uneventful.
It picked up again in the last 10% or so, and all in all it was a beautiful story about true love, that is not based or even ignite, by lust.
It's about love that stands tall in the face of war, of hate, of distance, of illness...
Wonderful!
This book was very well written.
It was beautiful and captivating, and I just loved every minute of the first half of the story.
The second half, though, which is about the years that followed ww2, was slow moving, and uneventful.
It picked up again in the last 10% or so, and all in all it was a beautiful story about true love, that is not based or even ignite, by lust.
It's about love that stands tall in the face of war, of hate, of distance, of illness...
Wonderful!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 139 reviews