Maybe a one star rating is too harsh. There's really nothing "bad" about the book, it just didn't do a thing for me. I've been a home schooling mom for 14 years and read plenty of books on the subject, so I'm fairly familiar with all the modes and methods of schooling your children. This one I purchased for 0.99 on kindle and read it in one sitting. The only thing that was interesting was the ending, where Joyce Swann highlighted each of her 10 children and explained what their adult lives look like.
Obviously Joyce was very successful in her homeschooling endeavors, as each of her children are now adults, working hard in their respective fields. Rigid is a word I'd use to discuss her home school. She used the same curriculum and method for each one of her children, at an accelerated rate. The result was that they all earned college degrees by the age of 16. I'm happy for her, I really am, but in reality, no one (except her) produces identical children. Her one-size-fits-all educational formula would doom 98% of homeschoolers to failure.
Her writing style was stilted and dry. When one son had severe medical problems that went undiagnosed by doctors, and when she herself was pinned underneath the family van resulting in long months of recovery, she wrote with the same voice she used in explaining household chores. This woman seems devoid of all emotions. None of them had learning problems. None of them ever complained or struggled. Everyone spent 2.5 hours per day, 5 days a week, 52 weeks a year at the table completing their school work. They all attended the same college on the same schedule in the same way. They all somehow landing incredibly lucrative positions with seeming ease.
I really did not find this book encouraging. If I were a struggling home school mom, questioning my own competence, wondering if I'm doing more harm than helping my children, I would undoubtedly feel like a complete failure after reading this. She's just too perfect to be real.