What do you think?
Rate this book


288 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1981

In this case, the TV adaptation is definitely more nuanced than this particular installment of Sharpe. Not least because of the Spanish actress Assumpta Serna, who played Teresa Moreno (and, of course, Sean Bean as Sharpe—he is simply matchless).
In the film, Teresa Moreno is a vibrant personality, whereas in the book, she is reduced to the status of an incidental inanimate object. On the whole, female characters are a weak point for Cornwell, but it is particularly glaring in this book. From the first page to the last, he refers to her simply as “the girl” and nothing more. Meanwhile, Sharpe comes across as even more of a blockhead than in the previous books.
Otherwise, all the standard ingredients are present: a secret order, gold, bad Spaniards, bad Frenchmen, good Germans, a siege, and amidst all the smoke—Sharpe, who has to maneuver in every direction for the sake of the gold and his own skin. The action is engagingly entertaining as always, but Cornwell follows the exact same formula everywhere in a rather tedious manner, with no variations and no character growth. The TV series clearly put more effort into this aspect.
I hope the next book is a bit more dynamic in terms of character development, rather than just nonstop gunfire. War is so much more than the schematic, enthusiastic depictions of mud and sweat in the name of glory that Cornwell swoons over so much.
3.5⭐️