I listened to this with my husband on a long car journey. We enjoyed it! It was fast-paced and engaging and thought provoking, but I had some ISSUES with it.
*spoiler warning for those who care*
The theme of a perfect utopia which turns out to be a sinister dystopia, where people are being disposed of down waste chutes as soon as they stop being useful and nobody is Truly Free, is a bit of a science fiction cliché. Even in the 70s it’d been done many times before, but I don’t think that matters, as long as the author puts a different spin on it.
My main issue was the relationship between Chip & Lilac. ‘Problematic’ is putting it mildly. He claimed to be in love with her but I thought his feelings seemed more like obsession, especially as he tended to focus a lot more on her appearance (e.g. her ‘rose-brown’ skin and ‘conical’(??) breasts) than her personality. She made it very clear on multiple occasions that she did not love him, and in fact was in love with someone else, but that didn’t deter him, heck no. After he kidnapped her it started to become obvious that he expected & felt he was owed sex. Wasn’t she grateful about how he’d RESCUED her?? I mean, it was at gunpoint, with violence and threats, but that was necessary. Plus, he'd spouted his feelings at her and told her about how much he loved her, and on two occasions he hadn’t even raped her when he could have! What was she WAITING for?? When she still steadfastly refused to sleep with him I knew what would happen next, and sure enough. Afterwards he rather reluctantly apologized, while explaining how it wasn't really his fault. She agreed, forgave him, requested sex the very next day, then... no I'm not kidding about any of this... fell in love with him and eventually married him.
What. The. Heck.
I could NOT believe it. I kept holding out hope that she was just playing along and waiting until he was asleep so she could stab him in the kidney, but nada. After they got married she pretty much turned into a submissive housewifey who got pregnant, did the dishes, sewed the clothes, and patted Chip on the back consolingly when he got drunk and embarrassed her at parties. He barely noticed when they had a baby, although of course it had to be named after HIS grandaddy. He was too busy planning his heroic mission, which he did against Lilac's wishes and without consulting her about anything. When she ventured a sensible (and correct, as it turned out) doubt about the plans, he patronisingly dismissed her and told her everything was fine, then worried about it secretly because she totally had a point. Also, near the end, as part of his cunning plan to play along with the programmers, he slept his way around the entire colony including two 16 year old girls at the same time on his first night (he is 37), which I’M SUPER DUPER SURE was a necessary evil, nobly done against his wishes in order to make sure nobody suspected him.
So yeah. I had, like, minus a billion sympathy for this guy, which is perhaps another reason why I found it hard to accept him as a hero.
Was he meant to be a hero? My husband thought maybe the entire novel was intentionally ironic. I’m not sure. It’s possible, but my feeling is that it’s not. I think Chip is genuinely meant to be the ultimate Defender of Freedom of Choice, the only one who can see things the 'right' way. Not just smart enough to escape from drugged oblivion in UniComp, not just a skilled leader and planner who can orchestrate a successful attack on Uni from Liberty island, but also principled enough to withstand being corrupted by the fabulous luxury of the programmers lifestyle! Even being offered basically eternal life in paradise, he STILL fights for the freedom of the human race.
Whether he’s supposed to be or not, we don’t think he IS a hero. He's quite mad, and evil! A megalomaniac, far worse than Wei. So convinced he knows what's best for everyone that he feels qualified to make decisions on behalf of the population of the entire world. He believes the system is corrupt and wrong, so instead of trying to fix it or make it better, he just chucks a bomb into the central hub, deliberately, knowing full well that worldwide chaos, anarchy, war, murder, starvation and BILLIONS OF DEATHS will result. Oh well, I'm sure they'll sort themselves out, right? Not Chip's problem! He's going to nip off back to the island in his chopper so he can sleep with his wife and ignore his baby again, happy in the knowledge that everyone in the world is now Better Off, by his estimation, even if they don't realise it.
He was in a position of power in the programmers group, and could quite conceivably have used that to slowly influence things for the better, to campaign for alteration of the things he saw as wrong, such as euthanizing everyone at 62. At the very LEAST he could have overthrown Wei and taken control himself, if he’s so sure he’s got it right. Wei’s system was corrupt, yes, but it was a functioning, peaceful society free from hunger and pain. Maybe Tom and I are both secret evil commie overlords, but we kind of agreed with a lot of Wei’s decisions, and felt with a few tweaks UniComp could actually have achieved a true utopia. Obviously there were some big problems, but by golly they had SOME things right. No sickness, ever, for the whole world's population! That's amazing! Everyone single person in the world has enough to eat, clothes to wear, and a warm clean place to sleep! Also amazing! Is population planning really too high a price to pay for that?
So yeah, although it aggravated me a little that Chip’s point of view was presented as morally correct and heroic, I liked the fact that other points of view were also introduced. Chip did have some conversations with Wei (and others) where they discussed the ethics of world leadership, freedom and control. The book raised a lot of interesting theoretical points about the way the world is and the way it could be or might be under different circumstances, which we really enjoyed discussing.