I love love love James Herriot's All Creatures Great and Small series (and of course I mean the novels here, although I also adore the ORIGINAL PBS television series starring Christopher Timothy, Robert Hardy, Peter Davidson and Carol Drinkwater/Lynda Bellingham as James, Siegfried, Tristan and Helen, but NOT AT ALL the more recent one, which is majorly, annoyingly different from the books and takes on an artificial and anachronistic feminism and sense of modernity that truly makes me personally cringe). And yes, I absolutely and utterly do adore everything about these novels (which I have read as the omnibuses All Creatures Great and Small, All Things Bright and Beautiful, All Things Wise and Wonderful, The Lord God Made Them All and Every Living Thing) and about James Herriot's (Alfred Wight's) narratives both in general and also more specifically (Herriot's storytelling, his thematics, from the combination of gentle humour and realism to the fact that the Yorkshire Dales themselves almost appear like an individual and living, breathing character, that landscape is as much an integral part of the featured texts as James Herriot and his wife Helen, as Siegfried and Tristan Farnon and as the Yorkshire farmers and eccentric characters like Granville Bennett and Mrs. Pumphrey and her Pekinese Tricki Woo are, and with not just humour but also tragedy, pain and heartbreak being shown and presented, since life as a veterinarian and also as an animal lover of course has its major ups and downs for Herriot and indeed for everyone featured and encountered in the All Creatures Great and Small novels).
However, while my ratings for the All Creatures Great and Small books (for the above listed five omnibuses) have been solidly five and four stars (and totally count as favourite comfort reading treasures for me and are as such also reread constantly), to be honest, albeit the published in 1986 James Herriot's Dog Stories has a nice and very sweetly readable collection of fifty stories from the All Creatures Great and Small series that feature dogs as the main characters and participants (and with a truly lovely introduction by James Herriot that quite glowingly shows him to be hugely and totally a dog enthusiast, an avid dog lover), well, because these canine themed accounts are not actually individual dog tales in and of themselves but basically just bits and pieces that have been taken, that have been gleaned by James Herriot from his veterinarian memoirs, for most if not actually for all of these stories, I sure am missing a lot of the context and the James Herriot as a farm veterinarian scope, feel and vision. And since I actually have always most enjoyed and appreciated the farm veterinarian angle of All Creatures Great and Small and the sequels, how James Herriot is first and foremost catering to livestock and not therefore focussing on and specialising like his friend Granville Bennett does in small animals (pet dogs, pet cats and the like), for me, James Herriot's Dog Stories, they are nice enough, but are basically very much a distant second place to the full texts of the memoirs (with the narratives of James Herriot's Dog Stories feeling a bit like chapters rather strangely yanked out of the omnibuses and existing without adequate beginnings and endings, still decently readable and enjoyable to be sure, but for me and to me, James Herriot's Dog Stories are only a three star reading experience at best and generally work much better in the novels where they originally appear, and I guess I should also point out that any canine based scenarios originally encountered in Every Living Thing would of course not have made their way into James Herriot's Dog Stories, since Every Living Thing was published in 1992 and James Herriot's Dog Stories in 1986).