Well, a bit ago I started Bruce Coville's four part alien saga. I figured now was a good chance to read the next one, with plans to finish it off in the first half of the year. Previously on My Teacher is an Alien, it was a pretty solid read with some clever humor and commentary alongside mostly good characters, but it didn't explain everything and ended on a bit of a rushed note.
Now we have the sequel where it's clear this was all a planned as a big saga. And it's also quite solid, better than the first in a lot of ways now that everything has been settled. This time we pull a Haunted Mask 2 as bully Duncan Doogal is our narrator. He's still a bully but here we find more of his depth. His family is a mess with his brother being a bully to him and his parents being unattentive at best.
With this going on, he tends to act up and such. After the ending of the last book, everyone is kind on edge as spoilers, Peter has vanished. One day while hiding in a dumpster (don't ask), Duncan finds a fake human hand that clues to the fact that aliens are still here even after Broxholm has left.
There are four new teachers this school year, and he must figure out which is the alien. But ontop of that, this experiment in one class fries his brains, making him super smart. This is good at first but like an addict, he goes back to the machine for more and this really creates complications.
So first, I really like the development for Duncan. We already had him soften up a bit in the first but this goes further into him. It captures how someone do a poor job handling a lot of bad stuff going, rather well. There's a bit where he wants to cry but he can't with his brother in the room and he just thinks about how he wishes he wasn't born. Damn.
Speaking of, the dad is straight up abusive, we're told as such. Most of it is past tense but at least one thing we're told was like damn. A bit real there. The smart thing works. He says it's more like he thinks he's dumb rather than being actually dumb which is a bit nuance, although weirdly Brain Juice goes more into that aspect.
This one gets more like a drug allegory, where he can't stop at just one hit. A few layers to this story that made complex. We also finally find out what the aliens are even up to. The mystery of who the teacher alien is is a bit obvious but just because I'm an adult who has read a lot of these, it's not badly done it has a solid misdirect.
The explanation of what is going in makes sense and I was like "yeah that actually checks out". Wow, an explanation in one of these that all works? That's rarer than a unicorn made out of four leaf clovers. The bigger explanation for the aliens adds in extra themes that I know the whole saga gets more into. Let's say we start to go into Weirdo Waldo zone. Oh yeah.
The story flows well, mixing these elements well. It takes a bit to get to the brain frying but I wasn't impatient as I was into Duncan's story. Susan is in this far less but that works fine for what it is. I do feel the writing is a bit weaker here, with too many parenthetical remarks. The first also had more clever humor than this does, although this has its moments.
The abrupt ending is worse here as it's full on to be continued without a more proper ending. That's fine as the next came soon but I do like multi part stories more than they can stand alone better. Still, not a big deal, it just means I'll get to the next one quicker, hopefully next month.
So I wouldn't day it's a step up in a hugely amazing way but it's still pretty good. As a sequel it changes things up well and makes Duncan a solid and fleshed out protagonist. We get solid depth as a few elements are juggled well and it ends on a solid note that makes me wanna push on.
These are shaping to be pretty solid, this one especially. How will things go from here? Find out sometime later, same Bruce time, same Bruce channel.
SIDE NOTES:
This is the first time reading any of these where dumpster is not capitalized. Given it’s done cuz Dumpster was a brand, I wonder how he got away with it.
This says hell, another slightly surprising moment for a book with a few illustrations in it.