I like the approach the author Morey Stettner takes with this book for new managers. As one would expect, it covers most of the topics a new manager would need – and they are handled in a clear and practical way that make it easy to absorb and apply. In addition to that, Stettner is a realist. He doesn’t presume to “know it all” and that his suggestions will fit every new manager’s style or needs. He asks new managers to try them out and adjust to suit. This is an unusual and unpretentious approach for a management “how to” book.
The book starts with asking the new manager to develop his or her personal credo by thinking about the qualities of good managers he/she has previously known or worked for. There’s a practical exercise, “My favourite manager”, that makes this task easy. Once again, the realistic approach comes into play with Stettner making sure that the new manager adjusts his/her ideal to account for their current organisational culture.
I particularly liked his advice on how to start one’s first meeting with new staff to create that all important first impression. I also liked the chapter on “listening” which gives some excellent, practical tips such as the three step tactic of how to avoid becoming defensive – Patience-Ask-Confirm.
The many practical examples made it easy to see how the author’s ideas might work in practice. However, it was a little frustrating when some chapters started with a case study to illustrate the problem, but did not finish the case with examples of how the manager solved the problem (I expected this to happen later in the chapter). I also found some examples a little dated (e.g. “type out your answers”) and there was no mention of a 360 degree tool when discussing how the new manager might seek feedback.
I would have also liked to see more emphasis given to planning and running meetings. There was no mention of how to manage emails. For most new managers these two tasks take a lot of time and focus.
However, overall these are minor criticisms. It’s nice to read a book written by a true professional who understands social psychology and how businesses work, but who doesn’t need to elaborate or preach about either. It’s just full of good, plain, workable advice. Highly recommended for any new manager.