This is Roland Green's second Conan pastiche, and while it's nothing spectacular, it's a noticeable step up from his first instalment, Conan the Valiant. Here, we get to see Conan battle a handful of monsters, navigate a plot of political scheming in Argos, and put his mighty thews to the test against sorcery once more. Conan is Conan, and we spend most of the book with him too, which is a nice change from some of the other pastiche authors who write stories in which Conan makes up 50% of the book at best - and sometimes much less. Some of the supporting cast were also fairly strong, especially Livia and Harphos who both have realistic characterisations and show genuine growth.
And yet, although this book is a step up for Green as a writer, it still falls victim to the flaws that were present in his last pastiche - if not quite so heavily, at least. The prose is hit and miss, sometimes strong but also sometimes messy and unclear to the point of needing to reread sections to fully understand what's going on. And, in typical Green fashion, he can't help but focus excessively on nudity, including once again forcing characters to be naked even in the midst of battle. This book also references Conan first seeing cities as a slave, which only ties in with the Schwarzenegger films, not Howard's actual Conan canon. These flaws, paired with forgettable villains whose motives I honestly could no longer remember before I even finished the book, lodge Conan the Guardian firmly in its spot as a middling entry in the extensive run of Tor's Conan pastiches.
Still, it ends on its highest note, pitching Conan against Lovecraftian slime from the depths of the earth - the Watchers, in their brief appearances, were better villains than the actual sorcerer and his master! - and it did a good job of reeling me back in when my interest had grown lukewarm. All in all, Conan the Guardian is a decent pastiche and one I wouldn't be averse to reading again. Not the best, but far from the worst.
3 stars from me, but a fairly strong 3 stars at that.