I was very optimistic when I picked this book up because: a. the cover is beautiful and b. I love books that fuse genres. I really enjoy noir as a genre, though I'll admit I'm not very versed in it, so it seemed like a good match.
Unfortunately, there were a few things that got in the way of me really enjoying this book.
For one thing, the banter, though good, was a little too much. The degree to which the main characters argued or misunderstood each other got in the way of the plot for me, even understanding that it's a satire. I often felt the same way about the jokes, like the plot's point was to set up jokes, rather than the other way around. Often the side characters they met (like the goblins) did little to advance the plot, and since many of them followed the same kind of formula (weird creature tries to sell Mallory something/has quirky problem he solves), they eventually felt like little more than world-building pieces or joke setups.
The biggest issue I had, however, was the treatment of pornography. It's a noir detective novel. I get that. Characters like Mallory and McGuire often have problems with porn. I get that too. But the degree to which they (and many of the other characters) either downplayed it as a joke or normal, okay behavior really bothered me. And while I can acknowledge genre expectations, that this was a satire half-poking fun at it (for example Nathan's Wings O'Bannon character) and the fact that yes, most men do struggle with pornography, it still bothered me not to see it treated a little more seriously/tragically. I'm not sure what would have fixed this other than having less of it, as that's not really what this kind of book is for, but it just made it less enjoyable for me.
That being said, I do understand that that wasn't the point of the book, and outside of those things, I still really enjoyed the idea of the world. I found Mallory a likable and capable detective, and really liked other aspects of the satire, such as his constant correction and contrast of Nathan's understanding of detective work. I liked Winnifred a great deal (and wish she would have been in it more, which is what I get for not starting with the first book), and adored Felina even if her constant bargaining did start to feel a bit tired by the end of the book. The writing on its own was great as well, if repetitive by the end, and while the ending did feel a little anti-climactic, I was surprised by Mallory's final plan.
Like I said, though Resnick's treatment of sex and porn are not my cup of tea (though massive credit to him for not being explicit), overall, I enjoyed it. 2.5 stars.