What do you think?
Rate this book
The Poldark Saga #5
The Black Moon
Cornwall, 1794-1795
The birth of a son to Elizabeth and George Warleggan serves only to accentuate the rift between the Poldark and Warleggan families, and the enduring rivalry between George and Ross finds a new focus for bitter enmity and conflict.
The birth of a son to Elizabeth and George Warleggan serves only to accentuate the rift between the Poldark and Warleggan families, and the enduring rivalry between George and Ross finds a new focus for bitter enmity and conflict.
546 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1973
947 people are currently reading
6091 people want to read
About the author
Winston Graham
215 books1,150 followersWinston Graham was an English novelist best known for the Poldark series of historical novels set in Cornwall, though he also wrote contemporary thrillers, period novels, short stories, non-fiction, and plays. Born in Victoria Park, Manchester, he moved to Perranporth, Cornwall in 1925 and lived there for 34 years. Graham published his first novel, The House with the Stained Glass Windows, in 1934 and married Jean Williamson in 1939, who inspired the character Demelza in Poldark. During World War II, he joined the Auxiliary Coastguard Service. Graham became a member of the Society of Authors in 1945, serving as chairman from 1967 to 1969, and was a fellow of the Royal Society of Literature, receiving an OBE in 1983. His Poldark series began with Ross Poldark in 1945 and concluded with Bella Poldark in 2002. He wrote 30 additional novels, short stories, and non-fiction works, including the acclaimed thriller Marnie, adapted by Alfred Hitchcock in 1964. Several other novels, including The Walking Stick and Fortune Is a Woman, were adapted for film. Graham also wrote plays, some adapted from his novels. His works have been translated into 31 languages, and his autobiography, Memoirs of a Private Man, was published posthumously in 2003.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 636 reviews
May 10, 2019
As always, Winston Graham has crafted a completely absorbing addition to the Poldark family saga, and in this one he took me along back into the 1700’s of Cornwall and France – a willing and eager passenger.
Ross Poldark’s old flame and his deceased cousin’s wife, now married to Ross’ worst enemy George Warleggan, gives birth to a son exactly at the time of ‘the black moon’, and George names him Valentine. Elizabeth hires her young cousin as governess for Geoffrey Charles, her 11 year old son with Francis, Ross’ deceased cousin.
Demelza’s second-oldest brother, Sam, and her youngest brother, Drake, come to Ross and Demelza’s home to ask for jobs. Sam is a devout Methodist and Drake is of the same faith but still young in his devotions. Drake meets Geoffrey Charles and his attractive governess, Morwenna, and a lovely friendship is cemented between the three. It is a friendship fated to be a major source of further conflict between the Warleggan and Poldark families. Demelza and Ross have a baby girl and name her Clowance.
Although the revolution in France has now extended to a war over the Netherlands, there seem to be more than enough Republicans to fight on several fronts. Ross selects 7 friends to go with him to France in an attempt to free a close friend of the family from the horrid prison that has been his home for the last year. Their plan is a good one: to coat-tail their landing in France on the Royalists’ attempt to take back control of their homeland. However, it turns into an incredibly harrowing experience for almost all of them.
There are more disturbing experiences and sad times on the home front. George Warleggan, for all that he wants to gain the trust and admiration of everyone in the county – and beyond, if he can – makes some bitter enemies as he wrong-foots his way on his imaginary ladder to success. In the end, an ancient woman defies him by whispering some seeds of doubt and trouble that almost immediately begin to sprout in George’s stubborn, yet fragile psyche.
When I start one of these novels, it is a challenge to do anything else but read and become tangled up in these family’s lives. Winston Graham is a master story-teller, and I love the feeling of mining the historical details that he slips into the story and weaves through it like shimmering threads, both informing and confirming.
I am once again looking forward to the next novel in this remarkable series which I will read next month.
Ross Poldark’s old flame and his deceased cousin’s wife, now married to Ross’ worst enemy George Warleggan, gives birth to a son exactly at the time of ‘the black moon’, and George names him Valentine. Elizabeth hires her young cousin as governess for Geoffrey Charles, her 11 year old son with Francis, Ross’ deceased cousin.
Demelza’s second-oldest brother, Sam, and her youngest brother, Drake, come to Ross and Demelza’s home to ask for jobs. Sam is a devout Methodist and Drake is of the same faith but still young in his devotions. Drake meets Geoffrey Charles and his attractive governess, Morwenna, and a lovely friendship is cemented between the three. It is a friendship fated to be a major source of further conflict between the Warleggan and Poldark families. Demelza and Ross have a baby girl and name her Clowance.
Although the revolution in France has now extended to a war over the Netherlands, there seem to be more than enough Republicans to fight on several fronts. Ross selects 7 friends to go with him to France in an attempt to free a close friend of the family from the horrid prison that has been his home for the last year. Their plan is a good one: to coat-tail their landing in France on the Royalists’ attempt to take back control of their homeland. However, it turns into an incredibly harrowing experience for almost all of them.
There are more disturbing experiences and sad times on the home front. George Warleggan, for all that he wants to gain the trust and admiration of everyone in the county – and beyond, if he can – makes some bitter enemies as he wrong-foots his way on his imaginary ladder to success. In the end, an ancient woman defies him by whispering some seeds of doubt and trouble that almost immediately begin to sprout in George’s stubborn, yet fragile psyche.
When I start one of these novels, it is a challenge to do anything else but read and become tangled up in these family’s lives. Winston Graham is a master story-teller, and I love the feeling of mining the historical details that he slips into the story and weaves through it like shimmering threads, both informing and confirming.
I am once again looking forward to the next novel in this remarkable series which I will read next month.
November 9, 2017
"Blemishes on the beauty of a person one loves are like grace notes adding something to a piece of music."
Have I mentioned before that I am completely wild about the Poldark series?! Well, I am! I am much like that slightly annoying, lovesick friend that won’t stop raving about her latest crush. In my case, the love affair is with a bunch of books written by the gifted author, Winston Graham. I know, embarrassing, right? A woman of my age carrying on in such an unseemly manner… Fortunately, dear Goodreads friend, you don’t have to live with me and put up with this on a daily basis! You can scroll right past my review if you like and I’ll never be the wiser ;)
Anyway, back to the book itself. This one is the fifth in the Poldark series, and it does not disappointment. I will say from the outset, it was just a wee bit slower in the first portion of the book than perhaps the previous installments – but that’s ok! They can’t all be 5-star reads, or you might start to question my ability to fairly assess their worth. In The Black Moon, we are introduced to some new and vibrant characters as well as another odious villain to loathe. It would be difficult to brand a bigger creep than George Warleggan, however. He continues down the path towards hell in this book as well. A sweet romance leads to a messy entanglement between two battling families. The war in Europe continues to seethe, while French émigrés concoct a plan to make a landing on their home soil with an attempt to end the revolution. A baby is born under the black moon and a chilling prophecy is uttered: "Good seldom comes to a child born under a black moon. I only know two and they both came to bad ends!" It remains to be seen whether said prophecy will be fulfilled.
The characterizations are impeccable, as I’ve come to expect from Mr. Graham. As noted above, the pace is a tad slower (but not dragging) in the first part of the book; but once the story ignites, the pace is swift and exciting. Yes, a tissue may be required in at least one scene. I love my favorites and I love to hate the scoundrels. These books are a pure joy to read. I can’t recommend them more highly to anyone that appreciates excellent and entertaining historical fiction.
"How I love a strong man!"
Have I mentioned before that I am completely wild about the Poldark series?! Well, I am! I am much like that slightly annoying, lovesick friend that won’t stop raving about her latest crush. In my case, the love affair is with a bunch of books written by the gifted author, Winston Graham. I know, embarrassing, right? A woman of my age carrying on in such an unseemly manner… Fortunately, dear Goodreads friend, you don’t have to live with me and put up with this on a daily basis! You can scroll right past my review if you like and I’ll never be the wiser ;)
Anyway, back to the book itself. This one is the fifth in the Poldark series, and it does not disappointment. I will say from the outset, it was just a wee bit slower in the first portion of the book than perhaps the previous installments – but that’s ok! They can’t all be 5-star reads, or you might start to question my ability to fairly assess their worth. In The Black Moon, we are introduced to some new and vibrant characters as well as another odious villain to loathe. It would be difficult to brand a bigger creep than George Warleggan, however. He continues down the path towards hell in this book as well. A sweet romance leads to a messy entanglement between two battling families. The war in Europe continues to seethe, while French émigrés concoct a plan to make a landing on their home soil with an attempt to end the revolution. A baby is born under the black moon and a chilling prophecy is uttered: "Good seldom comes to a child born under a black moon. I only know two and they both came to bad ends!" It remains to be seen whether said prophecy will be fulfilled.
The characterizations are impeccable, as I’ve come to expect from Mr. Graham. As noted above, the pace is a tad slower (but not dragging) in the first part of the book; but once the story ignites, the pace is swift and exciting. Yes, a tissue may be required in at least one scene. I love my favorites and I love to hate the scoundrels. These books are a pure joy to read. I can’t recommend them more highly to anyone that appreciates excellent and entertaining historical fiction.
"How I love a strong man!"
October 15, 2018
I love the Poldark series so much, even though I just finished book 5 and there are more to go!
I love the show even more as I love to see the people I love in action. Season 4 is currently on PBS and I have already pre-ordered the season on blu-ray. But it saddened me greatly when I got the email awhile back that they are filming season 5 right now and it will be the final season. 😕
I understand that some books do have an ending and so do their shows if they have one!
Happy Reading!
Mel 🖤🐺🐾
I love the show even more as I love to see the people I love in action. Season 4 is currently on PBS and I have already pre-ordered the season on blu-ray. But it saddened me greatly when I got the email awhile back that they are filming season 5 right now and it will be the final season. 😕
I understand that some books do have an ending and so do their shows if they have one!
Happy Reading!
Mel 🖤🐺🐾
July 15, 2025
Having just read this for a second time, I'm really not certain who I hate more - George or Elizabeth. In book four, I found myself at times almost sorry for both of them, but not no longer.
On second reading, I also realise what a heartbreaking story this is. Beautiful, certainly, but heartbreaking. The final couple of chapters cut as deep as any in the series, with the exception of Graham's description of Jeremy following the battle of Waterloo.
On second reading, I also realise what a heartbreaking story this is. Beautiful, certainly, but heartbreaking. The final couple of chapters cut as deep as any in the series, with the exception of Graham's description of Jeremy following the battle of Waterloo.
February 24, 2017
Winston Graham took a 20 year writing break between the fourth book of this series, Warleggan, and this fifth one, The Black Moon. At the beginning, I thought he might have lost his way during that hiatus, but boy was I wrong. He picked his story up and his characters led him into the heart of the battle. I wonder if there ever was a more believable and despicable villain than George Warleggan.
I had initially intended to stop reading this series at book four so that I would not infringe on the new season of the series which will begin later on this year. However, unlike Mr. Graham, I was not able to leave these characters celebrating their Christmas in 1793. I wanted to know what happened to them in 1794.
I haven’t been this in love with a male character since I fell for Rhett Butler when I was sixteen. It doesn’t hurt to have Aiden Turner’s face in my head when Ross Poldark is speaking to me (uh, I mean speaking to Demelza). I am so glad I decided to dive into this series of books. Graham is a marvelous writer, with style, finesse and a great ability to develop characters you can love or hate, want to shake, slap or kiss. I’m anxious to get on to book six.
I had initially intended to stop reading this series at book four so that I would not infringe on the new season of the series which will begin later on this year. However, unlike Mr. Graham, I was not able to leave these characters celebrating their Christmas in 1793. I wanted to know what happened to them in 1794.
I haven’t been this in love with a male character since I fell for Rhett Butler when I was sixteen. It doesn’t hurt to have Aiden Turner’s face in my head when Ross Poldark is speaking to me (uh, I mean speaking to Demelza). I am so glad I decided to dive into this series of books. Graham is a marvelous writer, with style, finesse and a great ability to develop characters you can love or hate, want to shake, slap or kiss. I’m anxious to get on to book six.
June 13, 2025
I adored the first three books in the Poldark series, but wasn't quite so keen on the fourth book Warleggan & decided to take a break from reading them.
What a coincidence - Graham also took a break from writing the books! Warleggan was published in 1953, The Black Moon in 1973. In the introduction to my edition, the author mentions that he himself became curious about his creations & decided to find out what happened to them!
Relationships between the Ross Poldarks & The Warleggans remain strained to the point of open hostility. Into this fraught scene comes a young relative of Elizabeth's, Morwenna Chynoweth, & two younger brothers of Demelza's, the fiercely Methodist Sam & the younger brother, Drake. Drake & Morwenna fall in love but the distance in social station & George Warleggan's relentless hostility to all things Poldark mean this romance heads towards tragedy.
In a separate plot strand, the kindly doctor Dwight becomes imprisoned in France.
While other readers have long disliked Elizabeth (this apparently includes Winston Graham!) I felt her conduct could be explained by being powerless & later by But in this book Elizabeth's inner bitch comes out. I don't fault that - I like complex characters. But Elizabeth certainly shows a side that is insensitive at best, cruel & indifferent at the worst. She is quite definitely a Warleggan now!
But this book towards the end is piling so much on. It does become a bit much.
The book was heading towards a 3.5★ rating, but Graham pulled a number of dramatic strands together deftly. & the next stage in Dwight & Caroline's romance was handled beautifully. I am looking forward to The Four Swans
What a coincidence - Graham also took a break from writing the books! Warleggan was published in 1953, The Black Moon in 1973. In the introduction to my edition, the author mentions that he himself became curious about his creations & decided to find out what happened to them!
Relationships between the Ross Poldarks & The Warleggans remain strained to the point of open hostility. Into this fraught scene comes a young relative of Elizabeth's, Morwenna Chynoweth, & two younger brothers of Demelza's, the fiercely Methodist Sam & the younger brother, Drake. Drake & Morwenna fall in love but the distance in social station & George Warleggan's relentless hostility to all things Poldark mean this romance heads towards tragedy.
In a separate plot strand, the kindly doctor Dwight becomes imprisoned in France.
While other readers have long disliked Elizabeth (this apparently includes Winston Graham!) I felt her conduct could be explained by being powerless & later by But in this book Elizabeth's inner bitch comes out. I don't fault that - I like complex characters. But Elizabeth certainly shows a side that is insensitive at best, cruel & indifferent at the worst. She is quite definitely a Warleggan now!
But this book towards the end is piling so much on. It does become a bit much.
The book was heading towards a 3.5★ rating, but Graham pulled a number of dramatic strands together deftly. & the next stage in Dwight & Caroline's romance was handled beautifully. I am looking forward to The Four Swans
https://wordpress.com/view/carolshess...
October 12, 2017
Alright, after months of reading, and it being a little slow I had some trouble getting into it. But, overall, I enjoyed it none the less. Here’s the gist: this book had everything I’ve come to expect (and still love!) of the Poldark saga; love triangles, backstabbing, family feuds, broken hearts, and plenty of drama. In this installment, though, there was something new: prison escapes and (spoiler) murder.
July 21, 2015
New characters are introduced in "The Black Moon" and with them comes a Romeo and Juliet scenario where Demelza's handsome brother Drake falls in love with Morwenna, a cousin of Elizabeth's who is now Jeffrey Charles's governess
George Warleggan and his bride Elizabeth are now living in the Poldark family home and his arrogance knows no bounds as he manages to make enemies of all his neighbors, rich or poor, with his high handed ways.
Ross's mine continues to bring forth riches and Ross has decided to build a 2nd floor to the Nampara manor house.
I'm continuing to enjoy the Poldark series and I'm on to the next book The Four Swans.
George Warleggan and his bride Elizabeth are now living in the Poldark family home and his arrogance knows no bounds as he manages to make enemies of all his neighbors, rich or poor, with his high handed ways.
Ross's mine continues to bring forth riches and Ross has decided to build a 2nd floor to the Nampara manor house.
I'm continuing to enjoy the Poldark series and I'm on to the next book The Four Swans.
March 10, 2016
5 STARS FUCKING BRILLIANT
![]()
September 21, 2016
Watching Ross and Demelza's love grow and develop is what makes these books worth reading.
I thought Demelza said something insightful on page 246:
You see, Ross, in every right marriage, in every good marriage a woman has to be three things, don't she? She's got to be wife and look after a man's comforts in the way a man should be looked after. Then she's got to bear his children and get all swelled up like a summer pumpkin and then often-times feed them after and smell of babies and have them crawling all about her... But then, third, she has also to try and be his mistress at the same time; someone he is still 'interested' in; someone he wants, not just the person who happens to be there and convenient; someone a bit mysterious like that woman he saw riding to hounds yesterday, someone whose knee or shoulder he wouldn't instantly recognize if he saw it beside him in bed. It's -it's impossible."
Loved this line from Drake on page 342:
I d'believe two people- a man and a woman- in perfect harmony can give more to the world and to God than either of 'em can do separate."
I've always had my doubts about Elizabeth and you finally get to see her true nature in the book. She is controlling and evil. Pay attention or you might miss it. I'm so glad Ross saw the light and went for Demelza. He did right.
I thought Demelza said something insightful on page 246:
You see, Ross, in every right marriage, in every good marriage a woman has to be three things, don't she? She's got to be wife and look after a man's comforts in the way a man should be looked after. Then she's got to bear his children and get all swelled up like a summer pumpkin and then often-times feed them after and smell of babies and have them crawling all about her... But then, third, she has also to try and be his mistress at the same time; someone he is still 'interested' in; someone he wants, not just the person who happens to be there and convenient; someone a bit mysterious like that woman he saw riding to hounds yesterday, someone whose knee or shoulder he wouldn't instantly recognize if he saw it beside him in bed. It's -it's impossible."
Loved this line from Drake on page 342:
I d'believe two people- a man and a woman- in perfect harmony can give more to the world and to God than either of 'em can do separate."
I've always had my doubts about Elizabeth and you finally get to see her true nature in the book. She is controlling and evil. Pay attention or you might miss it. I'm so glad Ross saw the light and went for Demelza. He did right.
October 29, 2022
My short hiatus from Cornwall has finally come to an end as I have plunged myself back into the saga that I have come to love and despise. I had been missing out on what was happening in the world of the Poldarks and the Warleggans but after this 5th installment, Winston Graham has done it again with a finesse for introducing new characters and building on the old ones that we know so well. The war in Europe is heating up and the feud between these two families is at a standstill but always threatening to boil up behind the scenes. George Warleggan, the ultimate villain, manipulates others with his vile and detestable ways for his own gain - of course he would! Aunt Agatha’s story - the oldest living Poldark still at Trenwith - is one that would have been a terrible miss if Graham had left it out. However, fans of Aunt Agatha (I am) will cheer her for the strong-will and feisty spirit she exudes from beginning to end.
Demelza’s two brothers, Sam and Drake, cause a stir in the community for their Methodist views. A cousin of Elizabeth’s, Morwenna Chynoweth, comes to Trenwith to serve as Geoffrey Charles’ governess and finds herself in a sticky situation and by the end we are introduced to another disgusting villain that will turn your stomach! This book is full of adventure, romance, battles of the heart and of the will. If you’re like me and can’t get enough of this story, then jump in and catch up as I get ready to find out what is coming next for these folks.
Demelza’s two brothers, Sam and Drake, cause a stir in the community for their Methodist views. A cousin of Elizabeth’s, Morwenna Chynoweth, comes to Trenwith to serve as Geoffrey Charles’ governess and finds herself in a sticky situation and by the end we are introduced to another disgusting villain that will turn your stomach! This book is full of adventure, romance, battles of the heart and of the will. If you’re like me and can’t get enough of this story, then jump in and catch up as I get ready to find out what is coming next for these folks.
March 10, 2016
The tears are falling from my eyes, the fury is boiling over within me, and the joy.... there is joy. Oh what a story this author doest weave.
October 3, 2015
Este libro es algo más calmado que el anterior pero pasa de todo, hay mucha emoción, aventura, amor, desamor... Este hombre es un maestro a la hora de escribir, me encanta cómo transmite lo que piensan y sienten los personajes. Presiento que los demás libros van a estar marcados por la manifiesta enemistad entre los dos rivales de toda la saga.
Y me he reconciliado (un poquito) con Ross.
Cada vez estoy más contenta de haberme puesto a leer esta saga :)
Y me he reconciliado (un poquito) con Ross.
Cada vez estoy más contenta de haberme puesto a leer esta saga :)
June 23, 2018
Actual review: 4.5
“We can’t alter the world, we can only adapt ourselves to it.”
I have quite a soft spot for the Poldarks and their extended family. The characters, the storylines and the drama is subtly interwoven in such a way that keeps me invested. Although not as good as the previous book, I was glad to see the characters move forward from the mess that had previously occurred.
I did miss a few characters in this installment, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I liked the additional characters introduced to us. I am not yet that invested in their stories, but the way it’s going, I’m sure that I will want them to be as happy as possible, too.
I must also tip my (imaginary) hat to Mr. Winston Graham, for his understanding of the female species, the complexity of relationships, and the ridiculous expectations about marriage. Demelza said it best:
“You see, Ross, in every right marriage, in every good marriage a woman has to be three things, don't she? She's got to be a wife and look after a man's comforts in the way a man should be looked after. Then she's got to bear his children and get all swelled up like a summer pumpkin and then often-times feed them after and smell of babies and have them crawling all about her... But then, third, she has also to try and be his mistress at the same time; someone he is still interested in; someone he wants, not just the person who happens to be there and convenient; someone a bit mysterious... Someone whose knee or -- or shoulder he wouldn't instantly recognize if he saw it beside him in bed. It's -- it's impossible.”
This series is just such a pleasure to read. The philosophies and discussions, especially, are those I find fascinating.
"Underneath the religious vision there is the harsh fundamental reality of all our lives, because we know we must live and die as the animals we are. But sometimes I suspect that under that harsh reality there is a further vision, still deeper based, that comes nearer to true reality than the reality we know.”
I look forward to the next book. There is such warmth in the writing, and I really enjoy that.
I’m also glad our favourite couple is working through what happened in Warleggan.
“We can’t alter the world, we can only adapt ourselves to it.”
I have quite a soft spot for the Poldarks and their extended family. The characters, the storylines and the drama is subtly interwoven in such a way that keeps me invested. Although not as good as the previous book, I was glad to see the characters move forward from the mess that had previously occurred.
I did miss a few characters in this installment, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I liked the additional characters introduced to us. I am not yet that invested in their stories, but the way it’s going, I’m sure that I will want them to be as happy as possible, too.
I must also tip my (imaginary) hat to Mr. Winston Graham, for his understanding of the female species, the complexity of relationships, and the ridiculous expectations about marriage. Demelza said it best:
“You see, Ross, in every right marriage, in every good marriage a woman has to be three things, don't she? She's got to be a wife and look after a man's comforts in the way a man should be looked after. Then she's got to bear his children and get all swelled up like a summer pumpkin and then often-times feed them after and smell of babies and have them crawling all about her... But then, third, she has also to try and be his mistress at the same time; someone he is still interested in; someone he wants, not just the person who happens to be there and convenient; someone a bit mysterious... Someone whose knee or -- or shoulder he wouldn't instantly recognize if he saw it beside him in bed. It's -- it's impossible.”
This series is just such a pleasure to read. The philosophies and discussions, especially, are those I find fascinating.
"Underneath the religious vision there is the harsh fundamental reality of all our lives, because we know we must live and die as the animals we are. But sometimes I suspect that under that harsh reality there is a further vision, still deeper based, that comes nearer to true reality than the reality we know.”
I look forward to the next book. There is such warmth in the writing, and I really enjoy that.
I’m also glad our favourite couple is working through what happened in Warleggan.
November 5, 2015
No Ross and Elizabeth scenes! About time! Lol. So this book had it's slow moments and there was a lot at the end with the French that I didn't always follow, but it was a great book all in all. I LOVED the drake and morwenna storyline and I can't wait to see where it leads. Also, seeing Ross and demelza in domestic bliss is always a plus and I think despite certain events, they've somehow grown closer. Can't wait to continue!
January 30, 2017
Winston Graham sabe enganchar. Ahora aparecen nuevos personajes que enriquecen la trama, tanto para amar como para odiar.
October 12, 2024
4,5 Sterne. Bisher mein Lieblingsteil der Reihe.
November 23, 2017
Ross Poldark prospers at last! He is content at Nampara with his wife, whom he has tried steadfastly to prove his devotion, his son and a good mine. He attempts to ignore George Warleggan sitting in the Poldark family home at Trenwith. George, delighted with his new son, tries to arrange his famiy life to his satisfaction. Trying to extricate Geoffrey Charles from his mother, hires Elizabeth's cousin Morwenna Chynoweth to be the boy's governess. Dwight Enys has gone to see and taken prisoner by the French. Caroline is determined to get him back. Demelza's two younger brothers come to Nampara with their Methodist principles and stirring up trouble. Times are tough in Cornwall but Agatha Poldark has seen 99 years of turmoil and triumph. At last she will be 100 and has outlived them all. She makes plans for the grandest birthday celebration of them all.
Woosh. I finally finished though I have yet to see the Season 3 finale. It became fairly obvious that the timeline of the show is moving faster than the book and there are certain events in the show that are not from this book. This book is a lot darker in tone than the earlier books and though it was written many years after Warleggan it picks up right where Winston Graham left off. His descriptive writing is still amazing and his knowledge of Cornish history and the way society worked in the 18th century is nearly equal to Georgette Heyer's knowledge. The story is told mostly from Ross's point-of-view so that limits the storytelling quite a lot. Where the screenwriter is able to shift to different characters, the reader must wait to be told what is happening or has happened with the other characters. The plot moves very slowly but is worth reading to the dramatic conclusion. I would most definitely recommend reading along with the show. There are some changes but only one major change that doesn't seem to affect the plot.
Ross is a little older and wiser here. He's settled into middle aged comfort without causing anymore trouble. His thinks more before he acts and he knows what Demelza is thinking. He worries what she'll think about his desire for more adventure and knows she would not approve. He goes and does it anyway. He seems a little more aware of things happening around him than show Ross. He just chooses not to talk about unpleasant suspicions or situations for Demelza's sake and the sake of their marriage. He knows he screwed up -big time! Show Ross is oblivious. Show Demelza is a little more appealing that book Demelza. I really like her character but she's a bit more demure in the book "Yes Ross" and a bit more socially conscious. She's aware that she's now living in a higher station than her brothers and having them around might be embarrassing. Demelza loves Ross passionately and is a good wife and mother. I think the screenwriters made her more spirited to appeal to modern audiences.
Over at Trenwith we have our villains-George and Elizabeth and their sons. Valentine, born on St. Valentine's Day under a black moon after Elizabeth fell down the stairs. It seems as if her fall was an accident and she went into labor early and had a premature baby. Whether she did or didn't is still ambiguous. Geoffrey Charles is now 10-11 and annoyingly precocious. He gets a little less stuffy once he becomes friends with Drake and more like a normal 10-year-old boy. I don't love him but I like him well enough. George is not so nasty in this book. He is happy with everything he's ever wanted. Even his dealings with Morwenna are not as fraught with tension and there is a big difference between page vs. screen towards the end of the novel. George is still oblivious to the concerns of the little people. He still doesn't get the concept of noblesse oblige and doesn't seem to understand what the French Revolution is all about! Elizabeth is still a cold fish and largely vapid. She suits George very well. She seems content with her life with him.
Caroline is one of my favorite characters. I like how she uses humor to dispel tension and get through difficult situations. Her love for Dwight is admirable and the lengths she goes to get him back unrealistic at best but determined! Dwight also has a sarcastic sense of humor. He's such a great doctor and an honorable man. He has come a long way since he first came to the neighborhood.
The new characters here are Demelza's younger brothers Sam and Drake Carne. Sam is a serious young man of an evangelical bent. I didn't understand what the big deal over the Methodists was in the show. The book makes this FAR more clear. The Methodists believe all men are equal in the eyes of the Lord. They don't recognize the hierarchy of the established church or the nobility. They seek to proselytize, which Ross doesn't like but the real problem is with their beliefs is that they go against the establishment. In England, the head of the church is also the head of state. In not recognizing the authority and hierarchy of the established church, the Methodists are one step away from the Revolutionaries in France! Sam is a little too earnest for me. He lives his life very piously in preparation for the next life. He's cautious and gloomy. Drake is more like his sister. He is spirited, mischievous, warm, loving and passionate. This may also be his downfall. He goes along with his brother because that's all he knows but as he gets older, I think he will develop more into his own person with his own views on things. I quite liked him!
Another new character is Tholly Tegirls. He's the next best thing to a pirate and an old friend of Ross's father and of Ross. Tholly is as shady as the night and as roguish as any pirate. He is a dangerous opponent with a hook for a hand and I really didn't like him. He is a man without principles. His purpose is to advance the action of the plot.
Then at Trenwith we have Morwenna Chynoweth, a young cousin of Elizabeth's. She naively enters Trenwith as a governess for Geoffrey Charles, unaware that she will become a bargaining chip for George's social climbing aspirations. Morwenna is very young and sweet. It's easy to see why she feels the way she does. Fans of the show are shocked by her storyline. In the book it's not that simple. She does what she does out of her own free will. Then Winston Graham makes no bones about what happens to Morwenna. This time he does use the word "rape." That scene broke my heart. I felt so awful for Morwenna and can't even imagine what it must have been like. I am impressed that a male author can enter the head of a young girl and know how she must feel. Trying not to spoil the plot, I'll say that there's no indication in that book that that other person is anything but lustful, stupid and lazy. None of the scenes in the show are in this particular book.
I can't say much more without spoiling the plot but this book is a tense and stressful read. It's well worth it though for fans of the series! I must get my hands on the next book soon.
Woosh. I finally finished though I have yet to see the Season 3 finale. It became fairly obvious that the timeline of the show is moving faster than the book and there are certain events in the show that are not from this book. This book is a lot darker in tone than the earlier books and though it was written many years after Warleggan it picks up right where Winston Graham left off. His descriptive writing is still amazing and his knowledge of Cornish history and the way society worked in the 18th century is nearly equal to Georgette Heyer's knowledge. The story is told mostly from Ross's point-of-view so that limits the storytelling quite a lot. Where the screenwriter is able to shift to different characters, the reader must wait to be told what is happening or has happened with the other characters. The plot moves very slowly but is worth reading to the dramatic conclusion. I would most definitely recommend reading along with the show. There are some changes but only one major change that doesn't seem to affect the plot.
Ross is a little older and wiser here. He's settled into middle aged comfort without causing anymore trouble. His thinks more before he acts and he knows what Demelza is thinking. He worries what she'll think about his desire for more adventure and knows she would not approve. He goes and does it anyway. He seems a little more aware of things happening around him than show Ross. He just chooses not to talk about unpleasant suspicions or situations for Demelza's sake and the sake of their marriage. He knows he screwed up -big time! Show Ross is oblivious. Show Demelza is a little more appealing that book Demelza. I really like her character but she's a bit more demure in the book "Yes Ross" and a bit more socially conscious. She's aware that she's now living in a higher station than her brothers and having them around might be embarrassing. Demelza loves Ross passionately and is a good wife and mother. I think the screenwriters made her more spirited to appeal to modern audiences.
Over at Trenwith we have our villains-George and Elizabeth and their sons. Valentine, born on St. Valentine's Day under a black moon after Elizabeth fell down the stairs. It seems as if her fall was an accident and she went into labor early and had a premature baby. Whether she did or didn't is still ambiguous. Geoffrey Charles is now 10-11 and annoyingly precocious. He gets a little less stuffy once he becomes friends with Drake and more like a normal 10-year-old boy. I don't love him but I like him well enough. George is not so nasty in this book. He is happy with everything he's ever wanted. Even his dealings with Morwenna are not as fraught with tension and there is a big difference between page vs. screen towards the end of the novel. George is still oblivious to the concerns of the little people. He still doesn't get the concept of noblesse oblige and doesn't seem to understand what the French Revolution is all about! Elizabeth is still a cold fish and largely vapid. She suits George very well. She seems content with her life with him.
Caroline is one of my favorite characters. I like how she uses humor to dispel tension and get through difficult situations. Her love for Dwight is admirable and the lengths she goes to get him back unrealistic at best but determined! Dwight also has a sarcastic sense of humor. He's such a great doctor and an honorable man. He has come a long way since he first came to the neighborhood.
The new characters here are Demelza's younger brothers Sam and Drake Carne. Sam is a serious young man of an evangelical bent. I didn't understand what the big deal over the Methodists was in the show. The book makes this FAR more clear. The Methodists believe all men are equal in the eyes of the Lord. They don't recognize the hierarchy of the established church or the nobility. They seek to proselytize, which Ross doesn't like but the real problem is with their beliefs is that they go against the establishment. In England, the head of the church is also the head of state. In not recognizing the authority and hierarchy of the established church, the Methodists are one step away from the Revolutionaries in France! Sam is a little too earnest for me. He lives his life very piously in preparation for the next life. He's cautious and gloomy. Drake is more like his sister. He is spirited, mischievous, warm, loving and passionate. This may also be his downfall. He goes along with his brother because that's all he knows but as he gets older, I think he will develop more into his own person with his own views on things. I quite liked him!
Another new character is Tholly Tegirls. He's the next best thing to a pirate and an old friend of Ross's father and of Ross. Tholly is as shady as the night and as roguish as any pirate. He is a dangerous opponent with a hook for a hand and I really didn't like him. He is a man without principles. His purpose is to advance the action of the plot.
Then at Trenwith we have Morwenna Chynoweth, a young cousin of Elizabeth's. She naively enters Trenwith as a governess for Geoffrey Charles, unaware that she will become a bargaining chip for George's social climbing aspirations. Morwenna is very young and sweet. It's easy to see why she feels the way she does. Fans of the show are shocked by her storyline. In the book it's not that simple. She does what she does out of her own free will. Then Winston Graham makes no bones about what happens to Morwenna. This time he does use the word "rape." That scene broke my heart. I felt so awful for Morwenna and can't even imagine what it must have been like. I am impressed that a male author can enter the head of a young girl and know how she must feel. Trying not to spoil the plot, I'll say that there's no indication in that book that that other person is anything but lustful, stupid and lazy. None of the scenes in the show are in this particular book.
I can't say much more without spoiling the plot but this book is a tense and stressful read. It's well worth it though for fans of the series! I must get my hands on the next book soon.
August 23, 2010
The Poldark Series continues. The time is February 1794. In the opening pages, the author evokes an image of a sleepy Cornwall in the depths of a harsh and frigid winter. George Warleggan continues to expand his power and influence over the community. His wife Elizabeth (once Ross Poldark's great love) has given birth to a son, Valentine. Her son from her previous marriage to Ross' cousin Francis, Geoffrey Charles, has been given a governess, Morwenna Chynoweth (a cousin of Elizabeth's) to tutor him.
Two of Demelza's brothers, Sam and Drake Carne, both ardent Methodists, come to Ross and Demelza, seeking a new life for themselves in the community. Ross is not exactly thrilled to have them there. But he gives Sam a job working in one of his mines and Drake assumes a trademan's life. With the coming of the Carnes, Methodism in the community is given a considerable boost, which doesn't sit well with a number of the local notables.
The novel goes on to describe the ongoing relationship between Caroline and Dr. Dwight Enys, who had gone into the Navy when it seemed impossible that he and Caroline could marry over the objections of Caroline's uncle and guardian, who had deemed Dr. Enys as socially unsuitable for his niece, who soon stood to acquire an inheritance. The ship on which Dwight is serving as a surgeon is involved in a naval battle near the French coast, and most of the ship's survivors, including Dwight, are taken prisoner. When Caroline gets wind of this, she begins, with Ross, a campaign for Dwight's freedom.
There is also a developing relationship between Morwenna and Drake, which creates further conflict between the Poldarks and the Warleggans.
Again, as in the other novels of the Poldark Series, this is a novel that never falters. Besides the principal characters, there are also a number of minor characters who further enliven and enrich the drama. This is some of the best historical fiction you'll ever find.
So, take a seat by the window of your favorite room or stay in bed one holiday or weekend morning and enjoy what is a richly textured, well-told story. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Two of Demelza's brothers, Sam and Drake Carne, both ardent Methodists, come to Ross and Demelza, seeking a new life for themselves in the community. Ross is not exactly thrilled to have them there. But he gives Sam a job working in one of his mines and Drake assumes a trademan's life. With the coming of the Carnes, Methodism in the community is given a considerable boost, which doesn't sit well with a number of the local notables.
The novel goes on to describe the ongoing relationship between Caroline and Dr. Dwight Enys, who had gone into the Navy when it seemed impossible that he and Caroline could marry over the objections of Caroline's uncle and guardian, who had deemed Dr. Enys as socially unsuitable for his niece, who soon stood to acquire an inheritance. The ship on which Dwight is serving as a surgeon is involved in a naval battle near the French coast, and most of the ship's survivors, including Dwight, are taken prisoner. When Caroline gets wind of this, she begins, with Ross, a campaign for Dwight's freedom.
There is also a developing relationship between Morwenna and Drake, which creates further conflict between the Poldarks and the Warleggans.
Again, as in the other novels of the Poldark Series, this is a novel that never falters. Besides the principal characters, there are also a number of minor characters who further enliven and enrich the drama. This is some of the best historical fiction you'll ever find.
So, take a seat by the window of your favorite room or stay in bed one holiday or weekend morning and enjoy what is a richly textured, well-told story. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
May 26, 2018
Winston Graham has done it again. Managed to pull me back into this time and place, among people that I love and hate, give me high adventure and simple pleasures, and continue the saga that just gets better and better. I will admit that this one started out rather slowly, possibly because the author took a 20 year hiatus between the last book and this one. He explained in a forward that he had grown tired of the novels and wanted to explore different styles of writing, but the characters kept whispering in his ear, and he decided to bring them back. He did so without missing a beat, or a detail, and introduced new characters for us to follow as well. (I'm looking at you, Drake and Morwenna.)
George Warleggan seemed to be mellowing until the very end, when his evilness returned in full force. But Aunt Agatha gave him as good as she got, and maybe a little more besides. Life Lesson: keeping a piece of knowledge to yourself until the perfect time to release it is every bit as good as a dagger or a poison pill.
Thank goodness Mr. Graham decided to continue with The Poldarks.
George Warleggan seemed to be mellowing until the very end, when his evilness returned in full force. But Aunt Agatha gave him as good as she got, and maybe a little more besides. Life Lesson: keeping a piece of knowledge to yourself until the perfect time to release it is every bit as good as a dagger or a poison pill.
Thank goodness Mr. Graham decided to continue with The Poldarks.
March 30, 2015
Set in Cornwall and a little bit in France 1794-95.
Excellent writing and a plot that continues to pull me in. The historical detail is top-notch. There is still daily life in the tin and copper mining areas of Cornwall but in this volume we also see the invasion of France in 1795 at Quiberon. There is new love that holds so much promise, as well as old hostilities and resentments. This short excerpt won't spoil but will give an idea of the emotion Graham writes with:
He had killed his viper. He had given it, he knew, a mortal wound. But as he took his foot from its neck it had turned on him and bitten him in the heel. And the venom it had left behind was working...For once in his life he felt ill and unsure of himself. The spread of the poison was slow but steady. He did not know if he could shake it off. It might be that he would die of it. It might be that others would die of it. He did not know and only time would reveal the extent of the poison...
Excellent writing and a plot that continues to pull me in. The historical detail is top-notch. There is still daily life in the tin and copper mining areas of Cornwall but in this volume we also see the invasion of France in 1795 at Quiberon. There is new love that holds so much promise, as well as old hostilities and resentments. This short excerpt won't spoil but will give an idea of the emotion Graham writes with:
He had killed his viper. He had given it, he knew, a mortal wound. But as he took his foot from its neck it had turned on him and bitten him in the heel. And the venom it had left behind was working...For once in his life he felt ill and unsure of himself. The spread of the poison was slow but steady. He did not know if he could shake it off. It might be that he would die of it. It might be that others would die of it. He did not know and only time would reveal the extent of the poison...
October 25, 2024
A lot happened but then again nothing? Essentially I’m just here for the family drama at this point and could care less about the plot. But the ending was a little wild, Aunt Agatha is a legend. George needs to come down a few pegs. Demelza is a queen, as always.
September 7, 2016
I shouldn't have finished this book tonight because how am I going to sleep?!? Many emotions are swirling around... but mostly sadness and, the main one, FURY! I had no idea I would end up abhorring three different characters in this one book. George Warleggan, damn you to hell. But not before you get damned, most putrid Whitworth.You are the scummiest scum the pond ever saw. Oh, and Elizabeth. Congrats, lady, you finally made my shit list.
Heartbreaking end to this book in so many ways. I must read on fast to get some good news to make up for this!
Heartbreaking end to this book in so many ways. I must read on fast to get some good news to make up for this!
January 14, 2011
This is the fifth volume of Poldgark saga where the fighting between Ross Poldgark and George Warleggan is still very intense. Some new characters are introduced such as Sam and Drake Carne (Demelza's brothers) and Morwenna (Elizabeth's niece), who falls in love with a man she cannot marry. In the meantime, Ross tries to recover some Cornwall people who have become prisoners in France. Excellent plot, as usual. Still looking forward to read the whole series of 12 books.
February 1, 2017
Boy, shit is going to go DOWN in the next book.
HOLD MY BEER.
HOLD MY BEER.
November 5, 2019
In the fifth book in the series, the author, after 20 years, decided to catch the thread from the beginning to continue his story. Of course, this new startup had many problems and challenges to make this reboot reasonable and interesting. The climax of the fourth part left behind a more subdued state, like post-storm silence, and with most issues resolved the writer was called upon to find inspiration to create something different that would set things back in motion. At the beginning of the book, I admit that I didn't find the author doing so well. The subdued situation led to a lighter atmosphere that was far removed from the climate of the previous books, with the introduction of new heroes and the developments of the war with France not enough to improve the situation. Fortunately, at some point, involvement in the war becomes more personal, as some revelations threaten to resurrect the hatred, and all of this combined with bad developments in the lives of the new protagonists leaves plenty of room for an exciting continuation in this series. So in the end, though for the most part, I was reading without much appetite, the impressions are sort of smoothed out and I believe that something good is waiting for me in the next book.
Στο πέμπτο βιβλίο της σειράς ο συγγραφέας μετά από 20 χρόνια αποφάσισε να πιάσει το νήμα από την αρχή για να συνεχίσει την ιστορία του. Βέβαια αυτή η νέα αρχή παρουσίαζε πολλά προβλήματα και πολλές προκλήσεις για να μπορέσει να γίνει αυτή η επανεκκίνηση λογική και ενδιαφέρουσα. Η κορύφωση του τέταρτου μέρους άφησε πίσω μία κατάσταση περισσότερο υποτονική, σαν την ησυχία μετά την καταιγίδα, και με τα περισσότερα ζητήματα να έχουν επιλυθεί ο συγγραφέας καλούνταν να βρει την έμπνευση για να δημιουργήσει κάτι διαφορετικό που θα έβαζε πάλι σε κίνηση τα πράγματα. Στην αρχή του βιβλίου ομολογώ ότι δεν έβρισκα ότι ο συγγραφέας τα κατάφερε και τόσο καλά. Η υποτονικότητα της κατάστασης οδήγησε σε μία περισσότερο ελαφριά ατμόσφαιρα που απομακρύνονταν πάρα πολύ από το κλίμα των προηγούμενων βιβλίων, με την εισαγωγή νέων ηρώων και τις εξελίξεις του πολέμου με τη Γαλλία να μην αρκούν για να βελτιώσουν την κατάσταση. Ευτυχώς από κάποιο σημείο και πέρα η συμμετοχή στον πόλεμο γίνεται περισσότερο προσωπική, την ώρα που κάποιες αποκαλύψεις απειλούν να ξαναφουντώσουν την έχθρα και όλα αυτά σε συνδυασμό με τις άσχημες εξελίξεις στη ζωή των νέων πρωταγωνιστών αφήνουν πολλά περιθώρια για μία συναρπαστική συνέχεια σε αυτή τη σειρά. Για αυτό στο τέλος, αν και στο μεγαλύτερο μέρος διάβαζα ανόρεχτα, οι εντυπώσεις κάπως εξομαλύνονται και πιστεύοντας ότι κάτι καλό με περιμένει στο επόμενο βιβλίο βάζω αυτή τη βαθμολογία.
Στο πέμπτο βιβλίο της σειράς ο συγγραφέας μετά από 20 χρόνια αποφάσισε να πιάσει το νήμα από την αρχή για να συνεχίσει την ιστορία του. Βέβαια αυτή η νέα αρχή παρουσίαζε πολλά προβλήματα και πολλές προκλήσεις για να μπορέσει να γίνει αυτή η επανεκκίνηση λογική και ενδιαφέρουσα. Η κορύφωση του τέταρτου μέρους άφησε πίσω μία κατάσταση περισσότερο υποτονική, σαν την ησυχία μετά την καταιγίδα, και με τα περισσότερα ζητήματα να έχουν επιλυθεί ο συγγραφέας καλούνταν να βρει την έμπνευση για να δημιουργήσει κάτι διαφορετικό που θα έβαζε πάλι σε κίνηση τα πράγματα. Στην αρχή του βιβλίου ομολογώ ότι δεν έβρισκα ότι ο συγγραφέας τα κατάφερε και τόσο καλά. Η υποτονικότητα της κατάστασης οδήγησε σε μία περισσότερο ελαφριά ατμόσφαιρα που απομακρύνονταν πάρα πολύ από το κλίμα των προηγούμενων βιβλίων, με την εισαγωγή νέων ηρώων και τις εξελίξεις του πολέμου με τη Γαλλία να μην αρκούν για να βελτιώσουν την κατάσταση. Ευτυχώς από κάποιο σημείο και πέρα η συμμετοχή στον πόλεμο γίνεται περισσότερο προσωπική, την ώρα που κάποιες αποκαλύψεις απειλούν να ξαναφουντώσουν την έχθρα και όλα αυτά σε συνδυασμό με τις άσχημες εξελίξεις στη ζωή των νέων πρωταγωνιστών αφήνουν πολλά περιθώρια για μία συναρπαστική συνέχεια σε αυτή τη σειρά. Για αυτό στο τέλος, αν και στο μεγαλύτερο μέρος διάβαζα ανόρεχτα, οι εντυπώσεις κάπως εξομαλύνονται και πιστεύοντας ότι κάτι καλό με περιμένει στο επόμενο βιβλίο βάζω αυτή τη βαθμολογία.
August 27, 2017
*3,5*
February 24, 2016
In this, the 5th of the Poldark series, new characters are introduced and older characters rise to new heights to further complicate the feud between the Poldarks and the Warleggans. Ross has not lost his intermittent craving for adventure and maybe even for danger. The relationship between Ross and Demelza seems to have grown stronger. Elizabeth's son may be a wild card as he seems to be willful and prone to a bit of a rebellious nature. Aunt Agatha is nearing 100, if not actually there, and has knowledge that can possibly make that rift even more pronounced.
Winston Graham has created some great characters - to love and to hate. This book was written some 20 years after the first four of the series and I feared some change in writing style, but it was just as well done as the first ones. This is good HF which I would highly recommend to those who love the genre.
Winston Graham has created some great characters - to love and to hate. This book was written some 20 years after the first four of the series and I feared some change in writing style, but it was just as well done as the first ones. This is good HF which I would highly recommend to those who love the genre.
April 16, 2023
3.5 stars. I feel disloyal in even criticising this wonderful series, but this book did not quite reach the mark of the earlier books in keeping me enthralled though out. However, I think this may be down to character preference rather than the story itself. In books 1-4 the action was very much centred around the lives of Ross and Demelza and their blossoming romance. Demelza did not feature much in this fifth instalment and Caroline too played a more minor role. Both women are very strong, feisty and opinionated characters and I missed their presence. There was also more talk of tactics and war in France which didn’t grip me in the same way as the trials amongst the Cornish mining community. Overall, it was still a strong plot and I am looking forward to continuing on with the series, where I hope to see a return of a five star rating!
March 20, 2017
Oh, Winston Graham, I must ask: what is your secret? Only a superb writer could write such a sweeping, riveting series. Never before have I detested a fictional character so much. George Warleggan is a dirty, rotten, conniving, bullying, dastardly, parvenu scoundrel. How do you do it? How do you recreate the history of the time so authentically? How do you casually insert at least 30 words lost and forgotten by the modern English language?!? Oh, Winston Graham, I do declare: keep those Poldark books a'coming!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 636 reviews