'The attacks on Finnegans Wake for its triviality might occur particularly in time of war, when texts are required to be politically engaged, ‘relevant’ in their concern with the pressing conflicts whose outcome will affect the lives of its readers. This reputation of importance, twinned with the disclosures of its impotence, is something, however, that Finnegans Wake actively contributes to itself. Through its experimentation with language, and the demands it makes on the reader, through its sheer concentrated effort, it seems to suggest there must be some profoundly meaningful justification to it all. But then by tipping into the abyss of meaninglessness and irrelevance, Joyce laughs at the presumptions of his own project to tell a ‘universal history’, and other projects with similar goals. This is another way of communicating its thematic preoccupation with the fall that is the fall of anything pompous. As we’ve seen with King Roderic, one of the basic shapes given to its manifold stories is a comedy of defeat, of collapse, of the fall, of a slapstick clown slipping over at the circus, and, perhaps self-consciously, getting up—if only to fall over again. This shape is a means of laughing at power’s mechanisms and representations of its upright self, its towers and rhetoric and laws, its ever- improving technologies of transport and communication.'
Excellent genetic reading of parts of Finnegans Wake. I have only read the first 170 pages Parts 1 and II since that is how far I am in Finnegans Wake. When I start reading Part III of Finnegans Wake I will return to this book
Really the two stars are less to do with Fordham, who is likely a very interesting person, but investigating the Wake more generally and the fruits it yields. I cannot recommend it as a piece of literature.
This was a different take on Finnegan's Wake than the other supporting texts I've read. Fordham excavates Joyce's authorship of sample texts, demonstrating how it developed over 17 years from a somewhat transparent story to the opaque masterpiece that is in our hands today. I most enjoyed the last chapter, when he walked through the development of "the little people" in the book.
Plenty of worthwhile insights provided, and a very helpful piece on understanding the "Wake a bit more.