Through networks of trails and rivers inland and established ocean routes across the seas, seventeenth-century Virginians were connected to a vibrant Atlantic world. They routinely traded with adjacent Native Americans and received ships from England, the Netherlands, and other English and Dutch colonies, while maintaining less direct connections to Africa and to French and Spanish colonies. Their Atlantic world emerged from the movement of goods and services, but trade routes quickly became equally important in the transfer of people and information.
Much seventeenth-century historiography, however, still assumes that each North American colony operated as a largely self-contained entity and interacted with other colonies only indirectly, through London. By contrast, in Atlantic Virginia, historian April Lee Hatfield demonstrates that the colonies actually had vibrant interchange with each other and with peoples throughout the hemisphere, as well as with Europeans.
Since the 1970s historians have been replacing Massachusetts with Virginia as the “most typical” North American colony, the province where some of the most critical features of American society first developed: racism and white supremacy (which Edmund Morgan connected to English contempt for the poor), exploitative individualism (as T.H. Breen and Jack Greene argued), and a dominance hierarchy in which race and gender interacted with and reinforced one another (as Kathleen Brown observed). In ATLANTIC VIRGINIA, April Hatfield makes another case for Virginia's primary importance, arguing that it was one of the first colonies to make the transition, conceptually if not economically, from an Atlantic to a continental orientation, from overriding preoccupation with England and the Caribbean to greater interaction with the other North American colonies.
The Englishmen who settled in Virginia were well aware of their Indian neighbors, but once they conquered the Powhatans and expanded to the boundaries of that confederacy (Tsenacommacah), they fortified their colony's periphery and for the next 50 years acted as though it were an island. Virginia's most important relationships followed Atlantic sea lanes rather than Indian trails, and European mariners became an important presence in the colony, not only because they exported tobacco and brought in supplies, but because they also frequently wintered in Virginia, used its courts to adjudicate shipboard disputes, brought in servants, and bought land. These sailors were not always English, and the sealanes they plied led to more destinations than Old Blighty. Until the 1650s the Dutch marketed most of Virginia's tobacco, and merchants from New Netherland later settled in the newer districts of the Southside and Eastern Shore, alongside white emigrants from Barbados, several hundred Puritans from New England, and Quakers from throughout the colonies. These districts produced naval stores, cordage, livestock, and other provisions, which the locals sold primarily to the planters in Barbados, the richest English colony in the seventeenth-century New World. It would be a bit too much to say that Virginia, like South Carolina, was a “colony of a colony” (namely the colony of Barbados), but Hatfield shows that the connection between the two colonies was much tighter than we previously realized. Barbadian migrants to Virginia introduced some of the first African slaves to the colony, and Virginia's assembly modeled its early slave code, including its pass laws, statutes against intermarriage, and classification of slaves as real estate (which ensured that widows and orphans got their fair share of inheritances), on that of Barbados. Virginia slavery was obviously an Atlantic institution, and Hatfield shows here that it was a peripheral one as well, established in the Eastern Shore well before it spread to the tobacco districts.
Virginia's colonists may have treated the province as an island, but geography and the region's indigenous inhabitants both disagreed with them. The Powhatan Indians developed a trade and communications network extending to the Gulf of Mexico, and exotic goods, such as copper, shell beads, and European artifacts, helped underwrite chief Powhatan's prestige. The early English settlers crushed the Powhatans, but by the 1630s they were trading with other nearby Indian nations, such as the communities on the Potomac River and the Piedmont nations in the Carolinas. (Hatfield suggests, and I suspect she is right, that Bacon's Rebellion [1676] began as an effort by traders, of whom Nathaniel Bacon was one, to break the Occaneechees' control of the colony's southern trading path and open direct trade with the Piedmont ([p. 32-36].) Indian paths facilitated trade but they also brought warriors, such as the Susquehannocks and Iroquois, into the colony's back counties, and Virginia's governors began communicating more regularly with officials in other mainland colonies to control this security problem. Other mainland connections were forged at the same time by runaway servants, who used the colonies' extensive inshore waterways to flee to Maryland or New Netherland, and by Quakers, whose travels between the Chesapeake and the Mid-Atlantic region helped them perceive the mainland colonies as “a contiguous whole” rather than just “islands of ... settlement” (133). This was becoming a more common perception among Virginians by 1700. They did not see themselves as Americans, but they were no longer a mere island in an English and Barbadian sea.
There are few flaws to ATLANTIC VIRGINIA, other than its inability to frame its argument quite as efficiently as I've done here and Hatfield's decision, probably done for the sake of space, not to discuss Virginia's territorial expansion and creation of a continental “empire” in the early 1700s. The framing issue makes this a hard book to teach to undergraduates, though scholars and graduate students will find it a useful bridge work between the two principal “schools” of modern colonial historiography, namely Atlantic and continental history. Non-academic readers of history, meanwhile, will appreciate a book that avoids some of the familiar cliches of Virginia history (Pocahontas, John Smith) and treats other well-known developments (the rise of the tobacco economy, Bacon's Rebellion) in an innovative new way.
Thought provoking! A wealth of archival data will leave you convinced that English colonies in the Americas were shaped as much by their interactions with each other, with other European colonies, and with indigenous groups as they were by their relationships with the "home office."