What do you think?
Rate this book
Warriors #5
Sur le Sentier de la Guerre
Cœur de Feu, lieutenant du Clan du Tonnerre, a de plus en plus de responsabilités à assumer. Il doit protéger les siens de Griffe de Tigre, qui a pris tête du Clan des Ombres et menace de se venger... Il doit en plus s'occuper d'etoile Bleue qui est atteinte d'une maladie physique et mentale. Celle-ci est persuadée que tous les membres de son clan sont des traîtres, que l'ancestral Clan des Etoiles l'a abandonnée et que le Clan du Vent chasse sur son territoire ! Etoile Bleue déclare alors la guerre malgré les protestations de Cœur de Feu, qui veut absolument éviter la bataille.
299 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 1, 2004
About the author
Erin Hunter
389 books11.5k followersErin Hunter is the pseudonym of five people: Kate Cary, Cherith Baldry, Tui T. Sutherland, Gillian Philip, and Inbali Iserles, as well as editor Victoria Holmes. Together, they write the Warriors series as well as the Seekers and Survivors series. Erin Hunter is working on a new series now called Bravelands.
Erin Hunter is inspired by a love of cats and a fascination with the ferocity of the natural world. As well as having a great respect for nature in all its forms, Erin enjoys creating rich mythical explanations for animal behavior, shaped by her interest in astronomy and standing stones.
Erin Hunter is inspired by a love of cats and a fascination with the ferocity of the natural world. As well as having a great respect for nature in all its forms, Erin enjoys creating rich mythical explanations for animal behavior, shaped by her interest in astronomy and standing stones.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,148 reviews
May 4, 2008
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGeeeeeeeeeeeeeRRRRRRRRRRRRSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
October 16, 2022
Someone tell me why I’m out here sobbing for a children’s cat book
December 26, 2019
This is the 5th book in the first series of Erin Hunter's Warrior Cats.
Okay, I must admit: I'm an adult (thirty - something) reading these children books, but, hey, I'm a crazy cat lady, so it's okay, right?
There's only one book left in these series and everytime I think: 'This story will loose it's magic', but everytime I'm relieved that it didn't. The story is full of loyality, suspense, intrige and there's Always a clifhanger.(In this book you can take that last part very literally).
At every moment that you think the story is dragging on or is getting boring, there is a new secret, dangerous situations,...that keeps you reading further.
When the dark threat grows in the forest, you can just feel Fireheart's fear. That's an example on how the author gives the cats 'human' feelings without exagerating.
I think these series are the perfect example for kids who find it difficult to find a good book or don't like to read. Maybe these can be the doorway to other books and keeping children stimulated to read.
Okay, I must admit: I'm an adult (thirty - something) reading these children books, but, hey, I'm a crazy cat lady, so it's okay, right?
There's only one book left in these series and everytime I think: 'This story will loose it's magic', but everytime I'm relieved that it didn't. The story is full of loyality, suspense, intrige and there's Always a clifhanger.(In this book you can take that last part very literally).
At every moment that you think the story is dragging on or is getting boring, there is a new secret, dangerous situations,...that keeps you reading further.
When the dark threat grows in the forest, you can just feel Fireheart's fear. That's an example on how the author gives the cats 'human' feelings without exagerating.
I think these series are the perfect example for kids who find it difficult to find a good book or don't like to read. Maybe these can be the doorway to other books and keeping children stimulated to read.
February 19, 2021
Se acerca el final y eso me entristece. Me he encariñado con estos personajes como no había pasado en mucho tiempo.
November 7, 2023
Yeah, fuck Tigerstar
July 17, 2017
“His voice barely more than a whisper, he added, “I love you.” Sandstorm’s eyes glowed. “I love you too, Fireheart,” she whispered.”
There is much left to be desired in this instalment of the series. Characters I loved previously became frustrating, the story dragged, and the climax of the whole thing was far from exciting. Nothing seemed to go well for Thunderclan (or Fireheart for that matter) and the final death in the book was almost a relief for me, although somewhat sad. Sadder still, my main emotion while reading this was a vague, "ehgggg"; something between frustration, annoyance, and a monotonous, "when will it end"? It was not a positive experience. I really, really enjoyed some of the previous in the series and even if they were not all that good technically they were entertaining and gripping in their content. But, although I spend so much time wanting something to happen much of this book was a lead up to a confrontation that fell short and left me wanting something....anything. I appreciated the darker atmosphere and tone but it was not communicated well. I'm still looking forward to reading the last in the first Warrior's series. I find myself wishing I had read these when I was younger, maybe I would have liked this better? Who knows. Let's just hope the next book is an improvement.
There is much left to be desired in this instalment of the series. Characters I loved previously became frustrating, the story dragged, and the climax of the whole thing was far from exciting. Nothing seemed to go well for Thunderclan (or Fireheart for that matter) and the final death in the book was almost a relief for me, although somewhat sad. Sadder still, my main emotion while reading this was a vague, "ehgggg"; something between frustration, annoyance, and a monotonous, "when will it end"? It was not a positive experience. I really, really enjoyed some of the previous in the series and even if they were not all that good technically they were entertaining and gripping in their content. But, although I spend so much time wanting something to happen much of this book was a lead up to a confrontation that fell short and left me wanting something....anything. I appreciated the darker atmosphere and tone but it was not communicated well. I'm still looking forward to reading the last in the first Warrior's series. I find myself wishing I had read these when I was younger, maybe I would have liked this better? Who knows. Let's just hope the next book is an improvement.
July 1, 2025
I…..
If you ever decide to read these books do not, I beg of you, get attached to any characters. Though I can’t discuss many things in detail, I will say that the death of specific character was handled beautifully. It brought everything full circle for Fireheart and his journey in Thunder Clan. The final lines spoken to him made so much sense. Once again, this is not a series to read without the next installments in hand because why did some kitty pets get thugged out?!? Another wonderful, fast paced, and wild book in this series.
If you ever decide to read these books do not, I beg of you, get attached to any characters. Though I can’t discuss many things in detail, I will say that the death of specific character was handled beautifully. It brought everything full circle for Fireheart and his journey in Thunder Clan. The final lines spoken to him made so much sense. Once again, this is not a series to read without the next installments in hand because why did some kitty pets get thugged out?!? Another wonderful, fast paced, and wild book in this series.
February 14, 2008
something is in the forest and Fireheart doesn't know what it is. Bluestar thinks that it is windclan steeling prey and she declares a fight. Fireheart found a way to stop it. Bluestar thinks every one in the clan is a traiter except for Fireheart until he stoped the fight. Riverclan tries to take part of thunderclans territory but thunderclan wont allow it. they start to fight. During the fight Bluestar tells mistyfoot and stonefur the truth that they were her kits and she gave them to riverclan. graystripe lives with riverclan now but he saves Fire heart from leapardstar and she extials him. he becomes a thunderclan cat again. whitepaw becomes a warrior and longtail is mad because his apprentice is older that him and deserves to be a warrior. since longtails apprentice and an apprentice brightpaw didn't become a warrior they went looking for the thing in the forest and try to defeat it so that they can become a warrior. Fireheart finds longtails apprentice dead and brightpaw badly injured. later Fireheart finds out that tigerstar is feeding a pack of dogs in thuderclan territory. he makes a trail of dead animals that leads to thunderclan camp and at the end of the trail is brindleface. Fireheart figures out a plan to get rid of the dogs. Bluestar risks her last life for her clan. The dogs are killed and Bluestar said that firestar will make a great leader.
May 30, 2008
moment of silent for bluestar............................................................................................................................................I HATED HOW ANNOYING SHE WAS IN THIS BOOK but it was sad when she died because she finally understood that her clan really loved her!TIGERSTAR HAS GOT TO GOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!evilllllllllllllllllllllll lol but i hate him for now on! and i agree if jacob or edward dies in twilight then i will also die!(please dont let it be JACOB I LOVE HIM!)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 30, 2008
This book was full of mystery and up and down romance. Now that Fireheart has found out that his enemy, Tigerstar, has gained leadership over ShadowClan. Fireheart is very frightened that this will destroy the forest,but a threat has come to the forest that no cat could ever dream of. But now that Fireheart thinks he knows what the threat is his only problem is getting Bluestar to listen to what he has to say. Many things happen in this book, but it was my FAVORITE of the series!!!!!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 12, 2020
Overall my son is enjoying the series. However, there is a passage in this book that I found offensive and disturbing. This is on page 82 of the edition we have. One of the kittens is deaf and the well respected leader of the clan says upon learning that the kitten is deaf that "I'm afraid he can never be a warrior"...he can't be taught to "fight or hunt...he can't hear commands in battle...and how could he catch prey if he can't listen" and then in the next chapter this kitten, specifically because he can't hear is killed by a hawk.
What would a child who is hard of hearing think upon reading this? The cats in this book aspire to be the best warriors they can be. That's the goal - to live by the warrior code and contribute to the clan. And here the well respected leader is saying that this kitten because he is deaf will never amount to anything and can't contribute to the community in any way.
Cats die in these books all the time and I believe it's important for children to read how the struggles and challenges they face have serious consequences but to say (not even imply) that a cat is worthless because of their deafness is beyond the pale.
I am shocked that a children's author could write these words and a publisher would print them.
What would a child who is hard of hearing think upon reading this? The cats in this book aspire to be the best warriors they can be. That's the goal - to live by the warrior code and contribute to the clan. And here the well respected leader is saying that this kitten because he is deaf will never amount to anything and can't contribute to the community in any way.
Cats die in these books all the time and I believe it's important for children to read how the struggles and challenges they face have serious consequences but to say (not even imply) that a cat is worthless because of their deafness is beyond the pale.
I am shocked that a children's author could write these words and a publisher would print them.
November 16, 2022
I don't like this book.
I remember not liking it as a child and I still don't like it now. It's as if all the parts which I dislike in warrior cats are conjoined into one book, with almost nothing of the parts which I enjoy.
It's the "unaware cult vibes", Blustar's madness, Lostface, the blind belief of the warriors in Starclan, the whole Bramblekit/paw story, Leopardstar (I hate Leopardstar and so should you), Tigerstar (I hate Tigerstar and so should you), cat racism and many more.
It's just all around uncomfortable to read. This is not a book I would like to give moral tips to a child.
Also, I might be chill with most religions, but if Starclan was real they'd be my only exception.
I remember not liking it as a child and I still don't like it now. It's as if all the parts which I dislike in warrior cats are conjoined into one book, with almost nothing of the parts which I enjoy.
It's the "unaware cult vibes", Blustar's madness, Lostface, the blind belief of the warriors in Starclan, the whole Bramblekit/paw story, Leopardstar (I hate Leopardstar and so should you), Tigerstar (I hate Tigerstar and so should you), cat racism and many more.
It's just all around uncomfortable to read. This is not a book I would like to give moral tips to a child.
Also, I might be chill with most religions, but if Starclan was real they'd be my only exception.
September 1, 2018
This book promises the same astonishment you feel when you read the other books in this series. Packed with suprises, jaw-dropping situations and unbelievable secrets, the story is difficult to stop reading. But above all, the amazing descriptions - the forests, the scents and sounds, the feelings and emotions, the thundering of the cats rushing into battle -make this novel come to life.
May 21, 2015
OH MY GOSH THAT ENDING :'( OH MY GOSH THIS BOOK :'(
January 28, 2023
Oh wow, co to była za część! Wojownicy to seria, która z każdym tomem jest coraz lepsza. Jest coraz więcej napięcia, coraz więcej akcji i tutaj zdecydowanie działo się naprawdę dużo, a ja już wiem, że zapewne za maksymalnie kilka dni wrócę do ostatniego tomu, tylko niech ochłoną emocje! Zacznijmy od tego, że nie mogłam się oderwać i po raz kolejny zastanawiałam się, czy potrzebuję snu, czy jednak wolę skończyć książkę :). W dalszym ciągu mam tak, że w trakcie słuchania doskonale wiem, kto jet kim, ale wymienienie imion tak po prostu sprawia, że przegrzewają mi się styli - jest ich naprawdę ogrom i są do siebie podobne, ale kociaki, które je noszą są na tyle różnorodne, że łatwo się w tym połapać.
Dodatkowo została nam tutaj przedstawiona Sfora i jestem ciekawa, czy to ta sama, która dostała swoją serię książek. Jeśli tak, to może być naprawdę ciekawie! No i mamy dość smutne i niespodziewane zakończenie, ale jednocześnie jest takie... w punkt! Naprawdę fajnie kończy niektóre wątki i wywołuje smutny uśmiech. Nie mogę się doczekać finału <3
Dodatkowo została nam tutaj przedstawiona Sfora i jestem ciekawa, czy to ta sama, która dostała swoją serię książek. Jeśli tak, to może być naprawdę ciekawie! No i mamy dość smutne i niespodziewane zakończenie, ale jednocześnie jest takie... w punkt! Naprawdę fajnie kończy niektóre wątki i wywołuje smutny uśmiech. Nie mogę się doczekać finału <3
April 13, 2023
fireheart is dumb 97% of the time, and you can't help but love him
July 1, 2022
Zakończenie było tak słodko-gorzkie, że nie wiem czy kocham tę serię czy nienawidzę że się nade mną pastwi...
August 9, 2024
Pack pack kill kill
November 21, 2016
La magia con que están escritos estos libros me hace devorarlos y disfrutarlos de una forma única. Este es hasta ahora el libro más duro de asimilar; una nueva y feroz amenaza en el bosque, un clan que trata de volver a levantarse, un traidor proclamado líder y el cumplimiento de una profecía que cambiará el destino del clan del trueno. Creo que es difícil de asimilar por la familiaridad que ya se tiene a estas alturas con los personajes y aunque sabes que un suceso en especifico era ya inevitable eso no evita que duela mucho. Es un libro duro pero preciso, lleno de momentos necesarios para lo que viene, que tengo el presentimiento que no será precisamente color rosa.
March 14, 2024
#SforaDoWoraAWórDoJeziora 😎 Boże najlepsza książka ever… Dosłownie kocham a okładka taka piękna (mam inne wydanie niż to które recenzuję) Ogniste Serce (mmmm teraz już bardziej Ognista Gwiazda ehehe) kocham cieeee 👊😭💕
SPOILER ALERT!
Na czym ryczałam:
• Jak dzieci Błękitnej Gwiazdy dzieliły się z nią językami na końcu 🙏
• Jak Tygrysi Pazur został przywódcą klanu (to z niedowierzania i ze złości) 🤮
• Jak Ognisty i Piaskowa burza wyznawali sobie milooooosc❤️❤️❤️❤️
Na czym się wkurwiałam:
• Na tym jak Tygrysia Gwiazda robił z siebie takiego uwu baka kotka i ojej ja jestem taki dobry i tylko chciałem się zobaczyć z dziećmi 🖕 fuck You Tigerstar
• Na tym jak Błękitna Gwiazda po raz 82625251726 raz mówiła że nie ufa swojemu klanowi i to zdrajcy ☺️🖕😕b*th to że jeden raz ktoś zdradził klan nie znaczy że wszyscy nagle zdradzą 🤯😱 no way
• „- (…) Zapamiętaj to miejsce, Ogniste Serce. To tu nie odbędzie się bitwa i nie zostanie przelana krew
- W takim razie powiedz mi, jak jej zapobiec” CALM DOWN ONA DOSŁOWNIE POWIEDZIAŁA CI ZE ŻADNA BITWA SIĘ NIE ODBĘDZIE (potem załapał więc oddaję honor) 🥸🥸🥸☠️☠️☠️
Dziękuję za te cudowne chwile z tobą, Fireheart 🙏🙏
POTRZEBUJE KOLEJNEGO TOMU 😍😍😍😍
SPOILER ALERT!
Na czym ryczałam:
• Jak dzieci Błękitnej Gwiazdy dzieliły się z nią językami na końcu 🙏
• Jak Tygrysi Pazur został przywódcą klanu (to z niedowierzania i ze złości) 🤮
• Jak Ognisty i Piaskowa burza wyznawali sobie milooooosc❤️❤️❤️❤️
Na czym się wkurwiałam:
• Na tym jak Tygrysia Gwiazda robił z siebie takiego uwu baka kotka i ojej ja jestem taki dobry i tylko chciałem się zobaczyć z dziećmi 🖕 fuck You Tigerstar
• Na tym jak Błękitna Gwiazda po raz 82625251726 raz mówiła że nie ufa swojemu klanowi i to zdrajcy ☺️🖕😕b*th to że jeden raz ktoś zdradził klan nie znaczy że wszyscy nagle zdradzą 🤯😱 no way
• „- (…) Zapamiętaj to miejsce, Ogniste Serce. To tu nie odbędzie się bitwa i nie zostanie przelana krew
- W takim razie powiedz mi, jak jej zapobiec” CALM DOWN ONA DOSŁOWNIE POWIEDZIAŁA CI ZE ŻADNA BITWA SIĘ NIE ODBĘDZIE (potem załapał więc oddaję honor) 🥸🥸🥸☠️☠️☠️
Dziękuję za te cudowne chwile z tobą, Fireheart 🙏🙏
POTRZEBUJE KOLEJNEGO TOMU 😍😍😍😍
August 12, 2009
Second read: September 15-19, 2017
I knew what the end of this book brought; it was sad, but it needed to happen for the sake of Thunder Clan. On to the next book and the epic battle that looms in the distance.
First read: August 10-11, 2009
I knew what the end of this book brought; it was sad, but it needed to happen for the sake of Thunder Clan. On to the next book and the epic battle that looms in the distance.
First read: August 10-11, 2009
April 28, 2018
I really enjoyed the first four books but this one wasn't that great. Bluestar was just annoying and unbelievable, the actions of the other clans toward Thunderclan weren't believable. Not figuring out what "pack, kill" meant was unbelievable. Plus nothing really happened. Apprentices were trained, cats hunted, cats went to meetings, cats died... but it was just really repetitive of other books. So many chances missed to kill Tigerstar (like at the very end). Well, one book left. Maybe it will get good again.
December 23, 2011
Originally read in December 2010.
Re-read September 1 ~ 10, 2013.
********SPOILERS*********
***REVIEW IS FOR PERSONAL NOTATION ONLY.***
*
*
*
Re-read September 1 ~ 10, 2013.
********SPOILERS*********
***REVIEW IS FOR PERSONAL NOTATION ONLY.***
*
*
*
March 5, 2022
Because BlueStar died 🤧😔😭😭😭😭😭😭🥱🥱😭😫😫😫😫😫
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 16, 2024
cried. don’t talk to me. i love you bluestar.
Read
July 23, 2024High death count in this one! Many cats harmed in the making!
January 21, 2016
IM SORRY THAT THIS REVIEW HAS SPOILERS D:
Fireheart is the new ThunderClan deputy, and he finds himself taking on more responsibility because his leader Bluestar is mentally and physically ill. To add-on top of that there is Tigerstar, the leader of ShadowClan, and the pack of dogs running wild in the forest. Also his leader, Bluestar, now thinks that everyone in the clan is a traitor, even Fireheart himself. She thinks that StarClan itself has abandoned her. And again she accuses that WindClan is hunting in their territory, and then Bluestar declares war on them and Firestar has to stop it. Will he do it in time or will the dogs wipe them out first?
I honestly don't get why Bluestar is acting so strange. I understand that she's been like sick and traumatized to the fact that their camp almost burned down because of the fire. Whenever Fireheart tries to talk to her, their conversation is basically something on the lines of this...
Fireheart: Bluestar! There's a bunch of dogs on the loose and prey is missing!
Bluestar: Get away from me you traitor! Starclan has abandoned me and has cursed my whole clan! You are all a bunch of traitors! (Yadda yadda yadda)
Fireheart: What could we possibly do?
Bluestar: *continues on raging of how Windclan has "stolen" their prey and how the clan is worthless*
Fireheart: Uh, okay. I'll leave you some peace...
Yep. The story could go on for hours.
However, the ending got pretty good. I was happy that Graystorm has finally come back to Thunderclan and now are best buddies with Fireheart. :) The most depressing part was that Bluestar lost her final life due to the plan of exterminating the dogs. But then when she said, "I knew it was you, Fireheart, who was going to save the clan. I'm sorry." I was like, "WHAT?! YOU KNEW THE WHOLE TIME?! AFGHAGHFGHAGFHA" Then after than I felt really bad and I wanted to blowtorch Tigerstar's head off. :)
End of the book. (and guess who' leader of thunderclan now :D)
Fireheart is the new ThunderClan deputy, and he finds himself taking on more responsibility because his leader Bluestar is mentally and physically ill. To add-on top of that there is Tigerstar, the leader of ShadowClan, and the pack of dogs running wild in the forest. Also his leader, Bluestar, now thinks that everyone in the clan is a traitor, even Fireheart himself. She thinks that StarClan itself has abandoned her. And again she accuses that WindClan is hunting in their territory, and then Bluestar declares war on them and Firestar has to stop it. Will he do it in time or will the dogs wipe them out first?
I honestly don't get why Bluestar is acting so strange. I understand that she's been like sick and traumatized to the fact that their camp almost burned down because of the fire. Whenever Fireheart tries to talk to her, their conversation is basically something on the lines of this...
Fireheart: Bluestar! There's a bunch of dogs on the loose and prey is missing!
Bluestar: Get away from me you traitor! Starclan has abandoned me and has cursed my whole clan! You are all a bunch of traitors! (Yadda yadda yadda)
Fireheart: What could we possibly do?
Bluestar: *continues on raging of how Windclan has "stolen" their prey and how the clan is worthless*
Fireheart: Uh, okay. I'll leave you some peace...
Yep. The story could go on for hours.
However, the ending got pretty good. I was happy that Graystorm has finally come back to Thunderclan and now are best buddies with Fireheart. :) The most depressing part was that Bluestar lost her final life due to the plan of exterminating the dogs. But then when she said, "I knew it was you, Fireheart, who was going to save the clan. I'm sorry." I was like, "WHAT?! YOU KNEW THE WHOLE TIME?! AFGHAGHFGHAGFHA" Then after than I felt really bad and I wanted to blowtorch Tigerstar's head off. :)
End of the book. (and guess who' leader of thunderclan now :D)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 1, 2023
A perfect book that was full of suspense, drama, love, action, and sadness. This book has multiple deaths due to a pack of dogs living in the forest. Swiftpaw died while trying to prove himself worthy as a warrior, brightpaw lost half her face, an eye, and an ear to the same reason, and brindleface died while hunting for her clan. Then, at the very end, Bluestar, the leader, dies. In between all of this, there is drama between ThunderClan and riverclan and windclan. I highly recommend for warriors fans or for fans of cat books!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 3, 2022
تو رهبر بزرگی میشی. یکی از بزرگترین رهبرهایی که قبیله به خودش دیده. تو مثل آتیش گرمی تا از قبیلهت محافظت کنی، و مثل آتیش سوزانی تا ازش دفاع کنی. تو آتشاختر میشی، نور قبیلهی تندر.
°Dead inside gif°
°Dead inside gif°
March 29, 2024
A dangerous path was a very good addition to the series. I read it after having a long break in the books due to needing a change of pace. But coming back to this book was an enjoyable experience. I felt refreshed and ready to continue.
I really appreciated Fireheart's bravery to step up and do what he felt was right for his clan. He truly has what it takes to be a leader. I only gave this book 4 stars because I felt that Bluestar's wavering leadership and distrust of her clan had gone on too long. I had grown annoyed with her unwillingness and lack of ANYTHING. She was a character that I really appreciated in the beginning of the series and I'm sad that she had grown to be an unlikable character. Spoilers ahead:
I also felt like the entire plot of ‘evil in the forest’ didn't feel as weighty as it could have. We only experienced the impact of the dogs near the very end of the book. It felt almost like a side story to help push everything else along rather than a urgent problem for the clan to deal with. But honestly, oh well, I kind of preferred everything else that was going on to the plot with the dogs anyways.
Some other moments worthy of acknowledgement; I loved Cloudpaw's passion for Brightpaw in this book. It was very cute to see such a erratic warrior be honed in by his love for another cat. I also appreciated the rocky relationship of Fireheart and Sandstorm and how they managed to patch it up in the end and finally acknowledge their feelings.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I am eager to see what the next book holds.
I really appreciated Fireheart's bravery to step up and do what he felt was right for his clan. He truly has what it takes to be a leader. I only gave this book 4 stars because I felt that Bluestar's wavering leadership and distrust of her clan had gone on too long. I had grown annoyed with her unwillingness and lack of ANYTHING. She was a character that I really appreciated in the beginning of the series and I'm sad that she had grown to be an unlikable character. Spoilers ahead:
I also felt like the entire plot of ‘evil in the forest’ didn't feel as weighty as it could have. We only experienced the impact of the dogs near the very end of the book. It felt almost like a side story to help push everything else along rather than a urgent problem for the clan to deal with. But honestly, oh well, I kind of preferred everything else that was going on to the plot with the dogs anyways.
Some other moments worthy of acknowledgement; I loved Cloudpaw's passion for Brightpaw in this book. It was very cute to see such a erratic warrior be honed in by his love for another cat. I also appreciated the rocky relationship of Fireheart and Sandstorm and how they managed to patch it up in the end and finally acknowledge their feelings.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I am eager to see what the next book holds.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,148 reviews