4.5 Stars
I really, really, really enjoyed this story.
If you’re sensing a tone of surprise, you’d be spot on. Picking a book, about a relationship-on-the-rocks romance, featuring a lot of miscommunications?! Yeah, both things I’m notorious for avoiding at the best of times.
Yet, I’d heard good things about DiDomizio’s earlier works and when the opportunity to read an ARC of this story came my way, I decided to throw caution (and my most disliked tropes) to the wind, in hopes of finding a hidden gem.
And what a gem I found!
When the story kicks off, we meet protagonist Ray Bruno, an outgoing, internet magazine writer—known previously for his click-bait lifestyle articles—now living a quieter life in suburban NY, with his slightly older, privacy-revering, family doctor fiancé, Kip Hayes.
From the outside, these two are very much #couplegoals, shacked up and still desperately in love (even five years into their relationship), with their Hamptons wedding impending. But they’re also polar opposites, born to different generations (Gen Y and Gen X), with wildly different upbringings, communication styles, and diverse past experiences as gay men that have shaped the people they are and the expectations/needs they have within the parameters of their relationship.
As Ray’s youthful romantic fantasies dictate, he and Kip find themselves heading back to Ray’s coastal New England hometown, to an idyllic resort, known to cater to couples seeking an “earlymoon” before their big day. Yet, what is meant to be a relaxing, romantic getaway, soon devolves into anything but, as they encounter old faces from their pasts, which, subsequently, brings to light some long-standing issues they each have, forcing them to face some deep personal revelations and emotional truths, and ultimately putting their relationship to the test in a big make or break way.
What follows are a lot of relationship challenging moments; scenes where you cringe or get mad or get smacked with hard-hitting personal truths that make you want to spontaneously cry while re-assessing your own life and what led you to this point. It’s one of those stories. One of those emotionally resonant pieces that challenge a reader’s own feelings and thinking, about everything, not just relationships and their personal ideals of love.
But DiDomizio is damn clever, because, he manages to make you feel all the deeper feels and think all the deeper thoughts, while also sneakily wrapping the heavier, angstier, “thinking” themes of the story within a narrative that is wholly fun, morish and entertaining; voicing it all through a highly likeable and relatable couple, who I couldn’t help adore from the first flashback scene of their meet-cute, through all their current-day arguments and miscommunications, and well beyond the point where my “reads romance for escapism” self would usually be annoyed to be reading about a book couple dealing so realistically with real-life coupley things.
All this is to say, it could have been a total downer but I found it refreshing, charming and, maybe surprisingly, deeply romantic.
As I mentioned earlier, I do not usually enjoy (or even bother with) established couple, relationship-on-the-rocks-type romances, but I was so damn impressed and consumed by this one—so much so that it has me re-evaluating my stance on this entire trope. And miscommunication!? Surely, no one is sitting around eager for their next miscommunication-themed read? Right?! Yet, this book just goes to show how any tropes—even ones we don’t normally like—can be made desirable when in the hands of great writers.
DiDomizio’s writing—in truth, his voice—was ultimately the biggest draw for me. Born of the same generation, I understood and related to everything Ray was about. From his nineties, pop culture entrenched upbringing, to his outward-validation-seeking, social media immersed twenties; to his probably-unrealistic romantic expectations and deeper personal insecurities that made him question his worth as a partner well into his thirties. I got this guy; lord, did I ever. And because of this authentic, me-specific MC relatability, I found myself completely consumed by his very simple, but deeply thought-provoking, personal-stance-questioning, often-hilarious and smile-inducing story.
Needless to say, I enjoyed the heck out of this story, and now I find myself so inspired, that I’m off to make a Lilith Fair greatest hits playlist to end all playlists, because as we all know (or should know), that shit is ICONIC! (inside joke for those playing at home)
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! <3
***A special thanks to the publishers (via Netgalley) for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.