2.5 Stars. Having enjoyed Heather Morris's informative historical novels in The Tattooist of Auschwitz series, I was excited to receive this ARC. I regret to say that I was disappointed in this story of women POWs detained in Japanese Prison Camps. The story begins with the fall of Singapore and the Malay district to the Japanese army in 1942 and continues until the end of WW2 in 1945.
A ship evacuated Residents and Australian nurses, but the Japanese bombarded and sank the ship. Among many onboard the sinking ship, there were deaths and injuries. The story focused on two women who survived, Nesta and Norah, who spent 24 hours in the water clinging to debris. They and other survivors ended up on a remote island, captured by Japanese soldiers and forced into a prison camp. The camp included Dutch nuns, Dutch and English civilians, and Australian nurses. The men were immediately separated from the women prisoners and interred in a different base. Norah's husband, ill with typhoid, was taken away. The women were moved from one camp to the next. These camps were filthy, disease-ridden, and lacked sufficient food and water. Conditions worsened, and punishments became more brutal when the Japanese guards knew they were losing the war.
The structure and flow of the story were choppy, and the narration was dialogue-heavy. Minor conversations covered some events without additional context. The narration was by telling rather than showing through basic, rudimentary dialogues.
I admired that the author based her characters on real people for us to get to know them so they would be remembered. There is a list at the book's end detailing what is known about the actual characters who form the basis of the story. Learning how the women banded together in sisterhood, sharing, nursing, and caring for one another with encouraging words or hope is uplifting. The survivors of the ship disaster had only the clothes on their backs, while others had money and suitcases full of clothing. This divided the prisoners into have and have-not groups. Petticoats were torn to provide bandages. When a food vendor was allowed into camp to sell healthy food, some could not purchase the much-needed food without the help of others.
The women raised spirits through music concerts, a voice orchestra and a newspaper. I became bored with all the lengthy descriptions of the music. At one point, everyone was sad and mourning the death of a woman who had never been mentioned before, so there was no emotional connection.
Having watched the wonderful TENKO on TV years ago and read about some POW camps, I found a few things hard to believe, such as prisoners cutting the grass with scissors and knives. I wonder if the frequent confrontations with the camp commanders about rule changes and the defying of guards would result in punishment. I wanted more description of the camps and the surrounding Sumatran jungle.
Norah and Nesta became the two main characters. Norah was an English musician, and Nesta was an Australian nurse. They were similar in words and actions, and it wasn't easy to distinguish them. Both women were dedicated to caring for others, raising hope and morale, and volunteering for the most unpleasant jobs. Too many background character names detracted from Norah's and Nesta's stories and caused me to fail to connect with the individuals on an emotional level. As they were moved from camp to camp, new names for camp captains and guards were added. There was never a lack of volunteers to do the filthiest jobs, such as cleaning sewage drains, clearing well bottoms, and patching the roof. Four women volunteered as 'comfort women' for the guards so their companions would be left alone and not harassed or punished.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. Despite my misgivings, I will watch for the author's next book. October 24 is the date of publication.