YEAR OF THE DRAGON YEAAAAAAAAH
I’m going to go ahead and say that I have not been particularly impressed by the “Merlin’s Dragon” trilogy. I liked this one better than the second one, I think, but also they never should have been separated. This one feels as if it’s the conclusion of a book, stretched out to make the story into a trilogy when it didn’t need to be.
There are things that this book does better; this feels more like a dragon book, for starters. All the dragon characters in this one are introduced in the last one, but here the book feels like it’s actually about them, which is cool and I prefer that. I would love to have seen more Avalonian dragon adventures, and the bits we got here were a good start. If only we had gotten more! Still, it’s really cool to see Basilgarrad, a water dragon, and a fire dragon, team up to fight the forces of evil.
Merlin’s better in this one, too. Here we get kooky-old-man-Merlin, as opposed to slightly-aged-up-Lost Years-Merlin, who is just a doof. I am back to liking him; he isn’t flawless, but he feels like he makes much more sense. There’s also a better idea of where this fits in the timeline with King Arthur and stuff, from comments that Merlin makes, which is something that has long bothered me with the Avalon books.
Krystallus is a mixed bag. Merlin’s son is still a doof. And I understand why! But at times it goes too far. One bit of dialogue claims that Merlin treated him the way Merlin’s own father treated his son, which no one corrects, and, uh, NO. Not even a little bit. Get your head out of your butt. I’m not sure about his relationship with Serella, either, considering that we KNOW he has a child later on, and I’m pretty sure Serella isn’t the mother? That’s an interesting sort of history for the character. At the same time, Krystallus and Serella’s relationship goes with the trend that Barron started in “Great Tree of Avalon” which is “Bickering Couple = True Love”, which is a bit annoying.
Also! Tell me, Thomas Archibald, what is the point of Doomraga? When he shows up in the first book, I assumed he WAS Rhita Gawr; the second names him and reveals he’s Rhita Gawr’s minion, and then in this one gets possessed by Rhita Gawr, meaning… he might as well have just been Rhita Gawr to begin with. Given how silly ‘Doomraga’ is as a name, and that he’s never mentioned again, and has no distinct personality traits… he doesn’t need to be a thing.
I wanted to like this trilogy much more than I did; it’s about Merlin’s Dragon Friend, after all! But it’s just kind of… filling in the gaps that didn’t need to be filled with a mostly bland story that isn’t interested in doing something all that new.