Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

We'd Rather Fight than Eat

Rate this book
Society has fallen.

And now the struggle for survival has begun.

This action-packed adventure brings childhood friends back to their isolated hometown, a rural community on an island in the Atlantic Ocean, where they find refuge. Among the ashes of the apocalypse, the people of Beckford must band together if they hope to stay alive.

Meanwhile, a new empire has emerged from the smouldering wreckage of St. John's, once the capital city of Newfoundland. Its leader, an enigmatic figure whose rise to power was paved with violence, has established a new world order. She plans to rebuild humanity according to her vision.

But the town of Beckford stands in her way.

As the will to protect Beckford from the people of St. John’s intensifies, it will take everything Jack, Megan, Sarah, and Brooke can give to ensure their survival.

280 pages, Paperback

Published August 4, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jay McGrath

3 books4 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
18 (26%)
4 stars
23 (34%)
3 stars
17 (25%)
2 stars
7 (10%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews
180 reviews3 followers
November 23, 2023
This speculative novel is set about a hundred years in the future, in Newfoundland. Society has collapsed and we see the residents of two small coastal communities trying to survive, and hang on to some semblance of order. The return of several people from St John's sets up a conflict with what passes for government. There's lots of well- done dialogue, and all the trouble and strife you'd expect in a doomsday story. Jay McGrath has done a fine job as author.
Profile Image for Erica Clark.
83 reviews2 followers
January 18, 2024
I really enjoyed seeing each characters point of view and learning tidbits of their life throughout the story. I did not expect the ending at all!
Profile Image for Harold Walters.
2,097 reviews37 followers
October 5, 2023
Which is the way the world ends?

T. S. Eliot says, “Not with a bang but a whimper.”

In scripture, sometime after Noah and all the two-by-twos have found dry land, God, or a biblical prophet, says, “Fire next time.”

Since WWII, throughout the Cold War era, till nowadays during Putin the Poop’s war on Ukraine, folks have feared the Bomb would trigger the Apocalypse.

So far, none of the above.

In his novel We’d Rather Fight Than Eat [Flanker Press] Jay McGrath suggests the world will end — has ended basically — because of Facebook.

That’s a lie.

Facebook isn’t flat out blamed, but an apocalyptic website is blamed because …

Never mind. Buy the book. Read the particulars.

Suffice it to say, when the story opens, the Apocalypse has happened.

And b’ys, get this: many of the survivors (of course, there’re always survivors) live out around the bay.

Here’s a surprise: other survivors who live in the Capitol City — familiarly known as “that crowd from St. John’s” — following their leader Daneille, want to annihilate, or Borg-like, assimilate the baymen. (Okay, baywomen, baychildren, baycats and baydogs. Frig sake, don’t you just hate genders-specific nouns?)

Considering the author’s boyhood place of abode, and from my point of view here in the GPA (Greater Placentia Area), Beckford, the outport setting of Rather Fight, is suspiciously like a community down the Cape Shore.

Be that as it may.

The first end-of-the-world book I read was Pat Frank’s iconic novel Alas Babylon, way back in a previous century — 1962, or thereabouts for frig sake. Its storyline: The Bomb has laid waste to the world and the survivors are struggling to cope with the aftermath and rebuild civilization, or whatever.

Familiar story, eh b’ys?

Since Babylon, I’ve read the end-of-the-world tale a thousand times and, like a well-written western, like a well-written murder mystery, the story never grows old. It is never truly cliche if the author keeps his characters interesting and the plot clippity-clopping along.

Rather Fight is the most recently read of the aforementioned thousand tales, and it deserves shelf-space among those long since spun doomsday yarns.

To drift off track a little …

… I’m not a complex man. Little things, tiny details often amuse me.

Bakeapples, for instance.

I don’t know the number of people out in the Big Wide World who know exactly what a bakeapple is, know that it’s a bog-berry shaped something like an orange cumulus cloud and tastes nothing like an oven-cooked compote whose main ingredient is an orchard fruit.

So?

Well, here’s the thing. Author McGrath mentions bakeapples a couple of times in Rather Fight. Once to describe an inept person as being “a few bakeapples short of a bucket,” and once as a passing reference — “The bakeapples are late this year.”

So?

Well, here’s another thing. Bakeapples don’t grow in abundance everywhere and berry pickers don’t all like to advertise their favourite berry patches. By alluding to bakeapples, I fear young Jay McGrath, despite providing a couple of daubs of local colour, has freed the feline regarding fruitful berry patches.

Down the Cape Shore. That’s your spot for bakeapples, eh b’ys?

A few lines back I’ve described the author as “young” Jay McGrath. And so he is, compared to me, a creaky old curmudgeon who has not yet scribbled his memoirs. The author is a whippersnapper who has written a gem-dandy end-of-the-world story.

So …

… whippersnapper or not, Jay old man, keep it up.

Thank you for reading.
Profile Image for Ian.
45 reviews1 follower
February 27, 2024
So I stopped this book but had to go back and finish. I really enjoyed it. Format was a little confusing and choppy but the overall narrative was fantastic.I’m hopeful that a sequel is in the works (spoiler possible) I’d love to see a resolution to the unfinished elements of this story.
Profile Image for Nicole.
536 reviews15 followers
November 23, 2023
“We’d Rather Fight Than Eat” is a debut novel by author Jay McGrath from local Newfoundland publisher Flanker Press. This is the story of survival amongst the ruins of small, isolated province and the people who have taken refuge there. Factions have arisen; what is left of the city of St. John’s finds itself under new, questionable leadership. The city is rife with violence and its new leader is bent on recreating a world of her own making, serving her and her followers regardless of the cost to everyone else.

Outside of St. John’s we have the town of Beckford. It’s a holdout and our main characters, Jack, Megan, Sarah, and Brooke are doing everything within their power to keep their small town safe from these outside forces. It may take everything in them to make this happen – maybe even their very lives.

This is a no holds barred action adventure set in the post-downfall society of Newfoundland. It is dark and violent and very entertaining. The characters are well developed, the plot is creative and fast-paced, the tone desperate and frenetic.

It’s a great read! I got through it quickly. The world that McGrath created here felt real enough that it makes the reader wonder if something like that could happen here in our small province. It felt authentic. It reminded me a bit of the first season of The Walking Dead where people are just trying to make it though, they only have each other to rely on and they aren’t sure exactly who they can trust.

Perfect for fans of dystopia or apocalyptic fiction!
Profile Image for Robert W. Lundrigan.
4 reviews3 followers
September 24, 2023
Hi Jay, I must confess, I have not yet read this book yet, so this is not as much a review as it is a commentary on a recent review. I have been following its progress since your book launch recently, and I am delighted to see the wonderful review of your book, "We'd Rather Fight Than Eat," by Joan Sullivan. Anytime a review refers to, "rich, full volume storytelling", and that the author has, "a wicked eye for detail", and then ends the review with the suggestion that, "this would make a great TV series", has to be gratifying experience for the author and, importantly, an unmistakable signal to readers that this is a MUST READ novel. I hope many people buy, read, and experience your very well written and creative work.

Big congratulations to YOU, Jay McGrath!!
2 reviews1 follower
December 27, 2024
Wow. Just wow.
An excellent read over the holidays! A great blend of community and characters. The suspense, small touches of that great Irish/NL dialect, a loyal dog, discussions/allusions to religion/the church, and the power of friendship, family, and community make this a fantastic read. This book is a treasure.
You will not regret reading this book. Will be looking for the sequel - here’s hoping!! It’s the type of book that after you finish reading you are speechless, curious, and eager to be on the journey with the characters, who I feel like became my friends (and family) along the way.
5 Stars!
(Ryan needs a sequel!!!)
5 reviews1 follower
January 24, 2024
It was an interesting premise for a suspense novel set in current times in rural NL. I appreciated the local geographical references. The dialog had a lot of common dialectal sayings. While it was not a genre I usually go for, I was compelled to keep reading. I was invested in the characters and the storyline.
1 review1 follower
August 15, 2023
Wow! I picked up this book because I’d heard a lot about it, and I now know why! This book is something else. I particularly love the strong female characters and the way the author incorporates a mix of humour and suspense. A must read for sure!
1 review1 follower
August 6, 2023
This book is a rare gem with thrilling storyline and captivating characters. Couldn’t put it down! Highly recommend if you’re looking for a thought provoking story packed with action.
18 reviews1 follower
January 15, 2024
It pained me to finish this book - I’ll leave it at that. Would not recommend.
Profile Image for David Lynch.
Author 4 books3 followers
April 30, 2024
Great job Jay. Really hope the story continues with a sequel.
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews