From the first page, I found Gondar utterly captivating. The first 10% of the book was a FULL FIVE, and it is very rare that I can give a book - or even part of one - such an accolade.
One of the most noticeable things for me is that there was not a single typo, at least, I didn't notice a single one, and typos usually jump out at me. This shows the rigor, the thoroughness, that is possible with traditional publishing, and I say that as a lover and supporter of e-publishing.
The prose was evocative, and gorgeously rich, succulent and satisfying.
Much is made of mysticism, of a tribal truth and a sort of psychic awareness, but despite the efforts of the author to be consistent, it ended up feeling like something he didn't fully support, because when I wanted and expected that mysticism the most, it wasn't there.
The characters are well-crafted, and ultimately believable. While certain elements of the story are predictable up to a point (how else could you write a single story about Africans and Scots?) there is enough to surprise the reader.
I was particularly impressed by the depiction of African wildlife, which really helped to immerse me in the story, and fill me with wonder.
A thoroughly enjoyable read.