As with any collection, this one is somewhat uneven, ranging in quality from the very beautiful to the frankly quite amateurish. The good, though, far outweighed the bad and the edition with it's dual language quality was both quite lovely and flattering to my not terribly advanced French language skills. This then, is a collection that is not just important (the voices of indigenous peoples of Canada is not something I have ever had much occasion to read before) but good.
And I can't help be left with a feeling of frustration when I see that I am the only person on goodreads who has read it. Earlier in the month I read the aggressively mediocre Miss Peregrine's School for Peculiar Children (it was suggested to me by a colleague and, as he sits across from me in the dressing room and sees me read all the time I couldn't avoid giving it a try). Not only was it bad, it made no real attempt to be good. And it has 416,954 ratings and 37,698 reviews! I understand wanting to read easy books that don't challenge. I do it all the time (I'm rereading a bunch of Sharpe novels at the moment!). But in between all the comfort food it is so important try something new. And when you go back to eating the chicken and waffles they will taste all the better for the spicy ramen (or sweet potato tagine or shrimp ceviche or whatever) you had before.
So this "review" ended up as a bit of a lecture or sermon. oops... oh well... so... back on topic... read this book! It's great!