I found this book after hearing Natalie on a podcast I love, The Realignment. I wanted to love this book. I wanted to tell all my friends to read this book. It has all the ideas I believe in the most. But there was something missing from it. It was almost like it was just the first half of the book, and I was waiting for the part where we find out what happens next.
Foster runs through the social movements for universal healthcare, childcare, higher education, housing, and more...detailing exactly how far we've come in just a few short decades. She talks about how each movement started, and how much they've each grown, and how our country is poised to accept these once-radical notions as part of a new social contract in America. But after that...it just sort of ends. She admits that many of these policies were put in place during COVID, and that many of them have also since expired or been repealed. There are no answers as to how we might bring them back. There is very little on how exactly we replace neoliberalism, or how any of this looks as a legitimate economic policy, which I would have loved to hear more about. There is very little meat other than to say "Hey! Look! We did a thing! We're still sort of doing a thing! Let's not quit now!" But maybe this book is meant more as a cup of water from the sidelines halfway through a marathon just before you're about to hit the wall. Just a quick reminder of how far we've come to help you forget about how far we still have to go.
Ms. Foster—Natalie—if you read this, I'm sorry. I really, really did want to love it. And I love your ideas, and all the work you've done, and please keep fighting the good fight! I know I will, too.