I am one of the judges of the special hybrid team Epic Space Stars for the SPSFC3 contest. This review is my personal opinion. Officially, it is still in the running for the contest, pending any official team announcements.
Status: Cut
Read: 20%
One advantage of judging books without reading the blurb or even see the cover is that I am entering the book with as much of an open mind as possible. If I had read the blurb of this book beforehand, I would have wanted to nope myself and not read the book at all.
Which would not be fair because the Three rivers plague is really, really good. Prosewise save for a few scenes that were confusing to me (like the one where Nick's group steals food from some weird cultists), I don't have any major complaints. I think I only spotted 1 typo in the first 20% of the book. Given this is quite a surprisingly big chonker (which I found to be unusual for this genre), I feel a huge appreciation for the two authors for editing the book. It must have been a titantic feat.
So, if the book is undeniably good, why would I cut it? This decision really tears me apart and I had been thinking about this decision for hours. For better or worse, this book had the odd fortune of being placed in a real group of death. There's at least 10 equally good books in this group and I doubt we can let more than 8 of them pass to the quarterfinals. If it had been placed in another group, it would have had good chances to advance to the next stage. In a nutshell, the book is great, but other books were just a tad bit better. One huge upside is that the SPSFC competition allows books to compete again for a second shot. I dare say even though this book is insanely long, I like the dual author's voice style and the read never felt tedious despite its massive length.
Now, everyone will wonder: what is the second problem that made me struggle so much with this book? Sadly, I really detest reading zombie books. If there was ever a top 3 of book tropes I almost never enjoy, one of them would be post-apocalyptic zombie books. Especially ones that take place in the US with zombies that are overpowered and there's lots of bullets being shot left & right. And yes, this book just happens to have the big three complete with shanty towns ruled by armed thugs. Fortunately, the protagonists in this book are insanely likeable and most of the thugs I have met so far seem agreeable.
What makes Three rivers plague stand apart is that our protagonists are all members of a punk 80's rock band that get ushered inside a VIP SUV by masked supersoldiers when the zombie outbreak begins and become trapped in a zeppelin prison. Up to the early point of the story, the scene where the zeppelin rocks to the side made me wonder if the government had sent a nuclear bomb. I was very invested in the book at first (once again, the writing quality is great) when I assumed this wouldn't be a Mad Max zombie book. But I still liked the protagonists, especially Thomas who frequently steals Valium pills from the nurse station. Quite frankly, I was surprised soldiers in the late 1980's had the technology to instantly detect if someone had the zombie disease. Instant 2 seconds. The soldier visors looked insanely advanced for the era. In a way, the way the city and technology is designed, the book is so vague that anyone could have assumed it happened as recently as 2005. I was also liking Nick a lot, he seems like a chirpy guy and knowledgeable about military grade weapons.
What didn't work for me (aside from the zombies)?
Perhaps the way the characters are purposely left 100% ignorant about the zombie disease so many months later. And the warden of the zeppelin gives them ample amounts of non-perishable food without telling them what kinds of dangers they will face. It would make sense he wouldn't know 100% of the disease, but someone would have a Ham radio. People in the 80's and 90's were quite good at building customized radios that detected all kinds of frequencies and eavesdrop on police messages or neighborhood gossip. The book hints the warden's decisions stem from stubborn ignorance, which makes sense. But I am still confused as to why even the soldiers didn't give them a heads up crash course while giving them so much food. These kinds of situations leaving characters off the loop for plot convenience are very common in zombie books.
Rachel was a nice character, but we never quite got to know her. Up until this portion of the book, female characters are almost nonexistant. It only further drives me a bit farther away from the book because I can't identify with the gun wielding strong male cast. I also enjoy post-apocalyptic books where somone with a huge physical and emotional disadvantage has to use wits and grit to overcome situations. In this way, Thomas's drug addiction could have been explored a bit more. Maybe later on in the novel, other characters discover he is having withdrawal symptoms. This isn't shown at the 20% point.
One thing I will add before I finish is Science Fiction is barely a plot point in the early stages of this novel. There is a chance we will get more science thrown in, but in a group of death with several very strong contenders for the quarterfinals, it would be natural books with more Sci-Fi elements early on would have a greater advantage.
To conclude this review, I am certain people that love the big three zombie book tropes will love this book. Having the 6 protagonists as members of the same music band was very clever and makes the reader get to know each member from the start. Maybe I will continue reading this book to discover how it ends. But the book depresses me so much at times that I really want to set it aside and read something more lighthearted.