4.0. I don’t think the description really did the book justice. There were some suspenseful moments, but I thought this was more of a really sweet love story. In reading the other reviews, most people who gave the book a low score said it was because of characters being annoying or the writing being juvenile. I’ll explain why I disagree in the applicable areas.
Plot:
Lilly Nightingale has just started college. While trying to avoid (and recover from) Will, the boy of her dreams in high school, she meets Brand Cole. The minute Brand takes a liking to Lilly, Will tries to re-enter her life. Both guys warn Lilly about the each other, and soon, several attempts are made on Lilly’s life. Similar strange occurrences have happened in the past, and Will was always present, but Lilly chalked it up to fate. As the story progresses, she finds out that everything happened for a reason. She also learns why Will was always there when bad things happened in the past, why he broke her heart, why someone wants to kill her now, and how Brand is involved in everything that is happening.
Characters:
In reading the other reviews, a lot of people found the characters irritating. To me, the characters were actually refreshing. I’ve said it a million times before, but in most YA novels, the heroine is extremely weak (think Bella Swan prior to becoming a vampire) or extremely snarky and brash (sorry, but Rose from Vampire Academy is the first to come to mind). While Lilly may seem to lean toward the former, and while the guys are bound and determined to protect her, she isn’t really weak because things happen to her BEFORE she has the chance to react. She does lack self-esteem, and she does feel cursed, but based on the comments her mother makes, the fact that no one other guy has ever taken interest in her, and the near death experiences she had in the past, her state of mind makes perfect sense.
The guys—Brand and Will, not so much Malcolm—aren’t your typical broody, smart-alecky, “I’m going to be indifferent and then suddenly fall in love with you” kind of guys either. (Think Edward Cullen or Jace Wayland.) Brand is sweet and romantic and tells Lilly he likes her immediately, and that’s kind of new. Will is also sweet and willing to put aside his differences with Brand to make sure Lilly is safe and happy. You can’t really ask for more than that in a book boyfriend. I did find Malcolm a little unnecessary and annoying, and I do hate it when every guy in a book falls in love with the heroine, so I will concede there. At least Lilly put a lot of thought into it and made a choice, so that’s good.
The other primary character, Tara, didn’t bother me either. She actually reminded me of Tara from True Blood, so I’m kind of used to the sassy, best friend aspect, and I could practically hear her voice in my head as I read her dialogue. It was also nice to see a friend question the heroine’s judgment or even tell her what the best course of action would be rather than just being in love with love like some book BFFs are.
Writing:
Some people mentioned that the writing was juvenile. I didn’t really feel that way. There wasn’t any fighting as foreplay or unrequited sexual tension. The romance was more old school and poetic, but sweet none the less. If anything bothered me about the writing, it was spelling/punctuation/grammatical errors. There were a lot of them but nothing so grievous that it took away from the story.
The Bottom Line:
I liked Cursed. It was an easy read with a nice twist on old characters (vampires, werewolves, angels, etc.). While there’s not really a drastic, “I’m stopping mid-action”-type cliffhanger, there are lots of questions that I’m sure will be answered in the next books. I’ve already downloaded Blessed and am happily looking forward to reading it.