In the interest of full disclosure, before you begin reading this book review, I must acknowledge that going into this the 4th book in Marie Force’s Treading Water series, (a book the blurb says her fans insisted she write) I knew I was going to struggle with embracing the love story between Kate Harington and Reid Matthews, whose love affair began in Marking Time, the 2nd book in this series. Much like Kate’s parents, in that story I was horrified at the idea of a romance between then 18-year-old (soon not to be) virgin Kate, and almost 46-year-old Reid Matthews who had been one of her father Jack’s Berkley College buddies. Already knowing from this book’s blurb that a big part of this story was Kate and Reid reuniting after a 10-year long separation during which Kate became a Taylor Swift level music star and Reid had sold off all of his businesses and headed off to San Kitts to leave the rat race behind and heal his broken heart after Kate left him. As a father of now adult daughters and myself being several years older than the Reid character in this story, I honestly didn’t find a renewed love affair between now 28-year-old Kate and 56-year-old Reid a whole lot more palatable than I did when they were 18 and 45 years old respectively. Okay, Kate at 28 years old is now a grown adult and has more worldly experience than she did when she first met Reid ten years ago. But still. Apparently, I wasn’t alone because the tension between Kate’s parents and Reid’s son Ashton over Reid’s and Kate’s renewed relationship is a big part of this story. Despite my misgivings, after reading the first two books in this series (I skipped Book #3) I was hooked on finding out what the future would bring for the Harrington family. So, I plunged ahead with this book. And if I’m again being honest, once I started it I found it difficult to put down.
As our story opens Kate is passing out on the concert stage in Oklahoma City after coming back too soon from a bad case of pneumonia. The only reason she rushed back into her concert tour schedule was to silence the paparazzi who not being able to find any real dirt on Kate liked to make up lascivious stories about alleged drug and relationship problems. While lying in her hospital bed Kate comes to the realization that for all of her fame and fortune, she’s not happy. She’s living in a guilded cage where all she does is write songs, practice songs,record her music and perform at sold out concerts all over the world. But she never really gets to experience any of the cities she performs in and she can’t go anywhere without an army of security around her. She rarely gets to spend any time with her family and her younger brothers are growing up not really even knowing her. She loves her music, she loves performing in front of her fans but the rest of the stuff is grinding her down. As she tells her older sister Jill who became her attorney/manager/Girl Friday after graduating at the top of her Harvard Law class, for all the money and possessions they have they never have any real time just for themselves to enjoy any of it. They rarely spend any time living in their luxury homes or driving their luxury cars or even doing simple things like riding their horses that live in the stable on their adjoining properties. Kate desperately needs to get off the celebrity merry-go-round for a while and she wants her big sister who spends 24/7 supporting Kate’s career to do likewise. What Kate doesn’t tell Jill at the time is she also desperately wants to find Reid Matthews, the only man she’s ever loved and apologize for her role in their break up and see if there’s still the same spark between them. Well, I hope Reid Matthews has loaded up on Viagra because a 56-year-old man is going to need it to keep a 28-year-old lover satisfied. Except apparently in contemporary romance where Reid looks forty and has the vitality of a man much younger.
Ashton Mathews Reid’s now 35-year-old son was hardly my favorite character at the start of this book. Somehow Ashton blames Kate for his father’s devastation over his and Kate’s break up. Despite being a normally level headed and intelligent man, Ashton blames a then 18-year-old and innocent Kate for the affair with his much older and more worldly father. An affair he personally hastened the end to by informing Kate’s father of what was going on between his daughter and Ashton’s father. I’m sure that in Marking Time no small part of the reason Ashton was so upset to discover his father was banging Kate and still holds a grudge against her was because Kate had rejected his attempts to be more than her friend because she was already in love with his father. But here’s the rub. Ashton is now attracted to Jill and Jill is attracted to Ashton. Since Ashton has made it clear from the day he found out about Kate and his father that he doesn’t like Kate, I don’t know how we readers were supposed to believe that Jill could ever be attracted to a man who didn’t like her sister and BFF? During one of their frequent business meetings (because Ashton represents Kate’s record label) he begins to flirt with Jill and asks a shocked Jill out. Jill has been crushing on Ashton for years. But considering the animosity between Ashton and Kate she never imagined her secret crush was reciprocated. As can only happen in a contemporary romance novel, what Jill thought was supposed to be a simple dinner date turns into Jill agreeing to fly from Nashville to Malibu with Ashton for an unspecified amount of time, where Ashton’s plane isn’t the only thing that takes off.
While Jill and Ashton are getting to know each other Kate flies to the island of St. Kitt to find Reid. She discovers Reid is living with Mari, a beautiful island woman. Her heart is broken but still she forges ahead delivering her apology to Reid for breaking up with him, telling him she’s never forgotten him and thinks about him every day. Reid gives her a rather cool reception telling her she has no need to apologize and then tells her he can hook her up at a nearby 5-star resort owned by a friend, for however long she plans to stay in St. Kitts. Reid watches Kate walk away with his heart and brain in turmoil. He has made a comfortable life for himself with Mari on St. Kitts. Would he be willing to blow it all up and hurt Mari to be with Kate? Mari loves Reid but she realizes he still loves Kate. After an angry confrontation with Reid she packs up a few of her things and leaves him. This leaves Reid free to act upon his feelings for Kate. So later that night he shows up at her suite where they pour their hearts out to each other. This is where their love story is reborn. They promise their undying love for each other and swear that nothing will ever cause them to part again. But the road to their happily ever after is not an easy one. A vengeful Mari does something to greatly embarrass Kate and damage her career. Reid’s son Ashton and Kate’s father Jack while not as openly hostile to their relationship as they were the first time around, are only begrudgingly accepting of it. Kate makes some decisions about her career that bring her into conflict with longtime country superstar Buddy Longstreet whom with his wife Taylor (also a country superstar in her own rite) have served as her music industry mentors and become her Nashville family. Buddy who is BFFs with Reid also owns the record label Kate is signed to and Kate is second only to Buddy and Taylor for record sales on the label. There’s a whole lot that happens in Kate’s and Reid’s and Jill’s and Ashton’s lives as the Thanksgiving-Christmas season draws near and they prepare to host a family Christmas for all of Kate’s large extended family, Reid and Ashton and the Longstreets. Despite all the obstacles the story ends with a very happy ending for everyone because life may not always give us a H.E.A. but contemporary romances always do.