It’s been a while since I read Sing Me To Sleep, but going back into this story was easy. The recollections of the first book were subtle enough not to be annoying and helped me get back on track.
The plot seems quite obvious. Saoirse has to leave Hayes behind and go to the other side of the barrier. She doesn’t know what’s waiting there – a people full of aggression against Keirdrens, an army big enough to destroy everything?
I expected so much action. While Saoirse as a siren and enemy of Keirdre probably has nothing to fear, she definitely wants Hayes to be safe. I expected her to fight for him on the other side, have the barrier come down, to have a full-on war.
But there was barely any action in this book. It’s much more on the intrigue side of things. Saoirse realises quite quickly that things are not as she (and I) expected them to be, but that doesn’t mean peace. There is so much scheming from basically everyone, so many hidden secrets. Multiple times I thought that we now know everything and then something knew got revealed.
It kind of fit. I had expected more action, but this way actually made so much sense and it wasn’t boring either.
Usually, I hate it when there is one revelation after the other, but in this case, it was so well done.
Unfortunately, this also made the book a bit confusing. I didn’t know anymore who wanted to do what and who had actually done what. But it did get cleared up before the finale.
One thing that did disappoint me, however, were the relationships. I wanted to see more of Carrik. He is so interesting! I really liked him and I was happy to see him in a huge part of the book, but he barely did anything. While he did get his moments to show his importance, it wasn’t enough. He could’ve played an even bigger role in my opinion. For quite a long time he felt like a pretty but unnecessary accessory.
I wasn’t quite happy with Hayes either. In a way, that made sense, considering the ending of Sing Me To Sleep. I would’ve been disappointed, if the two of them were able to overcome their problems without a second thought. But at the same time, it was so frustrating. Both of them lying, both of them not trusting each other. But at the same time Hayes is way too in love with Saoirse. He said some things that literally had me melting, but most of the time I just wanted to tell him that there is love and then there is stupidity. The way it got resolved was fine, but I feel like the two of them still have a long way to go. Them solving their problems could’ve taken even longer.
We get a couple of new characters and while they were interesting, most of them felt pretty one dimensional. They had their part to play and they did it well, but that’s it.
I’m still split about the overall ending. It was a bit strange and unrealistic, but this is a fantasy book, so who am I to judge? And at least it was something smart and different.
The writing style was good. I loved the descriptions and the emotions were very tangible. My heart broke for Saoirse over and over again. But I do believe that the pacing could’ve been better. The beginning was a bit slow, the ending seemed slightly rushed. I also wish we could’ve had more world building. Show me more of the different creatures, show me more of Pennex and how they all live together. There are barely any humans of importance, but all the creatures look like humans and never use their magic, so why even make the difference?
But it was a nice conclusion to the duology. I enjoyed it!
Thank you, NetGalley and Hodder&Stoughton for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!