I read a free advance digital review copy provided by the publisher via Netgalley.
This is a pre-publication review, so there may be changes in the published book. The version I read doesn’t include the murder trial of Alex Murdaugh, but there is an indication that the final published version will.
Much of the focus of the early part of the book is the history of the Murdaugh family as prosecutors and, at the same time, plaintiffs’ tort lawyers. I’m glad this is such a focus, because anyone who took any interest in this case already knows a lot about the events from the last few years, from housekeeper Gloria Satterfield’s death at the Murdaugh house, young Stephen Smith’s death on a rural road, Paul Murdaugh’s drunken boat driving causing the death of Mallory Beach, Alex Murdaugh being fired from his firm for embezzlement on a grand scale, his attempt to claim somebody tried to murder him and, finally, the murders of Alex’s wife Maggie and son Paul.
What we get from the history of earlier years is a much better sense of the extreme privilege, power, and utter corruption of this family. Author John Glatt includes story after story about the cynicism of the Murdaughs, who passed out favors as prosecutors and raked in money as tort lawyers, even going so far as to try to take everything from a local small businessman representing a woman who actually rear-ended him. Why and how would they do that? Person after person tells about how the Murdaughs knew absolutely everyone in their district, paid no attention to conflicts of interest, used a local law that would let them sue anybody with the slightest connection to their district, and could get juries to grant outrageously high damages because they knew the Murdaugh family and either liked or feared them—maybe both.
Despite being treated as if they were upstanding representatives of the law, there is evidence that the Murdaughs were active drug runners for decades; one of them being suspended for six months but escaping prison while a co-conspirator did time.
There is also much detail in the book about Alex’s embezzlement schemes; both how he set them up and who he scammed—from horribly injured poor clients, survivors of those killed in accidents (including Gloria Satterfield’s sons), right down to his own brother. Alex’s trial for financial misdeeds should be a doozy. Glatt also writes about the other men involved in Alex’s alleged drug-dealing and money-laundering activities, which I hadn’t previously known much about in detail. Again, another trial that should be eye-opening.
We all heard in the news coverage about how a teenage Paul was a habitual and nasty drunk. Maybe you wondered how his parents allowed him to get wasted and drive a car or boat. It turns out his father was at least as bad when he was a teenager and was just as indulged. Nobody ever thought there would be consequences for a Murdaugh, especially the Murdaughs—and while Maggie was unhappy living in tiny Hampton SC, she was more than happy to not work, leave the child-rearing mostly to Gloria Satterfield, spend loads of money, and fall right into the attitude that Murdaughs can do whatever they want.
When he reaches more contemporary events, Glatt skillfully contextualizes, so that the reader can see what might have triggered Alex’s actions. For example, certain court actions over Mallory Beach’s death, and the Satterfield sons’ learning that they hadn’t received money awarded in their wrongful-death lawsuit both happened very shortly before Alex took extreme actions to try to avoid having his embezzlement schemes revealed.
I came away from this book feeling I know quite a bit more of the Murdaugh family story and how generational power and corruption can change life for people far beyond the bounds of the family.