I read his first "Ash Cayne" character book only because I saw the author being interviewed on television a few months ago, and it was mentioned "Eagle Rock" was optioned for a move, so I decided to read his first Ashe Cayne series as I enjoy mysteries. And, and honestly, the first thing I noticed was the constant description of his protagonist's knowledge and descriptions of clothing/fabrics, vintage cars, high-end jewelry, hair, make-up, wine and food ordering choices, golfing comments, art, poets, Shakespear, etc., etc. I felt it was Ian Smith's way of banging over his readers' heads his own varied tastes, knowledge, etc., and it soon became tired and much of it unnecessary, I felt. Therefore, I skipped the next two books and went on to" Eagle Rock". Again, even more so in this book with the descriptions of everything from art, prose, sports, etc., to excess. BUT... what struck me most about these Ashe Cayne series was how much characters in it and the story construction are similar to characters of a mystery series I love and been reading over the years--the "Andy Carpenter" series in which the protagonist is an attorney. So, I gave it two stars only because I got through it to the end to see the outcome.