Thank you to BookSirens and the author for the ARC. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Other than some slightly uneven pacing (a little too slow at the start, a little too fast at the end), I loved everything about this book and still can’t believe it’s debut - many aspects of it are really, really well-crafted. The mystery unveils itself perfectly, the plot twists are all in just the right places with great foreshadowing, and the main character, Abbie… she has something that I don’t see a whole lot in these types of novels, and it’s a ton of character growth. She starts the novel and ends it in a completely different place - physically, of course, but mentally too. That kind of character growth and nuance being woven so well into a plot-based book is pretty admirable, as I feel like it gives the reader best of both worlds - character growth, a lot of it, that doesn’t sacrifice the mystery aspect.
This book also does a great job, through nuance and a lot of thought, at displaying injustice and cruelty and forgiveness and the nuances of all those. Even Abbie, the main character, realises that just because the people over the wall have it better, they also may have struggles of their own. It’s a realistic dystopia, I think, sadly, that the author’s crafted here, one in which the poor are continually exploited by the rich and powerful in every way. It draws parallels to our world while allowing the main characters to take control of their own lives, and at the same time gives us hope for the future if we work to change it while serving as warming for what said future could look like.
The POV shift was pretty well done - both voices sounded distinct and it did a great job of adding to the ominousness as the mystery unfolded.
Something I was also pleasantly surprised by was the rep! Two main characters of the same sex are in a relationship with each other, and while their main obstacle is not their queerness, the author has evidently thought much about their dystopian setting, because who treats them differently over their queerness is a reflection of what kind of character they are. I love escapist stories where homophobia and the like don’t exist, but for this realistic sort of dystopia, showing that discrimination can take many forms as society shifts and still include homophobia, though only perpetrated by the worst of us, was a nuanced and welcome choice.
That being said, while the characters do suffer quite a bit of misery in this book, it’s not all bleak. Again - my slight nitpick about pacing, but honestly it wasn’t enough to distract me from the story as I read. And speaking of which - I was super engrossed, actually, finishing this entire book in one sitting.
Also something nice was Abbie reflecting on her relationship with Ty, and why she stayed with him - in a lot of books where the girl stays with a bad boy the narrative doesn’t usually allow her this much of self-reflection and it was welcome to see that change here.
Tldr: check out the trigger warnings, but pick this up if you enjoy a bit more heavy-handed mysteries/action adventures, well-crafted and well-thought out dystopias, or strong female characters. Or all of the above, of course :)