I greatly enjoyed reading this book, for several reasons. It is very well written (except for some minor repetitions across chapters). Its author sure did her job regarding the necessary research—not a minor feat when faced with the daunting task of writing something of value about (to quote from the dust jacket text) Franz Kafka's life and afterlife: I dare any literary scholar to write a guide that is half as readable and equally exciting as Karolina Wątroba's (I trust she won't resent my restoring the diacritic on the first vowel of her last name). Unlike some books that purport to chronicle some personal or scholarly "search for Kafka", which are somewhat deceivingly framed as crime novels, this book is candid about what it attempts to do (namely, to answer the question "what makes Kafka Kafka" focusing on how all kinds of readers have responded to the man and the myth) and does, in my opinion, deliver—with panache, I would add.
More importantly, I think Metamorphoses: In Search of Franz Kafka passes my own little test for what I consider a good book. First, did it motivate me to actually do something? Most definitely: if nothing else, it made me revisit some of the texts by Kafka that Wątroba discusses at some length, but it also led me to reread other of his pieces and, of course, many a diary entry. Second, did I discover something precious in it? You bet: even though I have read several Kafka-centered novels, stories, or travelogues written in languages other than English and German, it made me realize that I had unforgivably neglected the East Asian offerings (especially considering that many of them are readily available in solid Western translations). Last, will I come back to it? I probably won't reread the passages about the English plays and the outlook on AI anytime soon; on the other hand, and rather surprisingly, I suspect I will return to the chapters on Berlin and Prague.
I would give it 4.5 stars if I could. Is this a masterpiece? I imagine the author would hasten to point out that it isn't. Is it the go-to book about Kafka's writings, as well as his life and afterlife? Hardly. But it is one of the most accessible, enjoyable, and inspiring introductory treatments of this inexhaustible subject I have encountered so far. This is truly a welcome addition to the Kafka shelves in my personal library!