Disclaimer: This review has both plot spoilers (I tried to keep it to a minimum) as well as trigger warnings for what to expect in the book as I read an advanced copy, but was not provided with these trigger warnings that would have been helpful as I read the book.
Book Trigger Warnings:
1. Death: The book opens at a funeral
2. Bully Romance, specifically, Forced/Blackmailed Marriage
As an author/writer, Evelyn (I want her to get ALL HER FLOWERS), is going to give you the book! I will elaborate. Many, if not all of Evelyn’s books are typically 50+ chapters, with an average of about 10 or so pages per chapter. Not only is she thorough and thoughtful of and to her readers, but she pens amazing stories with characters that have strong development and growth. Given that all of the works of Evelyn that I have read thus far have been interracial romances, one of the things that I greatly appreciate about her work is the reality she infuses about said interracial romances (which I often find missing in other interracial fiction romance stories). The element that she intentionally incorporates in her interracial romance stories is the fact that race, and more specifically, how folx may be perceived due to their race, is touched on. I am from and reside in the US. It is not realistic in 2023 that we're not having active and critical conversations related to race and culture, especially in interracial relationships. So when I say that Evelyn is going to give you the book, I mean that she's going to ensure that you get your money's worth of reading, that you understand who these characters are, their relatability (even those in/with morally gray behaviors), and an infusion of real life/world issues. Evelyn gon' give you the book!
With that said, Almost Paradise has been my least favorite book of Evelyn’s thus far. Overall, I rate this book between a 3 and a 4, while giving it four stars within the 5 star rating system. As I shared above, Evelyn “gon’ give you the book” and for that component, I rate it 5+ stars (the storytelling). As someone who has survived intimate partner violence, the bullying aspects, particularly the forced marriage, made me almost stop reading the book entirely. I have read a couple other books with elements of bully romance and while I didn't care for the character who engaged in those acts, I didn't quite have an issue with the book as a whole. While Drake's behavior was specific to him, there was also the backdrop of grief and death as well as the backdrop of both white privilege and racism, and white supremacy. It is 2023 and I live in the US. We are in a time in this country in which white supremacy is no longer "the quiet part." For someone who abhorred the actions of his father, in many ways Drake was and is his father's son given the behavior that he displayed toward Nia when he came back into her life. The forced marriage was too far for me and it made me deeply uncomfortable, particularly with the interracial romance element and him pulling that BS behavior on a Black woman. If this was in real life there would be nothing romantic about it. I read fiction to read fiction, not to see the same elements of my nonfiction reality.
I recognize that I am infusing my own experiences in with fictional characters, but Evelyn’s writing is such that I had a visceral and traumatizing reaction to what I was reading. Additionally, I had deep empathy for Nia as she was having said experiences. However, I did push forward and I am grateful that I did so. Even though this book was hard to read in parts, it unknowingly became a necessary read for me. This book helped me to identify the ways I am still/need to continue to heal.
Additional Notes and Commentary:
• I was very annoyed with Drake for his initial assumption that Nia would "ice him out" of his child's life. From both of their narratives, the year they spent together was life changing. So, if that is the case and this behavior seems unlike her, why would that have been the first assumption? ESPECIALLY with the backdrop of the father's death and Drake feeling like he knew his father was hiding/wanted to disclose something? #BoyMath
• Wyatt and Audrey? I definitely would like to read their story and do not find it to be a coincidence that they have the chemistry that they do. It is clear that Wyatt is already a bit smitten.
• Scarlett’s character was a WILD ride because there is so much that she represents: 1. You can be both victim (even if it is to circumstances you helped to engineer) and perpetrator 2. Do not settle for men that don’t think the moon and stars shine out of your butt. Some men will pretend to love you because you fill a void, not because you are truly who they want. I initially felt empathy for her, but I knew that she would do something, possibly illegal, to remove my empathy. Empathy removed. #FAFO
• In a land where I'm observing men not wanting to be loving husbands and fathers, it was refreshing reading Drake's description of his first meeting with Carter.
• The scene when Wyatt is informing the boys about whether they should be vampires versus werewolves is HILARIOUS!
• I enjoyed Wyatt. He brings balance to Drake's unnecessarily authoritative white privilege presentation of self.