Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A Case of Some Urgency

Rate this book
With shaking fingers, Bennet unfolded the missive and scanned to the bottom of the second page for a Fitzwilliam Darcy.

When Lydia Bennet elopes with George Wickham it seems certain that the fledging second chance at love between Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy has been destroyed. Dashing home from her visit to Pemberley, Elizabeth Bennet re-reads Darcy’s letter and regrets what surely can never be, not now.

Desperate times often call for desperate measures, as Mr Bennet is soon to discover under the most painful of circumstances. His search for Lydia and Wickham is proving unfruitful and still worse—he has discovered signs of a secret romance between his most sensible second daughter and none other than Mr Darcy.

Seeing an opportunity to both avoid ruination and perhaps have some redemption of the family name, Mr Bennet is quick to visit Mr Darcy with a proposed solution. But every solution provides a new set of challenges for Darcy and Elizabeth in this tale of romance lost and found.

172 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 23, 2023

94 people are currently reading
78 people want to read

About the author

Mary Smythe

18 books54 followers
Mary Smythe is a homemaker living in South Carolina with a rather useless BA in English collecting dust in a closet somewhere. She discovered the works of Jane Austen as a teenager, thanks to the 1995 BBC Pride and Prejudice miniseries featuring Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle, and has since gone on to read everything written by Ms Austen at least once yearly, always wishing that there were more. She has been writing since 2001, but only discovered Jane Austen Fanfiction in the summer of 2018.

Dare to Refuse Such a Man is the first full-length novel she has ever completed, though she can boast a few shorter works in her library, as well.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
266 (39%)
4 stars
277 (41%)
3 stars
99 (14%)
2 stars
28 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
Profile Image for J. W. Garrett.
1,736 reviews133 followers
October 27, 2023
SPOILER ALERT: This review may contain *** SPOILERS ***

>>Rating: teen and above: there are scenes of violence and an attempted assault
>>Angst Level: stressful during an assault attempt and being on edge as to what will happen next
>>Source: I received a free copy via Booksprout on 9-18-23 and volunteered to leave a review of my thoughts and opinions. A quick read at 15 chapters and an epilogue. [4.5-stars]
>>Timeline: Derbyshire after Lizzy received the letter of shame announcing Lydia’s flight with Wickham.

During the journey back to London, and while her aunt and uncle slept, Elizabeth was reading Darcy’s letter again and again. She now realized what she had lost and what her true feelings were. She was soon back home only to discover she no longer had Darcy’s letter.

London: Bennet and Gardiner scoured London’s seedier side trying to find the wayward couple. As Bennet adjusted his seat in the carriage, he found Darcy’s letter to Elizabeth. He was not pleased.

Bennet arrived at Darcy House demanding Darcy’s honor. He [an unmarried man] had sent his Lizzy [an unmarried woman] a letter. Darcy told Bennet he had already proposed but she wouldn’t have him. However, he was prepared to do the right thing. He also shared with Bennet that he had discovered the wayward couple, bought Wickham’s commission in the regulars, and paid his debts. The couple would shortly be married and on their way to Wickham’s new posting.

Longbourn: Lizzy was informed that Bennet had brokered a marriage for her. She was stunned to discover it was with Mr. Darcy. Bingley had returned with Darcy and Mrs. Bennet was thrilled.

London: Bennet and Darcy attended the wedding and traveled with the newly married couple back to Meryton. At Longbourn, Lydia was not happy with the cool reception she received, other than the one from her mother. Her sisters were not impressed with her marriage to the handsome Mr. Wickham. Mrs. Bennet, at least, was happy to see her youngest, and married at only sixteen.

Jealous, angry, petulant, and self-centered, Lydia and her husband caused all manner of trouble during their stay at Longbourn. The entitled ‘Duo of Shame’ were horrid and were willing to do the unthinkable to exact their revenge on Lizzy and Darcy.

1st read 9-21-23 as ARC
2nd read 10-26-23 as KU

Profile Image for Debbie.
1,680 reviews79 followers
October 24, 2023
This is a wonderful little novella that picks up Pride and Prejudice after news of Lydia's disappearance has reached Elizabeth and the Gardiners. They have left Lambton and Mr. Darcy behind and are traveling directly to Longbourn.

Elizabeth rereads Darcy's letter in the coach but hides it when Mrs. Gardiner comments about what she assumes her niece is reading. Lizzy neglects to retrieve it, and Mr. Bennet, who travels in the same coach back to London, is the one who discovers it. Without knowing exactly what has transpired between his second daughter and Mr. Darcy, Mr. Bennet is concerned that another scandal might be brewing and is determined to be a more diligent protector of his family. Upon reaching London, he meets with Darcy and insists that he marry Elizabeth.

There is some misunderstanding between the lovesick couple, but that's not what this story is primarily about. Lydia and Mr. Wickham are the largest irritants here.

Lydia is already displeased that her wedding day lacks the expected celebratory accoutrements and instead is surrounded by grim faces on her father, aunt, and uncle. However, she looks forward to arriving at Longbourn, where she will surely be fawned upon, especially by her doting mother, for being the first to wed and for catching such a handsome, dashing husband.

How will this spoiled, petulant girl react when she and dear Wickie aren't the center of everyone's attention?

It's an inspired premise, and Ms. Smythe executes it nicely. It's particularly interesting to see how the changes in timeline affect Mary and Kitty Bennet. Darcy and Elizabeth, of course, remain the prominent figures around whom the rest of the plot revolves. Their chemistry together is off the charts. Each of the characters are developed convincingly, and the book shifts to different points of view at each chapter to tell the story; the reader gets to peek inside the heads of Elizabeth, Darcy, Mr. Bennet, Lydia, and Kitty. The writing is stellar, with flowing prose and believable dialogue.

Content is clean. Mild trigger warning: an attempted sexual assault is thwarted early.

I received a free copy of this book via BookSprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Sam H..
1,222 reviews61 followers
October 23, 2023
An old letter triggers Mr Bennet to act

Mr. Bennet, on the coattails of Lydia's lament, takes a stand to save the family when he finds Darcy's letter to Elizabeth. Of course, ODC clear the air quite quickly and are happy to wed each other!

Things start to turn really sour when the Wickhams are permitted to visit Longbourn before traveling north. The story escalates and drama ensues near the end.

The glimmers we get from Mary and Kitty's points of view, and their growing interaction and maturity are sweet. 

I cheered when Darcy just came out and revealed his feelings to Elizabeth. No miscommunication for ODC here!

Another entertaining read from Mary Smythe. The re-scrambling of P&P puzzle pieces create a fun variation for all to enjoy!

Quills & Quartos have spoiled us this year with so many fabulous new books!

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
895 reviews70 followers
October 18, 2023
Love and Jealousy

I love Ms. Smythe’s imagination! This book may only be a novella, but it packed an incredible punch. This was an imaginative and highly entertaining variation that had my attention right from the beginning and didn’t let go.

“Her one token from Mr. Darcy, the only man she had ever come close to loving, was gone and she would never see it again.” (quote from the book)

Mr. Bennet and Mr. Gardiner are in search of Lydia Bennet in London after her elopement with Wickham from Brighton. He is exhausted, frustrated and not the least hopeful. But what’s this poking at him from behind in Gardiner’s carriage? A letter to Elizabeth? He didn’t recognize the writing. But once he realizes who it is from, he demands from Darcy that he marry Elizabeth. A battle of will ensues. Meanwhile, at Longbourn after rushing back with the Gardiners from Lambton, Elizabeth is frantically looking for her letter from Mr. Darcy.

“Darcy could not, as a gentleman and one who loved her deeply, be the instrument of her discontent.” (quote from the book)

Mr. Bennet returns with two major announcements for his family. Lydia and Wickham have been found and will be marrying and so will Elizabeth. I think what I loved most was how quickly Elizabeth and Darcy come to an accord. The scene in which this happens, was in my mind, simply perfect.

“For the first time, she thought that, perhaps, being the first to wed had done her no favours. Apparently, the quality of one’s husband also mattered.” (quote from the book)

My oh my, the proverbial poop hits the fan when Lydia and Wickham visit Longbourn before heading to Newcastle. Observations are made, not only by Lydia, but Kitty and Mary as well (great bonding between these two). The green-eyed monster rears its ugly head and soon morphs into an evil witch. What ensues will leave you stunned as to the lengths Lydia and Wickham will go to ruin our beloved couple’s happiness.

I highly recommend this latest offering from the ever-talented Ms. Smythe!

I received a copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my review.
Profile Image for Ree.
1,318 reviews78 followers
September 14, 2024
Oh Lydia…
Following Lydia’s elopement and his subsequent search for her in London, Mr. Bennet finds Darcy’s Hunsford letter to Elizabeth, which she had inadvertently left tucked away in Mr. Gardiner’s carriage during their return to Longbourn from Derbyshire. With one daughter ruined, and in order to protect the reputation of a second, he demands the couple marry. Darcy and Elizabeth, feel the other has no wish to marry them, but Mr. Bennet remains adamant, and once they resolve each other’s uncertainties, they acknowledge their love for one another. This was a lovely and sweet moment of communication between them.

However, when the betrothals of Lydia’s two eldest sisters overshadow her homecoming after her own hasty wedding, a jealousy-driven plot conceived on her part threatens our dear couple’s road to happiness. Kitty, no longer fooled into following her younger sister’s whims, and Mary, never ever impressed with Lydia’s selfish conduct and actions, are drawn closer as sisters and play a role in exposing her ongoing deceit.

While I'm not usually a big Lydia and Wickham fan, I thought this novella was another enjoyable and well-written page-turner by Mary Smythe.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Sheila Majczan.
2,677 reviews201 followers
October 27, 2023
The events in this story reflect canon for the most part. However, we are treated to reading thoughts and interactions connected with that story line.

A main difference is the fact that in rereading Darcy's letter to her after his Hunsford proposal, Elizabeth quickly tucks it away while riding in her uncle's carriage. Later, as Mr. Bennet spends time with Uncle Gardiner searching for Lydia in London, he finds Elizabeth's letter. Propriety forbids an unmarried or even unengaged couple from corresponding with each other and so Papa Bennet demands Darcy does the right thing.

That turns out to please both Darcy and Elizabeth.

However as they both return to Hertfordshire to plan their wedding so also do Mr. and Mrs. Wickham. Here we now have the bit of angst within this story line. Lydia is not at all pleased to find herself no longer the center of her mother's attentions and even ignored for the most part by her sisters. Lydia is not going to let that go without some retribution. The author's imagination here was well done. I won't spoil the story by revealing how Lydia (and Wickham) acted.

There is a short epilogue. I enjoyed this short story.
Profile Image for Lady Mercury.
221 reviews3 followers
October 18, 2023
Mary Smithe did it again, she HASN'T disappointed me in the least. Wow what a ride of emotions.

Quick Summary: It starts with Lydia's folly, when Mr. Bennet finds the letter, yes guys you read he finds Darcy's letter in the Gardiner's carriage. He confronts Darcy about it and soon our dear couple is engaged. With Lydia and Wickham being finally married and visiting Longbourn (like in canon), Darcy also being in Hertfordshire and spending all his time with Elizabeth, what else could there go wrong? Lydia is up to no good for ODC.

The Wickhams were like in canon, maybe Lydia was a little more jealous but I could imagine if she wouldn't have been the center of attention in canon at Longbourn after her marriage, and it was Darcy and Elizabeth, she would have reacted maybe the same?
For Elizabeth and Darcy, in my opinion they were also like in canon.
Bingley still this jovial guy and Jane speaking well of everybody, even the Wickhams..
For Kitty and Mary, they changed a bit. Both matured after Lydia's folly. Mary still quotes Fordyce's Sermons though.
Mrs. Bennet like in canon but this time never let Lydia speak for her. YAY
Mr. Bennet also like in canon.

-Angsty (Not too much. Perfect Balance)
-Clean Content (A Kiss before ODC is married)
-Quick Read

I really recommend the book! Enjoy it, dear Readers!

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Les.
2,911 reviews1 follower
December 4, 2023
I may be being very tough on this book but a clever plot was ruined by OOC behavior and the behavior was offensive

SO this is a short book, it starts with Lizzy heading back from her trip with the Gardiners and she is rereading Mr. Darcy's letter. I will admit this gave me pause while I know Lizzy kept the letter I can't see her dragging it all over creation

It is subsequently discovered by Mr Bennet who in his OOC behavior decides to demand Mr. Darcy marry Lizzy

Darcy still intervenes on Lydia's behalf and then heads to Meryton to beg Lizzy to marry him and we get quickly to a HEA until Lydia and Wickham create havoc.

Lydia is insanely jealous of Lizzy and in her OOC behavior tells Wickham to seduce her sister.
Okay this is simply deranged. I might believe Lady Catherine or Caroline Bingley dreaming up this scam but there is NO WAY IN HELL that a 16 year old newlywed in 1812 or 13 would tell her new husband who she thinks hung the moon to have sexual relations with her sister. No way NO CHANCE No How!!

Now if this had been a sneaky test of Wickham to see if he would say no Lyddie I only have eyes for you I might have bought it but this was RIDICULOUS
I was just so annoyed

Profile Image for Rita Deodato.
277 reviews13 followers
November 17, 2023
Review Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...

What if Mr. Bennet found Mr. Darcy’s letter after Lydia had run away with Mr. Wickham? What if he realized he could not have two daughters in a precarious situation and forced Mr. Darcy to do the right thing by marrying his second daughter? How would Elizabeth react to this imposition? And would Mr. Darcy have the strength to marry a woman whom he believes dislikes him?

In A Case of Some Urgency, Mr. Darcy finds himself in a forced engagement scenario that will once again place him in Elizabeth Bennet’s path, and I loved the strategies the author developed to take this couple to their HEA. I was captivated by this book for a variety of reasons, the plotline, the characters, the writing style, the length, it is as if all elements of the book combined perfectly 🙂

Why did I love it so much?

The plotline: I loved the the fact that Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy are already in love at the beginning of the novel and only need to overcome external difficulties to be together. But I also loved that their struggles didn’t keep them apart. They were fully aware of and conscious of their love for one another, and because their relationship was built over trust and a strong love, they had adult dialogues that allow them to face adversities together. I loved everything about this premise. It reveals an adult and mature relationship without miscommunications or resentments, and it was quite a ride to go through this story with Darcy and Elizabeth.

The romance: The romance between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth was very simple, the storyline wasn’t complicated at all, but the strength of their feelings for one another, the companionship they found in each other, the way Mr. Darcy stood up to defend Elizabeth’s honor, to respect her, and the way she took care of him, and cherished him was simply beautiful!

The characters: I loved the way the author developed each character in this novel. From Mrs. Bennet, who stayed true to herself without going overboard with cartoonish characterisations, to Kitty, whose character growth I adored, to Lydia, who was the ideal “villain,” and Mary, whose relationship with Kitty was definitely a plus in the book. Because each character added something unique to the narrative, A Case of Some Urgency was overall a stronger book.

The writing: The initial chapters of this novella are gripping with an intense and romantic writing style that made me hold my breath until I could see that Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy would in fact get to an understanding. I could feel Elizabeth’s despair in the initial chapter when she believes all is lost to her, and the love she feels for Mr. Darcy when he visits her for the first time. I could feel the intensity of his feelings, his gaze and his touch. The writing in this book made me feel exactly what the characters were feeling, and I think that is exactly what good books are suppose to do.

The length: I loved the fact that the author didn’t need to expand this story into a 300 page book to make it an exquisite read! It is not about the length, but the ability you have to tell a story and pull the reader into it. Mary Smythe excelled at this!

The cover: I loved the cover before reading the book, but while I was reading it, and I saw the cover is actually the perfect portray of one of the most important scenes in the book, I loved it even more. I could picture the entire scene even better because it was the perfect description of the cover. Excellent collaboration between the cover artist and the writer!

Thinking back at what I felt while reading this novella I have to say it is among my favourites of the year! All readers who like beautiful romances, but especially those who love cozy storylines where they can feel at home with the characters without experiencing too much conflict should definitely read A Case of Some Urgency. This book is pretty much angst free, and even though I love angst, it captivated me, so if you like low angst books, I can only imagine how much you’ll love it! I highly recommend it!
Profile Image for wosedwew.
1,337 reviews127 followers
February 18, 2025
Things spoken can be forgotten and forgiven, but the written word has the power to change the course of history, to alter our lives. ~ Teresa Mummert

As a child, I was told to be careful what I say about someone and even more careful about what I write. Words on paper can last a very long time.

“A Case of Some Urgency” concerns words on paper but in this case, the words lead to a desired outcome for the individuals involved.

In her uncle’s carriage, Elizabeth Bennet hurriedly hides her “Hunsford letter” and accidentally conceals it where it will be discovered later by her father. Mr. Bennet visits Fitzwilliam Darcy and insists he marry Elizabeth. Darcy agrees since it is his inclination anyway. Elizabeth resists since she does not want to push Darcy into a marriage he does not want.

For a welcome change, the couple confronts the issue together and reaches an understanding.

A jealous sister and her new husband provide the conflict in the story.

I enjoyed Mother Bennet’s comments and loved the ultimate outcome for the Wickhams.

The more articulate one is, the more dangerous words become. ~ May Sarton
Profile Image for Kim.
830 reviews1 follower
September 29, 2023
This short story has some unique and original plot lines that I really enjoyed. What would happen if someone found Darcy’s letter to Elizabeth? What if that someone was Mr. Bennet?

The story starts with Elizabeth leaving Derbyshire with the Gardiners just after Lydia’s elopement. Darcy steps in and saves the day, but he fears Elizabeth will never forgive him for allowing this to happen to her sister. Enter Mr Bennet with The Letter. Luckily the misunderstandings are quickly resolved, and Darcy and Elizabeth are soon a united front against the Wickhams who are visiting Longbourn. Jane and Bingley are together but play only a minor role. It was nice to see Kitty and Mary become closer friends.

The writing seemed effortless and the story moved at a fast pace that kept me eagerly turning the pages. I’ve become a big fan of this author and always look forward to her next release.

I received an advanced copy of this book from the publisher via Booksprout and voluntarily leave this review.
Profile Image for Browntigerdog's Papermoon.
89 reviews8 followers
October 30, 2023
I have always been nervous about the letter that Darcy wrote to Elizabeth!

Thinking back to my youth I would been extremely careful to keep my personal letters away from the probing eyes of my sister or mother!!

How in the world could Lizzy be so reckless as to reread this letter in front of her aunt while riding in the carriage?

Then to crumple it up behind her back and fall asleep. Never remembering to retrieve it when she woke!!

I would have needed Mrs Bennet’s salts when I realized it was missing!

Whoa what a surprising find for Mr Bennet on his ride back to Longbourn after Lydia’s wedding!!

I’m sure smoke was coming out of his ears after his first read! Especially “this” Mr Bennet!

Then imagine Lizzy’s shock at being requested in her father’s book room and being confronted with this letter !!

Wow it would be embarrassing to say the least.

Mary Smythe has outdone herself with this fast paced thoroughly enjoyable read:)

The Lydia/Wickham part is really well done! Got what they deserved for their horrible scheme!

Don’t miss this one!!


Profile Image for Talia.
969 reviews4 followers
October 25, 2023
I really loved this novella. Wonderfully done.
Profile Image for James S.
1,429 reviews
November 20, 2023
Lydia and Wickham play a large part of the story.

A well written story about the time Lydia eloped with Wickham. 4.5 stars rounded down because the author was VERY good at showing Lydia and W together and how bad they could be together. Left a bad taste in my mouth.

Profile Image for Katie.
471 reviews35 followers
October 24, 2023
I enjoyed the rare viewpoint of several secondary characters in this unique variation in which Mr. Bennet, of all people, essentially makes a match. It was especially gratifying to see the younger Bennet sisters forming new alliances and gaining new perspectives. Low angst, but with a satisfying confrontation and comeuppance, this story kept me reading into the wee hours of the morning.
Profile Image for Madenna U.
2,142 reviews1 follower
November 22, 2023
What a fun story! I don’t want to add spoilers but i like the focus on the thoughts, feelings, and behaviors of the younger three sisters in the aftermath of the Wickham wedding. Everyone needs to keep it together while Elizabeth and Darcy work towards their happily ever after.
Profile Image for Gratia.
224 reviews6 followers
October 27, 2023
Perfect for each other

This is a well-written and quick read that shows how perfectly paired some characters are in Pride and Prejudice. Showing their canon characteristics, Darcy and Elizabeth, and Lydia and Wickham are married in this variation. Ms Smythe's writing bared the ugliness of Lydia's character, making her Wickham's perfect match. I only wish she got more of a set down.
175 reviews1 follower
October 24, 2023
Nice story

I enjoyed reading this book because the story was told in an affection manner. It did not go very far in separating Lydia and Wickham from the rest of the family. But it was nice
208 reviews
October 24, 2023
almost a dnf

Once past the overlong exposition, I found a tale I’d not heard before: an in-depth telling of the 10 days that the Wickhams spent at Longbourn. Instead of said exposition, it might have been interesting to read the POV of Mrs Hill and Sarah. Mr Bennet’s churlishness was also a bit much.

KU, but will buy for permanent collection.
362 reviews8 followers
January 27, 2024
Another score for this wonderful author. *****

I was hooked from the start and couldn’t put it down. And I have stuff to do for Christmas!! Wow, I loved this.

As you expect a good short story to do, this one really moves and doesn’t lose momentum right to the end. The story starts out with Lizzy rereading ‘The Letter’ in the Gardiner’s coach leaving Pemberley behind after they received news of Lydia’s elopement. Lizzy is caught by Mrs Gardiner after waking from a nap, and Lizzy thrusts the letter behind her, but luckily Mrs G believes it’s Jane’s letter Lizzy is tortured over.

We already know how sad she was at this point in canon P&P that she believes that slim reawakening of accord between them is now lost since Lizzy believes Darcy would have nothing to do with her now that her family will be permanently attached to his enemy Wickham.

Next we see an exhausted Mr Bennet discovering the letter from Darcy, and the main premise of the story is set up when he goes to demand Darcy marry Lizzy. The rest could’ve dragged the story down but oh no, it just soars from there. You know what happens to Lydia and Wickham to get them hitched but this story tells us what happens when the Wickhams visit Longbourn, the twist is that Darcy and Bingley are already betrothed to Elizabeth and Jane. Lydia is furiously jealous because Mama Bennet isn’t gushing over Lydia’s wedding and instead she’s gushing over her new sons-in-laws to be. Woo!! The trouble brewing above and below the surface. I wanted to feel sorry for Lydia at the beginning because she just had no clue what a pile she’d stepped into, ignoring how she was already being treated in front of her family by that snake. But she was beyond the pale here. And kept digging herself deeper and deeper. Not only is she the worst brat ever, she’s out for revenge. Good grief.

The relationship we get to enjoy the most though, is between Darcy and Elizabeth which is thoroughly enjoyable, sweet and romantic…yummy.

Many parts of the story are enjoyable as things you always wish would happen, happen. No spoilers in that department from me. A great short read you can love when you want to have a break from the last gut wrenching story, or you’re procrastinating starting the next round of Christmas activities on your list. This will be a new favorite reread.

Highly recommended.
Profile Image for Kristin O'donoghue.
152 reviews7 followers
October 7, 2023
In the world of Austen inspired stories, Mary Smythe is an author whose books I have also enjoyed for a bit of lighthearted fun featuring our favorite couple, Darcy and Elizabeth.

Needless to say, I was so happy to get a copy of Smythe's latest Austenesque, novella, A Case of Some Urgency. Since it is novella length, it's the kind of quick read that you can tuck into for an afternoon when you are in the mood for something light and fast paced.

This story opens directly after Elizabeth regrettably has to leave Derbyshire and Darcy after she learns of Lydia's elopement with Wickam. Elizabeth finds herself nursing the regret of what she thought was the start of a renewed chance with Mr. Darcy. Her only token of 'what might have been', the note that Darcy had penned to her after his disastrous proposal in Kent. While once a source of harsh truths and painful reflections, Elizabeth has now come to treasure the letter as a token of the love Darcy once held for her.

Unfortunately for Elizabeth, this treasure become the source of much consternation for our couple as Mr. Bennet, reeling from the disastrous ramifications of his youngest daughter's actions, makes it his mission to ensure that Elizabeth will not fall prey to the same fate. I have always loved Mr. Bennet as a character in Austen's original work and so I enjoyed having more of this satirical father, who always had a soft spot for his second daughter, in the plot of the story. However, it was painful to watch Mr. Bennet looking to force Darcy and Elizabeth down a path he believes is necessary even if it was coming from a place of love for his child.

Luckily for the reader, we know that both Darcy and Elizabeth have been nurturing growing feelings for each other. It was touching to see how each was so concerned about the freedom of choice being protected for the other. I have always been conflicted about the character of Lydia and in this story her selfishness and conniving is on another level. I was almost as happy as all the Bennets when she and Wickam made their final exit.

While the reason for Elizabeth and Darcy's coming back together may not have been what either would have wanted, the end result still brought all the satisfaction of Austen's original tale. Smythe has you cheering for these two from the very beginning and if anything, the only thing I would have wanted is a little more time to enjoy the wrap up of the story; but this is also a novella so there is only so much time you get. If you are looking for a quick Pride and Prejudice inspired story with a twist that leaves you with a smile at the end, give this one a read!
761 reviews8 followers
November 2, 2023
Avid Reader

A lovely novella that I had to read from start to finish. We are past Hunsford, and Darcy has already arranged Lydia's and Wickham's wedding when Bennet shows up on his door with the letter Darcy wrote to Elizabeth. Bennet has awakened to the fact that he has been to lax and demands that Darcy do the right thing. Of course, Darcy thinks Elizabeth hates him and vice versa. They fall in each others arms and declare themselves once they get past their foolishness. Lydia can't stand the fact that Darcy and Elizabeth are actually in love. She realizes that Wickham doesn't look at her the way Darcy looks at Elizabeth. Once Elizabeth and Lydia have a blowout, all bets are off. Wickham and Lydia plan to hurt Elizabeth and Darcy by proxy. However, it doesn't go as planned leading to a serious fight between Darcy and Wickham and the Wickham's banishment from Longbourn and from the lives of the Darcy's, Bingley family, and Bennet family. Only Mrs. Bennet maintains contact with her daughter.
517 reviews3 followers
October 24, 2023
Short, sweet, and lively

Excellent story line, wherein Darcy's, famous letter following his Hunsford proposal, is misplaced, with serious consequences. We join our favorite characters as Darcy is repairing Lydia's folly and a very different ending ensues. Wit, humor, and nice writing, with a proper setdown for Wickham! Very good!
Profile Image for Gill M.
371 reviews27 followers
September 25, 2024
Review also posted on my blog

https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...

When Elizabeth Bennet visits Pemberley, it seems that she and Fitzwilliam Darcy will finally understand each other.

A much hoped for second chance at love is blasted by the news of her sister Lydia’s elopement with Darcy’s enemy, George Wickham.

On the rushed journey back to Longbourn, Elizabeth rereads Darcy’s letter, her only comfort. At one point, she needs to hide it from others in the coach and thus it becomes stuffed between cushions in her uncle Gardiner’s carriage.

Mr Bennet finds the letter, when he is searching for Lydia.
Having failed to parent Lydia, he decides to go overboard in protecting Elizabeth. Mr Bennet demands that Darcy do the honourable thing and propose to Elizabeth. Fortunately, both are keen on the idea!

The next twist in the tale is the arrival of the new Mr & Mrs Wickham. Lydia expects to be the centre of attention and is vexed to find that Elizabeth and Darcy are the focus.

Lydia and Wickham will go to some shocking lengths in response to the perceived slights. They are truly vile and frankly, deserve each other.

Really good story with romance and some edge of the seat moments!.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Nicole Barton Sasser.
556 reviews2 followers
October 14, 2024
Status: Read October 11-12, 2024 via kindle edition & audible edition of Fitzwilliam Darcy, Hero: A Pride and Prejudice Variation Duology

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (3.5)

Edition Read:

A Case of Some Urgency
by Mary Smythe
Kindle Edition, 172 pages
Published October 23, 2023 by Quills & Quartos Publishing (first published September 27, 2023)
ASIN: B0CFJXBB2C

With shaking fingers, Bennet unfolded the missive and scanned to the bottom of the second page for a signature: Fitzwilliam Darcy.

When Lydia Bennet elopes with George Wickham it seems certain that the fledging second chance at love between Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy has been destroyed. Dashing home from her visit to Pemberley, Elizabeth Bennet re-reads Darcy’s letter and regrets what surely can never be, not now.

Desperate times often call for desperate measures, as Mr Bennet is soon to discover under the most painful of circumstances. His search for Lydia and Wickham is proving unfruitful and still worse—he has discovered signs of a secret romance between his most sensible second daughter and none other than Mr Darcy.

Seeing an opportunity to both avoid ruination and perhaps have some redemption of the family name, Mr Bennet is quick to visit Mr Darcy with a proposed solution. But every solution provides a new set of challenges for Darcy and Elizabeth in this tale of romance lost and found.
Profile Image for Robin G..
68 reviews
October 23, 2023
A Case of Some Urgency by Mary Smythe is another wonderful variation by this author. What would happen if Elizabeth accidentally left Mr. Darcy’s letter in the Gardiners’ carriage after they learn Lydia has run off with Wickham? What if Mr. Bennet finds the letter and realizes he needs to be a better father? Mr. Bennet insists that Mr. Darcy needs to marry his daughter, and arranges their engagement. Meanwhile, Mr. Wickham is bribed to marry Lydia. The story moves along from there, and all I can say without spoiling anything is that Mr. Wickham and Lydia are made for each other.

I love the flow of this story, and how the author develops the characters, especially Mary and Kitty. Early in the story, the author writes, “It was as if they were separated by a wrought iron gate; they could see one another, even touch, but there would always be an impenetrable barrier between them.” It is beautiful and evocative, and later the author had them talking through a wrought iron gate. Thanks to that gorgeous cover, it is easy to picture the scene.

I recommend this book to all who love to read Pride and Prejudice variations.

I received a free copy of this book, and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
1,183 reviews29 followers
November 8, 2023
Wonderful

This author has become an automatic purchase for me. The story begins as Elizabeth and the Gardiners are leaving Derbyshire, having received the terrible news about Lydia's elopement with Wickham. During the journey Elizabeth rereads the letter Darcy gave her after his disastrous proposal. She accidentally leaves the letter in the Gardiner's carriage, only to be discovered by her father several days later. Mr Bennett now believes that not only his youngest and stupidest daughter has acted scandalously, but also his most intelligent and sensible daughter, Elizabeth, as well. This book is about what Mr Bennett does with this information.

The author has created a most interesting conundrum for Mr Bennett, for just when he wants to take Darcy to task for impropriety, he finds out that Darcy has saved Lydia's reputation, and by extension his whole family's. It was satisfying to have Mr Bennett finally shaken up about something, and nice to have him actually do something about it. I also appreciated the treatment given to Mary and Catherine Bennett in the face of Lydia's disgrace.

The romance is lovely. This is a swoon worthy Darcy, and a courageous and forthright Elizabeth. The book is well written and well edited. I recommend it highly.
Profile Image for Elizabeth S.
749 reviews16 followers
October 26, 2023
This was a short, fun read, with nothing angsty happening. I had trouble reconciling the catalyst of Mr. Bennet's actions. Elizabeth would never have been that careless with Darcy's letter. But it was a quick way of reuniting the two of them in a novella. The story begins on the trip back from Pemberley to Longbourn after the news of Lydia's elopement. The rest takes place at Longbourn, as the family contemplates ruin because of Lydia's actions. Darcy arrives to help deal with the fallout and to reconnect with Elizabeth. The villain in this novella is Lydia, who is almost cartoonish in her behavior. 4.5 stars rounded up.

The cover in the KU edition is beautiful. The one shown here must be a temporary cover.
Profile Image for Alena (Ally) Scott .
490 reviews4 followers
October 25, 2023
Entertaining, but too short!

Well developed and well written variation with our favorite characters of Elizabeth and Darcy taking center stage picking up the story with Lydia's leaving Brighton with Wickham. Lydia and Wickham certainly deserve each other. Bennet takes a surprising stand. Enjoy.
180 reviews4 followers
October 29, 2023
Quick and fun read, very well written. This is definitely a variation where Lydia is unequivocally awful and unredemptive, and I'm never quite sure how I feel about that. She is certainly selfish and petty in P&P but she is also a 15-16 year old girl preyed upon by a man nearly twice her age for revenge. Main love story between Elizabeth and Darcy is low angst.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.