I want to take this series and eat it. I want to squeeze it while I sleep. It's like a tangible thing I want to hold in my hands and not let go of.
The characters in this book are perfect. If perfectly flawed, sad, broken sinners can still be considered perfect anyway. They are certainly perfect to me. Mark Connelly might be one of my favorite fictional characters. Ever. I love every word out of his mouth, every nerdy, sexy thing he says and does. Every mannerism and tick and imperfection. I love love love him. Cadence is a mess. And I couldn't adore her more than I do. She is immature and spunky and lovely. I want to be her best friend. But I also want to steal her boyfriend.
The entire cast of characters in this book are perfectly thought out and developed. Avery and Dylan are perfectly placed in this story, adding such a critical component to this story. It brings so much perspective to the way I looked at Cadence and Mark's own relationship. I love the dynamic between these characters, the witty banter between them, how different they are from one another. Cadence's relationships with her brother, her parents, her new classmates, Mark's mother and her circle... it's refreshing and different. S Walden is phenomenal in the way she creates such complex personalities in her characters. I was never bored. I laughed constantly. And they broke my heart. Perfectly.
Why did I love this book so much? Why can I clearly set it apart from all other teacher/student relationship books? I love taboo relationships, I love teacher student forbidden romances. But Better is better than the rest. In many of the other stories I've read of this kind, I'm obviously rooting for the couple to make it out unscathed. And they always do, I always get my happily ever after. But somewhere in those other stories, the dynamic changes and you forget how forbidden this relationship actually is. Whether the female is more mature than every one else so naturally this older man is attracted to her. Or the male teacher is fresh out of college and there's only a 3 or 4 year age gap so it's not that big of a deal. Or the student is the aggressor and so the male is easily absolved of his faults. I could go on and on...
Better breaks the mold. Better reminds you that it is a big deal. This relationship feels wrong. Cadence isn't mature. She's your typical confused teenager, she's lost and vulnerable. And Mark is significantly older than her. And he is the aggressor, he's ballsy and direct and his desire to consume Cadence borders on uncomfortable at times. And that is why this book, this series is different. And better than the rest. You never forget how inappropriate this relationship is. And while they do work, you want them together, you want their happily ever after, you never take for granted why this relationship shouldn't work.
When Better picks up, Cadence is ready to start college. S Walden could have easily started off this book with Cadence's transformation into an independent, mature woman amidst a relationship with her somewhat older but equal boyfriend. But she didn't. She never lets you forget that Cadence is young and immature and inexperienced. The relationship never falls into a comfortable normal. You never take for granted the drastically different places these two people are in their lives. You consistently feel the gravity of that age gap. You never stop questioning how this can work. You never stop wondering what Mark's true intentions are with Cadence. He consistently teeters the line between this devoted lover who worships the woman in his life, and the older teacher who gets off on the fact that his girlfriend is barely an adult. You are never allowed to forget how imbalanced this relationship is. Cadence remains this naive immature teenager, the young naive girl dependent on her dominant alpha counterpart.
I read this book with a stomach full of unease. I waited for the bottom to fall out the entire time. And when it did, it was perfect. It was painful and raw but it was real. Mark is older. He has secrets and a painful past and he uses the fact that Cadence is young to defend his right keep secrets from her. Cadence is young, and she's already on shaky ground, so uncovering Mark's past sends her exactly where you'd expect an eighteen year old college student to go. Her rebellious behavior, her binge drinking, her flirtation and curiosity about other guys (and girls) was uncomfortable and painful but it was honest. Mark's hurtful words thrown out in the heat of an argument mixed with Cadence's juvenile coping tactics add the perfect angst I crave so much.
I'm redundant but I'll say it again. This book is perfect. It is the perfect portrayal of what a teacher student relationship should look like but rarely ever does in other books. The relationship isn't suddenly rainbows and sunshine because the teacher gets a new job and the student graduates. The obstacles never cease. The teacher in this book never stops being deemed a predator. Even when the name calling stops. And the outsiders back off, Mark still feels predatorial inside the relationship.
Readers who didn't love Good didn't love it because they were uncomfortable. They didn't like the vulgar way Mark spoke to Cadence in the coat closet. They didn't like being reminded of how wrong that relationship was. They think they like the idea of a teacher falling for his student, but when that relationship didn't rapidly fit in a perfectly wrapped box of appropriateness, they grew disgusted and left bad reviews. Better doesn't let you forget how wrong this relationship was. in some ways, it still is. We're not supposed to gift wrap it. It was wrong. We're supposed to be uncomfortable with Mark and Cadence being together. It's never supposed to sit right. We're always supposed to question whether Mark is with her because he loves her, or if he's there because she's innocent easy prey. Once you get comfortable with how uncomfortable it all is, then you'll really get it. This relationship will never fit in a box. It's not supposed to. It's beautiful in it's ugliness. And I loved every bit of it.