What do you think?
Rate this book
Idols: Unearthing the Power of Murti Puja
Why do people worship idols? Why does idol worship stubbornly persist despite many centuries of prejudice, bigotry and violence against it? Can such worship help us find our true purpose in life and ultimately attain peace and prosperity? In Idols , a companion volume to the bestselling Dharma , your favourite fictional characters are back, along with some new ones, to explore the essence and true meaning of idolatry. In this insightful and thought-provoking book, Amish and Bhavna tackle burning questions about idol worship through simple, varied and astute interpretations of myths and religious texts. They unearth the symbolic essence of Ishta Devata , dive into the benefits of bhakti and tackle the importance of religion for people and society. In the process, they reveal the expansive philosophy behind the practice and how it can lead us to experience-intellectually, ideologically and, most importantly, in our hearts-the Oneness of God, through transformation, acceptance and love.
272 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 16, 2023
40 people are currently reading
161 people want to read
About the author
Amish Tripathi
71 books7,753 followersAmish is an IIM (Kolkata) educated, banker turned award-winning author. The success of his debut book, The Immortals of Meluha (Book 1 of the Shiva Trilogy), encouraged him to give up a fourteen-year-old career in financial services to focus on writing. He is passionate about history, mythology and philosophy, finding beauty and meaning in all world religions.
His 7 books have sold over 5 million copies and been translated into 19 Indian & international languages. His Shiva Trilogy is the fastest-selling book series in Indian publishing history while his Ram Chandra Series is the second fastest-selling book series in Indian publishing history.
In 2019, Amish was appointed to a diplomatic role as Director , The Nehru Centre in London, India's premier cultural centre abroad.
His 7 books have sold over 5 million copies and been translated into 19 Indian & international languages. His Shiva Trilogy is the fastest-selling book series in Indian publishing history while his Ram Chandra Series is the second fastest-selling book series in Indian publishing history.
In 2019, Amish was appointed to a diplomatic role as Director , The Nehru Centre in London, India's premier cultural centre abroad.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
December 28, 2023
Idols by @authoramish and @bhavnahroy is a beautiful book that talks about the questions one has when it comes to worshipping idols. With simple, varied and astute interpretations of myths and religious texts, they discuss how spirituality is different for each of us.
It's a healthy discussion on faith, the importance of religion for people, stories of Lords, the benefits of bhakti, and the philosophy behind the puja and how it leads us to the divine experience. How we experience oneness with God through transformation, acceptance and love.
Candidly narrated with a crisp descriptive writing style, they keep it light and fun which makes it easy for the readers to connect to.
November 17, 2023
What attracted me to the book was the wonderful golden Ganapati murti on the cover along with the vibrant sindhoori background. Though I had read Amish’s books in the past, this was an instinctive purchase. Idols or rather murtis have special significance in our daily lives from being the forms of god to whom we pray to the comforting symbols on our desks during our work routine. As someone who is interested in the Iconography, ritualistic aspects of the murtis, I had great expectations from the book when I saw the cover.
The book is quite an interesting mixture of concepts. In my view, the authors had a very good premise, but perhaps the amount of information was overwhelming which ultimately lead the actual topic i.e. Idols being limited to a few pages at the end. That said, the book is actually a very interesting read for it addresses spirituality, worship, symbolism, iconography to some extent that is bound to hold the interest of the readers. The book is bound to evoke mixed / unique reactions from the wide spectrum of readers, but has some portions that would definitely resonate with them.
Written as a dialogue or conversation between few individuals in a specific context set around the Ganapati Festival, the book tries to explore the various facets of religion, the various Devis and Devatas from our Itihasas and Puranas. The authors have very intelligently interwoven various Upanishadic and Vedantic concepts deriving multiple concepts across various Upanishads. From Shreyas and Preyas of Kathopanishad to Pravrutti / Nivrutti, the author has to be commended for integrating such complex topics in a conversation and enabling the reader to connect to these concepts, at least at the top-level. The 3 principles of Nivrutti i.e. Sthitha Prajna, Atma Bodha and Nishkama Karma are explained in a very eloquent manner. The anecdotes, specially from the animal kingdom are simple, but effective illustrations of these deep concepts. This portion of the book is quite thought provoking and can easily lead to deep introspection. The portion on Shiva’s Baraat or Shiva’s Marriage retinue is very interesting and quite well captured. It is definitely one of the highlights of the book. The example of the Gorilla experiment is another interesting one, something this reviewer was unaware of.
When the characters in the book refer to the upanishads, ex: Ishopanishad, they refer to modern retellings and the works of modern celebrities (political figures, media personalities). I feel that the authors missed a great opportunity to refer to the original texts and perhaps refer to the works of Indic authors. This is definitely one of the letdowns for the reviewer.
One another unique feature of this book is the extensive references to Greek mythology, along with a concentrated effort to compare and equate with our Indic history. While there are quite extensive similarities, I would have loved the authors to consider both on their own merit. The concepts explained through some of the Gods of Greek pantheon could have easily been derived from our own rich history. Perhaps, there was a need to draw parallels with Greek narrative along with a smattering of Chinese history. There are some statements where a certain point is reinforced as compared to other practices. Any point could been proved on their own merit without the need for comparison.
One of the highlights of the book is the extensive description of various Devis and Devatas, including their implications on our external and internal lives. This is definitely one of the better portions of the book. The portion on “Apasmara” is must-read portion of the book. The snippet on Bali - Maha Vishnu - Lakshmi and their significance for Raksha Bandhan is yet another interesting portion. Since the authors have dedicated a large portion of the book to the explanation of the concepts, the main topic i.e. Idols / Murtis don’t get the space it deserved. The rituals and significance of murti Pooja is explained across a few pages at the fag end of the book.
The nuances of the vedantic concepts are better understood closer to the original, which usually gets diluted in retellings, which is reflected in the choice of references adopted by the characters of the book. There are some portions of the book which could have been avoided like equating / comparison with Greek history. One specific point which the reviewer would like to highlight is about Janaka. It needs to considered that Janaka was a titular position and every reference to Janaka needn’t be Maa Seetha’s father.
Lastly, the disappointing part of the book is the forced secularisation of concepts, something which could have been avoided. The other aspect which becomes a bit of eyesore is the conscious “Product Placement” where the characters of the book constantly refer to Amish’s articles and books. This could have been planned better.
If one is able to overlook some of these shortcomings, the book is definitely a good read. Vedantic concept explained in the best form possible i.e. as a story / conversation that one could relate to.
Recommended Read.
The book is quite an interesting mixture of concepts. In my view, the authors had a very good premise, but perhaps the amount of information was overwhelming which ultimately lead the actual topic i.e. Idols being limited to a few pages at the end. That said, the book is actually a very interesting read for it addresses spirituality, worship, symbolism, iconography to some extent that is bound to hold the interest of the readers. The book is bound to evoke mixed / unique reactions from the wide spectrum of readers, but has some portions that would definitely resonate with them.
Written as a dialogue or conversation between few individuals in a specific context set around the Ganapati Festival, the book tries to explore the various facets of religion, the various Devis and Devatas from our Itihasas and Puranas. The authors have very intelligently interwoven various Upanishadic and Vedantic concepts deriving multiple concepts across various Upanishads. From Shreyas and Preyas of Kathopanishad to Pravrutti / Nivrutti, the author has to be commended for integrating such complex topics in a conversation and enabling the reader to connect to these concepts, at least at the top-level. The 3 principles of Nivrutti i.e. Sthitha Prajna, Atma Bodha and Nishkama Karma are explained in a very eloquent manner. The anecdotes, specially from the animal kingdom are simple, but effective illustrations of these deep concepts. This portion of the book is quite thought provoking and can easily lead to deep introspection. The portion on Shiva’s Baraat or Shiva’s Marriage retinue is very interesting and quite well captured. It is definitely one of the highlights of the book. The example of the Gorilla experiment is another interesting one, something this reviewer was unaware of.
When the characters in the book refer to the upanishads, ex: Ishopanishad, they refer to modern retellings and the works of modern celebrities (political figures, media personalities). I feel that the authors missed a great opportunity to refer to the original texts and perhaps refer to the works of Indic authors. This is definitely one of the letdowns for the reviewer.
One another unique feature of this book is the extensive references to Greek mythology, along with a concentrated effort to compare and equate with our Indic history. While there are quite extensive similarities, I would have loved the authors to consider both on their own merit. The concepts explained through some of the Gods of Greek pantheon could have easily been derived from our own rich history. Perhaps, there was a need to draw parallels with Greek narrative along with a smattering of Chinese history. There are some statements where a certain point is reinforced as compared to other practices. Any point could been proved on their own merit without the need for comparison.
One of the highlights of the book is the extensive description of various Devis and Devatas, including their implications on our external and internal lives. This is definitely one of the better portions of the book. The portion on “Apasmara” is must-read portion of the book. The snippet on Bali - Maha Vishnu - Lakshmi and their significance for Raksha Bandhan is yet another interesting portion. Since the authors have dedicated a large portion of the book to the explanation of the concepts, the main topic i.e. Idols / Murtis don’t get the space it deserved. The rituals and significance of murti Pooja is explained across a few pages at the fag end of the book.
The nuances of the vedantic concepts are better understood closer to the original, which usually gets diluted in retellings, which is reflected in the choice of references adopted by the characters of the book. There are some portions of the book which could have been avoided like equating / comparison with Greek history. One specific point which the reviewer would like to highlight is about Janaka. It needs to considered that Janaka was a titular position and every reference to Janaka needn’t be Maa Seetha’s father.
Lastly, the disappointing part of the book is the forced secularisation of concepts, something which could have been avoided. The other aspect which becomes a bit of eyesore is the conscious “Product Placement” where the characters of the book constantly refer to Amish’s articles and books. This could have been planned better.
If one is able to overlook some of these shortcomings, the book is definitely a good read. Vedantic concept explained in the best form possible i.e. as a story / conversation that one could relate to.
Recommended Read.
November 22, 2023
“Idols” by Amish and Bhavna is a really interesting book about why people worship idols. The authors talk about how, even though idol worship has faced challenges over the years, it’s still a significant practice for many. They explore the meanings behind it, like the symbolic importance of Ishta Devata, and they discuss the benefits of devotion. The book is easy to understand and gives simple, but deep, insights into why people follow these ancient traditions. If you’re curious about the reasons behind idol worship, this book is a good, thought-provoking read.
November 28, 2023
Murti puja or idol worshipping, why do people do it?
Maybe because it provides people with faith and faith gives solace, security, sanctuary & cultural grounding.
Its just like a crutch.
You don't have to use them, if you don't need them.
I personally support movies like OMG. but do I find peace in murti puja? also yes
"Pray in whoever you want, however you want. You can't be wrong!"
Idols by @authoramish @bhavnahroy promises to tell more about murti puja but The concept of murti puja is limited to few pages at the end
The book is quite an interesting mixture of concepts but the information seems a little overwhelming. I could have used a little more knowledge in support/against of murti puja instead of greek mythology
Although the book touched on a fascinating topic initially, my interest waned as it shifted away from the main focus on idol worshipping. I believe staying true to that theme would have kept me more invested.
But As an overall book, its a great read if someone wants to gather more information and get to know some concepts of hindu mythology.
God is everywhere, in every corner of creation. Whether in the stillness of a murti, the beauty of nature, the innocence of animals, the dedication of your work, or the kindness of fellow humans, there are countless ways to connect and worship. Embrace the divinity in every moment and every being.
Read this book
- want to get to know more about hindu mythology
- Understand Vedic concepts in an easy way
- Mini stories of different god and goddess to know them better
Maybe because it provides people with faith and faith gives solace, security, sanctuary & cultural grounding.
Its just like a crutch.
You don't have to use them, if you don't need them.
I personally support movies like OMG. but do I find peace in murti puja? also yes
"Pray in whoever you want, however you want. You can't be wrong!"
Idols by @authoramish @bhavnahroy promises to tell more about murti puja but The concept of murti puja is limited to few pages at the end
The book is quite an interesting mixture of concepts but the information seems a little overwhelming. I could have used a little more knowledge in support/against of murti puja instead of greek mythology
Although the book touched on a fascinating topic initially, my interest waned as it shifted away from the main focus on idol worshipping. I believe staying true to that theme would have kept me more invested.
But As an overall book, its a great read if someone wants to gather more information and get to know some concepts of hindu mythology.
God is everywhere, in every corner of creation. Whether in the stillness of a murti, the beauty of nature, the innocence of animals, the dedication of your work, or the kindness of fellow humans, there are countless ways to connect and worship. Embrace the divinity in every moment and every being.
Read this book
- want to get to know more about hindu mythology
- Understand Vedic concepts in an easy way
- Mini stories of different god and goddess to know them better
December 28, 2023
The authors present to us in a fictionalised non fiction, conversation style prose many concepts surrounding spirituality as a whole. Dharma Raj s family gather together around a suspected medical emergency around the time of Ganesh Chaturthi and playing on the concept of faith at this point , the family and extended family converse on many topics.
.
The book is divided into 16 chapters all leading up to the murti puja of Ganesh in the ultimatum. Many concepts surrounding our religious books and history. Blending in Greek mythology to difficult ideologies becoming 'aatmabodha' has been discussed. My favourite is definitely the concept of Ishta Deveta that is how we get attracted to the idol motif of a God based on our characteristics. Touching on the Vedas, Upanishads, Yoga and Lord Shiva s marriage we learn of Nivrutti.
Many many terms in view of spirituality have been touched upon, like the lunar calendar, the mantras, etc. The book really explains with stories from mythological and religious history the origin of Murti s and the significance it has held.
In terms of learning in this genre, especially for Gen z the book is way forward. The tales of Krishna, Shiva, Mahisasur, Devi and Greek Gods add that special feel too. The cover with everyones favourite Ganesh ji is eye catching too.
My only problem is - in trying to impress upon the evolution and history of idol worship and such the actual purpose and debate is lost somewhere. I was left hungry to come to a conclusion regarding the blurb, promise and actual outcome and understanding of the book!
.
.
The book is divided into 16 chapters all leading up to the murti puja of Ganesh in the ultimatum. Many concepts surrounding our religious books and history. Blending in Greek mythology to difficult ideologies becoming 'aatmabodha' has been discussed. My favourite is definitely the concept of Ishta Deveta that is how we get attracted to the idol motif of a God based on our characteristics. Touching on the Vedas, Upanishads, Yoga and Lord Shiva s marriage we learn of Nivrutti.
Many many terms in view of spirituality have been touched upon, like the lunar calendar, the mantras, etc. The book really explains with stories from mythological and religious history the origin of Murti s and the significance it has held.
In terms of learning in this genre, especially for Gen z the book is way forward. The tales of Krishna, Shiva, Mahisasur, Devi and Greek Gods add that special feel too. The cover with everyones favourite Ganesh ji is eye catching too.
My only problem is - in trying to impress upon the evolution and history of idol worship and such the actual purpose and debate is lost somewhere. I was left hungry to come to a conclusion regarding the blurb, promise and actual outcome and understanding of the book!
.
March 3, 2024
#5 #indianauthors
I like this take on Idol worship through conversation amongst few friends. We need these kind of books which destroy myths around Idol worshipping. This book is written by Bhavna Roy who is Amish's real sister. Though Amish's famous name is all over the book. I like the easy writing of the book and perspective of Author.
I like this take on Idol worship through conversation amongst few friends. We need these kind of books which destroy myths around Idol worshipping. This book is written by Bhavna Roy who is Amish's real sister. Though Amish's famous name is all over the book. I like the easy writing of the book and perspective of Author.
July 24, 2024
Most slow paced and directionless reads.
When the writer says that he is using the form of conversation to make it intresting.
He forgets that eventually this is not a conversation. It's eventually a read
So it ends being neither, it's obviously not a conversation and it's also not a story.
Had to complete it for the sake of reading.
Why have characters in the book when there is no theme to it
Just rename them to character 1 or character 2 it still won't make any difference
And then the most irritating part is using your own book to mention one of your other books.
Why the brag Mr. Tripathi, yes you are a successful writer but rub it in the readers face.
I came from reading Anand neelkanthan's the asura way. That way much engaging
There were a couple of overlapping stories and the difference between the two authors is huge.
The sudama story, Anand goes on details how sudama refused a grain of boiled rice to krishna and how he denied saying there is nothing but mud to eat and that's what he got the rest of the life , and only when he was ready to offer his last portion of boiled rice that Krishna gave him all.
Anand not just gives more details but reads between the fine lines what it meant.
Amish has just been lazy telling that story.
Very lazy writing taking the readers for granted
When the writer says that he is using the form of conversation to make it intresting.
He forgets that eventually this is not a conversation. It's eventually a read
So it ends being neither, it's obviously not a conversation and it's also not a story.
Had to complete it for the sake of reading.
Why have characters in the book when there is no theme to it
Just rename them to character 1 or character 2 it still won't make any difference
And then the most irritating part is using your own book to mention one of your other books.
Why the brag Mr. Tripathi, yes you are a successful writer but rub it in the readers face.
I came from reading Anand neelkanthan's the asura way. That way much engaging
There were a couple of overlapping stories and the difference between the two authors is huge.
The sudama story, Anand goes on details how sudama refused a grain of boiled rice to krishna and how he denied saying there is nothing but mud to eat and that's what he got the rest of the life , and only when he was ready to offer his last portion of boiled rice that Krishna gave him all.
Anand not just gives more details but reads between the fine lines what it meant.
Amish has just been lazy telling that story.
Very lazy writing taking the readers for granted
December 9, 2023
Dissapointing
I haven't learned anything important in this which is not already obvious. Too much babbling without getting to any point.
I haven't learned anything important in this which is not already obvious. Too much babbling without getting to any point.
December 14, 2023
Being a girl who is always fascinated by Idols, I was very excited for this book. I have been an aderent reader of all the books by Amish Tripathi. Starting from The Rama Chandra series, Shiva Trilogy, till his non fiction book. Also will you guys believe, I purchased all his books in one go back in 2019 without even being aware of how the book will be and I think that was one of the best decisions till date. It also ignited my love for mythology.
I enjoyed his series of book a lot and when he co-authored his book Dharma with his sister I was now looking forward for the best to happen. That book was another feather to his cap. Thus, I pre-ordered "Idols". The book title itself fascinated me and OMG the book cover has my most favourite God Ganesha in it. The book had one more surprise in it. It had an inline postcard type of card, where the authors have signed it. The book was my companion for a journey to Pune and I enjoyed the journey with it.
The book highlights a very sensitive yet inspirational topic. Since its the successor of Dharma, the characters from Dharma are brought back along with few new. All the characters in the book enhanced the plot line. The book is all about Idol worship and its significance. IDOLATRY is always a personal choice and based on acceptance and belongingness one has with his God.
The book is very perspective and it takes us across cultures around the world, including the Grece, Romans, Egyptians, Vikings, etc.,. Each culture had its own practices for idol worship. The book blends the tradition with its modern explanation for each practice . The best part about the whole book is it left like any conversation happening at our home. Where the adults explain the values, culture and tradition we have in our roots. I felt myself as one of the family member and was enjoying each bit of conversation taking place.
If you are someone who is looking forward to know the importance of Idols and its worship, do read this book. I will also suggest the readers to read this book very slowly and not to rush up with the pages. As one turns each page, we have abundance of information. So take your time process it and enjoy the journey.
P.S - It took me almost 3 weeks to slowly enjoy the book and get indulged in the conversation among the characters.
I enjoyed his series of book a lot and when he co-authored his book Dharma with his sister I was now looking forward for the best to happen. That book was another feather to his cap. Thus, I pre-ordered "Idols". The book title itself fascinated me and OMG the book cover has my most favourite God Ganesha in it. The book had one more surprise in it. It had an inline postcard type of card, where the authors have signed it. The book was my companion for a journey to Pune and I enjoyed the journey with it.
The book highlights a very sensitive yet inspirational topic. Since its the successor of Dharma, the characters from Dharma are brought back along with few new. All the characters in the book enhanced the plot line. The book is all about Idol worship and its significance. IDOLATRY is always a personal choice and based on acceptance and belongingness one has with his God.
The book is very perspective and it takes us across cultures around the world, including the Grece, Romans, Egyptians, Vikings, etc.,. Each culture had its own practices for idol worship. The book blends the tradition with its modern explanation for each practice . The best part about the whole book is it left like any conversation happening at our home. Where the adults explain the values, culture and tradition we have in our roots. I felt myself as one of the family member and was enjoying each bit of conversation taking place.
If you are someone who is looking forward to know the importance of Idols and its worship, do read this book. I will also suggest the readers to read this book very slowly and not to rush up with the pages. As one turns each page, we have abundance of information. So take your time process it and enjoy the journey.
P.S - It took me almost 3 weeks to slowly enjoy the book and get indulged in the conversation among the characters.
January 21, 2024
Being a Bengali, I have grown up watching my grandparents and parents worship, and them placing a great deal of faith and importance on idols of various deities over the years. You can consider Durga Puja as an example of how much we love idols of our favourite gods, wherein we simply transcend the fact that they are made of clay and hay and start treating them as a part of our own family.
But I have never tried to understand the true meaning behind the practice of idolatry and how it helps us live a grounded life rooted in peace and understanding for ourselves and others.
Amish and Bhavna Roy help readers understand the whys and hows behind the practice of idolatry and also take a look back in the past to understand how idolatry has been treated then and how its philosophy has driven the core of so many people in the past, and it continues just the same in the present.
The content of the book unfolds in the form of a discussion between friends and family members of Dharma Raj and Lopamudra. In a manner of conversation, the readers learn about the history of idolatry, bhakti, self-realisation, contemplation, meditation, etc., and how each idol has attributes that strongly align with ours and help us in realising our potential and tapping into the deep reservoirs of resources within ourselves. Along the way, short stories from Indian and Greek mythology are used to reinforce certain aspects of idolatry. They are quite entertaining, can hook readers to each aspect, and aid in understanding the esoteric content.
Even though initially I disagreed with certain pointers in the book, later I fully immersed myself in what it had to say. Reading certain chapters at the near end of the book instilled a sense of peace and calm within me. I now understand the philosophy of idolatry much better than I did before, and it certainly helped me understand that god resides in us and we can be with the god within with the help of love, understanding, acceptance, and transformation.
A tremendously good spiritual self-help book to feel closer to God within and be one with it. It certainly comes with practice, but self-realisation is the first step, and this book certainly helps with that.
But I have never tried to understand the true meaning behind the practice of idolatry and how it helps us live a grounded life rooted in peace and understanding for ourselves and others.
Amish and Bhavna Roy help readers understand the whys and hows behind the practice of idolatry and also take a look back in the past to understand how idolatry has been treated then and how its philosophy has driven the core of so many people in the past, and it continues just the same in the present.
The content of the book unfolds in the form of a discussion between friends and family members of Dharma Raj and Lopamudra. In a manner of conversation, the readers learn about the history of idolatry, bhakti, self-realisation, contemplation, meditation, etc., and how each idol has attributes that strongly align with ours and help us in realising our potential and tapping into the deep reservoirs of resources within ourselves. Along the way, short stories from Indian and Greek mythology are used to reinforce certain aspects of idolatry. They are quite entertaining, can hook readers to each aspect, and aid in understanding the esoteric content.
Even though initially I disagreed with certain pointers in the book, later I fully immersed myself in what it had to say. Reading certain chapters at the near end of the book instilled a sense of peace and calm within me. I now understand the philosophy of idolatry much better than I did before, and it certainly helped me understand that god resides in us and we can be with the god within with the help of love, understanding, acceptance, and transformation.
A tremendously good spiritual self-help book to feel closer to God within and be one with it. It certainly comes with practice, but self-realisation is the first step, and this book certainly helps with that.
December 30, 2023
"Idols" by Amish Tripathi sheds light on subtle yet profoundly influencing intangible aspects of human existence that shape our perspectives on life, identity, and existence. This book explores the faith, convictions, and tenacity that have allowed humanity to coexist on this planet for millions of years.
Idols delves into the subject why people still participate in idol worship in spite of centuries of discrimination, prejudice, and violence against it. Idol worship has been a persistent subject of debate for many centuries, inspiring several discussions and hypotheses. Amish and Bhavna hope to illuminate the ways in which idol worship can help believers discover their own purpose in life and, in the end, achieve harmony and prosperity.
The narrative of the book with the exploration of various God, deities and their symbolic interpretation shares with us that there cannot be a good or wrong road, your way or mine; there is only a path that brings us joy on the journey we take in pursuit of becoming yourself, realizing the genuine nature of who you are, and uniting with your cosmic source.
The book presents a range of perspectives and insights regarding idol worship via the use of mythological tales and fictional but inspirational individuals. Anirban, who poses important issues and draws the story into critical examination of the nature of those concerns, is my particular favorite character. It conjured up images of a Gurukul studying human philosophy while in a state of Guru-shishya parampara, or mentor-mentee, which is how the ancient Hindu teachings known as the Upanishads were first transmitted.
Through offering a more profound comprehension of the idea underlying idol worship, Amish and Bhavna illustrate that it cannot result in the realization of Oneness with God unless you possess love, compassion and empathy within yourself.
"Idols" acknowledges the preconceptions and critiques directed against the practice and it also offers a balanced viewpoint that emphasizes its potential to promote spiritual and personal development.
Idols delves into the subject why people still participate in idol worship in spite of centuries of discrimination, prejudice, and violence against it. Idol worship has been a persistent subject of debate for many centuries, inspiring several discussions and hypotheses. Amish and Bhavna hope to illuminate the ways in which idol worship can help believers discover their own purpose in life and, in the end, achieve harmony and prosperity.
The narrative of the book with the exploration of various God, deities and their symbolic interpretation shares with us that there cannot be a good or wrong road, your way or mine; there is only a path that brings us joy on the journey we take in pursuit of becoming yourself, realizing the genuine nature of who you are, and uniting with your cosmic source.
The book presents a range of perspectives and insights regarding idol worship via the use of mythological tales and fictional but inspirational individuals. Anirban, who poses important issues and draws the story into critical examination of the nature of those concerns, is my particular favorite character. It conjured up images of a Gurukul studying human philosophy while in a state of Guru-shishya parampara, or mentor-mentee, which is how the ancient Hindu teachings known as the Upanishads were first transmitted.
Through offering a more profound comprehension of the idea underlying idol worship, Amish and Bhavna illustrate that it cannot result in the realization of Oneness with God unless you possess love, compassion and empathy within yourself.
"Idols" acknowledges the preconceptions and critiques directed against the practice and it also offers a balanced viewpoint that emphasizes its potential to promote spiritual and personal development.
July 30, 2025
*"मूर्ति पूजा : तथ्य और आस्था का संगम" लेखक: अमीश और भावना रॉय*
एक किताब जो रास्ता पूछती रही, मंज़िल तक पहुँची नहीं। किताब पढ़नी शुरू की थी इस उम्मीद में कि कुछ नया मिलेगा, कुछ ऐसा जो मुझे रुके हुए सवालों के जवाब देगा। पर जैसे कोई बातचीत शुरुआत में ही अपनी दिशा भूल जाए, वैसी ही उलझन इस किताब को पढ़ते हुए लगातार बनी रही।
लेखक कहते हैं कि यह संवाद की शैली में है, लेकिन जब पढ़ते-पढ़ते महसूस हो कि सामने कोई है ही नहीं, तो फिर संवाद किससे?
कहानी के नाम पर धर्मराज का परिवार मिला, गणेश चतुर्थी के आसपास एक बीमारी का बहाना मिला, और उसके ज़रिए आध्यात्मिक बातों को जोड़ने की कोशिश हुई। पर यह सब ऐसा लगा जैसे कोई स्क्रिप्ट हो, जिसे बिना भाव के, जैसे-तैसे पढ़ा जा रहा हो।
ताण्डव, अपस्मार, शिव विवाह, चंद्र पंचांग, मंत्र, योग, यूनानी देवता नाम बहुत आए, पर कोई बात पूरी नहीं हुई। विषय गहरा था, लेकिन किताब बस सतह से टकराकर लौट आई। कभी-कभी लगा कि अब कुछ निकलेगा, पर हर बार उम्मीद वहीं अटक गई। कुछ पौराणिक कथाएँ अच्छी थीं, शिव और देवी की कथाएं थोड़ी देर को रुचि खींचती हैं, पर फिर वही शैली थोड़ी थकी हुई, थोड़ी दोहराव भरी।
गणेश जी के चित्र वाला कवर सुंदर है। आस्था के उस प्रतीक को देखकर लगता है कि किताब में भी वैसी ही स्पष्टता होगी।लेकिन भीतर आते ही शब्द बिखरे-बिखरे लगे। किताब का उद्देश्य क्या था मूर्ति पूजा का इतिहास बताना? उसकी प्रासंगिकता या आलोचना करना? या बस विचारों को बहा देना? यह साफ नहीं हो सका।
कई बार लगा कि शायद मैं ही समझ नहीं पा रहा, पर फिर महसूस हुआ किताब खुद भी अपनी बात कहने में झिझक रही है।
"मूर्ति पूजा : तथ्य और आस्था का संगम" एक कोशिश है, लेकिन वह कोशिश अपनी ही उलझनों में फंसी हुई लगती है।
कई सुंदर विचार आए पर अधूरे।
कई सवाल उठे पर जवाब न मिले।
कुछ किताबें खत्म नहीं होतीं,
बस थक कर बंद कर दी जाती हैं।
यह वैसी ही एक किताब थी।
एक किताब जो रास्ता पूछती रही, मंज़िल तक पहुँची नहीं। किताब पढ़नी शुरू की थी इस उम्मीद में कि कुछ नया मिलेगा, कुछ ऐसा जो मुझे रुके हुए सवालों के जवाब देगा। पर जैसे कोई बातचीत शुरुआत में ही अपनी दिशा भूल जाए, वैसी ही उलझन इस किताब को पढ़ते हुए लगातार बनी रही।
लेखक कहते हैं कि यह संवाद की शैली में है, लेकिन जब पढ़ते-पढ़ते महसूस हो कि सामने कोई है ही नहीं, तो फिर संवाद किससे?
कहानी के नाम पर धर्मराज का परिवार मिला, गणेश चतुर्थी के आसपास एक बीमारी का बहाना मिला, और उसके ज़रिए आध्यात्मिक बातों को जोड़ने की कोशिश हुई। पर यह सब ऐसा लगा जैसे कोई स्क्रिप्ट हो, जिसे बिना भाव के, जैसे-तैसे पढ़ा जा रहा हो।
ताण्डव, अपस्मार, शिव विवाह, चंद्र पंचांग, मंत्र, योग, यूनानी देवता नाम बहुत आए, पर कोई बात पूरी नहीं हुई। विषय गहरा था, लेकिन किताब बस सतह से टकराकर लौट आई। कभी-कभी लगा कि अब कुछ निकलेगा, पर हर बार उम्मीद वहीं अटक गई। कुछ पौराणिक कथाएँ अच्छी थीं, शिव और देवी की कथाएं थोड़ी देर को रुचि खींचती हैं, पर फिर वही शैली थोड़ी थकी हुई, थोड़ी दोहराव भरी।
गणेश जी के चित्र वाला कवर सुंदर है। आस्था के उस प्रतीक को देखकर लगता है कि किताब में भी वैसी ही स्पष्टता होगी।लेकिन भीतर आते ही शब्द बिखरे-बिखरे लगे। किताब का उद्देश्य क्या था मूर्ति पूजा का इतिहास बताना? उसकी प्रासंगिकता या आलोचना करना? या बस विचारों को बहा देना? यह साफ नहीं हो सका।
कई बार लगा कि शायद मैं ही समझ नहीं पा रहा, पर फिर महसूस हुआ किताब खुद भी अपनी बात कहने में झिझक रही है।
"मूर्ति पूजा : तथ्य और आस्था का संगम" एक कोशिश है, लेकिन वह कोशिश अपनी ही उलझनों में फंसी हुई लगती है।
कई सुंदर विचार आए पर अधूरे।
कई सवाल उठे पर जवाब न मिले।
कुछ किताबें खत्म नहीं होतीं,
बस थक कर बंद कर दी जाती हैं।
यह वैसी ही एक किताब थी।
November 20, 2023
This book was a perfect read for all the festivities around the corner. Idols by Amish and Bhavna Roy is an impeccable read to understand the concept of idol worshipping that has existed for a long time and why it plays a significant role in our daily lives. I am someone who believes in God and enjoys all the rituals that my grandparents and parents have taught me along with idol worshipping, but never before this book I ever questioned about Murthy Puja. The other thing that attracted me to this book was a picture of golden Ganpati along with a bright shiny red cover. This was a very well-penned, thought-provoking book that revolves around the controversial topic that is Murthy Puja, The Author laid down a strong premise from the start discussing Greek mythology, and ancient Egyptian mythology along with Hindu Puranas.
As someone like me who has not read much of mythology in the past the information provided in the book could be a little overwhelming for me but as the book slowly made progress it turned a little interesting & led to our topic of idol worshipping. The other thing that I Admire about this book is that it is written in the form of a story, I must say Amisha and Bhavna are great storytellers. It is written in the form of a dialogue between a few people set around the Ganpati festival.
If you are someone who is into mythology and the topic of idol worshipping intrigues you then definitely give this book a go because you might learn and discover something new. Definitely a must-read.
As someone like me who has not read much of mythology in the past the information provided in the book could be a little overwhelming for me but as the book slowly made progress it turned a little interesting & led to our topic of idol worshipping. The other thing that I Admire about this book is that it is written in the form of a story, I must say Amisha and Bhavna are great storytellers. It is written in the form of a dialogue between a few people set around the Ganpati festival.
If you are someone who is into mythology and the topic of idol worshipping intrigues you then definitely give this book a go because you might learn and discover something new. Definitely a must-read.
July 11, 2024
“Unearthing The Power Of Murti Puja”, are the words that caught my attention when I first read about this book. Amish and Bhavana Roy have successfully answered questions about the significant practice of idol worship and why it stays relevant even today. This book is for those who are curious seekers, it creates awareness about the minute details and aspects of culture that are practised but often without understanding the significance.
This book primarily aids the reader in understanding how idol worship in India survived even after the barbaric destruction of temples and idols, by the Turks and Europeans because they believed these practices to be “demonic” or “satanic”.
Considering religion and faith as political or spiritual has always been a matter of debate and one can learn a lot about the factors that have led to this unfortunate situation. Understanding the source, the path and their interpretation are the key to understanding consciousness and the authors have done a brilliant job with historical evidence that’s apparent.
What I absolutely love about the book is the conversational flow of the various themes this book covers be it the Vedas and Upanishads, Idol worshipping, Paganism and culture in various parts of the world that was destroyed because of extremism in thought, drastically affecting the society and world.
Don’t miss this book! It is unique and insightful and a joy to read and unravel aspects that define the culture and essence of this land.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
This book primarily aids the reader in understanding how idol worship in India survived even after the barbaric destruction of temples and idols, by the Turks and Europeans because they believed these practices to be “demonic” or “satanic”.
Considering religion and faith as political or spiritual has always been a matter of debate and one can learn a lot about the factors that have led to this unfortunate situation. Understanding the source, the path and their interpretation are the key to understanding consciousness and the authors have done a brilliant job with historical evidence that’s apparent.
What I absolutely love about the book is the conversational flow of the various themes this book covers be it the Vedas and Upanishads, Idol worshipping, Paganism and culture in various parts of the world that was destroyed because of extremism in thought, drastically affecting the society and world.
Don’t miss this book! It is unique and insightful and a joy to read and unravel aspects that define the culture and essence of this land.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
January 3, 2024
🅱🅾🅾🅺 🆁🅴🆅🅸🅴🆆
𝑷𝒓𝒆𝒄𝒊𝒔𝒊𝒐𝒏𝑰𝒅𝒐𝒍𝒔: 𝑼𝒏𝒆𝒂𝒓𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝑷𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓 𝒐𝒇 𝑴𝒖𝒓𝒕𝒊 𝑷𝒖𝒋𝒂
🆀🅾🆃🅳#: Do you believe in IDOLS WORSHIP? And who is your favorite idol?
#AOTD#: I truly believe in this and favorite is Durga.
ᴀᴜᴛʜᴏʀ: Amish Tripathi
ꜰᴏʀᴍᴀᴛ: Paperback
ᴘᴀɢᴇꜱ/ᴄʜᴀᴘᴛᴇʀꜱ: 328
ᴘᴜʙʟɪꜱʜᴇʀ: Harper Collins
ɢᴇɴʀᴇ: Theology
Why do people worship idols? Since we consider idol worship quite primitive. Everyone has their own thoughts behind this ideology.
When I have heard about this book I was truly mesmerized by the approach and what it bring forth to its readers.
The author had shared the anecdotes from the mythological era. I loved the fact that the author has shared such a complex topic in a flowy conversation amongst 5-6 people from every age group. The book offers an amalgamation about different mythologies ( Greek, Egyptian, Indian) also.
The concept of Maya, Ishta Devta has also been beautifully explained in this book. Despite the complexities of the topic this book offers you wisdom through its lucid approach.
The attempt by the author in this book is truly commendable and how the concept of Idol worship and belief has been explained is truly appreciative.
I truly recommend this book to everyone.
- #readwithbindu
- #reviewwithbindu
#bookwormbindz.
𝑷𝒓𝒆𝒄𝒊𝒔𝒊𝒐𝒏𝑰𝒅𝒐𝒍𝒔: 𝑼𝒏𝒆𝒂𝒓𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝑷𝒐𝒘𝒆𝒓 𝒐𝒇 𝑴𝒖𝒓𝒕𝒊 𝑷𝒖𝒋𝒂
🆀🅾🆃🅳#: Do you believe in IDOLS WORSHIP? And who is your favorite idol?
#AOTD#: I truly believe in this and favorite is Durga.
ᴀᴜᴛʜᴏʀ: Amish Tripathi
ꜰᴏʀᴍᴀᴛ: Paperback
ᴘᴀɢᴇꜱ/ᴄʜᴀᴘᴛᴇʀꜱ: 328
ᴘᴜʙʟɪꜱʜᴇʀ: Harper Collins
ɢᴇɴʀᴇ: Theology
Why do people worship idols? Since we consider idol worship quite primitive. Everyone has their own thoughts behind this ideology.
When I have heard about this book I was truly mesmerized by the approach and what it bring forth to its readers.
The author had shared the anecdotes from the mythological era. I loved the fact that the author has shared such a complex topic in a flowy conversation amongst 5-6 people from every age group. The book offers an amalgamation about different mythologies ( Greek, Egyptian, Indian) also.
The concept of Maya, Ishta Devta has also been beautifully explained in this book. Despite the complexities of the topic this book offers you wisdom through its lucid approach.
The attempt by the author in this book is truly commendable and how the concept of Idol worship and belief has been explained is truly appreciative.
I truly recommend this book to everyone.
- #readwithbindu
- #reviewwithbindu
#bookwormbindz.
February 21, 2024
In "Idols," Amish and Bhavna skillfully delve into the complexities of idol worship, offering a captivating exploration that goes beyond mere religious discourse. What truly sets this book apart is its ingenious use of dialogue format, which makes the reading experience remarkably immersive and relatable.
Through conversations among well-developed characters, readers get to see different points of view and feel like they're part of the discussion. This way of storytelling makes complicated ideas easy to understand and interesting for everyone. The characters are unique, and it's refreshing to see them talking, especially since they come from different generations.
The authors' adept handling of dialogue not only elucidates the essence and significance of idol worship but also fosters a deeper understanding of its enduring appeal. By weaving together myths, religious texts, and personal insights, Amish and Bhavna create a rich tapestry of ideas that invites readers to contemplate the profound meaning behind this ancient practice that has withstood the test of time.
Overall, "Idols" is a thought-provoking and enlightening read that challenges conventional notions of worship while offering a pathway to spiritual fulfillment. Its immersive dialogue format ensures that readers not only comprehend but also internalize the profound wisdom contained within its pages.
Through conversations among well-developed characters, readers get to see different points of view and feel like they're part of the discussion. This way of storytelling makes complicated ideas easy to understand and interesting for everyone. The characters are unique, and it's refreshing to see them talking, especially since they come from different generations.
The authors' adept handling of dialogue not only elucidates the essence and significance of idol worship but also fosters a deeper understanding of its enduring appeal. By weaving together myths, religious texts, and personal insights, Amish and Bhavna create a rich tapestry of ideas that invites readers to contemplate the profound meaning behind this ancient practice that has withstood the test of time.
Overall, "Idols" is a thought-provoking and enlightening read that challenges conventional notions of worship while offering a pathway to spiritual fulfillment. Its immersive dialogue format ensures that readers not only comprehend but also internalize the profound wisdom contained within its pages.
December 14, 2023
I was always fascinated by Amish's meticulous research, his hardworking manner; his enthusiasm for Indian culture and Hinduism. It's a mammoth of history and he delves into this heritage with easing.
The narration following previously famous Dharmraj and his family, with consecutive incidents author unveiled the idol worship culture, talks about religion, Greek gods and goddesses with their significance, Paganism, Chinese, Aztec, spritual, yoga, diffrence of yoga and exercise philosophy and whatnot. He touched all aspects of Idol worship and philosophy behind it.
From palpable historical events that happened with Idol worship to family - love, bonding, togetherness in diversity; he narrates Vedas quote, recites Upanishads to discuss the embodiment of idols in such simple words that everyone would be capable of understanding the deep meaning.
A delightful narrative in candid style makes the book engaging. Beautifully he brings out unity in diversity formats in India's different cultural and mistic tales, it makes readers want to read more.
A well crafted plot exploring history and constantly explaining it in sharp witty style is an invitation for fiction and nonfiction readers to grab the book and small snippets to add more stories makes this book more captivating, you wouldn't want to put it down until you finish it. This book is a well implied constructive thought process and both authors'painstaking hardwork is visible in every page.
And the lucid conversational narrative is just a chef's kiss, making this a compelling read for everyone. Absolutely loved this book.
The narration following previously famous Dharmraj and his family, with consecutive incidents author unveiled the idol worship culture, talks about religion, Greek gods and goddesses with their significance, Paganism, Chinese, Aztec, spritual, yoga, diffrence of yoga and exercise philosophy and whatnot. He touched all aspects of Idol worship and philosophy behind it.
From palpable historical events that happened with Idol worship to family - love, bonding, togetherness in diversity; he narrates Vedas quote, recites Upanishads to discuss the embodiment of idols in such simple words that everyone would be capable of understanding the deep meaning.
A delightful narrative in candid style makes the book engaging. Beautifully he brings out unity in diversity formats in India's different cultural and mistic tales, it makes readers want to read more.
A well crafted plot exploring history and constantly explaining it in sharp witty style is an invitation for fiction and nonfiction readers to grab the book and small snippets to add more stories makes this book more captivating, you wouldn't want to put it down until you finish it. This book is a well implied constructive thought process and both authors'painstaking hardwork is visible in every page.
And the lucid conversational narrative is just a chef's kiss, making this a compelling read for everyone. Absolutely loved this book.
December 12, 2023
I have been a die hard Amish fan but halfway through the book I feel like giving up. They try to give info about Indian way of philosophy but if you are writing a book on idol worship, you should not digress so much that even after 111 pages there's no mention of any idol worship reasoning. I honestly got bored. I used to be one of those spiritual-but-not-religous persons and I was looking for a book that would help me get back to doing Pooja and reciting mantras in the morning with intent and not just for the sake of it. But this book felt more like a philosophical discussion on Dharma and aatma and I honestly couldn't connect the dots. Plus the conversation among the 5-6 characters doesn't look very natural. Anyways, Amish will always remain one of my favourite authors 🫶
P.S. Read this article incase you don't want to read the book. Found it on internet, actually answered my questions
https://www.exoticindiaart.com/blog/t...
P.S. Read this article incase you don't want to read the book. Found it on internet, actually answered my questions
https://www.exoticindiaart.com/blog/t...
October 22, 2023
A great book highlighting the history behind idol-worship across the globe and bringing to light many of the aspects of different Hindu Gods and Goddesses. I was looking for such a book for some time now and finally Amish delievered.
Here's what I loved about the book:
1. The Topic of Ishta Devtas and how devotees connect to them
2. Exploring the core as well an surface notions in Hinduism
3. Correlation with other polythiest religions like that of Greek and Egyptian
What I didn't enjoy as much:
1. Digressing from current topic too much to discuss correlations with Greek Culture.
2. Less information about Pranprathista in Murti Pujas and precursor to idol worships: Mandals & Yantras.
3. Less information about Nirguna Bhakti and it's parallelism with Abrahmaic Faiths.
Here's what I loved about the book:
1. The Topic of Ishta Devtas and how devotees connect to them
2. Exploring the core as well an surface notions in Hinduism
3. Correlation with other polythiest religions like that of Greek and Egyptian
What I didn't enjoy as much:
1. Digressing from current topic too much to discuss correlations with Greek Culture.
2. Less information about Pranprathista in Murti Pujas and precursor to idol worships: Mandals & Yantras.
3. Less information about Nirguna Bhakti and it's parallelism with Abrahmaic Faiths.
March 31, 2024
It's an interesting read. What I liked most is the symbolism of many gods and goddesses has been discussed. And a few anecdotes of how different names came to being. Example - Lord Hanuman is aka Panchamukhi, because he extinguished 5lamps in one blow in pataal lok to rescue Sri Ram and laxman.
But I won't recommend it to someone who haven't read any of Amish's work.
The conversations seem choppy and frequently jumping from one topic to another. And content is also some what tough to grasp (but that depends on the reader)
Also this book lacks debates. There were very good debates in its prequel , Dharma. That book made me introspect unlike Idols. Hope in next book we will get more of that.
But I won't recommend it to someone who haven't read any of Amish's work.
The conversations seem choppy and frequently jumping from one topic to another. And content is also some what tough to grasp (but that depends on the reader)
Also this book lacks debates. There were very good debates in its prequel , Dharma. That book made me introspect unlike Idols. Hope in next book we will get more of that.
October 23, 2023
📚 One of the best reads of 2023. Unputdownable, gripping with so much to learn.
📚 A companion volume to the book Dharma. The characters of the book are back to have conversations about Idol worship.
📚 Every character brings their experiences and insights making a simple conversation engrossing and thought-provoking.
📚The way Amish sir and Bhavana ma'am have crafted the significance of every god in the Hindu religion is mesmerizing. The philosophical explanations give you a deeper understanding of the topic.
I highly recommend this book to everyone. You will not be disappointed reading this book.
📚 A companion volume to the book Dharma. The characters of the book are back to have conversations about Idol worship.
📚 Every character brings their experiences and insights making a simple conversation engrossing and thought-provoking.
📚The way Amish sir and Bhavana ma'am have crafted the significance of every god in the Hindu religion is mesmerizing. The philosophical explanations give you a deeper understanding of the topic.
I highly recommend this book to everyone. You will not be disappointed reading this book.
October 9, 2024
Great idea, but terrible execution. The conversation read like the script of a bad play. Very little about idols and the iconography or how and more importantly why they are worshipped. The authors barely skim the surface of the title. Thought of giving up mid way, but managed to read the whole book. Just because the cover carries Amish's name, I guess the publisher thinks it will sell and maybe it does. There are many many better deeper books on similar lines and podcasts.
Om Swami's The secret of mantras is one such book. Rajshri Nandi's pod casts. Read Swami Vivekanand. This book and I think future books by Amish are avoidable.
Om Swami's The secret of mantras is one such book. Rajshri Nandi's pod casts. Read Swami Vivekanand. This book and I think future books by Amish are avoidable.
November 6, 2023
This book is enjoyable. I appreciate how it presents complex Hindu philosophy in a conversational style. It seems to follow the traditional Upanishadic approach to convey its message. I was particularly intrigued by this book because I once contemplated writing on this subject, but I abandoned the idea due to my limited expertise in the field.
That said, I found that in the latter part of the book, it deviated from its central theme. I believe it should have delved more into the positive aspects of Murti Puja. Greek God references were unnecessary at times.
That said, I found that in the latter part of the book, it deviated from its central theme. I believe it should have delved more into the positive aspects of Murti Puja. Greek God references were unnecessary at times.
September 11, 2024
*Idols* by Amish Tripathi had the potential to offer deeper insights into the philosophy behind idol worship, but it primarily focuses on various idols and their associated stories. While the narratives are interesting, many of them are already familiar to practicing Hindus. The book does touch on the powerful aspects of puja for dhyana (meditation) and its role in community building, which are compelling, but I expected a more profound exploration of idol worship itself. That said, it's a quick and easy read, so no regrets on the time spent, but it left me wanting more depth.
June 24, 2025
This book was an easy read because of its 'conversation style' writing - same style as our Upanishads apparently. It does give a lot of information about deep, philosophical meaning about some of our Vedic texts but it was a little haphazard and lacked the depth to actually answer the question at hand - idol worship. "Idols can be personifications of our tendencies, impulses and traits. They have gathered collective energy over millennia" - not bad but could have been better.
July 30, 2024
This is more about the general philosophical conversation which starts from Murti Puja, while it is written in a socratic method and which I enjoyed a lot. Some of the self references from Author himself feels a bit disappointing as the same story has been used multiple time which is why I have rated 4 stars
October 23, 2023
Good book. Preachy and nothing more to read than some superficial topics. Author also deviates a lot from the main topic. I went in to read the iconography of the idols but it was disappointing in that sense. 1 time read
November 25, 2023
I didn't understand the motto or the objective of this book. The conversations between the people seemed fictitious and out of context most of the time. Some of the mythological stories were nice but the overall book looked irrelevant and vague.
December 18, 2023
It is so nicely written. Thank you Amish for this. The best part of this book is it's a conversation among a bunch of people who are exploring and explaining the reasons and not just one person etelling others. I hope more comes on this line of thoughts from Amish and team in the future.
June 3, 2024
Lot of topics taken and discussed but a strong case for idolatory is not made. However, I liked the way many Gods and Goddesses were discussed and many stories from mythologies throughout the world were told.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews