What do you think?
Rate this book
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall
‘A king adorns the throne… He has no subtlety, no grace but he does not deserve to die in the way that has been planned and this is why we shall stop them, our men, our kin and save us all.’
1605
Bess Throckmorton is well used to cunning plots and intrigues. With her husband Sir Walter Raleigh imprisoned in the Tower of London, and she and her family in a constant battle to outwit Robert Cecil, the most powerful man in the country who is determined to ruin her, Bess decides to retreat to her beloved home, Crestwell Hall. But there she is shocked to hear talk of a new plot to murder the king. So, unbeknownst to their menfolk, the wives of the plotters begin to work together to try to stop the impending disaster.
Present Day
Isabella Lacey and her daughter, Emily, are excited to be starting a new life at her aunt’s home, Crestwell Hall in Wiltshire. During renovations, Isabella discovers an ancient bible that once belonged to Bess Throckmorton, and to her astonishment finds that it doubled as a diary. As Isabella reads Bess’s story, a new version of the Gunpowder Plot begins to emerge - told by the women.
When Emily’s life is suddenly in terrible danger, Isabella understands the relentless fear felt by Bess, hundreds of years ago. And as the fateful date of 5th November draws ever closer, Bess and the plotters’ wives beg their husbands to stop before a chain of events is set into action that can only end one way…
1605
Bess Throckmorton is well used to cunning plots and intrigues. With her husband Sir Walter Raleigh imprisoned in the Tower of London, and she and her family in a constant battle to outwit Robert Cecil, the most powerful man in the country who is determined to ruin her, Bess decides to retreat to her beloved home, Crestwell Hall. But there she is shocked to hear talk of a new plot to murder the king. So, unbeknownst to their menfolk, the wives of the plotters begin to work together to try to stop the impending disaster.
Present Day
Isabella Lacey and her daughter, Emily, are excited to be starting a new life at her aunt’s home, Crestwell Hall in Wiltshire. During renovations, Isabella discovers an ancient bible that once belonged to Bess Throckmorton, and to her astonishment finds that it doubled as a diary. As Isabella reads Bess’s story, a new version of the Gunpowder Plot begins to emerge - told by the women.
When Emily’s life is suddenly in terrible danger, Isabella understands the relentless fear felt by Bess, hundreds of years ago. And as the fateful date of 5th November draws ever closer, Bess and the plotters’ wives beg their husbands to stop before a chain of events is set into action that can only end one way…
386 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2024
632 people are currently reading
506 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews
January 24, 2024
“Remember, remember the 5th of November…”
These were the words that came to mind as I started reading. They are part of John Milton’s poem alluding to the events mentioned in this book.
I was initially drawn to this book because I saw that it focussed on an intriguing part of history and was set during two of my favourite periods, the Tudor and Stuart era. However, it was the depth of research and stellar prose that held my attention.
This dual timeline brings together two women, centuries apart, who are linked by a Tudor mansion in Wiltshire, Crestwell Hall, and spotlights women supporting each other in a time of crisis.
Elizabeth “Bess” Throckmorton Raleigh, Queen Elizabeth I’s former lady-in-waiting, is retreating to her secret estate in Wiltshire to thwart the wrath of Robert Cecil, Queen Elizabeth’s advisor. Leaving her husband imprisoned in the Tower of London was not ideal, but Bess realizes the value of distance and the support of her female friends.
In the present day, Isabella Lacey and her 10-year-old daughter, Emily, have arrived at her Aunt Thalia’s home, Crestwell Hall, partly due to a generous offer to end their homelessness after a divorce but more importantly, to help Aunt Thalia with renovations. Believing the house has an important historical past, wanting to turn it into a future viable business concern, and wanting to honor the legacy of her Great Uncle Philip, Isabella and her aunt begin the process of restoration. They find something that links the house to the Gun Powder Plot of 1605.
A keen Tudor and Stuart-era enthusiast, I didn’t think I could learn much more about this incident, but I was completely wrong. I eagerly noted the differences between gargoyles and grotesques, the recusancy laws, the inspiration behind Ben Jonson’s Sejannus, His Fall and Shakespeare’s Measure For Measure, why King James was such a disappointment and what use priest holes and voussoirs held for the Tudors! My highlighter was pulling double duty.
Walsh makes the period real on the page. Her love of research and her career have certainly contributed to this absorbing and compelling read. I appreciate that she highlighted the shadows where many women throughout history have hidden behind their husband’s misdeeds and, in this case, become lost in the notoriety of the Gunpowder Plot. I also appreciated women’s friendships and the value of confidantes showcased throughout history.
The discovery of an important book was the highlight of this read and was well framed and supported by themes involving the tie of blood, the bond of family and the imminent danger that forces people together in their reliance on safety.
Never underestimate the power of a woman scorned nor what a group of women working together can achieve!
I was gifted this copy by Boldwood Books and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
These were the words that came to mind as I started reading. They are part of John Milton’s poem alluding to the events mentioned in this book.
I was initially drawn to this book because I saw that it focussed on an intriguing part of history and was set during two of my favourite periods, the Tudor and Stuart era. However, it was the depth of research and stellar prose that held my attention.
This dual timeline brings together two women, centuries apart, who are linked by a Tudor mansion in Wiltshire, Crestwell Hall, and spotlights women supporting each other in a time of crisis.
Elizabeth “Bess” Throckmorton Raleigh, Queen Elizabeth I’s former lady-in-waiting, is retreating to her secret estate in Wiltshire to thwart the wrath of Robert Cecil, Queen Elizabeth’s advisor. Leaving her husband imprisoned in the Tower of London was not ideal, but Bess realizes the value of distance and the support of her female friends.
In the present day, Isabella Lacey and her 10-year-old daughter, Emily, have arrived at her Aunt Thalia’s home, Crestwell Hall, partly due to a generous offer to end their homelessness after a divorce but more importantly, to help Aunt Thalia with renovations. Believing the house has an important historical past, wanting to turn it into a future viable business concern, and wanting to honor the legacy of her Great Uncle Philip, Isabella and her aunt begin the process of restoration. They find something that links the house to the Gun Powder Plot of 1605.
A keen Tudor and Stuart-era enthusiast, I didn’t think I could learn much more about this incident, but I was completely wrong. I eagerly noted the differences between gargoyles and grotesques, the recusancy laws, the inspiration behind Ben Jonson’s Sejannus, His Fall and Shakespeare’s Measure For Measure, why King James was such a disappointment and what use priest holes and voussoirs held for the Tudors! My highlighter was pulling double duty.
Walsh makes the period real on the page. Her love of research and her career have certainly contributed to this absorbing and compelling read. I appreciate that she highlighted the shadows where many women throughout history have hidden behind their husband’s misdeeds and, in this case, become lost in the notoriety of the Gunpowder Plot. I also appreciated women’s friendships and the value of confidantes showcased throughout history.
The discovery of an important book was the highlight of this read and was well framed and supported by themes involving the tie of blood, the bond of family and the imminent danger that forces people together in their reliance on safety.
Never underestimate the power of a woman scorned nor what a group of women working together can achieve!
I was gifted this copy by Boldwood Books and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
May 29, 2025
I reached for another standalone novel by Alexandra Walsh, having enjoyed numerous stories she has told before. Walsh shines light on historical fiction, balancing a story in the present as well. The story works well as it is told in both time periods, and the reader is entertained until the final page. Another gem that has me pleased that I discovered Alexandra Walsh’s work!
Bess Throckmorton may be living in 1605, but she is not naive to the way politics isplayedr at the time. Cunning choices and numerous intrigues surround her as Bess handles her husband, Sir Walter Raleigh, who is locked away in the Tower of London. Seeking a reprieve from the drama, Bess and the family leave for their beloved Crestwell Hall, a home in the countryside. This will permit her a chance to plot against Robert Cecil, the man who remains a thorn in her side. Bess learns of a new plot to kill the King James, explosive in nature. She cannot let it come to pass, working with other wives of apparent plotters to neutralise the threat before anything happens.
Isabella Lacey enjoys life in the present day, mother to her energetic daughter, Emily. After the end to a rocky marriage, Isabella and Lacey start a new life at her aunt’s home in Crestwell Hall. As she renovates, Isabella comes across an old bible that once belonged to Bess Throckmorton. This document is not only filled with religious sentiment, but serves as a diary that Bess kept. What Isabella discovers is a narrative surrounding the Gunpowder Plot that history failed to document and which could have changed many lives had it come to light.
As the family processes troubling news, Isabella better understands the issues Bess suffered those many years ago in the same home, striving to make things right. At the same time, Bess seeks to overturn the villainy that seems about to take place and the men who will surely be accused of the plot. Walsh delivers yet another great piece for all to enjoy!
I have long enjoyed the work of Alexandra Walsh, who has mastered the multiple timeline historical fiction genre. The narrative directs the story forward, entertaining and educating in equal measure. Characters develop well as the story advances, leaving the reader feeling as though they know these people personally. Plot points prevent too much predictability as the story advances. Surprises layer amongst the various reveals and have long kept me eager to read anything Walsh has to offer.
Kudos, Madam Walsh, for another winning novel.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
Bess Throckmorton may be living in 1605, but she is not naive to the way politics isplayedr at the time. Cunning choices and numerous intrigues surround her as Bess handles her husband, Sir Walter Raleigh, who is locked away in the Tower of London. Seeking a reprieve from the drama, Bess and the family leave for their beloved Crestwell Hall, a home in the countryside. This will permit her a chance to plot against Robert Cecil, the man who remains a thorn in her side. Bess learns of a new plot to kill the King James, explosive in nature. She cannot let it come to pass, working with other wives of apparent plotters to neutralise the threat before anything happens.
Isabella Lacey enjoys life in the present day, mother to her energetic daughter, Emily. After the end to a rocky marriage, Isabella and Lacey start a new life at her aunt’s home in Crestwell Hall. As she renovates, Isabella comes across an old bible that once belonged to Bess Throckmorton. This document is not only filled with religious sentiment, but serves as a diary that Bess kept. What Isabella discovers is a narrative surrounding the Gunpowder Plot that history failed to document and which could have changed many lives had it come to light.
As the family processes troubling news, Isabella better understands the issues Bess suffered those many years ago in the same home, striving to make things right. At the same time, Bess seeks to overturn the villainy that seems about to take place and the men who will surely be accused of the plot. Walsh delivers yet another great piece for all to enjoy!
I have long enjoyed the work of Alexandra Walsh, who has mastered the multiple timeline historical fiction genre. The narrative directs the story forward, entertaining and educating in equal measure. Characters develop well as the story advances, leaving the reader feeling as though they know these people personally. Plot points prevent too much predictability as the story advances. Surprises layer amongst the various reveals and have long kept me eager to read anything Walsh has to offer.
Kudos, Madam Walsh, for another winning novel.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
January 29, 2024
Alexandra Walsh is a new author to me and after enjoying this book, one I shall be following. This is a dual timeline story, the historical part mainly set in 1605 together with a present day strand. I remember the rhyme and the story of the Gunpowder plot from childhood – Guy (Guido) Fawkes was discovered planning to blow up the Houses of Parliament, kill the King and hundreds of innocent Londoners. Guy however was not the instigator of the plot that involved 13 men – that was Robert Catesby, a Catholic cousin to Protestant Bess Throckmorton (Elizabeth, Lady Raleigh), wife of the imprisoned explorer Walter Raleigh. Instead of highlighting the plotters, the author has focused on their wives; how much did they know and what could they do to protect themselves and their families. Bess is the mainstay here with her discovery of the plot and her plan to foil it, potentially saving many innocent lives but involving the wives of the plotters in a daring and dangerous scheme.
In the present day, Isabella Lacey and her young daughter Emily following a tumultuous period in their lives, move to Crestwell Hall, an historic but rather dilapidated building filled with artefacts (and much rubbish!), inherited by her aunt Thalia, and which requires enormous amounts of restoration -and money. What they discover within the Hall has direct connections to Bess and the Gunpowder Plot and is the vehicle by which Bess’ story is revealed.
I enjoyed both timelines, especially the historical part which combined fact with fiction. This Bess was a remarkably strong woman and far more savvy and intuitive than might be expected of many women of the time when the pursuit of power and personal ambitions put many in danger and to be the subject of even the slightest suspicion could have brutal repercussions.
The writing style was so very readable and the transition between the two timelines seamless. The author’s note at the back makes clear how much detailed research was required and gives further information. I loved the historical retelling and even though I initially thought Isabella’s character was the weaker, I rather changed my opinion of her when during this topical contemporary plot, she was faced with a dramatic and dangerous situation. Supportive friendships, on which both women relied, are the backstop to this story and the light touch of romance was nicely done. The description of Crestwell Hall appeared so authentic that whilst reading I had to check if it was real.
Finally, I have to mention the detailed character listing at the beginning for both timelines. My initial thoughts were 😱 – so many names to remember (I have to confess I didn’t fully get to grips with all the minor historical characters), but these type of references are useful (even more so if you are reading a print version- rather than an ecopy as I was).
In the present day, Isabella Lacey and her young daughter Emily following a tumultuous period in their lives, move to Crestwell Hall, an historic but rather dilapidated building filled with artefacts (and much rubbish!), inherited by her aunt Thalia, and which requires enormous amounts of restoration -and money. What they discover within the Hall has direct connections to Bess and the Gunpowder Plot and is the vehicle by which Bess’ story is revealed.
I enjoyed both timelines, especially the historical part which combined fact with fiction. This Bess was a remarkably strong woman and far more savvy and intuitive than might be expected of many women of the time when the pursuit of power and personal ambitions put many in danger and to be the subject of even the slightest suspicion could have brutal repercussions.
The writing style was so very readable and the transition between the two timelines seamless. The author’s note at the back makes clear how much detailed research was required and gives further information. I loved the historical retelling and even though I initially thought Isabella’s character was the weaker, I rather changed my opinion of her when during this topical contemporary plot, she was faced with a dramatic and dangerous situation. Supportive friendships, on which both women relied, are the backstop to this story and the light touch of romance was nicely done. The description of Crestwell Hall appeared so authentic that whilst reading I had to check if it was real.
Finally, I have to mention the detailed character listing at the beginning for both timelines. My initial thoughts were 😱 – so many names to remember (I have to confess I didn’t fully get to grips with all the minor historical characters), but these type of references are useful (even more so if you are reading a print version- rather than an ecopy as I was).
January 3, 2024
Another interesting and well written book from this author. I enjoy reading about this era in history and she writes in such a way that its not hard going. History wasn't my strong point at school and she makes it easier to take in all the characters and dates. My thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
January 3, 2024
This book is a dual timeline story switching back and forth between Isabella in the present day and Bess Throckmorton in 1605. It was a well researched and interesting look into the Gunpowder plot from a different perspective.
Alexandra Walsh does an excellent job building the story and making the historical figures come to life on the page. I loved Isabella's discovery of the bibles that belonged to Bess and how they helped decipher her secrets.
I definitely enjoyed the 1605 timeline more. It seemed to me that some of the present-day storyline was unnecessary, especially the inclusion of Isabella's ex-husband Keith.
Thank you, Netgalley, and the publisher for allowing me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Alexandra Walsh does an excellent job building the story and making the historical figures come to life on the page. I loved Isabella's discovery of the bibles that belonged to Bess and how they helped decipher her secrets.
I definitely enjoyed the 1605 timeline more. It seemed to me that some of the present-day storyline was unnecessary, especially the inclusion of Isabella's ex-husband Keith.
Thank you, Netgalley, and the publisher for allowing me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
January 25, 2024
The Gunpowder Plot is a very famous event in British history, mostly thanks to the famous refrain of "Remember, remember the Fifth of November", and is still commemorated at bonfire nights each year in the UK. When I was young (as in back in the 70s- yes, I am that old) we still had Fireworks Night on 5 November each year, but I don't think it really happens here in Australia anymore.
The book opens with Isabella Lacey and her young daughter arriving for a new life at the stately home known as Crestwell Hall. Isabella's uncle previously owned the home, but now Isabella and Emily need a new start, and helping her aunt Thaiya resurrect the home feels like the perfect opportunity. She can put her ugly divorce behind her and hopefully provide a stable home for Emily.
Her Uncle Phillip was a collector of many historical items, and had always maintained that Crestwell Hall was connected to the failed Gunpowder Plot but no one knows why he was so adamant. What they do know is that there are a lot of historical artifacts that need to be sorted, catalogued and appraised. In order to start restoring the home, Isabella and her aunt really need an injection of funds, but they don't know exactly where that is going to come from. Could there be some hidden treasures in the house?
This is a dual time line novel and the historical plot derives from a very simple question. Did the wives of the conspirators in the Gunpowder Plot know what was going on? Did they know that the plan was to blow up parliament on the 5th of November 1605 with the aim of killing the king with the aim of then replacing him with a Catholic ruler. The most well known name is probably Guy Fawkes but there were many other people involved in the plot. That's a very over simplified summary, but still.
To read more head to
http://www.theintrepidreader.com/2024...
May 2, 2024
This was an interesting past-present timeline story looking at the 1605 Gunpowder Plot in England through the eyes of Sir Walter Raleigh's wife, Bess Throckmorton. I believe it is mostly fictional, but this time period fascinates me, and so I enjoyed delving into it.
February 11, 2024
I have read and thoroughly enjoyed all of Alexandra’s books. If you love English history, particularly the Tudor/Stuart era, then this is most definitely the author for you. The Marquess House series was an extraordinary feat in reimagining aspects of Tudor history. This time, Alexandra tackles the infamous Gunpowder Plot of the 17th century which is also inclusive of a contemporary timeline.
‘We must persuade them away from the horror of this plot. They are good men who have become misguided. In the misery of the past years with the plague and the disappointments of King James’s Catholic policy, they’ve forgotten that their lives are happy and there are people who love them.’
In a nutshell Alexandra considers whether the wives of the conspirators in the Gunpowder Plot of 1605 knew what was going on? Guy Fawkes is the name most associated with this event, however, Elizabeth (Bess) Throckmorton (wife of Sir Walter Raleigh who was being held in the Tower of London) is who Alexandra shines the spotlight on. There are plots swirling around her and Bess must look to protect those she loves from being implicated to rid England of its unpopular King. In the present day, Isabella discovers Bess’s diary and faces a mysterious modern day/contemporary danger herself. It proved fascinating reading but be warned, it is an intriguing and complex read. For those who love a good conspiracy theory look no further.
‘…breathing in the atmosphere, imagining she could hear snippets of conversations from centuries gone by as she perambulated through the rooms …. Bess is giving me an entirely new perspective on the Gunpowder Plot’
The dual narrative once again works well as the author has really done her research in an attempt to make the whole plot appear plausible! Love it! On the flip side however, there are A LOT of details, names and places and you really had to be thinking straight with the large (and I mean large) assortment of characters (all real though - which is actually mind blowing when you think about it). However, sometimes it did read a little like a history text book of ‘who’s who’ from the period. The book is about history, mystery, and romance, with a twist on the famous Gunpowder Plot of 1605.
‘Do you think we women are deaf?’ she hissed, anger giving her courage. ‘Or that we are fools? We have known for months that the men of the family have been plotting a heinous crime and we have done our best to save you from yourselves.’
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.
‘We must persuade them away from the horror of this plot. They are good men who have become misguided. In the misery of the past years with the plague and the disappointments of King James’s Catholic policy, they’ve forgotten that their lives are happy and there are people who love them.’
In a nutshell Alexandra considers whether the wives of the conspirators in the Gunpowder Plot of 1605 knew what was going on? Guy Fawkes is the name most associated with this event, however, Elizabeth (Bess) Throckmorton (wife of Sir Walter Raleigh who was being held in the Tower of London) is who Alexandra shines the spotlight on. There are plots swirling around her and Bess must look to protect those she loves from being implicated to rid England of its unpopular King. In the present day, Isabella discovers Bess’s diary and faces a mysterious modern day/contemporary danger herself. It proved fascinating reading but be warned, it is an intriguing and complex read. For those who love a good conspiracy theory look no further.
‘…breathing in the atmosphere, imagining she could hear snippets of conversations from centuries gone by as she perambulated through the rooms …. Bess is giving me an entirely new perspective on the Gunpowder Plot’
The dual narrative once again works well as the author has really done her research in an attempt to make the whole plot appear plausible! Love it! On the flip side however, there are A LOT of details, names and places and you really had to be thinking straight with the large (and I mean large) assortment of characters (all real though - which is actually mind blowing when you think about it). However, sometimes it did read a little like a history text book of ‘who’s who’ from the period. The book is about history, mystery, and romance, with a twist on the famous Gunpowder Plot of 1605.
‘Do you think we women are deaf?’ she hissed, anger giving her courage. ‘Or that we are fools? We have known for months that the men of the family have been plotting a heinous crime and we have done our best to save you from yourselves.’
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.
March 21, 2024
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is the spellbinding new timeslip novel from Alexandra Walsh.
In 1605, as wife to Sir Walter Raleigh, Bess Throckmorton is used to sinister scheming and cruel machinations. With her husband imprisoned in the Tower of London, Bess needs to protect herself and keep her family safe – which is far from being an easy task with Robert Cecil, the most powerful men in the country, determined to ruin her at all costs! Needing some time away, Bess retreats to her home Crestwell Hall and is shocked to her core when she hears of a plot to assassinate the king!
In the present day, Isabella Lacey and her daughter Emily are excited to be starting over at Crestwell Hall in Wiltshire. Isabella cannot wait to make her aunt’s home her own, however, during renovations she makes a shocking discovery: an ancient bible that once belonged to Bess Throckmorton that doubles as a secret diary. As Isabella becomes engrossed in Bess’s story, a new version of the Gunpowder Plot emerges – told by the wives of the men who had plotted to murder the king and their determination to stop this assassination.
When Emily’s life is placed in danger, Isabella begins to understand the fear that had consumed Bess centuries ago. As the past and the present begin to merge in the most unexpected of ways, will Bess and Isabella manage to protect their loved ones? Or are they both about to lose everything?
Alexandra Walsh’s The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is a beguiling, atmospheric and dramatic tale layered with intrigue, mystery, tension and suspense. Evocative and enthralling, this engrossing tale is brilliantly paced, immersive and packed with enough twists and turns to keep readers turning the pages late into the night.
A heart-pounding timeslip page-turner in the best-selling tradition of Barbara Erskine, Alexandra Walsh’s The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is not to be missed.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
In 1605, as wife to Sir Walter Raleigh, Bess Throckmorton is used to sinister scheming and cruel machinations. With her husband imprisoned in the Tower of London, Bess needs to protect herself and keep her family safe – which is far from being an easy task with Robert Cecil, the most powerful men in the country, determined to ruin her at all costs! Needing some time away, Bess retreats to her home Crestwell Hall and is shocked to her core when she hears of a plot to assassinate the king!
In the present day, Isabella Lacey and her daughter Emily are excited to be starting over at Crestwell Hall in Wiltshire. Isabella cannot wait to make her aunt’s home her own, however, during renovations she makes a shocking discovery: an ancient bible that once belonged to Bess Throckmorton that doubles as a secret diary. As Isabella becomes engrossed in Bess’s story, a new version of the Gunpowder Plot emerges – told by the wives of the men who had plotted to murder the king and their determination to stop this assassination.
When Emily’s life is placed in danger, Isabella begins to understand the fear that had consumed Bess centuries ago. As the past and the present begin to merge in the most unexpected of ways, will Bess and Isabella manage to protect their loved ones? Or are they both about to lose everything?
Alexandra Walsh’s The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is a beguiling, atmospheric and dramatic tale layered with intrigue, mystery, tension and suspense. Evocative and enthralling, this engrossing tale is brilliantly paced, immersive and packed with enough twists and turns to keep readers turning the pages late into the night.
A heart-pounding timeslip page-turner in the best-selling tradition of Barbara Erskine, Alexandra Walsh’s The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is not to be missed.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
February 4, 2025
I absolutely LOVED this story!! A fantastic dual-timeline, historical fiction book that was just excellent start to finish!
Dual-timeline books can be really good or not. This one was just terrific. Both storylines in the two timelines were interesting, dramatic, well-crafted and perfectly paced, keeping me reading and wanting to find out what the ending for both sets of characters was going to be.
I really, really liked both of our main characters, Bess in the past and Issy in the present day. They are both, strong, smart, kind and capable women who are absolutely determined to make their own way, protect those they love and build lives they can thrive in, and for the reader going along on their adventures this was thrilling and exciting.
I knew very little about the Gunpowder Plot before reading this book, and while it is fiction, as historical fiction I enjoyed the opportunity to learn more about the time, the life-and-death battle between Catholics and Protestants and the people involved in and peripherally connected to the plot.
I especially love that the author chose to make the wives of the plotters her focus, and gave them a - fictional, but so well-crafted - opportunity to try to save their foolhardy husbands and foil the plot to blow up Parliament.
Equally exciting was the present-day plot, which was its own unique and entertaining storyline surrounding not only the discoveries of Crestwell Hall (the connection between the present, and past storylines) but events in Issy's life that become almost as dramatic as the foiling of the Gunpowder Plot.
I really really loved everything about this story. It is everything, and exactly what the best historical fiction should be: great characters, strong plots in both the past and present timelines and great, engaging writing perfectly paced. I will definitely be looking at other books by this author. I highly recommend this book as a great read for historical fiction fans who also enjoy dual-timeline stories.
Dual-timeline books can be really good or not. This one was just terrific. Both storylines in the two timelines were interesting, dramatic, well-crafted and perfectly paced, keeping me reading and wanting to find out what the ending for both sets of characters was going to be.
I really, really liked both of our main characters, Bess in the past and Issy in the present day. They are both, strong, smart, kind and capable women who are absolutely determined to make their own way, protect those they love and build lives they can thrive in, and for the reader going along on their adventures this was thrilling and exciting.
I knew very little about the Gunpowder Plot before reading this book, and while it is fiction, as historical fiction I enjoyed the opportunity to learn more about the time, the life-and-death battle between Catholics and Protestants and the people involved in and peripherally connected to the plot.
I especially love that the author chose to make the wives of the plotters her focus, and gave them a - fictional, but so well-crafted - opportunity to try to save their foolhardy husbands and foil the plot to blow up Parliament.
Equally exciting was the present-day plot, which was its own unique and entertaining storyline surrounding not only the discoveries of Crestwell Hall (the connection between the present, and past storylines) but events in Issy's life that become almost as dramatic as the foiling of the Gunpowder Plot.
I really really loved everything about this story. It is everything, and exactly what the best historical fiction should be: great characters, strong plots in both the past and present timelines and great, engaging writing perfectly paced. I will definitely be looking at other books by this author. I highly recommend this book as a great read for historical fiction fans who also enjoy dual-timeline stories.
January 12, 2024
This book had a great premise with its focus on the wives of the Gunpowder Plotters, making it easy to empathise and wonder what it would be like to be plunged into such a situation. This was reinforced by the clever way the author wove threads linking modern-day radicalised extremists with the historic plotters. I loved this aspect of the book, with terrorists set on a destructive path and their womenfolk doing all they can to prevent death, ruin and disgrace.
The book was impressively researched and I was so pleased to find the author’s note at the end and get the detail of what was fact and how much was invented.
There were some lovely, vivid descriptions which made it easy to picture the setting. Halfway through I had to google Crestwell Hall to find out if it was real - a sign of clever and plausible writing in an historical fiction author.
The downsides of the book for me were a great many names being featured, which made it unnecessarily confusing - especially where these were from the back story of minor characters and I didn’t really need to know. It slowed down the pace and spoiled some of my enjoyment of the story. As much as I admired the author’s planning, I felt a stricter edit could have improved this aspect. The list of characters at the start isn’t easy to flick back to on a Kindle, and I must admit my heart sank a bit to see it there.
The modern-day treasure hunt in all those secret rooms was less convincing, for me, than the historical aspects of the story.
Overall, the book is an impressive achievement and one I’d recommend to anyone interested in Tudor and Stuart history.
The book was impressively researched and I was so pleased to find the author’s note at the end and get the detail of what was fact and how much was invented.
There were some lovely, vivid descriptions which made it easy to picture the setting. Halfway through I had to google Crestwell Hall to find out if it was real - a sign of clever and plausible writing in an historical fiction author.
The downsides of the book for me were a great many names being featured, which made it unnecessarily confusing - especially where these were from the back story of minor characters and I didn’t really need to know. It slowed down the pace and spoiled some of my enjoyment of the story. As much as I admired the author’s planning, I felt a stricter edit could have improved this aspect. The list of characters at the start isn’t easy to flick back to on a Kindle, and I must admit my heart sank a bit to see it there.
The modern-day treasure hunt in all those secret rooms was less convincing, for me, than the historical aspects of the story.
Overall, the book is an impressive achievement and one I’d recommend to anyone interested in Tudor and Stuart history.
February 3, 2024
Rating: 5 Stars!!
Review:
Thank you to Rachel's Random Resources for hosting this book's tour and for the FREE EBook to Promote and Review for Alexandra last month.
This was my first time reading a Historical Fiction Time Travel Novel by Alexandra so i wasnt sure what to expect but i have to say i read enjoyed this one especially when the history of Crestwell Hall was explained which made this book that much more facinating.
The Characters were fun and interesting to read about. Isabella, Emily, Thalia and Bess were definately my favorites. I loved that all their backgrounds were connected.
The Setting was beautifully described which made me feel like i was actually in 1605 Wiltshire especially when the scenery was described.
Overall a throughly enjoyable Historical Fiction Time Travel Novel!! Can't wait to read more by Alexandra in the future!!
Review:
Thank you to Rachel's Random Resources for hosting this book's tour and for the FREE EBook to Promote and Review for Alexandra last month.
This was my first time reading a Historical Fiction Time Travel Novel by Alexandra so i wasnt sure what to expect but i have to say i read enjoyed this one especially when the history of Crestwell Hall was explained which made this book that much more facinating.
The Characters were fun and interesting to read about. Isabella, Emily, Thalia and Bess were definately my favorites. I loved that all their backgrounds were connected.
The Setting was beautifully described which made me feel like i was actually in 1605 Wiltshire especially when the scenery was described.
Overall a throughly enjoyable Historical Fiction Time Travel Novel!! Can't wait to read more by Alexandra in the future!!
January 15, 2024
This is a historical fiction that alternates between two timelines which the authors weaves perfectly together to tell this story. The 17th century, where Bess Throckmorton and the wives of the Gunpowder Plot conspirators try to prevent a regicide, and in the present day, Isabella Lacey and her daughter Emily uncover Bess’s diary and face a mysterious threat.
The book is about history, mystery, and romance, with a twist on the famous Gunpowder Plot of 1605. It was interesting reading about The Gunpowder Plot in 1605
June 3, 2025
Great book for driving in the car. Duel timeline both taking place at crestwell hall. Delved a bit too deep into the names and characters of the Guy Fawlks gunpower uprising. I much more enjoyed the current timeline story.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 23, 2023
I love everything that Alexandra Walsh has done.
This one is in a similar vein to the Marquess House series.
The story sweeps seamlessly between the gunpowder plot in the 17th century and the present day.
Brilliant 10 out of 10
This one is in a similar vein to the Marquess House series.
The story sweeps seamlessly between the gunpowder plot in the 17th century and the present day.
Brilliant 10 out of 10
April 12, 2024
An interesting story, but there were WAY too many characters in the Elizabethan section of the book to keep it all straight. It felt to me like showing off her research was more important than creating a cohesive story line. The book was fine, but I doubt I'd read it again.
January 23, 2024
This is a story of mammoth proportions. I say this because it would have required a massive amount of research and a heaping dose of imagination. Hats off to Alexandra Walsh for succeeding in delivering such a fascinating and memorable novel!
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is presented in two distinct timelines showcasing two radical groups side by side. (There are other great parallels in the two storylines and characters, as well.) The premise of the historical thread (1605) is that of the famous Gunpowder Plot—a failed attempt to assassinate King James I of England during the Opening of Parliament. Guy Fawkes is discovered while he is preparing to detonate explosives. The plan was organised by Robert Catesby, a devout Catholic who hoped to kill the Protestant King and establish Catholic rule in England. The modern timeline is also intriguing as another radical group tries to take over a modern day version of the historical event.
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall opens with the first few lines of an English Folk Verse ‘Remember, remember the fifth of November / Gunpowder, treason and plot.’ It is a great way to remember the date and details. If you look up one of the many versions available, you will see the whole story presented in verse. (An additional bonus feature is found at the back of the novel in the author's historical notes which are highly beneficial in learning more about The Gunpowder Plot). Poet John Milton also composed a poem years after the event. His piece written in 1626 'Quintum Novembris' celebrates the anniversary of this failed attempt. His retelling surely made headlines in his day, too, during a year of witch trials and an influenza epidemic.
There are many things about this novel to admire, especially some brilliant lines. It’s a story about consequences particularly of men who are ‘craving the glory of power.’ But it also features the ‘silent army’ of women who ‘exist on the edges’ and learn to survive and ‘navigate the shadows’: those who work invisibly to keep everything running smoothly.
Bess Throckmorton, wife of Walter Raleigh, is an intriguing character and we learn a lot from her movements—the terror and tribulations she and others faced. The Gunpowder Plot has been skilfully delivered, with lots of action and reaction. The only difficulty I ran into was keeping track of the number of characters at times. But Alexandra does prepare us with a list at the front. It just might slow you down on occasion while referring back to it in digital format. A paperback version would likely remedy this.
Crestwell Hall itself is an impressive structure but I see it as a true character that houses, protects and breathes history. It is a mesmerising place that harbours centuries-old secrets. Hidden stories begin to explode when modern day Isabella digs into its past (while tending to its restoration). She has the enviable task of unearthing some very old treasures. I was quite taken with her journey and that of her daughter’s. She is divorced and dealing with the shock of unexpected change. Her ex-husband’s personality alterations after his war injury, what that leads to and his eventual realisation of his actions are well played out. I cannot say I ‘liked’ him and the danger he courts. There are some very tense moments but the ending sees justice served and repentance a reality.
There’s romance, mystery, danger, discovery, history, second chances and retribution to name a few. For those who love stories with very old houses, dual timelines and twisty rollicking adventures— get this novel! 4.5 Stars for this intriguing story. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
Thanks to Boldwood and Netgalley for the review copy.
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall is presented in two distinct timelines showcasing two radical groups side by side. (There are other great parallels in the two storylines and characters, as well.) The premise of the historical thread (1605) is that of the famous Gunpowder Plot—a failed attempt to assassinate King James I of England during the Opening of Parliament. Guy Fawkes is discovered while he is preparing to detonate explosives. The plan was organised by Robert Catesby, a devout Catholic who hoped to kill the Protestant King and establish Catholic rule in England. The modern timeline is also intriguing as another radical group tries to take over a modern day version of the historical event.
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall opens with the first few lines of an English Folk Verse ‘Remember, remember the fifth of November / Gunpowder, treason and plot.’ It is a great way to remember the date and details. If you look up one of the many versions available, you will see the whole story presented in verse. (An additional bonus feature is found at the back of the novel in the author's historical notes which are highly beneficial in learning more about The Gunpowder Plot). Poet John Milton also composed a poem years after the event. His piece written in 1626 'Quintum Novembris' celebrates the anniversary of this failed attempt. His retelling surely made headlines in his day, too, during a year of witch trials and an influenza epidemic.
There are many things about this novel to admire, especially some brilliant lines. It’s a story about consequences particularly of men who are ‘craving the glory of power.’ But it also features the ‘silent army’ of women who ‘exist on the edges’ and learn to survive and ‘navigate the shadows’: those who work invisibly to keep everything running smoothly.
Bess Throckmorton, wife of Walter Raleigh, is an intriguing character and we learn a lot from her movements—the terror and tribulations she and others faced. The Gunpowder Plot has been skilfully delivered, with lots of action and reaction. The only difficulty I ran into was keeping track of the number of characters at times. But Alexandra does prepare us with a list at the front. It just might slow you down on occasion while referring back to it in digital format. A paperback version would likely remedy this.
Crestwell Hall itself is an impressive structure but I see it as a true character that houses, protects and breathes history. It is a mesmerising place that harbours centuries-old secrets. Hidden stories begin to explode when modern day Isabella digs into its past (while tending to its restoration). She has the enviable task of unearthing some very old treasures. I was quite taken with her journey and that of her daughter’s. She is divorced and dealing with the shock of unexpected change. Her ex-husband’s personality alterations after his war injury, what that leads to and his eventual realisation of his actions are well played out. I cannot say I ‘liked’ him and the danger he courts. There are some very tense moments but the ending sees justice served and repentance a reality.
There’s romance, mystery, danger, discovery, history, second chances and retribution to name a few. For those who love stories with very old houses, dual timelines and twisty rollicking adventures— get this novel! 4.5 Stars for this intriguing story. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
Thanks to Boldwood and Netgalley for the review copy.
January 30, 2024
I couldn’t wait to dive in to this book as this is a period of history that fascinates me. Guy Fawkes was a Yorkshireman, after al, like me. He attended St Peter’s School in York, one of the oldest schools in the world, along with two of the other gunpowder plotters. This school is the alma mater of my uncle and to this date they do not burn a guy on Bonfire Night!
This book takes place over two timelines, present day and 1605, preceding the Gunpowder Plot. The main characters are Isabella in the present day who takes up residence in Crestwell Hall and is involved in investigating its history and Bess Raleigh in 1605, wife of the incarcerated Sir Walter Raleigh and owner of Crestwell Hall. Both women are strong characters who are perfect conduits to tell the story of the Hall’s link to the Gunpowder Plot.
What I loved about the author’s last book was the level of historical detail and this book is no different. The writing transports the reader right into the heart of Tudor England during the reign of James I where conflict between Catholic and Protestant faiths was rampant and people lived in fear of discovery for following their religious beliefs. Many were discontented with the way the King was reigning and rumours and plots were rife. People were keen to keep their families safe from taint and Bess is a prime example of this. Her family is extensive and, when she hears whispers that some may be involved in plots against the King, she has to take action to protect herself and her children. The stress and danger of the time rises palpably from the page and infuses the reader so this becomes an edge-of-your-seat read. This is particularly true of women who have little power and are viewed as lesser by the men, but who are often ones who hold the true answers to the problems.
In the modern day, Isabella is similarly eager to do best for her daughter after her divorce, despite it being difficult for her. She becomes fascinated by the history of the Hall and determined to uncover its secrets. Her own strength is called upon when she finds her family in a dangerous situation. Luckily, she is surrounded by her family and good friends who she knows she can trust and lean on when things are difficult.
Female friendship, resilience and ingenuity and the overriding themes of the book which play out across both timelines and are extremely well written. All of the women in this book have character, presence and power when they decide to take it for themselves, but are often belittled and underestimated by the men around them, usually to their detriment. If anyone is labouring under the illusion that feminism is a modern phenomenon, this book will disabuse them of the notion!
This book is really easy to read, the writer’s style approachable and engaging and will delight fans of historical fiction. I absolutely loved it, probably more than the last one, and have no hesitation in recommending it to anyone who enjoys this genre.
This book takes place over two timelines, present day and 1605, preceding the Gunpowder Plot. The main characters are Isabella in the present day who takes up residence in Crestwell Hall and is involved in investigating its history and Bess Raleigh in 1605, wife of the incarcerated Sir Walter Raleigh and owner of Crestwell Hall. Both women are strong characters who are perfect conduits to tell the story of the Hall’s link to the Gunpowder Plot.
What I loved about the author’s last book was the level of historical detail and this book is no different. The writing transports the reader right into the heart of Tudor England during the reign of James I where conflict between Catholic and Protestant faiths was rampant and people lived in fear of discovery for following their religious beliefs. Many were discontented with the way the King was reigning and rumours and plots were rife. People were keen to keep their families safe from taint and Bess is a prime example of this. Her family is extensive and, when she hears whispers that some may be involved in plots against the King, she has to take action to protect herself and her children. The stress and danger of the time rises palpably from the page and infuses the reader so this becomes an edge-of-your-seat read. This is particularly true of women who have little power and are viewed as lesser by the men, but who are often ones who hold the true answers to the problems.
In the modern day, Isabella is similarly eager to do best for her daughter after her divorce, despite it being difficult for her. She becomes fascinated by the history of the Hall and determined to uncover its secrets. Her own strength is called upon when she finds her family in a dangerous situation. Luckily, she is surrounded by her family and good friends who she knows she can trust and lean on when things are difficult.
Female friendship, resilience and ingenuity and the overriding themes of the book which play out across both timelines and are extremely well written. All of the women in this book have character, presence and power when they decide to take it for themselves, but are often belittled and underestimated by the men around them, usually to their detriment. If anyone is labouring under the illusion that feminism is a modern phenomenon, this book will disabuse them of the notion!
This book is really easy to read, the writer’s style approachable and engaging and will delight fans of historical fiction. I absolutely loved it, probably more than the last one, and have no hesitation in recommending it to anyone who enjoys this genre.
January 15, 2026
Alexandra Walsh shines in this rich work of historical fiction, expertly balancing a compelling present-day mystery with a vividly imagined past. Told through a dual narrative that moves between the modern day and the Tudor–Stuart era—centred around the Gunpowder Plot—the story grips from the opening chapters and holds its tension right through to the final page. A true gem.
The shifting timelines work seamlessly, never disrupting the flow, and instead deepen the intrigue. The historical strand in particular offers a fascinating reimagining of the Gunpowder Plot, highlighting how women in the 17th century were not only politically aware but intellectually engaged with the turbulent world around them. Walsh presents a hypothetical yet persuasive vision of women quietly organising, observing, and perhaps even influencing events from the shadows—and honestly, I found myself wishing it were true. Who’s to say it wasn’t?
This is dual-timeline historical fiction at its finest: entertaining, educational, and full of surprises. The twists genuinely caught me off guard, and the pacing never faltered. Walsh’s writing is highly readable, and the transitions between eras feel natural and fluid rather than forced.
While Isabella initially felt like the weaker of the two protagonists, my opinion shifted as her contemporary storyline darkened and became increasingly perilous. Both timelines are anchored by strong, supportive friendships—women relying on women—which form the emotional backbone of the novel. The light touch of romance is well judged and never overwhelms the mystery.
Crestwell Hall itself is so vividly described it feels almost tangible; I found pictures of the ruins online and it’s easy to picture the building at its best with Walsh’s depictions. The author’s note at the back further cements Walsh’s skill, clearly demonstrating the depth of research behind the story and adding valuable historical context.
An absorbing, intelligent novel that blends history, mystery, and female agency with impressive finesse
The shifting timelines work seamlessly, never disrupting the flow, and instead deepen the intrigue. The historical strand in particular offers a fascinating reimagining of the Gunpowder Plot, highlighting how women in the 17th century were not only politically aware but intellectually engaged with the turbulent world around them. Walsh presents a hypothetical yet persuasive vision of women quietly organising, observing, and perhaps even influencing events from the shadows—and honestly, I found myself wishing it were true. Who’s to say it wasn’t?
This is dual-timeline historical fiction at its finest: entertaining, educational, and full of surprises. The twists genuinely caught me off guard, and the pacing never faltered. Walsh’s writing is highly readable, and the transitions between eras feel natural and fluid rather than forced.
While Isabella initially felt like the weaker of the two protagonists, my opinion shifted as her contemporary storyline darkened and became increasingly perilous. Both timelines are anchored by strong, supportive friendships—women relying on women—which form the emotional backbone of the novel. The light touch of romance is well judged and never overwhelms the mystery.
Crestwell Hall itself is so vividly described it feels almost tangible; I found pictures of the ruins online and it’s easy to picture the building at its best with Walsh’s depictions. The author’s note at the back further cements Walsh’s skill, clearly demonstrating the depth of research behind the story and adding valuable historical context.
An absorbing, intelligent novel that blends history, mystery, and female agency with impressive finesse
January 20, 2024
I was entranced with this book. The story was history revealed in the best way possible.
Two timelines. One the 1600 and then the present day. Present times Isabella just after an acrimonious divorce is home with Emily her daughter, hoping for a new start at the Hall with her aunt Thalia. They hope to renovate the Hall, restore it from its neglected state and discover the secrets they know are stored there. It is a gargantuan task as decades of papers, receipts, boxes are there, along with undiscovered attics, cellars and priest holes.
In the 1600s it has been the home of Elizabeth Throckmorton, wife of Walter Raleigh now in the Tower of London. Elizabeth along with her clan women suspect that their menfolk are acting strangely under the guidance of Robin Catesby. They are frightened how it will affect them and their children, because though Elizabeth is Protestant her relations have remained staunchly Catholic, not a good thing at the time. It takes time for the women to piece together overheard conversations and copies of letters giving details of high treason. The men were planning to blow up Parliament, depose the King and take the Princess as hostage. The infamous Gunpowder Plot failed miserably, all the men were captured and were executed.
Isabella pieced the story together, and in the process discovered treasures of gold and paintings which would help in the restoration. The link for both women was the house which was much loved by both of them.
Elizabeth’s story could be one book in itself as it was a fascinating insight into how women sought to protect their families in whatever way possible when the stakes were high.
Romance in both eras were also a nice point. The terrorist group in the present day scenario of Isabella and Emily was stark, frightening and very realistic.
Altogether a five star read.
Two timelines. One the 1600 and then the present day. Present times Isabella just after an acrimonious divorce is home with Emily her daughter, hoping for a new start at the Hall with her aunt Thalia. They hope to renovate the Hall, restore it from its neglected state and discover the secrets they know are stored there. It is a gargantuan task as decades of papers, receipts, boxes are there, along with undiscovered attics, cellars and priest holes.
In the 1600s it has been the home of Elizabeth Throckmorton, wife of Walter Raleigh now in the Tower of London. Elizabeth along with her clan women suspect that their menfolk are acting strangely under the guidance of Robin Catesby. They are frightened how it will affect them and their children, because though Elizabeth is Protestant her relations have remained staunchly Catholic, not a good thing at the time. It takes time for the women to piece together overheard conversations and copies of letters giving details of high treason. The men were planning to blow up Parliament, depose the King and take the Princess as hostage. The infamous Gunpowder Plot failed miserably, all the men were captured and were executed.
Isabella pieced the story together, and in the process discovered treasures of gold and paintings which would help in the restoration. The link for both women was the house which was much loved by both of them.
Elizabeth’s story could be one book in itself as it was a fascinating insight into how women sought to protect their families in whatever way possible when the stakes were high.
Romance in both eras were also a nice point. The terrorist group in the present day scenario of Isabella and Emily was stark, frightening and very realistic.
Altogether a five star read.
May 28, 2024
As noted in the blurb, this is a dual timeline novel. In the present is Isabella who has just come with her daughter Emily to live at Crestwell Hall with her Aunt Thalia. She's fairly recently divorced and her ex-husband is unreliable at best. Turns out the house, which had been owned by her Uncle Phillip, may have some connection to the Gunpowder Plot of 1605. Thalia and Isabella are determined to clear the place out -- Phillip had become a bit of a hoarder in his later years -- and return the house to it's glory so as to open it for public tours.
The other narrative involves Bess Throckmorton, wife of Sir Walter Raleigh in the months leading up to November 5, 1605. When she hears rumors of a plot being spearheaded by her cousin and involving a number of family members, she rallies the wives to do what they can to dissuade their husbands from attempting something so dangerous. Though many of the ladies are Catholic, they all agree the plan must not be allowed to go ahead as it will only make things worse.
The two plots move along in parallel; Isabella is excited to find Bess's journal among various treasures in the house though troubled by secrets she's sensing between her aunt and a hired architect/builder as well as the difficulty Emily is having whenever she has her weekend with her dad.
I found the "Romance" aspect a little clunky, but fortunately not a major plot thread. And the final climax by the present day environmental extremist group felt a bit unrealistic, but other than that it was a decent read. I learned rather more about the Gunpowder plot than I had known, though keeping all those early 17th century names straight was a lost cause: it felt like all the women were Elizabeth and all the men either Robert or John!
In the end, I liked it well enough that I may try others by this author.
The other narrative involves Bess Throckmorton, wife of Sir Walter Raleigh in the months leading up to November 5, 1605. When she hears rumors of a plot being spearheaded by her cousin and involving a number of family members, she rallies the wives to do what they can to dissuade their husbands from attempting something so dangerous. Though many of the ladies are Catholic, they all agree the plan must not be allowed to go ahead as it will only make things worse.
The two plots move along in parallel; Isabella is excited to find Bess's journal among various treasures in the house though troubled by secrets she's sensing between her aunt and a hired architect/builder as well as the difficulty Emily is having whenever she has her weekend with her dad.
I found the "Romance" aspect a little clunky, but fortunately not a major plot thread. And the final climax by the present day environmental extremist group felt a bit unrealistic, but other than that it was a decent read. I learned rather more about the Gunpowder plot than I had known, though keeping all those early 17th century names straight was a lost cause: it felt like all the women were Elizabeth and all the men either Robert or John!
In the end, I liked it well enough that I may try others by this author.
January 27, 2024
This novel presented a compelling premise by focusing on the wives of the Gunpowder Plotters, inviting readers to empathize and ponder the challenges they faced. The author skillfully wove threads connecting modern-day radicalized extremists with their historic counterparts, adding depth to the narrative. I particularly enjoyed the portrayal of terrorists on a destructive path and their women striving to prevent death, ruin, and disgrace.
The book demonstrated impressive research, and I appreciated the author's note at the end clarifying the blend of fact and fiction. The vivid descriptions painted a clear picture of the setting, prompting me to even search for Crestwell Hall to determine its existence—an indication of the author's clever and plausible historical fiction writing.
However, the abundance of featured names, especially from the backstories of minor characters, created unnecessary confusion for me. It slowed down the pace and hindered my enjoyment of the story. While I admired the author's planning, I believed a more stringent edit could have improved this aspect. The list of characters at the start was challenging to reference on a Kindle, causing a bit of disappointment.
The modern-day treasure hunt in the secret rooms felt less convincing compared to the historical elements of the story. Despite these drawbacks, the book stands as an impressive achievement, recommended for those intrigued by Tudor and Stuart history.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. This review was originally posted on Storied Conversation
The book demonstrated impressive research, and I appreciated the author's note at the end clarifying the blend of fact and fiction. The vivid descriptions painted a clear picture of the setting, prompting me to even search for Crestwell Hall to determine its existence—an indication of the author's clever and plausible historical fiction writing.
However, the abundance of featured names, especially from the backstories of minor characters, created unnecessary confusion for me. It slowed down the pace and hindered my enjoyment of the story. While I admired the author's planning, I believed a more stringent edit could have improved this aspect. The list of characters at the start was challenging to reference on a Kindle, causing a bit of disappointment.
The modern-day treasure hunt in the secret rooms felt less convincing compared to the historical elements of the story. Despite these drawbacks, the book stands as an impressive achievement, recommended for those intrigued by Tudor and Stuart history.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. This review was originally posted on Storied Conversation
January 24, 2024
The shadows of the past are inextricably linked with the future and by cleverly combining two dual timeframes we learn The Secrets of Crestwell Hall and the part it played in the 1605 Gunpowder Plot.
Isabella Lacey and her daughter Emily arrive at Crestwell Hall in order to make a new start. A failed marriage has left Isabella wary and suspicious but she is determined that with Crestwell’s owner, her aunt Thalia, she will help to bring the house and its history alive once more. However, finding Crestwell’s secrets is no easy task and whilst the echoes of the past intrude so we start to build up a picture of the previous owner of Crestwell Hall. Elizabeth Throckmorton was the wife of Sir Walter Raleigh but with Raleigh languishing in the Tower of London and with plots and counter plots swirling around her Elizabeth must look to protect herself and those under her care from being implicated in the plot to rid England of its unpopular King.
The history of the time is well explored and this retelling of the Gunpowder Plots adds an altogether different dimension, it was particularly interesting to read of the family, and friendship, connections between those who were plotting and those who wished to see it fail. The dual time aspect is done really well and I found that as one time frame finished we were whisked away either into the past with Bess and her troubles or forward into the future as Isabella and her aunt set about bring Crestwell Hall back to life.
An easy page turner, with much to enjoy, this dual time story has everything I wanted, well researched history, a lively plot and enough intrigue in both time frames to make for a satisfying read.
January 25, 2024
Firstly I have to comment on the cover, it's beautiful! It drew me in before I'd even read the blurb. But I was intrigued by this book from the moment it mentioned the gunpowder plot, It is a part of history that I only know the basics about and having it as a key element of the plot really sounded interesting, especially hearing it from the female point of view.
I loved the fact that in both timelines we have a strong set of women who support each other and help one another with whatever they need without really questioning it too much. Issy has The Coven, I love that her aunt named them that by the way it made me smile every time it was said, and they instantly are there by her side as soon as they even hear in her voice that she's struggling. I loved getting a bit more of Bess's story and then flipping back to Issy and waiting for her to gradually uncover that bit of the story for herself it was very clever the way that Alexandra Walsh flips between the two at the points she chooses to, and how we get to piece together and fill in gaps in the history with Issy. I think the pace of the story is just right, it moved with enough speed that I just kept telling myself that I'd read just one more chapter before sleeping/cleaning etc and I'd find myself 4 chapters later caught up in what was happening. I really enjoyed the writing style of it too and I definitely think I need to go read more by the author, she's brought the period and the characters right off the page for me, it's been a fantastic read.
I loved the fact that in both timelines we have a strong set of women who support each other and help one another with whatever they need without really questioning it too much. Issy has The Coven, I love that her aunt named them that by the way it made me smile every time it was said, and they instantly are there by her side as soon as they even hear in her voice that she's struggling. I loved getting a bit more of Bess's story and then flipping back to Issy and waiting for her to gradually uncover that bit of the story for herself it was very clever the way that Alexandra Walsh flips between the two at the points she chooses to, and how we get to piece together and fill in gaps in the history with Issy. I think the pace of the story is just right, it moved with enough speed that I just kept telling myself that I'd read just one more chapter before sleeping/cleaning etc and I'd find myself 4 chapters later caught up in what was happening. I really enjoyed the writing style of it too and I definitely think I need to go read more by the author, she's brought the period and the characters right off the page for me, it's been a fantastic read.
February 6, 2024
Isabella Lacey and her daughter, Emily, are beginning a new chapter with Isabella’s aunt in her home, Crestwell Hall. The home once belonged to Isabella’s Uncle Phillip who believed that the Hall had a connection with the famous Gunpowder Plot. During renovations of the Hall, and Phillip’s hoarding collections, Isabella discovers a bible that alleged belonged to Bess Throckmorton, or Lady Walter Raleigh. Bess’s bible is also her diary and shows a new version of the Plot as told by the women.
When Emily is suddenly in danger, Isabella feels a connection with Bess that transcends all of time. And how one woman could possibly save them all.
I loved this novel, not just for the plot, characters, and overall story, but the obvious in-depth research. However, the research didn’t just extend to the immediate characters. The author researched all of the members of the Gunpowder Plot, the royal family, architecture, Shakespeare and his literature, and other literature that was inspired by the Plot. It made me want to go out and find an autobiography of Elizabeth “Bess” Throckmorton, Walter Raleigh, the Plot, and so many other topics. There were many things that I did not know about.
Each character was a strong, compassionate female with such motivations to save their families as well as themselves. Never did any of the woman, Isabella, Thalia, Bess, or young Emily, make the reader feel like women were insignificant. Quite the opposite, the author wrote these characters giving the reader the feeling of taking on the world. Thalia, though, was by far my favorite character, and I would love the author to create a secondary story but with Thalia as the main character. I loved her storybook energy, and her resilience. I just really loved this novel overall.
Overall, I rate this novel 5 out of 5 stars.
When Emily is suddenly in danger, Isabella feels a connection with Bess that transcends all of time. And how one woman could possibly save them all.
I loved this novel, not just for the plot, characters, and overall story, but the obvious in-depth research. However, the research didn’t just extend to the immediate characters. The author researched all of the members of the Gunpowder Plot, the royal family, architecture, Shakespeare and his literature, and other literature that was inspired by the Plot. It made me want to go out and find an autobiography of Elizabeth “Bess” Throckmorton, Walter Raleigh, the Plot, and so many other topics. There were many things that I did not know about.
Each character was a strong, compassionate female with such motivations to save their families as well as themselves. Never did any of the woman, Isabella, Thalia, Bess, or young Emily, make the reader feel like women were insignificant. Quite the opposite, the author wrote these characters giving the reader the feeling of taking on the world. Thalia, though, was by far my favorite character, and I would love the author to create a secondary story but with Thalia as the main character. I loved her storybook energy, and her resilience. I just really loved this novel overall.
Overall, I rate this novel 5 out of 5 stars.
July 3, 2025
For starters, this was a great idea for a historical fiction novel. As it was, I went in blind, but had I known what the story was going to be about, I would absolutely have been on board.
But oh boy, did I have some issues with the execution.
First of all, the exposition is so very, very clunky, especially in the historical timeline. A lot of it is done in dialogue, and not at all done well. Frankly, I cringed quite a bit and thought the attempts were really quite painful. There was some of that in the contemporary timeline too, but not nearly as much, which makes sense, as not as much would need explaining.
There is also a lot of repetition. Because obviously we readers will have forgotten something explained 20 pages ago, so will need it explaining again. And maybe another time or two for good measure. That got a little tedious after a while!
There is a 10-y-o that often talks like an adult and knows random stuff like what a butter churn looks like but was narrated like a 5-y-o (in fact, there were a few really bizarre choices made by the audio narrator in terms of voices for characters. Not much of a fan overall!)
I mean, this wasn’t awful, but honestly seemed more like a rough draft that needed going over to iron out issues like awkward exposition before it was ready to publish.
But oh boy, did I have some issues with the execution.
First of all, the exposition is so very, very clunky, especially in the historical timeline. A lot of it is done in dialogue, and not at all done well. Frankly, I cringed quite a bit and thought the attempts were really quite painful. There was some of that in the contemporary timeline too, but not nearly as much, which makes sense, as not as much would need explaining.
There is also a lot of repetition. Because obviously we readers will have forgotten something explained 20 pages ago, so will need it explaining again. And maybe another time or two for good measure. That got a little tedious after a while!
There is a 10-y-o that often talks like an adult and knows random stuff like what a butter churn looks like but was narrated like a 5-y-o (in fact, there were a few really bizarre choices made by the audio narrator in terms of voices for characters. Not much of a fan overall!)
I mean, this wasn’t awful, but honestly seemed more like a rough draft that needed going over to iron out issues like awkward exposition before it was ready to publish.
January 25, 2024
The Broken Vow was an intriguing story set during WWI
The story opens with widowed Rosamunde Fitznorton awaiting the birth of her child in the Dower House of Plas Norton her deceased husband’s estate. Meanwhile her estranged step-daughter Charlotte is in London reluctantly assisting in the war effort while awaiting word of her fiance Eustace and missing all the fun parties and shopping from before the war. Charlotte stands to lose her inheritence if the baby Rosamunde is expecting is a boy. While awaiting the resolution of her inheritence, Charlotte decides to turn Plas Norton into a rehabilitation hospital for her fiance and other soldiers decimated by the War. Tragedy strikes for Rosamunde, and Charlotte is left with the custody of her infant sister and the duty of keeping her familly and estate together through the depravations of war.
I really enjoyed this book. Charlotte starts off as an unlikeable spoiled young girl, but shows real grit and resilience through the trials and tribulations she faces. She experiences real growth by the end of the novel and I found myself rooting for her.
Thanks to Netgalley, Storm Publishing and the author for the chance to read and review this book.
The story opens with widowed Rosamunde Fitznorton awaiting the birth of her child in the Dower House of Plas Norton her deceased husband’s estate. Meanwhile her estranged step-daughter Charlotte is in London reluctantly assisting in the war effort while awaiting word of her fiance Eustace and missing all the fun parties and shopping from before the war. Charlotte stands to lose her inheritence if the baby Rosamunde is expecting is a boy. While awaiting the resolution of her inheritence, Charlotte decides to turn Plas Norton into a rehabilitation hospital for her fiance and other soldiers decimated by the War. Tragedy strikes for Rosamunde, and Charlotte is left with the custody of her infant sister and the duty of keeping her familly and estate together through the depravations of war.
I really enjoyed this book. Charlotte starts off as an unlikeable spoiled young girl, but shows real grit and resilience through the trials and tribulations she faces. She experiences real growth by the end of the novel and I found myself rooting for her.
Thanks to Netgalley, Storm Publishing and the author for the chance to read and review this book.
January 29, 2024
The Secrets of Crestwell Hall has all the hallmarks of an Alexandra Walsh story – strong women, a secret twist to a well-known piece of history, and a modern journey of growth and discovery.
I was especially excited to find out that the story features Bess Throckmorton, Queen Elizabeth I’s former lady-in-waiting, and wife to Sir Walter Raleigh. She’s a figure from the Tudor era that I’ve always wanted to read more historical fiction about.
The link between the past and the present is Crestwell Hall, where in the past, Bess retreated to, and in the present, is inhabited by Thalia, Thalia’s niece Isabella, and Isabella’s young daughter, Emily. The discovery of Bess’ bible/diary is the link between the women that spans centuries.
As with her previous books, Walsh makes history come alive with vivid descriptions, strong emotions, and realistic friendships and relationships, especially between her women characters. And while I know I’m reading a fictional version of history, it is so well-written and researched that it never feels false. Her stories are intriguing and absorbing and Walsh has created another wonderful cast of characters that bring the story (and history) to life.
*** Thank you to Rachel’s Random Resources blog tours and the publisher, Boldwood Books, for providing me with an e-copy of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.
I was especially excited to find out that the story features Bess Throckmorton, Queen Elizabeth I’s former lady-in-waiting, and wife to Sir Walter Raleigh. She’s a figure from the Tudor era that I’ve always wanted to read more historical fiction about.
The link between the past and the present is Crestwell Hall, where in the past, Bess retreated to, and in the present, is inhabited by Thalia, Thalia’s niece Isabella, and Isabella’s young daughter, Emily. The discovery of Bess’ bible/diary is the link between the women that spans centuries.
As with her previous books, Walsh makes history come alive with vivid descriptions, strong emotions, and realistic friendships and relationships, especially between her women characters. And while I know I’m reading a fictional version of history, it is so well-written and researched that it never feels false. Her stories are intriguing and absorbing and Walsh has created another wonderful cast of characters that bring the story (and history) to life.
*** Thank you to Rachel’s Random Resources blog tours and the publisher, Boldwood Books, for providing me with an e-copy of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.
December 11, 2023
What a good book! I could hardly put it down.
I loooove secrets. It's what kept me turning the pages, especially the history of the different Bibles that Isabella found. Imagine! That'd be cool to find!
Crestwell Hall is an amazing home in itself. I love the history behind it.
I enjoyed meeting Isabella's friends. They seem like a great group of ladies.
I don't trust Keith a whole lot. Seems kind of sneaky to me.
I loved Bess's story the most. She seemed like a great person to know.
And a smart woman too.
There's a little bit of everything that this new to me author has included to make an awesome adventure/rollercoaster ride! I didn't want this story to end.
The cover and title of this book grabbed me and from the first page I was totally invested.
What an awesome read! So glad I picked this up.
I highly recommend 5 stars for some excellent research and writing.
I'll be thinking about these characters for a long time to come.
My thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books publishing for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
I loooove secrets. It's what kept me turning the pages, especially the history of the different Bibles that Isabella found. Imagine! That'd be cool to find!
Crestwell Hall is an amazing home in itself. I love the history behind it.
I enjoyed meeting Isabella's friends. They seem like a great group of ladies.
I don't trust Keith a whole lot. Seems kind of sneaky to me.
I loved Bess's story the most. She seemed like a great person to know.
And a smart woman too.
There's a little bit of everything that this new to me author has included to make an awesome adventure/rollercoaster ride! I didn't want this story to end.
The cover and title of this book grabbed me and from the first page I was totally invested.
What an awesome read! So glad I picked this up.
I highly recommend 5 stars for some excellent research and writing.
I'll be thinking about these characters for a long time to come.
My thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books publishing for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
February 24, 2024
I've enjoyed reading the new dual timeline novel, The Secrets of Crestwell Hall, by Alexandra Walsh, which switches between the present day and events leading up to the 1605 Gunpowder Plot.
The suspense simmers as we get to know the likeable central characters, Isabella Lacey, her ten-year-old daughter, Emily, her Aunt Thalia - and the enigmatic Lady Elizabeth Raleigh.
I'm always fascinated when new Tudor primary sources turn up, such as the 2023 discovery of a jewelled fifteenth-century prayer book in Trinity College Library depicted by Holbein in his portrait of Thomas Cromwell. I was therefore hooked as Isabella searched the dark corners of Crestwell Hall for lost Elizabethan relics.
I particularly liked the focus on the wives and female relatives of the Catholic 'Gunpowder Plotters', and their different point of view of the planned revolution.
There is a genuine 'well, I wasn't expecting that!' twist in the final chapter, which brings together several stands that kept me guessing. I highly recommend The Secrets of Crestwell Hall, which I'm happy to award five out of five stars.
Tony Riches
The suspense simmers as we get to know the likeable central characters, Isabella Lacey, her ten-year-old daughter, Emily, her Aunt Thalia - and the enigmatic Lady Elizabeth Raleigh.
I'm always fascinated when new Tudor primary sources turn up, such as the 2023 discovery of a jewelled fifteenth-century prayer book in Trinity College Library depicted by Holbein in his portrait of Thomas Cromwell. I was therefore hooked as Isabella searched the dark corners of Crestwell Hall for lost Elizabethan relics.
I particularly liked the focus on the wives and female relatives of the Catholic 'Gunpowder Plotters', and their different point of view of the planned revolution.
There is a genuine 'well, I wasn't expecting that!' twist in the final chapter, which brings together several stands that kept me guessing. I highly recommend The Secrets of Crestwell Hall, which I'm happy to award five out of five stars.
Tony Riches
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews