This book definitely had its ups and downs for me. “Throwback” is the latest book by Maurene Goo. Sam, an overly privileged Gen-Z high school kid has a mom that wants things she considers to be old-fashioned if not downright archaic, ie membership in a country club. They rarely see eye to eye. After a huge fight, Sam is transported back in time by a magical rideshare and given a chance to help her teenage mom win homecoming queen. If her mom doesn’t win, she won’t get to go back to her own time.
Let me start with the positives about this book, the things I definitely enjoyed. I did in fact grow up in the L.A. and Orange County area throughout the late 90s and early 2000s, so a lot of the things that were being described I can definitely verify are true. A line in the book hit the nail on the head for instance when it comes to rainy day traffic in L.A/OC (“You forget how to drive. What is driving? Water is touching my car!”). So I did find it relatable. Ms. Goo’s humor from her last book is definitely in tact as well, and I did find myself laughing quite a bit at various lines. (“No I have never partaken – partook? – in such wonders.”)
I found myself agreeing with some of Sam’s views on things, ie women having to worry about their size and weight, or children having to have their life paths planned at the age of 18. I also enjoyed the many sweet relationships she has with members of her family like her grandmother, and eventually, her teenage mom. Seeing her forge those bonds, learn about herself, grow as a person and character were enjoyable. I would say I found probably from about the halfway mark on to the end extremely enjoyable.
The first half of the book wasn’t as enjoyable for me, and that leads into the negatives of this book. I realize that the main character is a Gen Z high school kid, and very “woke”. (She refers to herself by this term.) She sees everything through this lens, including when she time travels back to the 1990s. She tends to refer to most characters by their race and has some viewpoints that can come across as preachy at times, or downright prejudice. An example is that when she learns her mother – Priscilla - hangs out with white friends and dates a white guy, Sam is completely taken aback. She doesn’t understand why she isn’t part of an Asian group, referring to them as “her community” and making it sound as if her mom should only associate with Asians. She also seems to come across as having an overall disdain for white people in general. This whole viewpoint is off-putting in real life, and when the character was behaving this way, I found the book off-putting as well.
Now to be fair, Priscilla DOES come in and adjust Sam’s attitude on this particular viewpoint. She calls out her daughter for being presumptuous and judgmental, and Sam does learn to somewhat get over this point of view by the end of the book. Before this attitude adjustment, it was a bit hard for me to wade through all the Gen Z rhetoric and it wasn’t enjoyable and didn’t make for a character I could really relate to, like and root for. The other thing I noticed was that unlike its predecessor, “Somewhere Only We Know,” this book has a lot of strong language. I do understand that this is the way kids this age talk, but I still wouldn’t feel comfortable giving the book to kids in middle grade or very young teenagers. Final negative is the few typos and grammatical errors I noticed, but that’s just a note for anyone as fixated on those things as I am.
Overall, if you can get through the first half of the book when Sam is a bit insufferable, I think you will enjoy the story. Solid 3.5 stars. Thank you so much to Edelweiss+, Ingram Publisher Services and Zando Young Readers for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.