What do you think?
Rate this book
Children of the Earth: A Mothmar Novel
Receive from above or take from below, Light versus Dark, you reap what you sow.
With her newly acquired Gift burning inside her, Solyana Marusda leads her group through the Mothmar snow in search of the prophecy's secrets. But when they stumble upon the city of Takanah, they find themselves surrounded by the Taka Reu and all it threatens to unleash. Desperate for answers, Solyana finds herself on a path paved with the sacrifices of others-sacrifices that make her wonder whether she is the savior or the destruction of her people.
In the wake of carnage, nearly everything Pallah Bogson holds dear has slipped through her fingers. With a rumor of hope, she sets out in search of the truth that promises a place of belonging. But as her connection to the Mother Below grows, so too does the influence of forces beyond her control-and when Pallah finds herself the instrument of chaos, there is no way of telling what is or isn't her own will.
All the while, someone is watching, waiting-with more sinister schemes than either girl can know.
A story of friendship, family, and the choices that shape us. Dive into the world of Mothmar and experience magic, animal companionship, and adventure layered through time and dipped in mystery.
With her newly acquired Gift burning inside her, Solyana Marusda leads her group through the Mothmar snow in search of the prophecy's secrets. But when they stumble upon the city of Takanah, they find themselves surrounded by the Taka Reu and all it threatens to unleash. Desperate for answers, Solyana finds herself on a path paved with the sacrifices of others-sacrifices that make her wonder whether she is the savior or the destruction of her people.
In the wake of carnage, nearly everything Pallah Bogson holds dear has slipped through her fingers. With a rumor of hope, she sets out in search of the truth that promises a place of belonging. But as her connection to the Mother Below grows, so too does the influence of forces beyond her control-and when Pallah finds herself the instrument of chaos, there is no way of telling what is or isn't her own will.
All the while, someone is watching, waiting-with more sinister schemes than either girl can know.
A story of friendship, family, and the choices that shape us. Dive into the world of Mothmar and experience magic, animal companionship, and adventure layered through time and dipped in mystery.
- GenresFantasyYoung Adult
410 pages, Hardcover
Published November 7, 2023
6 people are currently reading
369 people want to read
About the author
Amanda Auler
7 books208 followersAmanda Auler lives in Sanford, North Carolina with her husband and four growing boys. Though Amanda writes for every audience, her roots in Christianity shine through her work as she explores themes of redemption, forgiveness, and grace. When she's not writing you can find her baking cookies, drinking too much coffee, and staying up past her bedtime to watch anime with her husband.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 103 reviews
October 5, 2024
This is what YA fantasy should be.
May 17, 2024
3.5⭐️
I am trying to decide between 3-stars “I liked it” and 4-stars “I loved it”.🤔 I didn’t find it as engaging as the first book, I think, because it is significantly darker. I don’t mind darkness in books at all, but there weren’t many bright spots at all, so it felt very heavy.
However, as middle-books go, I thought it was well-done. *And* I anticipate a brighter future for at least one of our MCs, if not both, in the last book.
3.5⭐️ rounded down, whereas the first book, I rounded up.😌
I am trying to decide between 3-stars “I liked it” and 4-stars “I loved it”.🤔 I didn’t find it as engaging as the first book, I think, because it is significantly darker. I don’t mind darkness in books at all, but there weren’t many bright spots at all, so it felt very heavy.
However, as middle-books go, I thought it was well-done. *And* I anticipate a brighter future for at least one of our MCs, if not both, in the last book.
3.5⭐️ rounded down, whereas the first book, I rounded up.😌
August 31, 2023
✨ENDORSEMENT✨
Children of the Earth is a marvelous sequel to a unique, masterfully written debut. Struggling among an unforgiving landscape and navigating the trials of young adulthood, Pallah’s and Solyana’s destinies are laid bare. Questions are asked and hearts are broken, but through it all, Auler creates both a villain to love and a hero to follow.
Children of the Earth is a marvelous sequel to a unique, masterfully written debut. Struggling among an unforgiving landscape and navigating the trials of young adulthood, Pallah’s and Solyana’s destinies are laid bare. Questions are asked and hearts are broken, but through it all, Auler creates both a villain to love and a hero to follow.
August 18, 2023
If the first book didn't leave you wanting more of Mothmar, this book will!
In my review of DOTS, I had praised Auler's worldbuilding, and COTE only got better. More characters, more diverse settings, more animals, more romance, more magic, more relationships, more heartbreak, more betrayal... and more cliffhangers.🫠
I think DOTS will remain my favourite of the two, just because of the darker content in COTE, but I'm looking forward to book 3, because there is still so much hope for Solyana and the people of Mothmar!
Not only is the story engaging and exciting, the writing is beautiful, well-paced, and unexpected.
The characters are imperfect and believable, even the heroes. Their frustration of not knowing what the right path is, making choices and facing the consequences of their decisions... And seeing how villains become who they are, making you sympathetic and hopeful they will choose the right path in the end...
I feel like I have so much more to say but I don't want this review to contain spoilers.
I have MANY theories so if/when you read this and you want to talk theories, feel free to message me!!
4.5 stars rounded up.
I received a free eARC in exchange for an honest review.
In my review of DOTS, I had praised Auler's worldbuilding, and COTE only got better. More characters, more diverse settings, more animals, more romance, more magic, more relationships, more heartbreak, more betrayal... and more cliffhangers.🫠
I think DOTS will remain my favourite of the two, just because of the darker content in COTE, but I'm looking forward to book 3, because there is still so much hope for Solyana and the people of Mothmar!
Not only is the story engaging and exciting, the writing is beautiful, well-paced, and unexpected.
The characters are imperfect and believable, even the heroes. Their frustration of not knowing what the right path is, making choices and facing the consequences of their decisions... And seeing how villains become who they are, making you sympathetic and hopeful they will choose the right path in the end...
I feel like I have so much more to say but I don't want this review to contain spoilers.
I have MANY theories so if/when you read this and you want to talk theories, feel free to message me!!
4.5 stars rounded up.
I received a free eARC in exchange for an honest review.
June 12, 2023
Did I read it in a day? Yes.
This book was so stinking good. If you love Avatar and Game of Thrones but want darker themes and twisty fantasy with a moral compass still intact, try this series out! Book 2 absolutely did not disappoint.
This book was so stinking good. If you love Avatar and Game of Thrones but want darker themes and twisty fantasy with a moral compass still intact, try this series out! Book 2 absolutely did not disappoint.
November 8, 2023
I rounded up from 4.5 stars.
What a sequel! Auler's craft has only improved since book one, and the emotional depth she gives her characters is spot-on; they feel real, make mistakes, and are faced with complex problems and choices.
From the additional POV to the lovable side characters to the twists that always seemed to surprise me, I think I loved this book even more than Daughter of the Sun.
This book is significantly darker than book one, but the themes of hope are strong through it all. I'd recommend this series to an older teen audience and up.
⚠️ Semi-graphic violence, blood, death, abuse, manipulation, injury
🌶 A slow-burn relationship that doesn't go further than brief kissing
What a sequel! Auler's craft has only improved since book one, and the emotional depth she gives her characters is spot-on; they feel real, make mistakes, and are faced with complex problems and choices.
From the additional POV to the lovable side characters to the twists that always seemed to surprise me, I think I loved this book even more than Daughter of the Sun.
This book is significantly darker than book one, but the themes of hope are strong through it all. I'd recommend this series to an older teen audience and up.
⚠️ Semi-graphic violence, blood, death, abuse, manipulation, injury
🌶 A slow-burn relationship that doesn't go further than brief kissing
November 14, 2023
wow.
review brewing
need extra stars.
--- update:
Content Rating: Teen +
Reading Level: Young Adult
Genres: Fantasy - High Fantasy
Themes: Prophecy - Intrusive Thoughts - Good vs Evil
Spice Level: 1 (Light Kissing/Slow Burn)
Pace: Medium
Recommend?: 1000%
Amanda never ceases to amaze me with her writing, which flows so effortlessly. This sequel was everything and more! Especially since I tend to lean towards villains, and these ones are so gooood. Dahvid actually gives me nightmares and Erval is the embodiment of an intrusive thought -- he's def my fave. And, as it should, it built upon the first book in such an epic way! I thought I was obsessed with DOTS, but then this released!
I cannot wait for the next in the series. I loved the new POV and I really enjoyed all the world-building presented in this sequel. Don't sleep on this series!
review brewing
need extra stars.
--- update:
Content Rating: Teen +
Reading Level: Young Adult
Genres: Fantasy - High Fantasy
Themes: Prophecy - Intrusive Thoughts - Good vs Evil
Spice Level: 1 (Light Kissing/Slow Burn)
Pace: Medium
Recommend?: 1000%
Amanda never ceases to amaze me with her writing, which flows so effortlessly. This sequel was everything and more! Especially since I tend to lean towards villains, and these ones are so gooood. Dahvid actually gives me nightmares and Erval is the embodiment of an intrusive thought -- he's def my fave. And, as it should, it built upon the first book in such an epic way! I thought I was obsessed with DOTS, but then this released!
I cannot wait for the next in the series. I loved the new POV and I really enjoyed all the world-building presented in this sequel. Don't sleep on this series!
December 2, 2024
A fantastical & enthralling read! Auler has built a rich world filled with powerful characters, and I can’t wait for the final book in this trilogy. Highly recommend!😍
November 28, 2023
I really enjoyed the continuation of this series. So often the second book lets you down, and this one did not! It had a faster pace than the first book (which I liked), but Auler didn't let that take away from her beautiful prose either. The descriptions were vivid, the motivations and emotions of the characters clear, and the storyline took me on the wild ride I fully expected! 😂
In DOTS, Solyana was my clear favorite POV. However, in COTE, Pallah took over for me! Don't get me wrong, I was still highly invested in what was going on with Sol, but Pallah's story gripped me and I had to know what was going to happen! I love the way their dual timelines reveal the answers to you slowly. It's such a unique premise and it really keeps me engaged! Can't wait to find out what happens in book three!
In DOTS, Solyana was my clear favorite POV. However, in COTE, Pallah took over for me! Don't get me wrong, I was still highly invested in what was going on with Sol, but Pallah's story gripped me and I had to know what was going to happen! I love the way their dual timelines reveal the answers to you slowly. It's such a unique premise and it really keeps me engaged! Can't wait to find out what happens in book three!
November 14, 2023
Another home run for Amanda! Even better than the first one! You are a real success at leaving the reader chomping at the bit for the next one!! I got nothing done at home until I finished this one!
October 11, 2023
There really was no good place to set this book down - and that's a good thing. I never wanted to quit "flipping" the pages of my e-reader.
Initially it was a bit difficult to recall a lot of the details of book 1, but that dissipated pretty quickly as the story moved forward. A quick refresher before picking this one up could have been good, but I managed just fine without doing that. CotE really did answer a lot of questions I had from DotS, yet left so much more to ponder for book 3. And, just to be clear, I need the third one YESTERDAY.
Auler doesn't shy away from darker topics and subject matter, which does make this an edge-of-the-seat kind of read, but sometimes quite heavy. I appreciated the moments of humor (stay spicy!) and beauty that are peppered throughout. I definitely think this fits best for an older young adult audience.
I can't wait to see how she wraps all of this up in book three. I will say this: I am absolutely desperate for the Light and Truth and Resolution to shine through into these character's lives.
Initially it was a bit difficult to recall a lot of the details of book 1, but that dissipated pretty quickly as the story moved forward. A quick refresher before picking this one up could have been good, but I managed just fine without doing that. CotE really did answer a lot of questions I had from DotS, yet left so much more to ponder for book 3. And, just to be clear, I need the third one YESTERDAY.
Auler doesn't shy away from darker topics and subject matter, which does make this an edge-of-the-seat kind of read, but sometimes quite heavy. I appreciated the moments of humor (stay spicy!) and beauty that are peppered throughout. I definitely think this fits best for an older young adult audience.
I can't wait to see how she wraps all of this up in book three. I will say this: I am absolutely desperate for the Light and Truth and Resolution to shine through into these character's lives.
November 7, 2023
If I could give this book more than 5 stars I would. I didn’t think it would be possible to love this book more than the first book, Daughter of the Sun, but here we are.
Bringing a unique take on fantasy without being confusing, Children of the Earth by Amanda Auler is steeped in captivating mystery, riveting adventure, and even political intrigue (which surprised me but I’m here for it). In this mouth watering second helping of Mothmar, we see the world Auler has created get bigger and more stunning. Get ready for dazzling imagery and fantastical creatures, some lovable and some terrifying.
I was thrilled to dive deeper into the characters’ stories, hopeful that more connections would be made and motivations would be revealed. I wasn’t disappointed. Auler manages to craft characters that are relatable despite living in a fantastical world. Their stories become darker and twistier, more intertwined than I could have imagined. Pallah’s journey in particular is gut-wrenching and incredibly dark. Despite everything revealed in this book, I still have hope for her. Hope for a girl who was dealt a rotten hand and has had to endure more than her fair share of life’s darkness.
The ending had me in tears. I have never read such a hopeful cliffhanger. I cannot wait to read the 3rd book in this series!
I was thankful to receive an advanced copy of this book. It becomes available to purchase on November 7 and I highly recommend it!
Bringing a unique take on fantasy without being confusing, Children of the Earth by Amanda Auler is steeped in captivating mystery, riveting adventure, and even political intrigue (which surprised me but I’m here for it). In this mouth watering second helping of Mothmar, we see the world Auler has created get bigger and more stunning. Get ready for dazzling imagery and fantastical creatures, some lovable and some terrifying.
I was thrilled to dive deeper into the characters’ stories, hopeful that more connections would be made and motivations would be revealed. I wasn’t disappointed. Auler manages to craft characters that are relatable despite living in a fantastical world. Their stories become darker and twistier, more intertwined than I could have imagined. Pallah’s journey in particular is gut-wrenching and incredibly dark. Despite everything revealed in this book, I still have hope for her. Hope for a girl who was dealt a rotten hand and has had to endure more than her fair share of life’s darkness.
The ending had me in tears. I have never read such a hopeful cliffhanger. I cannot wait to read the 3rd book in this series!
I was thankful to receive an advanced copy of this book. It becomes available to purchase on November 7 and I highly recommend it!
August 24, 2023
Thank you, Amanda, for the advance read. A thrilling follow-up to book 1, Auler does it again!
Children of the Earth builds on the world of Daughter of the Sun by thickening the plot, stirring up the motivations for her characters, and introducing enchanting creatures, complex characters, and fantastical settings. The series is bursting with creativity and imagination (who doesn't want a Sabretooth tiger pet that's connected to your mind?). Young adults will fall into the evolving world of Monthmar and get swept up with the magical animals and elemental powers. Adults will appreciate the character development and hero journey that spends a lot of time in the gray zone (plot twists, new perspectives, very relatable internal and existential conflict; there is no simple binary choice between good vs. evil).
Much like Two Towers is the best of the LOTR trilogy, I was excited to find COE to be not only a great Sophomore novel, but perhaps even better than the first (no pressure for book 3!).
Children of the Earth builds on the world of Daughter of the Sun by thickening the plot, stirring up the motivations for her characters, and introducing enchanting creatures, complex characters, and fantastical settings. The series is bursting with creativity and imagination (who doesn't want a Sabretooth tiger pet that's connected to your mind?). Young adults will fall into the evolving world of Monthmar and get swept up with the magical animals and elemental powers. Adults will appreciate the character development and hero journey that spends a lot of time in the gray zone (plot twists, new perspectives, very relatable internal and existential conflict; there is no simple binary choice between good vs. evil).
Much like Two Towers is the best of the LOTR trilogy, I was excited to find COE to be not only a great Sophomore novel, but perhaps even better than the first (no pressure for book 3!).
April 30, 2024
I enjoyed the first book but the second one really blew it out of the water!! The world got broader, the characters got deeper, and the twist got even more exciting.
Amanda does such a good job of breaking her characters in the best way. Their pain feels real, which makes them very relatable. I wanted to keep turning the pages because the stakes were high and the plot had me on the edge of my seat. Nice job Amanda - ALL THE STARS!!
Amanda does such a good job of breaking her characters in the best way. Their pain feels real, which makes them very relatable. I wanted to keep turning the pages because the stakes were high and the plot had me on the edge of my seat. Nice job Amanda - ALL THE STARS!!
November 7, 2023
I love Amanda Auler and the Mothmar world she has created so much!
This story is ever changing and challenging not only for her characters but for me as a reader. The themes set in this fantasy world are so relevant and applicable to real life - a reading experience I’ve never had with fantasy before reading Children of the Earth.
Everything about this series draws you in to keep reading and I can’t wait for the next book 🤩
This story is ever changing and challenging not only for her characters but for me as a reader. The themes set in this fantasy world are so relevant and applicable to real life - a reading experience I’ve never had with fantasy before reading Children of the Earth.
Everything about this series draws you in to keep reading and I can’t wait for the next book 🤩
May 24, 2024
SO GOOD! Even better than the first book! The world expands so much in this one and I really felt transported into the world while reading!
November 4, 2023
Warning! This book is the 2nd in a trilogy! Spoilers ahead for book 1! If you haven't read Daughter of the Sun yet, go read it first!
All caught up? Great, let's go!
...
THAT CLIFFHANGER. I'm LOSING. my MIND.
*ahem*
I have a new favorite series to inflict all my hapless followers, friends, and family, and I'm only a little furious I have to wait so long for the next book in this series because it ends on a cliffhanger and I nearly threw my phone across the room when I realized That was the last page. I won't be discussion spoilers for COTE in this review, except to warn you that your heart will be broken. Amanda Auler gave me an ebook copy and this is my voluntary unbiased review.
In Daughter of the Sun, I fell in love with the characters of Solyana and Pallah as they both navigated their world as Rána - giftless members of their society where people usually have one of three gifts, bestowed by the Celestial deities. Both girls struggle with their worth to their families, and though both are raised in the villages of Mothmar with most of the same customs, as you read through the book, you realize, their worlds look just a little different. Solyana's Mothmar is ravaged by irregular blizzards and cloud filled skies that prevent them from ever seeing the sun - the Father of the Day. More and more people in her community are born as Rána, and they only have one person left who uses the gift of Heitt: the ability to manipulate heat and fire, which is given by the Father of the Day. That person is the Priestess Avi, who declares her to be the chosen one of prophecy, and sends her on adventure. In Pallah's narrative, we see a world that isn't in an ice age yet - there are still forests and the temple is full of priests and priestesses that practice Heitt, including her mother and sister. She's abused by her father, and joins a group that practices dark gifts, called the Taka Reu, which connect to the Earth, not the Celestials. These hints lead us to realize that Pallah's narrative is taking place in the past, and the end of the book reveals that she's become the Priestess Avi and she's gained the other gifts through accessing the Taka Reu.
I LOVE complex plots and framing sequences, and this decision to simultaneously tell the prequel and the current story is honestly a stroke of genius. I've never seen it before, and yet Auler pulls it off with masterful precision and I'm beyond impressed at the technical skill it takes to make that work so seamlessly. Children of the Earth continues telling Solyana and Pallah's stories side by side, as well as introducing a new POV character.
The knowledge, we gain at the end of DOTS begs the question of how Pallah became the Priestess. How did this angry, powerless, outcast become THE most powerful person in the valley? What ulterior motives does she have? What did she learn in the meantime? We get to see her develop into the cold-hearted elder as she reacts to mistreatment and pain. While her actions become terrifying, manipulative, and violent, we never once loose sympathy and understanding for why she's choosing this path, and that's an impressive balance to strike. This book answers more of those questions, but we still don't have the whole story and I'm so curious to read the rest of her evolution in the third book.
Before she leaves on her journey, Priestess Avi reveals her secret of the Taka Reu to Solyaha. This throws shadows of doubt over every decision that Solyana makes in this book, and combined with the out of character knowledge that the prophecy is wrong, it creates a building sense of dread and higher stakes. As she travels through Greater Mothmar, she grapples with the terrifying realities of life being so much bigger and more dangerous than she knew and the worldbuilding becomes so much more expansive and interesting. I already loved her character and watching her navigate her inner struggles and punishing external conditions, made me admire her strength of character, however misguided she might become. She's doing her best to save her people and her sister, despite not having all the information she needs, and it's heartbreaking to watch her stumble through these expectations. It's also beautiful to watch how her friends: Gamaliel, Jonas, and Lone, all work together to support her throughout the quest. I love their little found family group so much.
I've mentioned the worldbuilding a few times now and this book takes everything we knew about Mothmar and the magic system and breaks it wide open. We learn so much more about the Taka Reu and how messed up it can be (imagine ATLA if it weren't for kids), we see different versions of the religious orders, new cults, and travel to a bunch of new cities. I love getting to see a world that I love expand its edges and it feels like such a real place. Before I called it "mythological and epic in proportions" and it's only doubled down on that. I also admire how Auler is able to weave in the Christian themes of temptation and sin with the Taka Reu - it seems so appealing at first, and its used with all the good intentions in the world, but after time passes, it takes root and festers and rots. It never feels preachy, but it does feel like a very real spiritual and physical danger that the characters must avoid. Her craft is masterful and I admire her ability to weave these ideas into the character's arcs so authentically.
In conclusion, I'm ridiculously impatient for the third book in this series to come out and in the meantime I'm going to be yelling at everyone I know. Go read the Mothmar Trilogy. It's at the top of my list for favorite books I've read this year, and my favorite fantasy overall.
All caught up? Great, let's go!
...
THAT CLIFFHANGER. I'm LOSING. my MIND.
*ahem*
I have a new favorite series to inflict all my hapless followers, friends, and family, and I'm only a little furious I have to wait so long for the next book in this series because it ends on a cliffhanger and I nearly threw my phone across the room when I realized That was the last page. I won't be discussion spoilers for COTE in this review, except to warn you that your heart will be broken. Amanda Auler gave me an ebook copy and this is my voluntary unbiased review.
In Daughter of the Sun, I fell in love with the characters of Solyana and Pallah as they both navigated their world as Rána - giftless members of their society where people usually have one of three gifts, bestowed by the Celestial deities. Both girls struggle with their worth to their families, and though both are raised in the villages of Mothmar with most of the same customs, as you read through the book, you realize, their worlds look just a little different. Solyana's Mothmar is ravaged by irregular blizzards and cloud filled skies that prevent them from ever seeing the sun - the Father of the Day. More and more people in her community are born as Rána, and they only have one person left who uses the gift of Heitt: the ability to manipulate heat and fire, which is given by the Father of the Day. That person is the Priestess Avi, who declares her to be the chosen one of prophecy, and sends her on adventure. In Pallah's narrative, we see a world that isn't in an ice age yet - there are still forests and the temple is full of priests and priestesses that practice Heitt, including her mother and sister. She's abused by her father, and joins a group that practices dark gifts, called the Taka Reu, which connect to the Earth, not the Celestials. These hints lead us to realize that Pallah's narrative is taking place in the past, and the end of the book reveals that she's become the Priestess Avi and she's gained the other gifts through accessing the Taka Reu.
I LOVE complex plots and framing sequences, and this decision to simultaneously tell the prequel and the current story is honestly a stroke of genius. I've never seen it before, and yet Auler pulls it off with masterful precision and I'm beyond impressed at the technical skill it takes to make that work so seamlessly. Children of the Earth continues telling Solyana and Pallah's stories side by side, as well as introducing a new POV character.
The knowledge, we gain at the end of DOTS begs the question of how Pallah became the Priestess. How did this angry, powerless, outcast become THE most powerful person in the valley? What ulterior motives does she have? What did she learn in the meantime? We get to see her develop into the cold-hearted elder as she reacts to mistreatment and pain. While her actions become terrifying, manipulative, and violent, we never once loose sympathy and understanding for why she's choosing this path, and that's an impressive balance to strike. This book answers more of those questions, but we still don't have the whole story and I'm so curious to read the rest of her evolution in the third book.
Before she leaves on her journey, Priestess Avi reveals her secret of the Taka Reu to Solyaha. This throws shadows of doubt over every decision that Solyana makes in this book, and combined with the out of character knowledge that the prophecy is wrong, it creates a building sense of dread and higher stakes. As she travels through Greater Mothmar, she grapples with the terrifying realities of life being so much bigger and more dangerous than she knew and the worldbuilding becomes so much more expansive and interesting. I already loved her character and watching her navigate her inner struggles and punishing external conditions, made me admire her strength of character, however misguided she might become. She's doing her best to save her people and her sister, despite not having all the information she needs, and it's heartbreaking to watch her stumble through these expectations. It's also beautiful to watch how her friends: Gamaliel, Jonas, and Lone, all work together to support her throughout the quest. I love their little found family group so much.
I've mentioned the worldbuilding a few times now and this book takes everything we knew about Mothmar and the magic system and breaks it wide open. We learn so much more about the Taka Reu and how messed up it can be (imagine ATLA if it weren't for kids), we see different versions of the religious orders, new cults, and travel to a bunch of new cities. I love getting to see a world that I love expand its edges and it feels like such a real place. Before I called it "mythological and epic in proportions" and it's only doubled down on that. I also admire how Auler is able to weave in the Christian themes of temptation and sin with the Taka Reu - it seems so appealing at first, and its used with all the good intentions in the world, but after time passes, it takes root and festers and rots. It never feels preachy, but it does feel like a very real spiritual and physical danger that the characters must avoid. Her craft is masterful and I admire her ability to weave these ideas into the character's arcs so authentically.
In conclusion, I'm ridiculously impatient for the third book in this series to come out and in the meantime I'm going to be yelling at everyone I know. Go read the Mothmar Trilogy. It's at the top of my list for favorite books I've read this year, and my favorite fantasy overall.
November 6, 2023
I’m never quite sure what to expect from a second instalment. It can go any which way, but Children of the Earth is the perfect companion to Amanda Auler’s first book, Daughter of the Sun.
The series has strong Avatar the Last Airbender vibes (you see this in the way Amanda names the books for the “element” each book focuses on, the same way Nickelodeon named each season of Avatar for water, earth, and fire).
The strength of Amanda’s work is her world building and her ability to sympathise with Pallah. I’m typically not a villain sympathiser. I feel like 99.9999999999% of villains “had a way out”.
Pallah Bogson is the first time I’ve ever felt “yep. What you’re doing is messed up, but I see how you came to make those choices.” While Pallah is 100% responsible for her choices, this is the first time those in her life are as equally to blame as Pallah herself.
Without condoning Pallah’s actions, I 100% sympathise and hurt for her. One bit of sincere love from anyone would’ve made the difference in her life. Her tether to Tinloh proves she’s capable of great compassion, love, and nurture. Despite her own hurts, she doesn’t hurt the one creature that shows her a little bit of affection.
Pallah has the soul of a wild creature. After a while, wild creatures that are cornered lash out to protect themselves.
All I want her and Tinloh to find a cosy, warm place somewhere in the wild that they can call their own.
My other favourite element are the animals: the mammoths; smiladon; the wolf; the falcon; the owls. Oh, I loved these creatures SO. And the MAMMOTHS. My goodness.
My only wish is that this could have been 200 pages longer! This isn’t a critique so much as yearning— and I know that this is my very personal preference. I know not every book can be this long. I know not every story has this in it. I believe authors should write the books they want their stories to be! I can easily separate my (cheerful) longing for a lengthier book while cheering on an author doing what they need to do.
But I was the fourteen-year-old kid who ate up chapters like “The Old Forest” and “In the House of Tom Bombadil”. My favourite Harry Potter books are Order of the Phoenix and The Half Blood Prince. Not that I think Amanda’s work should be that lengthy. But when you love a story that much, you don’t want it to end<3
The series has strong Avatar the Last Airbender vibes (you see this in the way Amanda names the books for the “element” each book focuses on, the same way Nickelodeon named each season of Avatar for water, earth, and fire).
The strength of Amanda’s work is her world building and her ability to sympathise with Pallah. I’m typically not a villain sympathiser. I feel like 99.9999999999% of villains “had a way out”.
Pallah Bogson is the first time I’ve ever felt “yep. What you’re doing is messed up, but I see how you came to make those choices.” While Pallah is 100% responsible for her choices, this is the first time those in her life are as equally to blame as Pallah herself.
Without condoning Pallah’s actions, I 100% sympathise and hurt for her. One bit of sincere love from anyone would’ve made the difference in her life. Her tether to Tinloh proves she’s capable of great compassion, love, and nurture. Despite her own hurts, she doesn’t hurt the one creature that shows her a little bit of affection.
Pallah has the soul of a wild creature. After a while, wild creatures that are cornered lash out to protect themselves.
All I want her and Tinloh to find a cosy, warm place somewhere in the wild that they can call their own.
My other favourite element are the animals: the mammoths; smiladon; the wolf; the falcon; the owls. Oh, I loved these creatures SO. And the MAMMOTHS. My goodness.
My only wish is that this could have been 200 pages longer! This isn’t a critique so much as yearning— and I know that this is my very personal preference. I know not every book can be this long. I know not every story has this in it. I believe authors should write the books they want their stories to be! I can easily separate my (cheerful) longing for a lengthier book while cheering on an author doing what they need to do.
But I was the fourteen-year-old kid who ate up chapters like “The Old Forest” and “In the House of Tom Bombadil”. My favourite Harry Potter books are Order of the Phoenix and The Half Blood Prince. Not that I think Amanda’s work should be that lengthy. But when you love a story that much, you don’t want it to end<3
November 7, 2023
“A story of friendship, family, and the choices that shape us.”
Children of the Earth is a continuation of where we left off in the first book of the Mothmar trilogy, Daughter of the Sun. We take a journey further into the world of Mothmar and learn more of the background of some of our main characters and how they are all connected.
There are so many themes that I found woven throughout the story, especially: dark vs. light and the tough choices that determine our path in life.
Though there are multiple points of view to follow, I never got lost. I said it after reading Daughter of the Sun and I’ll say it again now, the world building is fantastic!
If you’re looking for a spicy romance, you’re not going to find it here. What you WILL find are subtle, butterfly inducing moments that will linger with you. There is a scene where my two favorite characters hugged (very PG, that’s all), and I still cannot stop thinking about it.
This is an epic fantasy that is gripping and so unpredictable. I feel blessed to have received an ARC and now can’t believe how long we have to wait to find out what happens after such a cliffhanger ending!
P.S. If you share my love for indie authors, please run and get a copy of this. You won't be disappointed.
Children of the Earth is a continuation of where we left off in the first book of the Mothmar trilogy, Daughter of the Sun. We take a journey further into the world of Mothmar and learn more of the background of some of our main characters and how they are all connected.
There are so many themes that I found woven throughout the story, especially: dark vs. light and the tough choices that determine our path in life.
Though there are multiple points of view to follow, I never got lost. I said it after reading Daughter of the Sun and I’ll say it again now, the world building is fantastic!
If you’re looking for a spicy romance, you’re not going to find it here. What you WILL find are subtle, butterfly inducing moments that will linger with you. There is a scene where my two favorite characters hugged (very PG, that’s all), and I still cannot stop thinking about it.
This is an epic fantasy that is gripping and so unpredictable. I feel blessed to have received an ARC and now can’t believe how long we have to wait to find out what happens after such a cliffhanger ending!
P.S. If you share my love for indie authors, please run and get a copy of this. You won't be disappointed.
June 16, 2023
An absolute thrill ride! Amanda Auler’s book 2 of the Mothmar series is a stunner. With continuous adventure, twists, and a deepening of her world, she crafts an easy to get lost in page turner. The book keeps you gripped and asking for more each chapter.
Also, I cried multiple times in the last few chapters as your connection to the characters makes you feel their joy/pain. Their struggles and triumphs became heart felt. Yes, I may be a bit biased, but this book is an instant classic that I never wanted to end.
So proud - and I cannot wait for more from this epic author!
Also, I cried multiple times in the last few chapters as your connection to the characters makes you feel their joy/pain. Their struggles and triumphs became heart felt. Yes, I may be a bit biased, but this book is an instant classic that I never wanted to end.
So proud - and I cannot wait for more from this epic author!
November 6, 2023
Magical sequel in a brilliant fantasy world!
My favorite new author Amanda Auler does it again with a gripping, thrilling, and imaginative follow-up to her series starter Daughter of the Sun. The world building is warm and thorough without ever becoming tedious. The main characters are interesting and written in such a way that you care about each of them, flaws and all. The light vs dark overtones are purposefully less subtle in this entry and the magical systems are intricate and well thought out. Despite not having much time to read these past few weeks (except for audiobooks while in traffic but the audiobook for this wasn’t available yet) I couldn’t put it down and lamented each time I had to while sneaking in a couple chapters here and there between work and coaching kids football. While this could conceivably be read without having read book 1, I highly recommend working your way through both. Book 1 sets the stage and introduces the players while this book takes the plot and excitement to a whole new level. A more comprehensive review will come later tonight/tomorrow(here and on my FunreliableNarrator socials as well) but I’m so excited I had to post something! Five Stars!
My favorite new author Amanda Auler does it again with a gripping, thrilling, and imaginative follow-up to her series starter Daughter of the Sun. The world building is warm and thorough without ever becoming tedious. The main characters are interesting and written in such a way that you care about each of them, flaws and all. The light vs dark overtones are purposefully less subtle in this entry and the magical systems are intricate and well thought out. Despite not having much time to read these past few weeks (except for audiobooks while in traffic but the audiobook for this wasn’t available yet) I couldn’t put it down and lamented each time I had to while sneaking in a couple chapters here and there between work and coaching kids football. While this could conceivably be read without having read book 1, I highly recommend working your way through both. Book 1 sets the stage and introduces the players while this book takes the plot and excitement to a whole new level. A more comprehensive review will come later tonight/tomorrow(here and on my FunreliableNarrator socials as well) but I’m so excited I had to post something! Five Stars!
October 31, 2023
How Amanda Auler avoided second book syndrome was masterful. The story unfolds exponentially as the two (can we call them protagonists? Our anti-protagonists) navigating a Mothmar bigger than they, or we, have ever experienced before. The humanity that comes through these characters while facing such inhumane circumstances is so relatable and at times really powerful.
Plot: Yes. Just yes. You're never quite sure what will come next, she plants doubt so craftily in your mind you can't trust it. At the end of Daughter of the Sun I saw one more book. At the end of Children of the Earth I'm not sure how she'll wrap it all up in a way I don't expect, which if I've learned anything it's that I won't. Bravo.
Characters: We dig so much deeper into the ones we love and meet a good chunk of new ones. The animal companions are so fun, stay spicy Curry, and there are so many special side characters. The addition of Erval's perspective is really interesting. And the human unraveling in the face of hardships, abuses, and temptations are masterfully depicted.
World: Wow! The unfolding of the magic system is something I wasn't ready for. It goes WAY deeper than the first book ever unfolded but in a way that feels so seamless and natural. Greater Mothmar has been a joy to explore and the extremes we run into within their religious scope was a treat.
Prose: I said it in book 1 and I'll say it again, this is my kind of writing. It meanders a bit, we follow the POVs and it feels more intimate than most 3rd person writing allows for. No complaints. There was only one term that threw me, "slumming it" lol.
I struggled to review the last book and I struggle to review this too without spoilers because you just want to dive into all the reasons the story is brilliant. But suffice to say, it's a huge winner for me!
Plot: Yes. Just yes. You're never quite sure what will come next, she plants doubt so craftily in your mind you can't trust it. At the end of Daughter of the Sun I saw one more book. At the end of Children of the Earth I'm not sure how she'll wrap it all up in a way I don't expect, which if I've learned anything it's that I won't. Bravo.
Characters: We dig so much deeper into the ones we love and meet a good chunk of new ones. The animal companions are so fun, stay spicy Curry, and there are so many special side characters. The addition of Erval's perspective is really interesting. And the human unraveling in the face of hardships, abuses, and temptations are masterfully depicted.
World: Wow! The unfolding of the magic system is something I wasn't ready for. It goes WAY deeper than the first book ever unfolded but in a way that feels so seamless and natural. Greater Mothmar has been a joy to explore and the extremes we run into within their religious scope was a treat.
Prose: I said it in book 1 and I'll say it again, this is my kind of writing. It meanders a bit, we follow the POVs and it feels more intimate than most 3rd person writing allows for. No complaints. There was only one term that threw me, "slumming it" lol.
I struggled to review the last book and I struggle to review this too without spoilers because you just want to dive into all the reasons the story is brilliant. But suffice to say, it's a huge winner for me!
November 7, 2023
I've been completely blown away by this series so far. It isn't often that I give a book a 5 star rating, but this one ticks all the boxes. From believable characters to an inhabitable world, the story so far has been very satisfying.
Erval, my love 💝
*Ahem anyway, this book doesn't suffer from the sloppy sequel syndrome, and for that, I'm truly grateful. I enjoyed the characters' journeys, both internal and external, and I'm looking forward to the conclusion of this matter.
The descriptions in this book are so vivid, ngl at some points it felt like I was watching a Disney animated movie like Encanto or Moana. I think if it were made into something like that, it would be truly epic.
Would highly recommend it for anyone who loves fantasy.
Erval, my love 💝
*Ahem anyway, this book doesn't suffer from the sloppy sequel syndrome, and for that, I'm truly grateful. I enjoyed the characters' journeys, both internal and external, and I'm looking forward to the conclusion of this matter.
The descriptions in this book are so vivid, ngl at some points it felt like I was watching a Disney animated movie like Encanto or Moana. I think if it were made into something like that, it would be truly epic.
Would highly recommend it for anyone who loves fantasy.
November 3, 2023
Children of the Earth picks up right where Daughter of the Sun left us. We get the perspectives of Solyana and Pallah and now a new perspective which is super cool. More is exposed in this book as this story moves forward. Amanda brilliantly takes us through each perspective that connects into the larger story being told. You find yourself turning page after page fully absorbed and attached. You find yourself questioning things and wondering if you got it right but then find that you know nothing much like our main characters you join them all in their growth and the prophecy wondering how it's all going to unfold. This story will take you through depths of emotions and story telling it's everything you could want in a series. The writing is brilliant, the world building places you in the story, the characters feel like real friends, real enemies. You can feel the heart and soul that went into this writing I cannot wait for book 3.
Ps: I suggest taking a day off or two because you won't want to put this down.
Ps: I suggest taking a day off or two because you won't want to put this down.
November 8, 2023
Cliffhanger! But I loved this book. I loved that it was a smooth continuation from book 1 to book 2. I didn’t have to reread anything to reacquaint myself. I love the multiple POV’s. I love how the ending in book 2 tied back to the start of book 1. That was a nice little surprise I wasn’t expecting.
I am still not 100% sure about Pallah. Is she the total bad guy or a redeemed bad guy. Or a led wrongly bad guy who realized her mistake! I can’t wait for book 3 so I can find out.
I am still not 100% sure about Pallah. Is she the total bad guy or a redeemed bad guy. Or a led wrongly bad guy who realized her mistake! I can’t wait for book 3 so I can find out.
November 8, 2023
first off, i finished this book in 24 hours, which should say a lot lol 😂 I absolutely devoured(like a smilodon hehehe) the character development, the tension in relationships, and the continued depth to the magic system! I really appreciate how the Mothmar world has so much focus in family members, both positive and negative, and shows the complexity that those kind of relationships bring. I will definitely be purching this series for many friends and family gifts:)
November 28, 2023
An amazing sequel to Daughter of the Sun. A necessary read for anyone living in our current age where the lines of good and evil are blurred. Loved every minute of this book and am so anxious to get my hands on book 3! Lifelong fan of Auler and her work.
Auler's writing style is excellent. Easy to understand, yet elevated use of language. Depth and imagery abound. I haven't read books this well written in awhile.
I would give infinity stars if they existed.
Auler's writing style is excellent. Easy to understand, yet elevated use of language. Depth and imagery abound. I haven't read books this well written in awhile.
I would give infinity stars if they existed.
November 7, 2023
Daughter of the Sun was amazing and Children of the Earth did not disappoint! It was such a good sequel. The Mothmarian adventures continue with Palla, Solyana, and, a third POV. COTE was a page turner! I ✨consumed✨ this story! If you love Avatar the Last Airbender, this story is for you!
November 6, 2023
Auler's storytelling skills are on full display in her second book and the sequel in the Mothmar Trilogy. Far from being a slump, COTE is a fast-paced, page-turner that made me want to devour the book. Just as DOTS kept me up late, COTE has done the same. I couldn't just stop at the end of a chapter. I had to keep reading to know what happened next. My sleep schedule was thrown out the window for a few days while reading it, and I'm not mad about it.
The magic system gets another layer that is both terrifying and fascinating. I was glued to the book during Pallah's chapters as she navigates that magic system, and we get to know her character better than we did in DOTS
The three POVs were slightly confusing at first, but they converged toward the end making things a little clearer. I would definitely suggest reading DOTS before reading COTE even if you've read it already. This story is definitely more a mystery than the first book (which is saying something), but it does answer some questions from DOTS.
Auler wrote perhaps the most evil character in Erval, and I loved it and hated it. His charm is deceptive, and though he's intriguing, he's absolutely the worst. His chapters were difficult to get through, whether from his POV or from Pallah's.
So, who cares about that dragon book coming out this week...go read this one instead. Do it for Curry.
The magic system gets another layer that is both terrifying and fascinating. I was glued to the book during Pallah's chapters as she navigates that magic system, and we get to know her character better than we did in DOTS
The three POVs were slightly confusing at first, but they converged toward the end making things a little clearer. I would definitely suggest reading DOTS before reading COTE even if you've read it already. This story is definitely more a mystery than the first book (which is saying something), but it does answer some questions from DOTS.
Auler wrote perhaps the most evil character in Erval, and I loved it and hated it. His charm is deceptive, and though he's intriguing, he's absolutely the worst. His chapters were difficult to get through, whether from his POV or from Pallah's.
So, who cares about that dragon book coming out this week...go read this one instead. Do it for Curry.
November 9, 2023
Book one, Daughter of the Sun, left me with such a plot twist, that I wasn’t sure what to expect from the second book. Wow, it hits you running right away, so much happening and so many things that had you really thinking! I loved it and the dual characters continued to deepen and develop and I love them both! The addition of Erval has really deepened the story and has you wondering where he’ll end up in the final spectrum. Some definite sad moments, but this story has continued to captivate my imagination and push my predictions all over the place! I can’t wait for the final book to come out! On pins and needles to see how it all come together!!!
Another home run Amanda! Thank you for sharing your world of Mothmar with us❤️
Another home run Amanda! Thank you for sharing your world of Mothmar with us❤️
Displaying 1 - 30 of 103 reviews