Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Trials of Gabriel Ward #1

A Case of Mice and Murder

Rate this book
The Inner Temple, 1901: a warren of shaded courtyards and ancient buildings that has formed the heart of legal London for hundreds of years. A place where tradition is everything, the police enter only by consent, and murder is only to be found in the case archives. Until now…

At precisely two minutes to seven every morning, Gabriel Ward KC steps out of his rooms in the Inner Temple, presses his oak front door three times to ensure it is locked, and walks to his office to begin his day. Except for today.

Today, the dead body of the Lord Chief Justice of England, immaculately clad in evening dress except for his bare feet, is lying on his doorstep – with one of the silver Temple carving knives sticking out of his chest.
As rumour and gossip fly round the chambers and the press set up camp outside the gates, an internal investigation is ordered by the head of the Temple, who coerces a very unwilling Gabriel into taking charge.

Paired with the eager young Constable Wright, he must draw on every bit of his legal training to solve the case – but not before he discovers that there are more surprising, and sometimes sinister, secrets hiding behind those heavy oak doors than he'd ever imagined.

The first in a brand-new series introducing a wonderfully eccentric sleuth, perfect for fans of S.J. Bennett and Richard Coles.

352 pages, Kindle Edition

First published July 18, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Sally Smith

5 books234 followers
Sally Smith spent all her working life as a barrister and later King's Counsel in the Inner Temple. After writing a biography of the famous Edwardian barrister, Sir Edward Marshall Hall KC, she retired from the bar to write full time. A Case of Mice and Murder, her first novel, was inspired by the historic surroundings of the Inner Temple in which she still lives and works and by the rich history contained in the Inner Temple archives. A Case of Mice and Murder is the first in a series starring the reluctant sleuth Sir Gabriel Ward KC.

source: Amazon

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2,136 (33%)
4 stars
2,876 (44%)
3 stars
1,184 (18%)
2 stars
207 (3%)
1 star
59 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 991 reviews
Profile Image for Alexandra.
646 reviews145 followers
November 6, 2026
Everything about this book is wonderful

London, 1901. Welcome to the Inner Temple, a world of judges and barristers with its own jurisdiction and ancient customs. Meet Sir Gabriel Ward, barrister, King’s Counsel. Gabriel is brilliant. He is also a man of routine who almost never leaves the Temple. He is definitely on the autistic spectrum and has OCD.

Lord Chief Justice has been murdered, and Gabriel literally stumbles over the body. Since we can’t have “policemen crawling all over” the Inner Temple (the horror!), Gabriel is to “make enquiries”.

We also follow one Gabriel’s current legal cases that involves a hugely successful children’s book about a mouse named Millie, its publisher and its (possible) author.

The mystery is very interesting and skilfully constructed. But the biggest reason for my five stars and gushing about this book to anyone who would listen is that the mystery is lovingly wrapped in a novel of manners, humanity, witty sentences, immaculately recreated historical setting, and great characters.

Gabriel is awesome. Besides the wonderful analytical mind, he has kindness and decency. I loved how his safe world was made bigger by the mystery he had to solve. Go, Gabriel. I also hope that Constable Wright will make an appearance in book 2. I’ve grown very fond of Constable Wright.

I think I would describe this book as “quietly brilliant”. I was hugging the book in delight during so many scenes. How is it possible that this is a debut novel? How?

I guessed the solution to the mystery, but I kept hoping that I was wrong. I wasn’t. The ending is heartbreaking.
I am ready for more. And you, my friend, should just go and read it if you haven’t yet.

Quotes:

“She is still beside herself.” (Be quiet, said Gabriel to his inner lawyer.) – The inner lawyer is the part of Gabriel that takes everything literally ;)

“Gabriel shifted hastily away from the dangerous bog of human emotion and onto the firm ground of fact.”

“I am going to hell.”
Gabriel blinked. “I am sorry to hear it. May one ask why?”

“For Gabriel was a traveller. Not of the pith helmet and bamboo stick variety, not even of the Baedeker guide and Gladstone bag kind, but a traveller in the mind, scaling the mountains of learning created by historians and philosophers, scientists and poets and novelists. The books in Number Four King’s Bench Walk were friends into whose warm embrace he fell every evening and who held him until bedtime at half-past midnight every night.”
Profile Image for K.J. Charles.
Author 70 books13.2k followers
Read
December 9, 2024
Murder mystery set in the Temple (weird legal area of London with its own rules) with OCD bachelor barrister Sir Gabriel Ward reluctantly dragged in to investigate the killing of the Lord Chief Justice. It's very readable and very likeable, with a slightly odd but kindhearted lead, well laid clues, and some sharp observations. It perhaps suffered a bit by comparison to Sarah Cauldwell's legal murder mysteries, in that they push the boundaries so much further, but comparisons are odious. Terrifically researched setting that feels note perfect. Will definitely get the next one.
Profile Image for Stephen the Bookworm.
1,054 reviews218 followers
January 29, 2024
A Case of Mice and Murder could be categorised as 'cosy crime ' or even in some senses a 'locked room murder " but this would very much under play the quality, uniqueness and enjoyment of this historical period story through placing it simply under these popular categories

Set in the enclosed world of the Inner Temple- home of the highest judges and barristers - a murder has been committed - the death of the Lord Chief Justice. The crime takes place upon the doorstep of barrister Gabriel Ward- who is then assigned the task of carrying out internal enquiries to determine the perpetrator of the murder...The Temple is its own realm ( rather like the Vatican) and police may only enter the grounds with permission. The murderer can only have been somebody who was permitted within the Temple environs.

Accompanied by Constable Wright , Gabriel embarks on his task with reluctance as life beyond the temple walls are a source of anxiety and mystery; he has cocooned himself within his chambers and the legal world.

Whilst trying to explore the death of the Lord Chief Justice, he is also challenged by the curious case of determining the authorship of the hugely popular children's book, "Millie The Temple Mouse"

Sally Smith has created a wonderful protagonist and this is the start of a promising series - combining period details, the greed for power among the judiciary and their wives , creating the atmosphere of Temple life and combining a few red herrings along the way, this is an enjoyable crime/detective procedural with a twist.
Profile Image for Amina .
1,554 reviews
February 1, 2026
✰ 4 stars ✰

“I have learned that each of us has places in the heart where we do not wish others to trample.”

giphy4sg

Considering my own disregard and firm avoidance for all things cozy, it is a pleasant surprise that I enjoyed this a lot more than I expected to. For if I were to define this, it would be a comical cozy, where the protagonist's personality propels the plot in a way that is both entertaining and intriguing. 💁🏻‍♀️

From the instance Sir William, the Temple's Treasurer, issued the resolute order to the reluctant but resigned barrister of 30+ years, Gabriel Ward, the very last sort of man to become an amateur sleuth, that he had approximately one week to find the murderer of his former classmate and fellow Templer, Lord Chief Justice Dunning, there was something about Gabriel that just drew me to him. 👍🏻

“Nothing is unarguable to a good lawyer.”

Gabriel was a mesh-up of Colombo and Monk, incomprehensible - Sir William notes, someone firmly committed to following routine, while also being entirely unaware of his ability to ruffle others' feathers - inadvertently so - unbothered and unfazed, as he's investigating official Temple business, not of his volition - but still, never far from using his keen sense of judgment and justice to ensure the righteous path is followed. 😌

I love a book that can make me chuckle, and there was just the right amount of tongue-in-cheek and dry wit and wry humor that doesn't adhere to over-dramatic, but rather a subtle, soft-assured way of enacting reason to triumph over incredulity. 🤌🏻🤌🏻 The narrative shifts seamlessly between multiple perspectives, but never crowds itself, never repeats, but engages and explains the context behind each puzzle or clue Gabriel discovers upon his little gentle questioning within the Inner Temple community.

“Speculation was rife, questions were numerous, answers unhelpful.”

Don't let the title fool you. 😤 It is A Case of Mice and Murder, and the author's ability to have both perplexities run parallel to each other is no easy feat, but it's pulled off in such style that the hints and details for both sides were covered in fair and intriguing ground by the nascent revolutionary, that kept me surprisingly uncertain of who the guilty part was until it's reveal.

It was also amusing to see the most famous cross-examiner in London Gabriel's own practiced courtroom observations and skillsets be put to use in a more direct approach with his suspects, an endeavor that somehow also shifted his understanding of humans - a belated reaction, so to speak that made him feel so much more real with his own breakthrough into solving the mystery. 🥺

“How curious people were, Gabriel thought... What a patchwork of complex underlying emotions they felt. How little he knew about any of them.”

giphyf

It had a colorful supporting cast, with fun dynamics steadily introduced and developed, mainly Constable Wright, torn between duty to his superior and his gushing hero worship for Gabriel. 😄 It was fun to see how his youthful eagerness and awareness brought helpful insight into Gabriel's own purposes, making for an endearing duo that I'm looking forward to seeing how well they'll still work together henceforth.

The author's own personal expertise in the Inner Temple, a little world of its own, an independent enclave, also allowed her to make the setting rich with unique historical detail and provide depth to the time, touching upon relevant themes prevalent during that period. Social inequality, class divide, and other notable challenges that, in their own way, guided Gabriel to cracking the case in a believable and realistic, if not bittersweet portrayal. ⚖️
Profile Image for Grandma Susan.
773 reviews297 followers
July 19, 2025
I listened to the audio version. I plan to read it on kindle and see if I like the story better, I think I will. The narrator ruined this book for me. Mediocre performance at best. I feel I’m a good judge of this as, I listen to most of my books because I’m legally blind. I wouldn’t recommend the audio version, but read the book.

I was blessed with an audio ARC of this book. The opinions expressed are my own and unbiased.
Profile Image for Krystal.
2,315 reviews523 followers
May 16, 2025
Narrated by Matthew Lloyd-Davis
Presented by Bloomsbury UK Audio


Another fun detective story!

Err, I mean, LAWYER.

Yes, Sir Gabriel Ward is tasked with investigating a murder that's happened on Temple grounds. That's not, as I first misunderstood, a literal temple, but rather a special lil section of London where Lawyers rule. Gabriel is a little odd, but it's part of his charm.

I'll admit, the narrator didn't work for me at the beginning. For some reason I find some male narrators hard to hear at times, like they trail off at the end of the sentences or in the middle and I can't make out the words properly. Very frustrating. I also found the pacing off compared to how I'd read, but I wouldn't go so far as to say he did a bad job.

He did grow on me as I became more involved in the story, but I did find myself tuning out a lot at the start. The story sucked me in though and I regretted not paying thorough attention!

There's a double mystery here - the murder that Ward has been tasked with investigating, and the case he's currently undertaking in his role as a lawyer, that concerns the author of a children's book. It's the latter that really piqued my curiosity; Millie the mouse has become a hugely successful book and yet her authorship is unknown. Fascinating!

Eventually this book delivered everything I've really been enjoying in the Japanese crime novels I've been devouring: strange, seemingly irrelevant pieces, a large cast of potential suspects, quirky stories and completely wild ideas. I enjoyed the way everything started to be pieced together and the ultimate conclusion.

This is a great introduction to the series, but given all the clues and red herrings I'd love to read this one physically so that I can properly absorb every detail.

Highly recommend to crime fans who just want a straight up murder mystery without the brooding detectives and their messy love lives.

With thanks to NetGalley for an audio ARC
Profile Image for Ivonne Rovira.
2,811 reviews273 followers
August 20, 2025
Author Sally Smith’s debut novel is the first in a series featuring a cerebral, observant barrister of the Inner Temple teaming up with a clever young constable proved great fun from the very start. Gabriel Ward KC leads a solitary life by choice, surrounded by books and difficult legal cases; to his dismay, he’s tapped to investigate the stabbing murder of Lord Chief Justice Norman Dunning. Ward and his assigned helper, Constable Maurice Wright, may come from nearly opposite ends of the social strata, but in so many ways, they emerge as kindred spirits.

Smith packs the novel with humor, an excellent plot and plenty of revelations. I cannot wait for the sequel! Highly, highly, highly recommended.
Profile Image for Megan.
584 reviews8,658 followers
February 25, 2026
3.5 stars. reading vlog: https://youtu.be/SJY1WjjPKKU

really a book of two halves for me! found the plot, pacing and mystery really dragged in the first half, but came alive in the second half! I felt I could almost feel Sally Smith growing as a writer throughout!
Profile Image for Prasanna.
Author 5 books25 followers
October 6, 2025
This is one of the few books where I didn’t enjoy the audio version—the narrator’s portrayal of the main character just didn’t connect with me.

That said, the plot itself is engaging, with just the right balance of humor and mystery. The story opens with the Lord Chief Justice found dead—stabbed and barefoot—in the Inner Temple, a legal district in the heart of London. Such eccentricities, which I found amusing as a modern reader, were considered normal for the period. The investigation falls to Sir Gabriel Ward, an eccentric but brilliant lawyer who hasn’t left the Temple’s confines in decades. As he interviews witnesses and unravels the murder, he’s also preparing for a high-profile case involving the authorship of a much loved and popular children’s book.

I especially appreciated how the novel captured the social sentiments of the era, particularly the restrictions on women entering the legal profession and the mistreatment of the lower classes.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the advance copy.
Profile Image for Leandra.
551 reviews650 followers
October 14, 2025
Delightful is the best word for this mystery.

I read this book just before I picked up Cyril Hare's classic crime novel, Tragedy at Law. It was a serendipitous pairing, as the books have many elements in common even though the latter was published in 1942. Both mysteries are heavily entwined with the British justice system of the early 20th century, each depicting the Old Bailey at a time pre-Blitz, and both feature crimes against judges that are, to put bluntly, not nearly as impressive as the women and other peers that surround them. I cannot recommend reading these two in close proximity purely for the joy of comparing and contrasting them!

Zeroing in on A Case of Mice an Murder, I adored this book. It was one of the easiest 5 stars I have given this year. Sally Smith juggles two mysteries: the murder of the Lord Chief Justice of England and the disputed authorship of bestselling children's book Millie the Temple Church Mouse. Like multiple POVs, when multiple mysteries are being juggled, there is the risk that readers' investment will be uncomfortably out of balance, but I was equally invested in both plots. It helped that the man investigating them was barrister Gabriel Ward. He finds comfort in order, in legal histories and court proceedings, and in the Old Bailey as his home. That peace is disrupted when he is the person to find the Lord Chief Justice's corpse on his doorstep. Now, he must find a way to solve the murder while making progress in his latest case.  

A lovely investigative duo can be found in Ward and Constable Wright that sometimes bleeds into a supportive mentorship. There is great social commentary on the experiences and restrictions of women at the time, as well as discussions of classism and privilege. This is a well-plotted mystery, and I am highly anticipating book 2!

Featured in the following vlog: I found a HIDDEN GEM new FAVORITE book! 🤩 | reading vlog~ mystery, cozy, sci fi, and horror

Actual Rating: 5.0 stars 
Original Pub Date: 17 June 2025 (US)
Reading Format: e-book + audiobook

Thank you NetGalley, Bloomsbury USA, and Raven Books for an E-ARC copy in exchange for this honest review!
Profile Image for Manon (mysterymanon).
245 reviews486 followers
May 31, 2025
A delightful intertwining of two mysteries: a murder, of course, and the anonymous author of a popular children’s story. I adored our lawyer-sleuth Gabriel Ward and his meticulous approach to these investigations. The mysteries were puzzling and complicated.

The historical setting (1901, in London’s Middle and Inner Temples) was nicely constructed. It introduced me to this little world with so much history and peculiar traditions.

Fans of cozy mysteries with a strong historical edge will enjoy this!
Profile Image for Grisette.
793 reviews101 followers
August 31, 2026

4 stars

Great cover, very nice title, intriguing settings, a reclusive lawyer as the sleuth... all elements reunited to attract me. I love scholarly settings à la Oxbridge for a murder scene (I have Dorothy L. Sayers to thank for that) and with this book, the choice of a famous Inn of Court was definitely an alluring bait.

For a debut novel, I liked it. The writing was good and the intimate knowledge of the legal world and the Inner Temple was palpable and laudable. The closed urn universe was exactly the kind of atmosphere I was expecting. The plot was original and well conducted. Being the first book in the series, the two concurrent sub-plots seemed at first wholly unconnected and hence quite puzzling why as a reader, I had to wade through them (despite each being interesting in their own right). Of course, it all tied up together at the end but I fear many readers will still find the delivery disjointed. Personally, I accepted it for its originality and moreso, as already mentioned, I am a fan of the settings. I found the ending bittersweet, esp. considering the plight of the character concerned - wretched patriarchy!

The main character was certainly special. Sir Gabriel Ward KC is not at first glance a compelling main character. He leads a dry life and loves it so, more the respect for him (btw, he is a huge book lover, so one big cookie point for him). However, his 'dryness' did translate through the pages, so much so that the narrative tone was necessarily dry too. This did lend a personal tone to the world of Sir Gabriel, but it also made for a 'dry' reading experience and often, I had to take breaks before taking up the plot again. That said, as the pages went by, I became more accustomed to him and now look forward to follow his future adventures, quirks included.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Gavin Armour.
667 reviews138 followers
January 27, 2026
Der Temple-Distrikt in London, zwischen der Fleet Street im Norden und der Themse gleich südlich gelegen, ist bis heute eine einzigartige Einrichtung des englischen Rechtswesens und seiner Geschichte. Hier sind mit dem Inner Temple und dem Middle Temple Inns of Court zwei wesentliche Kammern der britischen Anwaltschaft beheimatet, mit der Temple Church eine der ältesten Kirchen Englands. Benannt nach dem Orden der Tempelritter, die den Distrikt, vor allem aber die Kirche begründet haben, bietet The Temple nicht nur einen Rückzugsraum der Ruhe mitten in der Hektik der Metropole, sondern eben auch einen geschützten Raum des Rechtswesens, in dem bis heute ganz eigene Regeln gelten, u.a. dass die Polizei hier nur eingeschränkte Zugriffsrechte hat. Dies ist ein wesentlicher Punkt für die Handlung des vorliegenden Romans.

Die Kronanwältin Sally Smith, die ihr Berufsleben nach eigener Aussage fast ausschließlich im Temple zugebracht hat und mit den dortigen Gepflogenheiten, aber auch der Geschichte des Distrikts bestens vertraut ist, hat diesem mit DER TOTE IN DER CROWN ROW (A CASE OF MICE AND MURDER, 2024; Dt.2025) ein kleines literarisches Denkmal in Form eines herrlich britischen Kriminalromans gesetzt.

Der Barrister – man sollte, muss aber nicht genauer mit den Feinheiten des englischen Rechtswesens und der unterschiedlichen Bezeichnungen und den entsprechenden Differenzen zwischen einem Barrister, einem Anwalt, der vor Gericht auftreten und plädieren darf, und einem Solicitor, der einen Mandanten berät, vertraut sein, um dem Roman folgen zu können – Gabriel Ward, ein Meister seines Fachs, stolpert eines schönen Morgens im Jahr 1901 über eine Leiche, die unmittelbar vor den von ihm genutzten Räumen liegt. Es handelt sich hierbei um den obersten Richter des Courts. Da die Polizei im Temple nur eingeschränkte Rechte besitzt und nicht unmittelbar hinzugezogen werden muss, wird Ward damit beauftragt, den Fall möglichst geräuschlos zu klären. Ward kommt dies sehr ungelegen, da er eigentlich damit beschäftigt ist, einen großen Fall vorzubereiten: Ein Verleger bat ihn um Rechtsbeistand, da er mit einem Kinderbuch, das von einer Maus erzählt, die im Temple beheimatet ist, enormen Erfolg gehabt hat, es allerdings nie zu einer klaren Absprache mit der Autorin des Buchs kam, die sich nie zu erkennen gegeben hatte. Nun aber ist eine Dame aufgetaucht, die behauptet, die Urheberschaft des Buchs für sich beanspruchen zu dürfen. Ward versucht also, beiden Fällen gerecht zu werden und muss feststellen, dass die Dinge manchmal näher beieinander liegen, als man so annimmt.

Neben Gabriel Ward, der den geneigten Leser*innen in Zukunft wahrscheinlich noch häufiger begegnen dürfte, eignet sich die Figur doch geradezu exemplarisch, um eine Serie zu beginnen, lässt Smith eine ganze Reihe ebenso skurriler wie oftmals sehr authentisch wirkender und zumeist auch recht liebenswürdiger Figuren auftreten. Sicherlich greift sie dabei häufig auf literarische Vorbilder zurück – sowohl Charles Dickens, als auch Jane Austen dürften hier vor allem Pate gestanden haben – und auch das eine oder andere Klischee wird nicht gerade umschifft, vor allem bei den Schilderungen der geschlossenen Herrengesellschaft im Temple kann sich die Autorin das eine oder andere Stereotyp nicht verkneifen. Doch sind die meisten mit viel Liebe und Hingabe zum charakterlichen Detail ausgeschmückt; vor allem Theodora Dunning, eine Dame der Gesellschaft, die Ward im Laufe seiner Ermittlungen kennen- und schätzen lernt, ist überzeugend als frühe Feministin gezeichnet, die wirklich darunter leidet, dass sie trotz ihres offenbar überragenden Intellekts und ihrer Kenntnisse des Rechtswesens (ihr Bruder ist das Opfer des Mords im Temple) niemals die Gelegenheit haben wird, selbst den Beruf einer Anwältin oder gar eines Barristers zu ergreifen.

Smith gelingt ein sehr interessanter Balanceakt, indem sie ihre Figuren ausreichend skurril und mit Eigenarten schildert – so ist Ward ein Eigenbrötler, der sich in seinen vier Wänden im Temple geradezu hinter Büchern, also Wissen, verschanzt, während er nur wenig mit der Welt außerhalb dieses Bezirks zu tun hat – und damit durchaus Witz und Humor in ihren Roman einschreibt, zugleich aber die Anliegen, die bspw. eine Theodora Dunning umtreiben, wie das himmelschreiende Unrecht, als Frau im immer noch viktorianisch geprägten England des ausgehenden 19. Jahrhunderts unter strenger gesellschaftlicher Kuratel zu stehen, angemessen ausspielt, ohne sie je der Lächerlichkeit preiszugeben. Hier gibt es keine billigen Scherze auf Kosten eines andern. Vielmehr wird eben erstaunlich souverän der Grat zwischen einem wirklich geschickt konstruierten Kriminalroman und einem Gesellschaftsportrait gehalten, wobei beides durch eine gewisse Leichtigkeit der Erzählung getragen wird. Dazu trägt die Nebenhandlung um das Kinderbuch bei, auf welches der englische Originaltitel des Romans anspielt. Dessen Verleger und sein schier aussichtsloser Kampf um die Rechte und gegen das eigene schlechte Gewissen, bringt ebenfalls ein wenig Humor in die Handlung, zugleich wird anhand dieses Strangs durchaus glaubwürdig von jenen in der englischen Gesellschaft erzählt, die wenig haben und viel riskieren, um ein wenig vom Ganzen abzubekommen. Allerdings muss der Kenner britischer Literatur auch hier an ein Vorbild denken, droht doch der „kleine Lord“ Fauntleroy im Klassiker von Frances Hodgson Burnett ebenfalls durch einen Hochstapler um sein Erbe gebracht zu werden. Smith lehnt sich also oftmals an große, manchmal vielleicht gar übergroße Vorbilder an.

Doch gelingt es Smith darüber hinaus vor allem, die authentische Atmosphäre eines London des späten 19./frühen 20. Jahrhunderts einzufangen. Offenbar kennt sie sich sehr gut in der Stadt aus, vor allem aber in der Geschichte der Stadt. So können wir den Figuren vom Temple ins damals immer noch düstere und gefährliche East End, aber ebenso in die vornehmen Gegenden des West End folgen und dabei diese Stadt, die damals Mittelpunkt eines sich weltweit immer noch ausbreitenden Imperiums gewesen ist, ein wenig begreifen. Die Moderne macht sich bemerkbar – nicht nur mit der aufkommenden Emanzipation der Frauen, sondern vor allem auch in den Mitteln und Methoden, die hier zur Kriminalitätsbekämpfung angewandt werden. Der Ward zur Seite gestellte Constable Wright ist ein noch recht junger Mann, der sich mit dem Barrister auch deswegen so gut versteht, weil beide das Lesen schätzen und vor allem die daraus gewonnen Erkenntnisse. So macht Wright fotografische Aufnahmen vom Tatort und nimmt den Verdächtigen Fingerabdrücke ab – beides damals noch verpönte Ermittlungsmethoden, die teils vor Gericht auch noch nicht zugelassen waren. Wrights Kampf um Anerkennung seiner Mittel spiegelt recht gut den Kampf, den Theodora Dunning um die Anerkennung von Frauen in Männerberufen führt.

DER TOTE IN DER CROWN ROW ist ein wahrlich klassisches Beispiel gelungener Kriminalliteratur, weiß der Roman doch nicht nur zu unterhalten, sondern eben auch über sich selbst hinauszuweisen. Er vermittelt einen guten Eindruck einer Gesellschaft an einem Wendepunkt, vermittelt ein schönes Bild Londons und vor allem dieses wenig beachteten Distrikts namens The Temple, der jedem London-Besucher empfohlen sei. Vor allem aber bietet der Roman einen herrlichen Plot, ist spannend und wartet mit interessanten Figuren auf, ohne sich selbst allzu wichtig zu nehmen. Was will man mehr?
Profile Image for Reagan Formea.
466 reviews16 followers
April 14, 2025
I received this as an ARC in a giveaway!
Sadly, this book did not do much for me. It felt like it was dragging while only being about 300 pages and I could not connect to the writing style. I wish I liked it more because I think the cover is so cute for some reason.
Profile Image for Andi.
468 reviews86 followers
October 21, 2026
A cozy, historical murder mystery that didn't blow me away, but was nonetheless a good time - especially for chillier weather.
Profile Image for Babel.
2,411 reviews202 followers
March 1, 2026
Prepara la taza de té, la lupa y la ventana mojada por la lluvia. Vamos a acampar en un confortable sofá para resolver un misterio penal en Londres en 1901.

Una servidora jamás se resiste a la tentación de una buena historia de cosy crime. ¿Sucede en Londres? ¿El detective involuntario es un maniático del orden y con pobres artes sociales? ¿Hay un ratón de por medio y no sabemos por qué? Ya está la libreta de investigador lista con las preguntas importantes.

Claves de la novela:
-el asesinato inusual de un juez
-un racimo de litigantes que lidian con el crimen a diario pero no saben qué pensar de la muerte de su líder
-un protagonista que prefiere estar a solas con sus libros
-un caso de derechos de autor 

¡¿Pero qué pasa con el ratón?! Paciencia.

Eso es lo que exhibe el pobre abogado al que le endosan la investigación interna del crimen. Al menos lo ayuda un agente de policía bastante más pizpireto de lo que parece. En pleno corazón de Londres, existe una especie de Vaticano de balanzas y leyes donde el tiempo no transcurre ni el progreso se inmiscuye en sus privilegios. Es el Temple. Un oasis donde impera la ley, se celebran juicios con togas y pelucas empolvadas y nadie osa entrar sin el permiso expreso de los residentes. También vive un ratón imaginario que ha desatado un juicio mediático al mismo tiempo que el lord presidente aparece asesinado en circunstancias sospechosas.

Esta novela de corte sobrio, investigación metódica y humor sutil es perfecta para los que disfruten con la solemnidad inteligente de S J Bennet y la minuciosidad y cultura británicas de Ben Aaronovitch. Me ha mantenido intrigada porque se va componiendo un mosaico de personajes y sus actos a través de interrogatorios. Me ha entretenido por el ambiente legal inglés, los toques de humor y la gran devoción al conocimiento y la literatura. De fondo, los pensamientos lógicos y algo asustadizos de sir Gabriel Ward, un hombrecillo tan brillante como recto, compasivo y poco emotivo. Una combinación que funciona muy bien en este ámbito.

Debo añadir que la autora ha mostrado una delicada sensibilidad en el desarrollo y resolución de ambos casos que se completan en un final resolutivo y agridulce. Es una serie que estaría feliz de continuar.  
Profile Image for Tim Robinson.
1,331 reviews59 followers
January 27, 2025
English, introverted and upper middle class, as all good detectives and detective fiction should be. At times the style comes close to Socialist Realism, which is not a good thing. But elsewhere it is very funny: much funnier than many books that are sold as comedies. Everyone has a secret, but for the most part these secrets are touchingly innocent, or if not entirely innocent, at least motivated by very human and commendable motives.

Thoughts that occurred to me: (Not exactly spoilers. And not all my ideas turned out to be correct!)
Profile Image for Jill Elizabeth.
2,141 reviews56 followers
February 25, 2025
There was a lot that I really liked here, unfortunately there was even more that I found repetitive and slow going, and that was a problem for me... I liked the setup. I liked the concept. I liked the main characters. But in between those elements that I liked, I found a lot of very wordy description and plodding "investigation" that kept pulling me out of the witty banter and clever characterizations.

I struggled with this one - more than most apparently - and don't know if I would continue this series although I might just to see if the follow-up book tightens things up enough that I could thoroughly enjoy the elements of the story without feeling mired in detail.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
Profile Image for Jeneane Vanderhoof .
242 reviews60 followers
September 4, 2025
This debut by Sally Smith is a captivating start to a new historical mystery series. The book’s intrigue kept the pages turning and when the central mystery was fully unraveled, the final pages left me with a strong desire to continue the journey (or better said, start the journey all over again with another mystery) when the next volume arrives. Sally Smith is a real-life (albeit retired) barrister and a member of King’s Counsel, and her firsthand experience in the field is, in my opinion, likely what gives the book its authentic charm.

The story unfolds within the cloistered, almost medieval enclave of London’s Inner Temple in 1901, a secluded legal district with a distinct identity and its own long-held traditions. Within these historic grounds resides Sir Gabriel Ward KC, a barrister known for his meticulous routine and studious isolation. His precisely ordered life is abruptly upended one May morning when he discovers the lifeless body of the Lord Chief Justice on his doorstep, stabbed and with the inexplicable absence of his footwear. This bizarre discovery forces Gabriel to reluctantly take on the role of investigator, a task urged by his superiors to keep the matter internal before involving outside authorities. He is also given seven days to solve this mystery.

Gabriel’s private inquiry into the death of the Chief Justice swiftly reveals a complicated network of ambition, secrets, and bitter rivalries lurking within the Temple’s hallowed halls. The murder weapon itself, a carving knife from the Temple kitchen, strongly suggests a crime committed by an insider.

At the same time, Gabriel is faced with a separate legal dispute for his client, Herbert Moore, which turns into a wildly entertaining subplot. This case involves the highly popular children’s book, Millie the Temple Church Mouse. The original manuscript was left on the doorstep of a publishing house, rescued by the publisher’s daughter, and published to humor the child when she fell in love with it. The book became a runaway success, but the publisher only has the name “Miss. Harriett Cadamy” and she can’t be found. This situation leads to a lawsuit from a sleazy minister, in partnership with a Miss. Susan Hatchings- who is claiming authorship. The dual narrative strands of a high-stakes murder and a charming literary puzzle intertwine throughout the novel in clever and unexpected ways.

The novel’s greatest strength lies in its ability to educate the reader (in an entertaining way, of course) about the British Legal system and the role of the four Inns of Court which are, as follows: Lincoln’s Inn, Gray’s Inn, the Middle Temple and the Inner Temple (which has land that was once owned by the Knights Templar, some of who are buried there). These are professional associations for barristers that are responsible for the recruitment, education and training of future barristers, they call them to Bar (a ceremony that formally admits an individual to the legal professions and grants them to “utter bar” in court. This signifies the completion of the legal training and the “symbolic crossing” that historically separates lawyers from the public in a courtroom). The inns also provide legal support and disperse any disciplinary action.

Historically, the inns were those who trained barristers and they served as social and professional hubs. Lectures and moot courts may be attended but most learning was done in a form of apprenticeship and formal instruction. If you have ever heard the phrase “reading in chambers”, the reference may not have been applied correctly. When the term originated “reading in chambers” was when a pupil (or law student) underwent a “hands-on” apprenticeship, learning directly from a practicing barrister.

Sally Smith’s own background as a barrister lends an authentic and precise quality to her prose, a style that feels perfectly suited to the era. The descriptions of the architecture and the intricate customs of the legal world are exceptionally vivid, creating an immersive and authentic backdrop that avoids any modern feel. The Inner Temple’s unique status, operating largely independently of the City of London’s typical jurisdiction, enhances its appeal as an intriguing stage for these unfolding events.

Smith even delves into the class divisions present in British society at the time. Almost always hailing from old money- the upper class had distinctions, privileges, were given more respect and if you compared the entertainment available for each, societal balls, hunting- all while being waited on hand and foot by multiple servants. In comparison, if the lower class could even get an education they were lucky, they usually had no opportunity for advancement in society, were trapped in a cycle of debt (and often locked behind bars for it) and had a hard time meeting their basic needs. With options limited by low pay and long working hours, the lower class did have music halls, local pubs (a central hub for the working-class social life), sports and things like libraries, museums and art galleries. For most though, relaxation was sought with everyday pleasures like going to the pub or a hobby like reading, gardening or keeping a pet.

The character of Sir Gabriel Ward undergoes significant and gratifying development. Initially a man immersed in his legal texts and a life of solitude, his reluctant interactions with a variety of new individuals broaden his perspective and force a personal evolution. The investigative dynamic is further enhanced by his collaboration with Constable Wright, whose differing background provides a pleasing contrast to Gabriel’s more academic approach. While the murder mystery provided an interesting puzzle with a satisfying and unforeseen conclusion, the Millie the Mouse storyline offered a second peek for the reader (into the life of a very busy man), and the plot and sub plot wove well together.

Overall, A Case of Mice and Murder is a rewarding read, blending a classic whodunnit with a more academic legal mystery. It marks an auspicious and well-crafted beginning to a new series, with many aspects suggesting continued enjoyment for those who appreciate meticulously detailed historical crime fiction.

Happy Reading!
Profile Image for Shauna.
468 reviews
June 27, 2025
I was very impressed by this debut novel set in 1901. It centres around the murder of the Lord Chief Justice in London's Inner Temple. The characters were interesting and I thought the historical detail rang true. Thankfully it is the start of a series featuring Gabriel Ward KC. The only real negative is the frequent references to the snuffling of the lead character . Irritating and unnecessary. I look forward to the follow up book which is out next month.
Profile Image for Riathulhu.
231 reviews1 follower
January 16, 2026
A cozy murder mystery. The setting in the Inner Temple in London, the wold of barristers and high judges was immediately very interesting. Our investigator, Sir Gabriel Ward has his quirks but his endearing nature and keen observation skills make him very fun to read. Plus he is a book lover and with a few legal discussions thrown in for good measure - what’s not to like?

The mystery was very well constructed with clues and little red herrings throughout the story. I found the solution very satisfying, even though I already guessed part of it. The book feels like a nice cup of hot chocolate, most people have some good in them after all and nothing bad happens to them (except for the dead Lord Chief Justice, but he was a misogynist so well…)

I definitively want to read the next book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Jane.
2,667 reviews75 followers
February 18, 2025
What a delight. A Case of Mice and Murder took a little while to draw me in (hence four stars instead of five), but once it did I loved it. Fans of other books featuring accidental detectives may enjoy it as well.

Set in 1901 London, it introduces us to the Temple, a cloistered spot where lawyers have lived and worked for 700 years (and which was all new to me) and to Sir Gabriel Ward. Gabriel “is the very last sort of man to become an amateur sleuth.” He is a barrister because he has respect for the law, for the need to be precise in its application, and for the certainty in its results. He is neurodivergent and has obsessive-compulsive disorder. He has a brilliant mind and is fortunate to have people around him who understand his quirks. Gabriel could come off as annoying but I found him charming and believable instead.

When the Lord Chief Justice is murdered, Gabriel gets called on to do a little behind-the-scenes, unofficial sleuthing. This certainly throws a wrench into his routines, but it also challenges his mind in new ways. During times of crisis, Gabriel often refers back to the phrases and actions his old nanny used on him as a child, and he finds them surprisingly successful. A young constable is assigned to assist him, and they form a partnership that is satisfactory to both of them.

After the murder, we see justices (and their conniving wives) hoping to become the next Lord Chief Justice, an unhappy widow, an irritating boy who also manages to be appealing, and a vicar who loves his cat. We know that secrets are being kept from Gabriel. The secondary plot sees a publisher being sued by a woman who claims to have written his company’s runaway bestseller Millie the Temple Church Mouse.

The Case of Mice and Murder is funny, and the mysteries are slowly explained away as Gabriel doggedly investigates. The author manages to make important points without being out of step with the time period. The murdered judge’s sister had a better mind for the law than he did, but she was not allowed to study to become a lawyer, for example. Gabriel empathizes and finds it a waste. A scullery maid shows compassion to a man living on the streets and Sir Gabriel must use all his wits to see that she is not punished for her acts by the people of power and influence. He must also safeguard the rights of the homeless man.

I read an advance reader copy of A Case of Mice and Murder from Netgalley. It is the first book in a series, and I hope it has a long successful run.
Profile Image for 4cats.
1,062 reviews
April 18, 2025
Firstly, I must say I don't usually read 'cosy crime' novels, they are really not my thing. And although in the description A Case of Mice and Murder mentions cosy crime I would suggest that this is far more, the historical element (the workings of the Inner Temple and the KC's work) lifts this crime novel up a notch or 2 in my estimation. With it's well rounded cast of characters, especially Gabriel Ward KC and Constable Wright who shine out of the pages, the well thought out plot carries you along nicely and finally most importantly, it's really well written (the quality reminds me of Christie). I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Profile Image for Sandra by loslibrosdesissi ♡.
273 reviews19 followers
March 4, 2026
—𝑁𝑎𝑑𝑎 𝑒𝑠 𝑖𝑛𝑠𝑜𝑠𝑡𝑒𝑛𝑖𝑏𝑙𝑒 𝑝𝑎𝑟𝑎 𝑢𝑛 𝑏𝑢𝑒𝑛 𝑎𝑏𝑜𝑔𝑎𝑑𝑜.

🧩 La novela juega con dos enigmas que se cruzan constantemente: por un lado, un asesinato; por otro, la identidad oculta tras un famoso libro infantil.
🕰️ Gabriel Ward me ha caído muy bien. He empatizado mucho con su carácter meticuloso y reservado.
🔎 Ha sido una verdadera delicia acompañar al abogado junto con el agente Wright en sus pesquisas.
👥 Los personajes están bien construidos, lo que hace que todo resulte más creíble.
🏛️ La ambientación histórica es un gran acierto. La recreación del Inner Temple resulta muy vívida y cuidada, y la autora integra con naturalidad las particularidades del derecho en 1901.
🕯️ Sally Smith muestra al lector las injusticias que sufrían quienes tenían menos recursos y pone de relieve cómo las mujeres, a pesar de su talento y esfuerzo, ocupaban un lugar relegado y limitado en la sociedad de la época.
⏳ El ritmo es fluido y constante; la historia avanza con soltura y en ningún momento se me ha hecho pesada. La sensación de intriga se mantiene firme de principio a fin.

🐭 Ward ha sido, para mí, lo mejor de todo. Su personalidad me ha conquistado y me encantaría reencontrarme con él en futuros libros.

🔍 Si disfrutas de un 𝑐𝑜𝑧𝑦 𝑚𝑦𝑠𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑦 con su toque histórico, añade este libro a tu lista de pendientes.
Profile Image for Clbplym.
1,171 reviews2 followers
August 10, 2025
This was very good. There are two cases for Gabriel: one is the death of the Lord Chief Justice and the other is the authorship of a novel about Millie the Temple Mouse. The story is set in the early 20th century and Gabriel is given a week to investigate the death before allowing the police in as they have no jurisdiction within the Temple area (something I did not know). I actually enjoyed the mouse part more but the characters of the other barristers and Judges were marvellous. I listened to this on Audible and the narrators voice was very expressive but occasionally the dips in volume weren’t ideal for listening in a car! I am definitely going to read the second novel.
Profile Image for Linda.
1,374 reviews24 followers
December 25, 2025
This one was a DNF @17%
Maybe it was me or the narrator but I am being much more brutal in my old age about just moving on to the next title. It doesn’t mean it was a bad book, it just means it wasn’t for me.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 991 reviews