Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries #11

Murder on the Atlantic: A 1920s Historical Mystery

Rate this book
Murder on the high seas! Atlantic Ocean 1926
Having sent Jane and Alfred off on their honeymoon, Penelope “Pen” Banks and her other friends are soon off on their own voyage across the Atlantic for a few months in Europe. Unfortunately, the rumor of a maid’s disappearance (was it murder?) during the maiden voyage of their ship has their bon voyage feeling rather tainted. While the crew is in denial about what happened, the drama among her fellow passengers is enough to create a distraction. This includes a ghost from Penelope’s reckless youth spent in Raul García. He is intent on making his own waves between Richard and Penelope, by attempting to pick up where they once left off. At least until a passenger is murdered…and Raul is the only plausible suspect. Soon, the ship’s past also clashes with its present when it turns out both murders may be related. Raul makes Penelope an offer she can’t refuse if only she’ll clear his name and find out who is really guilty of both crimes. Murder on the Atlantic is the eleventh book in the Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries series set in the 1920s. Join her and her friends as they set sail from New York to Europe!

260 pages, Paperback

Published August 23, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Colette Clark

44 books115 followers
Colette Clark lives in New York and has always enjoyed learning more about the history of her amazing city. She decided to combine that curiosity and love of learning with her addiction to reading and watching mysteries. Her first series, Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries is the result of those passions. When she’s not writing she can be found doing Sudoku puzzles, drawing, eating tacos, visiting museums dedicated to unusual/weird/wacky things, and, of course, reading mysteries by other great authors.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
44 (30%)
4 stars
63 (44%)
3 stars
29 (20%)
2 stars
6 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
Profile Image for Noah.
604 reviews578 followers
December 10, 2024
I don't deservе someone loyal to me, don't you think I see? / And I don't want to bе a prisoner to who I used to be (Is There Someone Else? – The Weeknd).

Please wait a second, I’m currently basking in the moment… okay, I’m done, I'm here now. Hey, this is a cause for celebration because I’ve managed to reach the eleventh book in a series and it’s still just as good as it was when I started all those books ago! Cool stuff. Just like all the others, this was a lot of fun, and I really wasn’t exaggerating with all my singing of praises up there, because the thing is, Murder on the Atlantic is singular in the way it's such a testament to Colette Clark’s skill as a writer and actually works as more of a victory lap as it’s a wonder that she's been able to constantly up the ante and yet maintain the same quality of intrigue in such long running mystery series. The story this time around is that after Penelope Banks’ friend’s wedding, she and her little Scooby Gang decide to go on a cruise ship to party it up. You know how it is, holida~ay… celebra~ate! Among the cast of characters this time around includes her usual stick-in-the-mud love interest, Detective Prescott, the jazz singer and apparently-only-person-of-color-in-the-book, Lulu, Socialite and allegedly-the-only-gay-person-in-the-book, Benny, and incessant reporter, Kitty! Oh yeah, and also Pen’s cousin. Phew I’m out of breath, this is why I never do plot summaries. Anyway, other than the titular murdering going on the Atlantic, deeper, more personal troubles arise as Pen runs into an old lover who used to paint her like one of his French girls, thus driving a bit of a wedge in her relationship with her current man, Detective Man, Richard. Now, normally I’m of the mind that jealousy plots are kind of lazy and only show up whenever the writer runs out of ideas, but I honestly didn’t really mind it here because Richard is normally kind of boring, walking around like a discarded piece of cardboard. So yeah, I’ll honestly take any story line that proves he still has a pulse. Come on, shock some life into him and reanimate him like the corpse of Frankenstein! Yes, I know Frankenstein is the doctor… but if he treated “The Creature” like a person, like his son, then he would be a Frankenstein! Also then the plot of the book wouldn’t have been a tragedy. Also, also, Victor wasn’t a doctor, he was a college drop-out. I know that! These are all things that I know!

Going back on track though, yeah, I didn’t mind the jealously story line at all, because Pen normally has more chemistry with literally every other character than her love-interest, so it was nice to see their relationship in a different light. Besides, this new angle made Richard look a little more alive and a little more like a realized character rather than a plot device to just stand there like a mannequin only to arrest the bad guy at the end. I also liked how their relationship squabbles were written with a normal and healthy amount of insecurity and suspicion rather than having Richard flying off the handle in a rage the way these things are normally portrayed. They both have good reasons for being vexed with each other and I honestly couldn’t even decide who I thought was in the right and who was wrong. It felt like I was singing both parts in Paula Abdul’s “Opposites Attract” (not that I speak from experience). Arguments in fiction are usually set out with the intention of being “objective” by the writer, but often fail to hit the mark. Like how Noah Baumbach’s Marriage Story (spoilers) was supposed to be seen as this super enlightened and unbiased piece of art, a monument to how objective a man can be in the face of a deteriorating relationship, and yet he just couldn’t help but portray his self-insert as some kind of self-flagellating martyr figure in the end. I got the impression that he wanted us to feel soo~ooo bad at Adam Driver's longing, sad puppy eyes by the end of that film. Were we really supposed to be surprised? Because I wasn't! No duh, dude of course he lost custody of the kid in the end! He punched the wall and passed out when he was trying to impress the social worker (another scene where the writer was trying to be self-deprecating yet still portray his self-insert as a bumbling, yet lovable fool). Scarlett Johansson had Laura Dern as her lawyer! He didn't even want a lawyer!! He was always going to lose!! I don't know, it's just another example of an artsy guy patting himself on the back and getting a high off of his own self-pity. Hey, let's take a gander at The Weeknd's discography for a couple sentences. Hundreds of songs about vulnerability and the pains of being a sad boy, yet never actually changing for the better. Believing that the mere act of acknowledgment equates to absolution. I love the movie Before Midnight, but it’s another example of one of those male writer’s “rational man verses emotional woman” story lines that I could do without. Anyway, what I’m trying to say is that even when arguments are written with the intention of allowing us to “see both sides,” it’s actually very challenging to actually do so successfully. And I’m usually pretty good at picking sides, you know? One thing about me is that I’ve never been accused of being a centrist.

Otherwise, I think Penelope is kind of the perfect mystery protagonist because she has enough money in the universe to go anywhere and the author can literally put her in any situation. Which is helpful for mysteries because location is a deciding factor that helps separate them from the rest. This ones on a boat, that one was in a mansion, there was one in a hotel, “Where in the World is Penelope Banks” and all that, but what’s most important is the fact that she’s also experienced poverty, which gives her an “everyman who helps the everyman” appeal that's highly reminiscent of early Sherlock Holmes stories. And normally her perfect memory thing would seem like cheating in a mystery novel, but it’s written in such a way that Pen never feels like she has a super power.. even though having a picture perfect memory would certainly seem like one to me! Anybody remember that scene in The Pursuit of Happyness where Will Smith has to remember a specific set of numbers and he doesn’t have a pen and paper on him at the time and in his pursuit to find them there are a bunch of little obstacles where people would unintentionally be throwing him off? Yeah well, I wouldn’t even get that far to be thrown off by some dude screaming random numbers at me, becasue by the time I’d look away from original the list of numbers, there’s a good chance that they’d already be gone from my memory banks forever. Poof, bye bye bye! Haha! Wait, what was I going to say next? Oh yeah, I was ending this review. Um, I’ll always keep coming back to the Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries because they never fail to pleasantly surprise me. Emphasis on "pleasantly, because mysteries can often feel the need to adhere strictly to a tone, a concept, and because of that they end up ironically feeling predictable. Like how Black Mirror is supposed to be this mind-blowing new-age concept, yet in my experience, every single episode ends the same way; with the worst possible outcome you could possibly imagine for the characters. I mean, literally every one of these things ends with either the main character being a secretly terrible person (gotcha!), some kind of vindictive “moral” lessons that doesn't actually say anything, or just some guy being trapped in a mind palace. Seen one, seen them all. Oh, spoilers for every episode of Black Mirror, I guess. So I've always love of how this series’ twists are always of the “twisty, yet narratively satisfying” variety rather than being on the “cruel twist of fate” side of things. I get that by their very nature, mystery books have to be formulaic, but I’ve always found that the ones that catch me unawares are the ones that don’t bother going out of their way to subvert expectations. Yup, this was a good book! And I reckon enough time has passed since I've finished this, so now I can go on and read next one!

“Either way, love, greed, jealousy – three very good motives for murder.”
Profile Image for Lady Tea.
1,947 reviews133 followers
August 31, 2023
Rating: 3.2 / 5

I'm...not sure how to say this except directly, and it hurts to say it at all, but I must: I was disappointed by this one.

I will try to be as fair as possible in my review of this, but you all know what being disappointed is like, especially when we're not expecting it. It just...feels harsher, somehow.

Ahem, anyway to get into the story itself, this time around we have Pen and the gang just fresh off the wedding of Jane and Alfred, and headed to Europe for a trip that they can all enjoy, generously provided by Pen, of course. Once embarking, they realize that there's talk of a murder having happened on the maiden voyage of the ship, but that's surely no reason to get involved now, right--right?!

Well, as it so happens, quite a few First Class passengers from that same voyage are back on the boat again, despite having spent a relatively short time in America. This includes the dazzling actress, Vivian Adler, who is the focus of everyone during the voyage, including Penelope's old Spanish beau.

*screeches to a halt* Wait, WHAT?!?!?!?!?!?!

________________

And there is where things start to go wrong, and only get worse as the story progresses.

In short, what happens here is that the author is trying to force a love triangle on us with the sudden appearance of Mr. Spanish Hotness Painter (aka Raul), whom apparently Penelope not only had a fling with, but they also shared an apartment together and he did some racy paintings of her?! Um....WUT?!?!?!

Like...this is beginning to have all the trimmings of Alfred Hitchcock's 1929 film "Blackmail"--

First off, there's everything wrong with trying to force a love triangle onto readers at all and especially not so many books into the series once Penelope and Richard have already braved the deep waters and come out to a good place together; but it's also COMPLETELY INCONCEIVEABLE AND NOT SUITED TO PENELOPE'S CHARACTER THAT SOMETHING LIKE THIS WOULD HAVE HAPPENED!!!

Ahem, first off, she's 24/25, which is NOT old enough to have had a "living with a hot guy in Spain for months at a time" affair. I mean, not if we're supposed to believe that she's been living like a pauper for the last 4-5 years and surviving on her wits since her failed engagement with Mr. Whatshisface Cheating A-Hole--and then strongly under her father's thumb until then! You can't tell me that Penelope seriously had time for a relationship with both these two men and that she meant it both times. And the thing is, Penelope is a woman that DOES mean things and that's NOT frivolous, so making it seem like she has "oh so much of a past" is just flimsy and does a complete 180 on what you were portraying her as before. It makes me question how genuine she is in her relationship with Richard as well, because, I'm sorry, but loose people (men and women alike) and commitment do NOT go together.



Secondly, and I can't stress this enough, but Penelope would NOT do nude paintings. Not to say that she's been an angel or anything, but I always felt that she had dignity in what she did, such that she used her photogenic (eidetic) memory to cheat at cards rather than be a "hostess" or an "escort" or "call girl" or whatever. Say what you will, but there's a limit to how "daring" she was or even could be, no matter what she may allude to as being "wild" about her youth.

And ALSO ALSO, what really doesn't work about this love triangle is...well, Richard. Let me be direct and honest about this, but what in the heckity heck did you do to Richard in this story? Since when does he...take a back seat to everything that's going on and become so...passive? Like...I get that he and that he's suspended from the police force and furthermore this isn't even a case under his jurisdiction, so it makes sense for him not to get involved; but I do NOT see him just being this passive whilst Penelope is possibly putting herself at risk to figure things out, and also not to see justice done, regardless of how much he's allowed to get involved or not. If not to protect Penelope and for his own moral reasons, then why on earth has he been putting up with everything until now but then suddenly goes, "Meh, yeah, it's your case, whatever"?!

It. Just. Doesn't. FIT!

As if that weren't enough, it does get worse, friends. Oh yes, that it does.

Apart from Richard not feeling like Richard, in this story...*deep breath* Penelope did NOT feel like Penelope.

Nope, I don't mean with regards to the love triangle bullshit stuff. No, I've already gone over that.

What I mean is that instead of developing as a character, here Penelope seems to have...regressed, and lost what was unique about her character. Let's count off the sins, shall we:

1. She hardly interacts with anyone on a friendly basis anymore, not even Cousin Cordelia, and instead all her interactions with them seem to be based around solving the murder.

2. Despite what I just mentioned above, Penelope's also surprisingly DIM and SLOW to catch on to things in this story. Like...her friends, particularly Kitty (who's not really a friend, but anyways) and Lulu, end up giving her more answers and help her find what she's looking for than Penelope being productive about learning these things herself. Just what the heck was she doing all the time? (And since I can't answer that, you KNOW there's something wrong.)

3. She doesn't ONCE use her eidetic memory to solve the case. Nada, not even once. This was SUCH a big and unique part of her character in all the mysteries before, but for some reason it's just not present here. She remembers the exact sound of a door slamming when she kind-of witnessed the after-effects of the murder, but this doesn't really turn out to be a helpful clue anyway, so I'm not counting it.

4. At one point, and this really irked me the wrong way, Penelope mentions how she thought that she was "the glue holding her friends together" and she's surprised that they get along well without her being present. Um....WHAT?! Again, I'm repeating this a lot, but that's NOT like Penelope! Since when is she so self-absorbed?! (Especially with Lulu and Benny, why wouldn't they get along without her? I thought they were pretty tight!)

5. Penelope is...fairly self-serving in this book, to the point that she's either childish or stupid at times. This includes NOT telling Richard about the blackmail stuff right away (or, better yet, reporting it and letting Raul serve a sentence and try to save his own sorry butt--like, she doesn't owe him anything, and in fact should be madder at him than she is for the painting bullshit), and at one point just being a jerk to everyone because...wait for it....because she's crabby because she's hungry. Um...what?! You're telling me that she can't handle a morning without food when much bigger foodies than her (Eleanor Swift comes to mind) have spent hours upon hours with nothing to eat but have been just fine?!

6. AAAAAAAAND, lastly, all of a sudden Penelope seems to notice that she's rich, but in the WRONG way. Like, what pissed me off is (and spoiler alert), that

____________________

So...yeah, to conclude my long but honest rant, friends, this is probably the worst of the lot from all the Penelope Banks books, which until now have been pretty good. What stings is that the first bad apple in the batch IS after you've already got so many good apples in your basket, that you really have to wonder just what the author was thinking when writing this. Did they push themselves to publish this before it was ready? Maybe. Did they want to just publish SOMETHING because they'd lost inspiration and were hoping to bring some sparks back? Possibly.

But, whatever the reason, I think that this would have benefited some more edits and going over before it was put out.

Oh, and in case anyone's wondering about the mystery element itself, let's just say that what I've talked about above are the reason that two stars have been removed; of the three remaining stars, two are there for the mystery, which was just okay, and one star because I still do love the series and even a three star rating hurts me to give.

However, I definitely can't give credit where it isn't deserved, and any higher would just be dishonest on my part.

I'll end off with my reaction to the book overall, which may well be your reaction once you finish reading (or midway through, or whatever):

Profile Image for Tam Sesto.
914 reviews18 followers
October 16, 2023
Quick paced story with fun characters and an interesting plot with a bit of history thrown in. This was the first book in the series that I read, but didn’t have any problem following along. I am excited about going back and starting with book one as I loved the protagonist, Pen.

My review is voluntary and all comments and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Michelle.
1,965 reviews23 followers
September 16, 2023
After Jane’s wedding and subsequent honeymoon Pen and crew are inspired to hit the high seas and hie off to Paris. They are some of the first passengers to take this new French cruise liner. You’d think a new ship would be free of secrets and intrigue not so. There’s a missing maid, an old flame, an enigmatic actress and a murder oh my! Pen has her work cut out for her if she’s going to get to the bottom of this mess.
This is a most entertaining series. I enjoy the glimpses into the past that each book gives us and this one was especially exciting as we are on a luxury liner. Pen and her crew are as lively and colorful as ever and just as creative in finding ways to solve mysteries. Definitely recommend giving the series a shot if you haven’t already!
Profile Image for Larry.
3,325 reviews20 followers
December 15, 2024
After 11 books in this series, the main characters, especially Penelope Banks, have grown quite beloved to me. She is a fascinating character and someone I would have loved meeting. The plot is straightforward and the premise began with the news a maid, on the ship Penelope was taking to France, turned up missing just before it arrived in New York. The Penelope crew decided to see if she had been murdered by being thrown off the ship and why. The answers provided quite a few revelations. I most definitely recommend this book.
Profile Image for Lonny Johnson.
509 reviews12 followers
December 26, 2024
Colette Clark continues to maintain the high level of quality in the Penelope Banks series. We're off to France, but first we must solve the murder of a famous actress and her maid. Are the killings connected and if so, which was actually killed first?
Profile Image for Lass Loda.
70 reviews
October 23, 2025
book's characters were like caricatures of themselves - and the whole time Raul had a wife and kid??
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews