I'm writing this book review, to be honest, despite the author telling me to write a review. I originally wanted to not write a review because of that.
The book is only about half about reading, and then there's an assortment of notes about sunlight exposure in the morning and bath salts. This is not an exaggeration. In half of the book, the author forms a coherent narrative about reading and its value for your life with some useful tips about the how to, and then there is an added section (?) or part 2 of the book, which is just health, wealth, and happiness advice from books (but also podcasts, I believe). For some, there is a source for others. There isn't - though, one suspects that it's Andrew Huberman. Some of it might be already debunked Huberman advice, I think.
There's a lot of Ryan Holiday, Tim Ferris, Wim Hof, and Andrew Huberman in this. Sometimes, it's explicit. Sometimes, it's less so. I was about to call the author a bit of a fanboy, but at least when it comes to Ryan Holday, that would be the kettle calling the pot black. And then there's Jim Kwik, Jocko... if you're like me, you get the picture. The author reads 15 minutes in the morning, does cold showers, meditation, ... Although, if you mention Josh Waitzkin and Jocko in the same book, don't you have to mention BJJ? I mean, Matthew Hussey had time to mention the benefits of BJJ in "Love Life. "...
There is some really good advice in this book. However, Hutchison is a habit tracker and if you are trying to become a better listener, improve your relationship or deal with anything that's harder to quantify, it's there's a lot of less useful information in there. I got one good piece of advice for quitting nicotine, but the section wasn't about smoking. I would have loved the author to be more explicit about note taking. He does speak about reading a lot and improving your memory, but the key he says is repetition to retain. I didn't get enough information about how he takes notes from this, though. I do now feel relief that I'm not the only one now combining physical or ebooks with audiobooks. Hutchinson, like me, does a lot of his book consumption in the car. But tbh, how he keeps notes there is left a little unclear. I literally went: "Ok, so I'll have to figure out how to do it now that I know that it's possible." My main problem isn't reading a lot and memorising things; it's finding time for effective note keeping in between.
Overall, it's very mixed. It's sort of what one would expect. On the other hand, one would sort of want more. I mean, there's YouTube content about how people put X into practice after reading a book. Or looking at Ali Abdaal's "Feel-Good Productivity" that would be a good example of a different implementation but a similar kind of book. Hutchinson states that he applies SMART goals; Abdaal also mentions SMART goals, but then explains NICE goals as a better way. If "Rise of the Reader" wasn't, in fact, more of a book about habit tracking, it could probably have done without the discussion of SMART goals.
If you're already into reading lots of self-help, you either can't get much new information here, or you'll be happily nodding along. If you haven't but want to start on self-help ... this is the part where I should recommend this book, but ... then start with Marianne Power "Help Me" and if we're nearing Christmas Jenny Colgan "The Christmas Bookshop". If then you haven't dove head first into "The Secret" or gone onto a Tony Robbins binge, maybe this is a good place to start.