Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Fate wouldn’t tie me to these men, would it?

Sent to the ruthless academy for magicals after years hiding from the authorities, I'm behind, poor and, with my pet pig in tow, struggling to fit in.

No surprises I'm picked out for ridicule by the other students - as well as the teachers.

And four men in particular seem determined to make my life here hell.

The man who caught me.

My grumpy, sharp-tongued professor.

The star of the school's dueling team.

And the academy's deadly heart-breaker.

They all find their own special way of torturing me, but I'm determined not to bow.

I hate them.

And yet when I'm with them, I feel like a fish on a hook, tugged in their direction, my insides swirling with a lot more than simply hate.

Is this magic or something far more dangerous?

***A new why choose paranormal romance series with magic, ruthless love interests and fated mates. Fractured Fates is the first book in the Arrow Hart Academy series. This story will not complete in book one and contains some scenes that readers may find challenging.

392 pages, Kindle Edition

First published September 22, 2023

5343 people are currently reading
18981 people want to read

About the author

Hannah Haze

45 books1,525 followers
I'm Hannah Haze, a why choose paranormal romance author known for my sweet omegaverse books and not so sweet magical academy series. If you enjoy a touch of humour, a lot of steam and plenty of swoony, romantic moments; strong fmcs who know what they want and mmcs who vary from the devoted to obsessive, then I am the woman for you!

My other loves include long romantic walks in the countryside, undisturbed soaks in a hot bath and even hotter stories. I have one husband, three children, a very naughty cat and a new fluffy pupster. When I’m not writing stories, I’m thinking about stories, listening to stories, reading stories or dreaming about them.

Come follow me or get in touch!

Sign up to my newsletter: www.hannahhaze.com/about

Join my readers' group: www.facebook.com/groups/375024943829423/

Visit my website: www.hannahhaze.com

Catch me on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@hannahhaze_author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
5,386 (37%)
4 stars
5,420 (37%)
3 stars
2,784 (19%)
2 stars
565 (3%)
1 star
255 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 834 reviews
Profile Image for Michaela Okland.
57 reviews227 followers
July 6, 2024
I’m literally so embarrassed that I read this please ignore this I’m so embarrassed don’t look at me I’m begging u. I’m starting the second book now
Profile Image for Doom Sunshine.
617 reviews73 followers
March 11, 2024
DNF 47%
The author adds nothing new to the Academy/RH genre.

The professor (who is supposed to be 31 years old) acts like a 16 year old. FMC's two other fated mates hate her "just because" and continue to have sex with anything that walks, the "bad boy" who is mysterious and helps her in subtle ways have ALL been written, exactly like this and it's just SO boring.

Mean girl and OW drama, boring.

At 47%, no advancement in the plot, just day to day living from the perspectives of the FMC and MMC. Boring.

FMC has one or maybe two friends, not new and boring.

FMC is "strong" and wanting to escape, yet she yields to everyone at all times and doesn't make any plans to escape and reclaim her life.

Boring. Boring. And everything has been done before.

Author should also learn what comma splices and run on sentences are as they will help her dialogue better.
Profile Image for Emily Thomson.
74 reviews1 follower
December 14, 2023
Dnf at 46%. There's absolutely no way to redeem a love interest who publicly dumps a bunch of shit into the FMC's mouth.
Profile Image for Caroline.
539 reviews169 followers
October 4, 2023
Happy Release Date to Fractured Fates!!! I really loved this.
_______________
I LOVED this book. This is book 1 in a new paranormal why choose series. This book has:

- Why Choose / Reverse Harem
- Fated Mate Bonds (very slow-burn)
- Bully Romance
- Academy Romance
- Age Gap
- Student/Professor
- Hidden Identity
- Animal Sidekick (a pig named Pip!)
- Bi-sexual MC
- Mind-reading powers


This book is definitely has some pretty heavy bullying throughout this book, so if that's not your jam, then you might not like it. However, I think it's such a good set-up for a lot of groveling in book 2 (I loveeee me some groveling). There are also some other heavy triggers in this, so check your content warnings.

I really like Rhianna. She is a bit naive, which isn't usually my favorite, but it kind of worked for her character's background. There's a lot we still don't know about how she grew up, but I liked that she is so clueless about how the world and school works. I do think she gets pushed around a lot in this book, and I got a little bit tired of her just rolling over. I hope she f*cks shit up in the next book and makes all of these guys regret how they've been treating her. Stone, Tristan, and Spencer certainly deserve it.

The cliffhanger for this book absolutely killed me. I need book 2 ASAP.

This was so good!! Thank you to Hannah Haze for the eARC. I loved it! I already want to re-read some of my favorite parts.
Profile Image for GimmeAllTheWerdssss.
597 reviews255 followers
October 12, 2023
This is more straight down the middle at 2.5 but I rounded up because it kept me interested and turning the pages. However, it left me pissed off on numerous fronts.

First, I’ve only read a few of this authors books and wasn’t impressed. I found that the stories got monotonous in the middle and it just killed almost every single one of them. In fact I had pretty much written her off. This book synopsis did intrigue me though so, what the hell, let’s give it a try.

Overall, it wasn’t a horrible book. The idea is good but I found the characters lacking. The heroine wasn’t necessarily a Mary Sue but for living the life she has she sure did roll over a lot and take the abuse. She just let people abuse her. She had one or two “strong” moments but they didn’t last very long. I wanted her to stand up for herself more. I wanted her to display the fortitude she talked about. Ultimately I just wanted more from her.

Now the guys…the guys were part of the biggest issue. She has 4 mates, however, only two of them recognize the mate signs and are actively trying to undo it. One of them essentially mind rapes her and degrades her repeatedly. The other two are abusive assholes. They didn’t show any redemptive qualities. They bullied and humiliated her repeatedly. One of the guys physically attacked her multiple times but called it “training” - we’re talking throwing her on the ground and tackling her. Plus, she gets nauseous when they are hooking up with other women. She doesn’t understand what’s going on but as the reader we do. They feel drawn to her and can sense power in her but still treat her like shit. Of the four only one showed the ability to be a decent mate and only because he somewhat accepted the mate pull and ended up saving her life in the end - but it came with a price…to her, not him necessarily, but to HER!

My other big issue is that I felt like the author dangled nuggets of info with no payoff. At the end we know absolutely not more information about our heroine that we did in the beginning. Mind raper found out some big secrets but do we get even a hint at what they are? Nope! The only decent on finds a file on what we are led to assume is her mom but do we get a hint at what’s in there? Nope! The other two abusive assholes recognize s long lost power that she may have but is it elaborated on? Nope.
As a reader I don’t appreciate this tactic. Does it keep someone interested and reading? To an extent but overall it just serves to piss people off. There was basically NO payoff in this book. However, it is interesting enough for me to read the next one when it comes out. But there is a caveat…the heroine needs to be a hell of a lot stronger, the Heros need to beg - I’m talking on their knees crawling over glass - for her forgives, she needs to tell them to fck off and actually make them pay for their abhorrent behavior to their MATE, and then she needs to kick some major ass magically. Am I holding my breath? Only partially because I can see the potential but the author hasn’t proven she can pull it off.
198 reviews2 followers
February 14, 2024
I hate finished it because I’ve had too many dnfs lately. The writing was terrible, the story not original.

FMC is “not like other girls” 🙄. She is an idiot as well. She refuses to wear her uniform and then is surprised that everyone else is wearing uniforms? When her roommate warned her? Fmc went from a stick figure to curvy in 2 weeks, when the food situation still wasn’t great?

The MMCs are also lumbering idiots. They all stomp around in rages - but they have no reasoning for any of it. If you are showing mmc pov in a bully romance, you have to show their motivation beyond “me mad, girl hot.” None of their actions in this book made any sense to me.

Why is the common room a bedroom? I thought all the rich kids had nice suites? Shouldn’t it be like a rec room? Why would they allow a pig when this girl has a roommate? Why would the powers that be insist she get an education and accommodate her pig request but not give her needed materials for school and tutoring since she’s never been to school in her life.

Some of my questions were answered in this one exchange:

"It's like ... it's like she's torn back a layer of your skin ..."
I shake my head. That's the other thing that reveals itself when he drops the bored act. He has a fucking poetic way with words. It left me captivated as a kid, now it pisses me off.

If this is sarcasm I’m missing just let me know, but if the author thinks this is poetic I now understand why the whole book was so awful.
Profile Image for cha.
312 reviews631 followers
September 3, 2024
a pretty ok read if you're craving bully academy RH featuring your typical popular jock, golden boy, hot professor & mysterious dude - and you have nothing else to read.

that ending was criminal, but also chef's kiss.

the writing is a little juvenile for my taste. and the fmc grates on my nerves a little bit lol

nothing really happens in the first 60% of the book except for the fmc getting bullied left and right. and every time she gets enough of it and wants to leave, she finds excuses the next day not to. this happens like probably three separate times where she's like everywhere else is better than here, but then the next day she's like but maybe I kinda like school. well school does not like you miss maam.

to be fair, she does have bad guys chasing her and wanting her dead, so leaving is not really the smartest choice considering she's bad at fighting and using magic. BUT.

everywhere else is literally better than the academy where everyone hates her 😭 I'd honestly take my chances with the bad dudes than go another day in a place where every single person thinks my shit is worth more than my being lmao and like if I die, I die. and at least it would be at the hands of badass villains than a whiny ass bitch like Summer.

the MMCs are also mean for absolutely no reason. some might hate her because she's unregistered and the stereotype is unregistered magicals are like the stinkiest garbage. that's ridiculous, but I get it. but the rest *ahem, Tristan and Spencer* hate her because of what....? she has a pet pig?

I knew there would be some bullying going into this bc that's honestly why I read it, but it just doesn't make sense to me. maybe they want to hate her because they want to fight the undeniable pull or whatever but do they really have to bully her then? 😭 if you don't want her then just stay away bitch lmao???? from their POVs it seems like they hate her so much, like she's wronged them personally but she's never done shit 😭

at one point she said to one of the MMCs she got held up by an asshole, and the MMC was like "you ever wondered whether it's you that's the asshole?" uhhhhh fuck no? again, she's never actually done anything wrong, she's not even bitchy or anything so why the fuck would she ever?

and PLEASE I don't usually mind ow drama or the mmc being a manwhore especially in RH because it adds to the drama but I HATEEE it in this. not really ow drama tho more like the MMCs being manwhores. Just a mention of it here and there is fine, I DO NOT need to see it in action. bleugh.

anyways, still entertaining tho at least. AND I SEE THE POTENTIAL so I hope I'm not wrong. Book two I go!!
Profile Image for hafsi.
383 reviews23 followers
January 10, 2024
Usually am a big fan of Hannah haze as harmless escapism but this was not it. I also think the bully trope does nothing for me.

Protagonists seem quite bland and the whole pig aspect was a lot for me as a Muslim lmaooo
Profile Image for Desiree.
421 reviews59 followers
July 30, 2024
I just knew I was going to love this book, and it did NOT disappoint. The fated mates in this book 🤭, it just reaffirmed my love for fated mates especially in RH/why choose books!! I absolutely love all of the characters even though there are three who are complete assholes and two who are straight up bullying her 🫣, but I just know these men will make up for it and I mean, the TENSION??? Like these men HATE that they want her and how she is on their minds 24/7 🤭🤭. Like I’m loving this giddy feeling while reading this book which I haven’t felt in a little bit. But y’all, I could NOT stop reading this book, like at first I only had difficulty in the beginning because I had a headache but once that went away, I seriously could not stop reading. I mean I finished it in a day!! But I will definitely be starting the next book like right away, I need MORE. And y’all, I went into this knowing it’s an incomplete series and the final book is coming out in October, but I am not ready for the cliffhanger that the fourth book will give us and having to wait like 3 months 😩, but I legit couldn’t wait to read this series like it was literally calling out to me. And y’all, this pig better live the entire series or else I’m going to go insane.

So we meet Rhianna, a 20-year old, an unregistered magical (which is a crime in this world), who has a pet pig named Pip, who has been on the run her whole life with her aunt from the authorities and everyone else for reasons we don’t know yet. That is until, Rhianna gets discovered by the authorities enforcer who is named the “man in black” literally the entire book and she feels a tug in her gut to him…but he is there to take her to Arrow Hart Academy, a requirement for magicals to attend until they are 21. We also meet Stone, the hot grumpy professor (who gives Lance Orion vibes for all my ZA girlies, and instead of telling everyone that they aren’t special, but just tells her, iykyk) who assists “the man in black” to escort her to the academy. Then of course, there are two popular guys in school who are best friends but are absolute assholes to her and they are Tristian and Spencer who honestly cannot leave this girl alone but torture her any chance they get. But there’s a certain someone out of that duo, who gives into this thoughts and desires and kisses her 🤭. And there may or may not be one more guy who may be a potential mate that we learn about in the end…But y’all everyone in this damn academy cannot give this girl a break and bully her any chance they get, except her roomie, Winnie—thank goodness—, and is basically her only friend there.

So if you don’t like the bullying trope, even though it’s only 2/4 maybe ⅖ guys, you might not like this, but for everyone else, you NEED to read this. The tropes are magical academy, fated mates, bullying, asshole MMCs, RH/why choose, age gap, and student x professor .

Favorite quotes/scenes:

“What the fuck is that?” (Stone)
“My pig.” (Rhi)
“Why the fuck does she have a pig?” (Stone)
The man in black shrugs.
“Is she mentally unstable?” (Stone)
“Possibly.”

“You going to kiss me back, sweetheart? Kiss me back.” (Literally swooned 😩)
Profile Image for Holland.
93 reviews119 followers
July 13, 2024
hahahahahahaha WHAT (and why did I like it). 3.5
5 reviews
July 7, 2024
I had high hopes but it was not it. You mean to tell me her 30 years old professor, who knows that she's his fated mate (a rare gift) just splurges literal dung on her so that everybody sees after she worked in the sun on the brink of fainting? After witnessing her other fated mate railing girls left and right?

I get there is bullying in this book but wtf? And the heroine is just like I will not be this weak girl and then proceed to do literally nothing.

I think it was a waste of time for me and no groveling in the world could make me forgive this kind of shit.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Haste.
223 reviews5 followers
April 12, 2025
DNR: just heard a lot of ow drama. Unredeemable men as they sleep with other girls constantly even knowing the fmc is their true mate. They are mean for no reason to her and humiliate her while the mean girls bully her.
Profile Image for Polina.
41 reviews
July 26, 2024
idk who gave this book 4,16 rating but that’s kinda embarrassing.
Profile Image for Christy.
900 reviews38 followers
September 21, 2024
I actually had no idea why they hated her so much. I think it's because she's new????😂 They just don't know her???? Like just sit down and be nice to her and maybe she'll give you that info, idk?
Profile Image for omega’s rights activist.
193 reviews29 followers
November 21, 2024
Second half turned it from 3 to 4 stars. Predictable story but that’s what we read these for right? Low spice
Profile Image for Maddie Vaters.
568 reviews437 followers
November 24, 2024
4⭐️

While this book may not be anything profound in the world of paranormal academy romances, I did really enjoy it and will definitely be jumping into the rest of the series! This book is kinda like if Zodiac Academy & Blood Oath by Morgan B. Lee had a baby. I’m always a sucker for a good bully romance and this one is definitely intense. If you liked the vibes between the heirs and Vegas in ZA, then you will probably enjoy Rhi and her potential men. Now I say potential because this is definitely a slowww burn, which personally I am very here for. We don’t get much smeggsual action or romance in this book except for a couple strange kisses (like really though- they come out of nowhere), so I’m excited to see the romance and connections blossom in the next books! It also appears that we are going to have 5 love interests, and the more, the better right?😌 Anywho, for all my Why Choose book lovers out there- this gets my stamp of approval😘
Profile Image for Tay.
233 reviews29 followers
December 22, 2025
I hit my reading goal so now I get to read my silly kindle books
Profile Image for ☀︎El In Oz☀︎.
797 reviews417 followers
August 25, 2025
4.5/5

I DEVOURED this book. Fated mates plus bully romance PLUS reverse harem???!!! An ideal combination for me. I loved all the love interests, I loved the side characters and Rhi, our main character, plus I enjoyed the plot. But the fated mates truly made this book for me. So so good
Profile Image for ..
446 reviews39 followers
October 28, 2023
back at it again with weirdos and their biological need to fuck love u omegaverse 🤞
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
3,680 reviews327 followers
did-not-finish
December 18, 2024
DNF

This first scene with a dude feels super sketchy. And then, I realize I am not going to like a bully romance anyway so I may as well stop here.
Profile Image for Hannah Tilley.
133 reviews3 followers
October 7, 2025
The audiobook for this is soooo bad, I have to DNF. I made it 20% but just can’t do it. Maybe I’ll go back eventually and read it on kindle
Profile Image for Stefi.
79 reviews3 followers
October 9, 2025
This is dogfood and I'm a ravished chihuahua.
Profile Image for Bookish Darling .
64 reviews
June 5, 2024
Seeing the 4 stars review really got my hopes high.

Currently 100 pages in and this girls knows nothing but whining. She's so God damn stupid that I wonder how the mmcs are gonna fall in love with her. I expected a mature girl who knows how to survive, not someone who just wants to runaway from things without making the most out of it.

Also- I think people would hate it if a near stranger roommate touched their stuff. The FMC decided that her roomie wouldn't mind if she used her laptop without permission.


115 pages in and the main characters aren't all that great. "Surprisingly, she actually possesses a nice looking rack, her tits are a perfect handful"

The pig had more personality than her. And broh, is she that important that they would allow her to keep a pig 🐷? It's a supposed prestigious academy. The FMC has no interest in becoming better. It's all high school shit.


They all call her pig girl. Bhai, where the hell is ACTING YOUR AGE.

If I wanted the age play, I would have read Dom/Sub, Daddy/Babygirl books.
474 reviews
November 7, 2023
DNF at 45%

Why 2 stars? Because the author is a good writer.

However, the characters are horrible. The MFC is ignorant and weak. She showed NO growth at the almost halfway point. The guys are awful just to be awful. They sleep around even knowing they are mated to her. They are deliberately mean knowing they are mated to her. These are not heroic characters.

I'm not a fan of bully storyline because how do you start a romance with someone that treats you like crap?
Profile Image for Abstract ♥ Books.
1,281 reviews1,765 followers
February 15, 2025



ALL MY REVIEWS CAN BE FOUND ON MY BLOG: ABSTRACT BOOKS

line

Star Rating : 4.5 / 5 Stars

POV : Dual

Cliffhanger : None

Pace of the story : Moderate

Angst Rating : 6/10

Heat Rating : 6/10

Overall Opinion :
It’s been a while since I have picked up a fantasy romance and I can’t even tell you guys how much I am loving this one! This series was amazing and I remember when I started this one , only 4 books were out in this series and I binged them all back to back. Then after sometime when the last book came out , I was probably one of the first ones to read it lol.

The dynamics in this one are good and the best thing I liked was the character chemistry. That is often hard to achieve with RH but this author got the perfect balance of that and it made the series pretty good. All the heroes are crazy but I remember the way she handled Renzo because he grew to become one of the favs. Somehow all the heroes have their own take with her and they make it work which was the best part.

Definitely recommending this one to all the dark romance loving people out there.

My-Post-3 Website | Bookstagram | Facebook Page | Newsletter
Profile Image for Ilona (Inkmates Read).
522 reviews10 followers
February 25, 2025
I really enjoyed The Bonds That Tie series and this gives similar vibes so I am sad I didnt like this one more. I think it’s because I am not a fan of most of the characters, especially the FMC. She is so fucking whiny, I cannot stand it. It is possible that it is the person doing her voice in the audiobook so I am going to continue because I am still somewhat interested in the story but fuck I am close to stopping.
Profile Image for Chi.
108 reviews9 followers
August 1, 2025
I was intrigued enough to finish with lots of skimming but not enough to continue on to the next book . I liked the plot and characters I just wish it didn't have the extra fluff . It felt like a YA with just a single kiss of adult in it . It wasn't bad , don't get me wrong , so you might enjoy this . I just need a little more intensity and getting to the points quicker .
Profile Image for a.
468 reviews
August 7, 2024
3.5

had to force it but when it delivered i was hooked
Displaying 1 - 30 of 834 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.