I'm an early reader and just finished the audiobook after its release. Firstly, the reading by George Newbern continues to be excellent. His inflection is great and the production is perfect. An engaging and easy listen. The emotional parts are read with strong emotion - I really felt some of these scenes.
In book 2 it's become more of an epic adventure and less about slavery, now that Ariock & friends have sort-of-escaped. Starting this book, it felt dark at first, definitely a darker tone than a lot of recent fiction. Within the first few chapters, it becomes clear its tone is because the author thought everything through carefully. This writing isn't winging it. It's deep and interesting. I'm really enjoying that!
Personally, I don't normally like any darkness at all. So I asked myself, why do I enjoy this? Because it's more realistic and meaningful. It's being set up for hard wins, not easy wins. Because the series is completed, the story arc is epic, happening over the whole series rather than 1-2 books.
Innovative epic series have been hard for me to find lately; most of the new good stuff is serialized. Serialized series, much like TV shows, often wane as they get longer, getting mired in details or unplanned events. Torth is the antidote to that; the plot is tight, it's going somewhere, and everything matters.
I definitely feel for Thomas in this book. As the only telepath in his party, I realized, there's an element to one-way telepathy where it's like you're talking but nobody can hear you, while you can hear others' thoughts. Overall this is a really tough book for Thomas. No spoilers, but he has a hard time. By the end, he's getting out of it. The author does a good job of showing that his friends care about him during this. And, that situation is an interesting mirror to book 1, where Ariock was in a difficult position (as gladiator).
I'm ready for book 3!