2.5 stars.
I enjoyed this at first, but thought with Faith being so invested in her religion and being extremely inexperienced, that giving herself to Geoff so quickly was unrealistic. It just didn't sit well with me how quickly Geoff was able to sway her to sleep with him. Someone who, at the time, was Atheist and a Privateer and a confessed rake, she was more than eager to put all that aside to experience pleasure and passion. Her character just wasn't consistent.
However, I continued to read because the writing style was very easy-flowing. But things just moved too quickly, became cliche and a bit cringe, and then the several chapters where Geoff and Faith were apart and the whole situation with Diego was just bizarre and random and boring. Geoff finding his faith (and not just the woman) was also a bit in the face and cringe.
Ultimately, the writing style was impressive but the story telling, the pacing and the lack of consistency really let this book down.