2.5 stars rounded up.
Can I say something controversial yet brave? This book left me feeling a whole lot of nothing. I didn't dislike it, but I'm not 100% sure I liked it either. I don't have a single strong opinion about it, and that's making it extremely difficult to rate and review.
Let me start by saying that I'm not poly and have only a basic understanding of the dynamics, terminology, etc. I'm not completely uneducated but certainly not an expert. This is the first poly romance I've read, so I went into it excited to try something new (to me) and potentially learn a little bit. All that said, I don't really have much to say on the poly rep in this book. Given that I have no point of comparison, I can't speak to its accuracy. The only thing I can assert with any confidence is that I didn't personally feel any investment in the romance(s), which is a bummer given that it is, in fact, a romance novel.
Before I dive into that any further, let me first say that I did appreciate that this book had a lesbian MC who was explicitly referred to as a lesbian. I've said it before, and I'll say it again: the word "lesbian" is good and beautiful and right, and we deserve to see it used kindly, boldly, and proudly. It's a shame that, even in queer books, it's so often shied away from; I'm glad that wasn't the case here. It was also cool to see a romance between a lesbian and a nonbinary person who wasn't just Woman Lite™️. Lesbians so often are portrayed as the "villains" of the queer community, and there's a lot of rhetoric about us being these horrible, vile, inherently transphobic people. While it's true that there are transphobic lesbians—just as there are, unfortunately, transphobic people within every other sexuality—nothing about our identity is fundamentally transphobic. We, too, love and date and experience attraction to people beyond cisgender women, but that's something I very rarely, if ever, see represented in books or other media. Super cool to see it here!
Now, back to the part where this book didn't wow me. I think, overall, my issue was with the fact that Mel, Bebe, and Kade all read as very flat. They felt like they existed solely as their identities (lesbian, poly, genderqueer, etc.) and their jobs (bartender, lawyer, artist) rather than as whole people. There wasn't a lot of noteworthy character development aside from Mel's transition from feeling like she was over the idea to romance to—surprise—falling in love with both Bebe and Kade. Even that was underwhelming because it wasn't as fleshed out as it could've been. I would've liked to see more discussion about Mel's hesitations with romance, her grappling with her emotions after realizing she was falling for Bebe, and so on. But that just wasn't there, and so I didn't care all that much when the shift happened. Furthermore, I wasn't particularly sold on the chemistry between...any of them. Mel and Bebe were clearly physically/sexually attracted to one another from the jump, but the romantic chemistry was lacking. I wanted to be shown more and told less so I could really believe they were falling in love. That's even more true with the dynamic between Mel and Kade. Throughout the entire first portion of the book, Kade is portrayed as aloof and seemingly uninterested in...everything. Then, after getting snowed in at a skiing cabin with Mel, they confess that they have feelings for Mel. And, wouldn't you know it, Mel reciprocates those feelings! Their relationship completely lacked setup. They're never shown as having interest in or attraction to one another prior to going on the ski trip, so even though I knew it was coming, it still felt like it came out of left field.
I know that at this point it probably seems like I lied when I said I didn't have any strong opinions about Triple Sec, but I mean it when I say I didn't. There were things I appreciated about it and things that made it difficult for me to feel invested in both the characters and the plot, and in the end they sort of canceled one another out. I finished the book and thought, "Well, I finished the book." It wasn't bad. It wasn't necessarily for me. YMMV.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review. (I actually ended up receiving two advanced copies of this, one digital and one physical, so I feel extra obligated to review as thoroughly and honestly as possible!)